Except Kangana Ranaut no other actress who could have made the persona of Praful Patel credible in Simran
Except Kangana Ranaut no other actress who could have made the persona of Praful Patel credible in Simran

In defence of Simran : Good girl, bad girl, every girl

Why Simran is definitely not a confused feminist fantasy...
By Java Singh and Roli Jindal | Hindustan Times
UPDATED ON SEP 25, 2017 09:02 PM IST

Praful Patel is addicted to gambling. She takes on risks without weighing them against rewards, she manipulates her parents remorselessly to wrangle money out them, she is callously acerbic to a perfectly decent suitor who treads the ground around her with amiable trepidation. She is not kind to anyone, not even to the frail, asthmatic cashier whom she leaves at the brink of death after robbing his bank. She shows no gratitude, not even to the cherubic, rotund fellow Gujarati who selflessly gives her money at a casino to lift her spirits, all he gets from her is a jovial high-five. Praful does not need anyone. Except Kangana Ranaut. I cannot think of any other actress who could have made the persona of Praful credible.

A few other actresses have taken off the pancake to establish themselves as serious performers, but Ranaut’s genius lies in her accomplishing the feat without abandoning the pancake. She uses her body to counter the culture industry’s strategy for the objectification of women. The first step to blinding someone is getting them to open their eyes: Ranaut blinds the male gaze with her plastic perfection, then delivers a spirited KO punch that belies her saleable appearance.

Ranaut’s journey through her films is a progression in autonomy. In Tanu-Manu she enters the marriage negotiation process on her own terms, in Queen she rejects marriage, settling for a mild flirtation with an exotic Italian instead, and finally, in Simran, she has no space to offer any of the men who surround her – father, fiancée, ex-lover, ex-husband all fade into irrelevance as her madness consumes her.

Her insane self-destructive behaviour is suggestive, instead, of a thousand, small, humiliating, disconcerting calibrations of the mind and body that almost every girl endures at the hands of people wiser-than-her, stronger-than-her and maler-than-her.

Simran could have been a lot more palatable. Acceptable, even. The makers simply needed to pitch their protagonist as mentally unstable or psychopathic – that’s been Ranaut’s territory for years. They could have built a back story of abuse. They could have played up the deprivation. This would have distanced her from the audience, made her the ‘other’ – a person unlike us.

Simran moves the conversation forward. It is the every-girlness of Praful that is unsettling. The movie showcases the pathological dimension of female frustration. The reasons for Praful’s gambling addiction and her abnormal risk-taking are not explained. The story stays silent on the failure of Praful’s first marriage, silent on her childhood experiences, silent on the reasons why her recent relationship with her boss ended. Her insane self-destructive behaviour is suggestive, instead, of a thousand, small, humiliating, disconcerting calibrations of the mind and body that almost every girl endures at the hands of people wiser-than-her, stronger-than-her and maler-than-her.

Simran could have been a better film, a better story. But of all the faults to pick, I wouldn’t go into the inanity of the robbery scenes. Silly as they are, they are no sillier than a single hero beating up a dozen goons with an uprooted hand-pump. Remember that these robberies actually happened, and happened pretty much as shown. The story has other problems, but nothing takes away from the importance of the larger story that it tells, and tries hard not to explain.

In Queen Ranaut rejects marriage, settling for a mild flirtation with an exotic Italian instead
In Queen Ranaut rejects marriage, settling for a mild flirtation with an exotic Italian instead

On the surface, this film seems pointless. Neither is Praful’s story uplifting, nor does it evoke sympathy. There is no justification for her actions, no villain, no revenge. Still, she stays with you, long after you have left the theatre, she and her sly humour, her joie de vivre and her ‘character flaw’. Her chuckle, her guffaw, her jubilant dance in the casino, her plaintive loser’s wail. Praful imagines she has wings on her back; she imagines she is flying in endless space that she shares with no one. Sometime or another, don’t we all?

(Java Singh, an alumna of IIM Ahmedabad, is a researcher on gender issues at the School of Language, Literature and Culture Studies, JNU and Roli Jindal, also an alumna of IIM Ahmedabad, is a corporate executive and an author)

From HT Brunch, September 25, 2017

Follow us on twitter.com/HTBrunch

Connect with us on facebook.com/hindustantimesbrunch

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
Join the #BrunchBookChallenge and win!
Join the #BrunchBookChallenge and win!

Hello, #BrunchBookChallenge 2021

By HT Brunch Team, Delhi
UPDATED ON JAN 17, 2021 01:46 PM IST
  • Read the most books this year, tweet and win!
Close
Kapoor & Sons director Shakun Batra with his friends Ayesha DeVitre (let) and Avantika Malik (right), on their way from Jaisalmer to the airport, when their car broke down
Kapoor & Sons director Shakun Batra with his friends Ayesha DeVitre (let) and Avantika Malik (right), on their way from Jaisalmer to the airport, when their car broke down

“At 22, I was idealistic and brash when I reviewed films... ”: Shakun Batra

By Dinesh Raheja, Delhi
UPDATED ON JAN 17, 2021 12:23 PM IST
The filmmaker talks about living in Mumbai, earning 9,000 per month, and working 15 hours a day.
Close
How uplifting are those who brighten up our bleak times with halos of neon green and unearthly purple (Parth Garg)
How uplifting are those who brighten up our bleak times with halos of neon green and unearthly purple (Parth Garg)

Humour: Happy new hair

By Rehana Munir
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 09:09 PM IST
The two seasons of Phoebe Waller-Bridge’s Fleabag were filled with acute observations about the messiness of modern lives
Close
Technical Guruji explains the ARM-based chip for Mac computers being made by Apple and if you should move to Signal or Telegram
Technical Guruji explains the ARM-based chip for Mac computers being made by Apple and if you should move to Signal or Telegram

Guruji: Decoding the WhatsApp privacy debate and the M1 chip

By Gaurav Chaudhary
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 10:14 PM IST
Should you switch to Signal or Telegram or stick to WhatsApp? And what’s the Apple M1 chip?
Close
With so many options once travel becomes safer, Jeremy picks out what works best for him
With so many options once travel becomes safer, Jeremy picks out what works best for him

Jeremy Jauncey: Travel choices - Maldives or Seychelles, Airbnb or hotels?

By Jeremy Jauncey
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 10:18 PM IST
Let Jeremy Jauncey help you out with your travel destination and stay dilemmas
Close
Mushrooms are key when making an all-vegetarian burger at home
Mushrooms are key when making an all-vegetarian burger at home

Prateek Sadhu: Veggie burger, anyone?

By Prateek Sadhu
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 10:18 PM IST
Tell me how I can make the best all-vegetarian burger in the world
Close
Saloni Gaur’s went viral under the garb of Nazma Aapi found resonance with the Twitterati when she spoke about current affairs (Sagar Malhan)
Saloni Gaur’s went viral under the garb of Nazma Aapi found resonance with the Twitterati when she spoke about current affairs (Sagar Malhan)

Nazma Aapi? Kangana? Sonam?

By Shruti Nair
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 08:52 PM IST
The pool of social media influencers has found another entrant, 21-year-old Saloni Gaur, who has fans in both Dolly and Kusha
Close
Vivek Oberoi reads in his bedroom in Mumbai during the photoshoot for this column (Prabhat Shetty)
Vivek Oberoi reads in his bedroom in Mumbai during the photoshoot for this column (Prabhat Shetty)

In Bed With Vivek Oberoi

By Dinesh Raheja
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 08:44 PM IST
The actor shows off his collection of books on a sunny winter afternoon in his four poster bed in his Mumbai home
Close
Abhilasha Sinha (left) and Kamakshi Khanna are calling out those who body shame women for having body hair and love handles (Aryaman Dixit and Kamakshi Khanna)
Abhilasha Sinha (left) and Kamakshi Khanna are calling out those who body shame women for having body hair and love handles (Aryaman Dixit and Kamakshi Khanna)

Two millennial musicians on body issues, confidence and sisterhood

By Karishma Kuenzang
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 08:21 PM IST
  • How NY-based Abilasha Sinha, 26, and Kamakshi Khanna, 27, from Delhi are using social media to spread the right idea
Close
Here’s how you can gear up for the perfect Spring look; Model: Salman Hasan (An entrepreneur and fashion model)
Here’s how you can gear up for the perfect Spring look; Model: Salman Hasan (An entrepreneur and fashion model)

Men’s style and grooming by Yatan Ahluwalia: Spring it on!

By Yatan Ahluwalia
UPDATED ON JAN 17, 2021 05:39 PM IST
  • An all-round trend forecast for clothes and accessories, and the essential grooming guide for men for the much awaited months ahead
Close
For Trinetra Haldar Gummaraju, growing up transperson in India means a relentless othering
For Trinetra Haldar Gummaraju, growing up transperson in India means a relentless othering

“Growing up trans means a relentless othering”

By Trinetra Haldar Gummaraju, Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 16, 2021 06:49 PM IST
  • Karnataka’s first transgender doctor tells her story of transition and celebrating self-love
Close
Do what you must to get yourself through - weep, vent; and then get back on track(Shutterstock)
Do what you must to get yourself through - weep, vent; and then get back on track(Shutterstock)

Campus life by Zuni Chopra: Grieve. Strive.

By Zuni Chopra
PUBLISHED ON JAN 16, 2021 06:46 PM IST
  • Be as negative as you want. But through it all… keep going
Close
Indian cricketer Shikhar Dhawan’s Instagram Reels videos show him unabashedly at the core of some very entertaining action with his teammates during the 2020 IPL season in Dubai
Indian cricketer Shikhar Dhawan’s Instagram Reels videos show him unabashedly at the core of some very entertaining action with his teammates during the 2020 IPL season in Dubai

Social Media Star of the Week: Shikhar Dhawan

By Shruti Nair
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 06:42 PM IST
The cricketer wins this week because of the sheer ease with which he has taken to the Instagram feature even those half his age struggle with: Reels!
Close
Kusha Kapila and Dolly Singh, two former media colleagues who quickly became fast friends are Internet divas today – funny, entertaining and witty, just like the content they create; Art direction: Amit Malik; Styling assistant for Kusha Kapila: Meharjot; Styling for Saloni Gaur: Sagar Malhan; Make-up: Srishti Anand Mathur; Hair: Amlesh Thakur; Outfit, Ordinaree; jewellery, Studio Metallurgy; Styling for Dolly: self; Co-ord set, Zara(Shivamm Paathak )
Kusha Kapila and Dolly Singh, two former media colleagues who quickly became fast friends are Internet divas today – funny, entertaining and witty, just like the content they create; Art direction: Amit Malik; Styling assistant for Kusha Kapila: Meharjot; Styling for Saloni Gaur: Sagar Malhan; Make-up: Srishti Anand Mathur; Hair: Amlesh Thakur; Outfit, Ordinaree; jewellery, Studio Metallurgy; Styling for Dolly: self; Co-ord set, Zara(Shivamm Paathak )

HT Brunch Cover Story: Slay it with a smile with Kusha Kapila and Dolly Singh

By Shruti Nair
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 08:18 PM IST
How the “South Delhi Aunties” reinvented themselves as independent content creators and became India’s most popular women in comedy.
Close
The most famous versions of sourdough come from France and Germany.
The most famous versions of sourdough come from France and Germany.

Rude Food by Vir Sanghvi: Sourdough saga

UPDATED ON JAN 17, 2021 05:46 PM IST
The bread is now an Internet craze but it’s often not the real thing.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP