As SC demands roadmap for smog towers, experts debate efficacy and technology

Published on Nov 27, 2019 12:00 AM IST
HT Image
HT Image

New Delhi: A day after the Supreme Court asking the Centre to come up with a road map on installing smog towers in Delhi-NCR within 10 days to combat rising pollution, officials of the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) and the Delhi Pollution Control Committee (DPCC) met in the capital on Tuesday.

“We are deliberating on the project and will come up with a plan on how to implement it. There are various aspects that need to be looked into, as the project involves high costs and adequate space,” said a senior DPCC official.

“We will be meeting experts from the Department of Science and Technology and IIT scientists, who are working on this project, to be able to take a decision,” the official said.

Installation of smog towers to mitigate pollution was first proposed to CPCB in 2018. A proposed pilot project to consider the efficacy of smog towers is being undertaken by IIT-Bombay in collaboration with IIT-Delhi and the University of Minnesota. The US-based institution has helped build a smog tower in Xian, northern China.

“We have proposed a prototype on an experimental basis to deal with ‘severity’ of air pollution. It is to deal with acute situations and not the final solution to pollution. We have identified the University of Minnesota, which has been working in the field of filtration technology for the past 40 years. For the pilot, we will have to import filers from there while all the other work will be done here,” said a senior IIT-Bombay scientist.

Sri Harsha Kota, an assistant professor at the department of civil engineering, IIT- Delhi, who is closely associated with the project, said, “It is on an experimental stage and logistics still have to be decided. There is no data or a model as such to test its feasibility.”

The project is estimated to cost around Rs 10-12 crore, said project members at IIT-Delhi. Also, it would require building a 25-metre high concrete structure with a monitoring station and other equipment.

However, experts questioned the feasibility of the project given that Delhi is a congested city where space is at a premium. Also, they said, there have been no studies to assess the impact of this technology on the ambient air quality.

Santosh Harish, a fellow at the Centre for Policy Research said, smog towers may be the last resort in a place like Delhi, where the nature and scale of the problem is massive, but one must examine the proposal properly before investing in an untested technology.

“It may remove some dust from the vicinity, but controlling pollution at source may not be possible. Even in China, which has two such towers, this technology was not well received or widely implemented,” he said.

D Saha, former head of CPCB air laboratory, said smog towers are not suitable to Delhi’s meteorological conditions. “There is a constant intrusion of dust in Delhi because of various geographical and local factors. How much can a filter suck? A model such as this cannot be successful for a city like Delhi.”

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
  • ABOUT THE AUTHOR

    Vatsala Shrangi joined HT Editorial team on July 2, 2018 as Principal Correspondent. She covers Environment, Civic bodies and the Social Sector.

Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Police sources said the assailants had used a silencer while opening fire

    Petrol pump owner shot dead in Amritsar

    The owner of a fuel station was gunned down by unidentified car-borne persons in the Holy City colony of Amritsar on Wednesday night. The incident took place at around 10:30pm when Mohan had reached outside his home, after work. As per information, when Mohan reached just outside his house, a Toyota Innova SUV also reached there and the assailants in the car opened fire. Police commissioner Arun Pal confirmed Mohan's death.

  • Haryana deputy chief minister Dushyant Chautala suggested that the Bill be referred to a select committee of the House for examination. Subsequently, the home minister moved a motion to refer the amendment Bill to a select committee of the assembly. (HT File Photo)

    Haryana assembly passes 4 Bills, refers one to select committee

    The Haryana assembly on Wednesday referred to a select committee of the House the Haryana Police (Amendment) Bill, 2022 for examination. The amendment Bill which sought to do away with the powers of the Haryana State Police Complaints Authority to take suo motu cognisance of a matter was opposed by Congress MLA Varun Chaudhary. Deputy chief minister Dushyant Chautala suggested that the Bill be referred to a select committee of the House for examination.

  • Shiromani Akali Dal (SAD) leader Bikram Singh Majithia being greeted after being released from prison on bail, in Patiala district, Wednesday. (PTI)

    Faith in judiciary reposed, says SAD on Bikram Majithia’s release in drugs case

    The Shiromani Akali Dal on Wednesday said the party's faith in judiciary had been reaffirmed by the Punjab and Haryana high court's decision to grant bail to former minister Bikram Singh Majithia in a “politically motivated case of vendetta”. The party spokesperson asserted Majithia was not guilty of offences he has been charged with in the FIR registered in December, 2021, under different sections of Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985.

  • As the PRTC bus was being operated under the kilometre scheme, MACT directed its owner and driver to jointly pay the relief to the petitioner. (Getty Images/iStockphoto)

    Patiala man left disabled after accident gets 13-lakh relief

    Over five years after a Patiala resident suffered permanent disability in Kumar's arm due to an accident, the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Chandigarh, has awarded him a compensation of ₹13 lakh. The compensation will be paid by the owner and driver of the PRTC bus that had hit the car of the victim, Rohit Kumar, 33, a resident of Mangal Basti, Patran, Patiala.

  • The reserve prices of 17 freehold residential properties have been reduced by about 15% compared to the last e-tender. Bids can be submitted from August 16. (Getty Images/iStockphoto)

    Chandigarh Housing Board puts up 154 properties for sale

    The Chandigarh Housing Board has invited e-bids for 154 commercial and residential properties from August 16. CHB chief executive officer Yashpal Garg said, “The reserve prices of 17 residential units on freehold basis located at Indira Colony, Manimajra, have been reduced by about 15% compared to the last e-tender. As many as 30 residential units, including 2BHK and EWS flats, and one commercial unit have been included for the first time in the e-tender process.”

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Thursday, August 11, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now