Sign in

Jhansi hospital fire: Expired extinguishers, faulty alarms, say eyewitnesses; hospital refutes claims

Deputy chief minister Brijesh Pathak said a fire safety audit of the entire medical college was carried out in February this year

Updated on: Nov 17, 2024, 02:45:17 IST
Share
Share via
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin
  • whatsapp
Copy link
  • copy link

Jhansi Both the state health department and Maharani Laxmi Bai Medical College, where a late-night fire in its Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU) killed 10 newborns, have claimed that the ward was equipped with functioning fire extinguishers that were used to contain the flames.

Firefighters work after a fire broke out in a neonatal intensive care unit at Jhansi Medical College hospital in Jhansi (AP)
Firefighters work after a fire broke out in a neonatal intensive care unit at Jhansi Medical College hospital in Jhansi (AP)

However, it has emerged that the extinguishers had labels on them indicating that their expiry was due in 2022. Also, the fire alarm failed to activate during the incident. Eyewitnesses confirmed that the extinguishers were ineffective when used by hospital staff.

Eyewitnesses and first responders, including Kripal Singh Rajput, Kuldeep Sikarwar and Govind Das from Barauli Kharag in rural Jhansi, stated that a ward boy, Pawan, used four fire extinguishers in his attempt to put out the flames. “They [the extinguishers] did not discharge foam as they should have,” said Kripal and Govind.

The fire dousers had labels on them showing that they were refilled in 2019 and were set to expire in 2022. They had been supplied by Peetambara Fire Services in Jhansi. The company’s office did not respond to this reporter’s calls.

Kuldeep stated that the fire alarm installed above the entrance did not go off at all when the fire broke out.

Despite these concerns, the medical college and the health department maintained that the firefighting equipment was functional. The medical college’s chief medical officer, Dr. Satish Chandra insisted that the fire extinguishers were refilled in June this year. “Rudraksha Traders refilled the extinguishers in June, and we have receipts to prove it,” he added.

Deputy chief minister Brijesh Pathak also weighed in and stated that a fire safety audit of the entire medical college was carried out in February this year, and shortcomings that emerged during the exercise were promptly addressed. Additionally, a mock drill to assess emergency preparedness was conducted in June, he added.

When asked about the labels on the extinguishers, Pathak said it was common for the refilling companies to not remove old labels. “In this case, the old labels were not removed, and it is being looked into as to why this happened,” he said. “The medical college had installed four fire extinguishers in the ward. They were refilled in June and were working. A ward boy emptied all of them [in his attempt to put out the flames],” he added.

  • Haidar Naqvi
    ABOUT THE AUTHOR
    Haidar Naqvi

    Haidar Naqvi is an Assistant Editor with the Hindustan Times in Kanpur and has been with the newspaper since May 1997, after beginning his journalism career with The Times of India. Over more than three decades, he has reported on terrorism, internal security, politics, governance and public affairs, with a particular focus on the changing nature of extremist movements in India.From 2008 to 2011, Haidar was part of the Hindustan Times National Reporting Team, contributing to coverage of some of the country's most significant security stories. He was among the reporters who covered the 26/11 Mumbai terror attacks as they unfolded and continued reporting on the investigation that exposed the conspiracy behind them.His reporting has followed the rise and evolution of the Students Islamic Movement of India (SIMI), the Indian Mujahideen and India's counter-terrorism response, alongside extensive coverage of organised crime and the underworld. He has also reported on Indian Mujahideen serial blasts, the Maoist insurgency, communal riots, parliamentary and assembly elections, and major political developments. Over the years, he has interviewed political leaders, senior police officers, intelligence officials and policymakers, while reporting from communities affected by violence, conflict and public policy.Beyond national security, Haidar has covered politics, minority affairs, governance, wildlife and human-interest stories across Central Uttar Pradesh and Bundelkhand. A recipient of the coveted Hindustan Times' Star Award, he brings historical perspective, field experience and institutional knowledge to reporting on the intersection of security, governance and society.Read More