Brazil's Neymar appeals after a challenge in the penalty area from Costa Rica's Giancarlo Gonzalez during their FIFA World Cup 2018 Group E match at Saint Petersburg Stadium, Saint Petersburg, Russia on June 22, 2018.(REUTERS)
Brazil's Neymar appeals after a challenge in the penalty area from Costa Rica's Giancarlo Gonzalez during their FIFA World Cup 2018 Group E match at Saint Petersburg Stadium, Saint Petersburg, Russia on June 22, 2018.(REUTERS)

FIFA World Cup 2018: VAR controversy mars Brazil’s win over Costa Rica

Brazil beat Costa Rica 2-0 in their Group E encounter to put one foot into the knockout round of the FIFA World Cup 2018, but there was a controversial call made late in the game when Neymar was denied a penalty due to Video Assistant Referee (VAR).
By Shayne Dias | Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON JUN 22, 2018 08:16 PM IST

Brazil’s second Group game of the FIFA World Cup 2018 looked headed for a goalless draw as a stubborn Costa Rica defence and some wayward finishing left the Selacao frustrated. (BRA v CRC highlights)

Things seemed to look up in the 79th minute of the game when Neymar was brought down in the penalty area and the referee had no hesitation in pointing towards the spot.

He did, however, decide to use the Video Assistant Referee (VAR) to double check his decision. It was at this point when things got interesting.

The video replays showed that while there was contact made by the defender to pull Neymar down, it was minimal and the referee came to the conclusion that the forward made the most of the challenge.

READ | How Lionel Messi’s Argentina can qualify for FIFA World Cup 2018 knock-out round

The referee then overturned his decision, much to the angst of Brazil fans and players alike. The call to reverse the decision can be debated but there are two major issues that will likely be a source of contention among fans and experts.

For one, there appears to be a lack of consistency when it comes to referees deciding what constitutes a foul and on which part of the pitch.

Neymar has been known to go down easily in the past but there was definite contact made by the defender and had this foul been committed anywhere outside the penalty area, he would have been awarded a free-kick.

The logical call, therefore, would be to either not give free-kicks and penalties for tackles that see minimum contact or to award a foul whenever contact is made, regardless of the severity of the challenge.

READ | FIFA World Cup 2018: Lionel Messi goes missing on Argentina’s biggest night

It’s also worth noting that the referee did not book Neymar for simulation, despite the fact that this is usually the norm in such a situation.

Since the rules of the game are largely open to interpretation, the referee likely concluded that Neymar had not dived but rather simply did not make enough effort to stay on his feet after a weak challenge and therefore was not booked.

However, that would imply that he believed there was contact made by the defender, which once again brings up the issue of consistency in refereeing calls; after all, fouls are almost always awarded if there is any form of contact made.

But for now at least, the teething issues of using VAR will take a back-seat for Brazil as they had reason to celebrate by the end of the game.

READ | Diego Simeone says Argentina look lost, questions Messi in leaked audio

Late goals from Philippe Coutinho and Neymar saw them register a 2-0 win that knocked Costa Rica out of contention for a place in the next round.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
Tottenham Hotspur's Hugo Lloris celebrates with manager Jose Mourinho after the match (REUTERS)
Tottenham Hotspur's Hugo Lloris celebrates with manager Jose Mourinho after the match (REUTERS)

100 goals not bad for a negative team, says Tottenham boss Mourinho

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 05:44 AM IST
Until the current three-match winning run in the Premier League, Tottenham were sliding down the table with Mourinho's tactics coming under scrutiny.
Close
Manchester United's Luke Shaw celebrates scoring their second goal, against Manchester City, with teammates Pool via REUTERS/Peter Powell(REUTERS)
Manchester United's Luke Shaw celebrates scoring their second goal, against Manchester City, with teammates Pool via REUTERS/Peter Powell(REUTERS)

Manchester United down City in derby, Spurs rout Palace as Kane & Bale hit brace

Reuters
UPDATED ON MAR 08, 2021 06:54 AM IST
Pep Guardiola's side could have few complaints as a second-minute penalty converted by Bruno Fernandes and Luke Shaw's fine finish early in the second half earned United a surprise win.
Close
Real Madrid's Karim Benzema celebrates scoring their first goal with Casemiro (REUTERS)
Real Madrid's Karim Benzema celebrates scoring their first goal with Casemiro (REUTERS)

Atletico title pursuit stalled by late Madrid equalizer

AP
PUBLISHED ON MAR 07, 2021 11:14 PM IST
  • Karim Benzema, back in the Madrid squad after an injury layoff, scored in the 87th minute after Luis Suárez's early goal for Atlético at the Wanda Metropolitano Stadium.
Close
Fulham players celebrate at the end of the English Premier League soccer match between Liverpool and Fulham at Anfield stadium in Liverpool, England, Sunday, March 7, 2021.(AP)
Fulham players celebrate at the end of the English Premier League soccer match between Liverpool and Fulham at Anfield stadium in Liverpool, England, Sunday, March 7, 2021.(AP)

Liverpool suffer sixth straight Anfield loss as Fulham win 1-0

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON MAR 07, 2021 09:49 PM IST
Juergen Klopp made seven changes to the Liverpool side that lost 1-0 to Chelsea on Thursday but it made little difference as Lemina out-muscled Mohamed Salah on the edge of the box to take possession before lashing the ball home in the 45th minute.
Close
Roma's Lorenzo Pellegrini, foreground is challenged by Genoa's Gianluca Scamacca during the Serie A soccer match between Roma and Genoa at the Rome Olympic Stadium Sunday, March 7, 2021. (AP)
Roma's Lorenzo Pellegrini, foreground is challenged by Genoa's Gianluca Scamacca during the Serie A soccer match between Roma and Genoa at the Rome Olympic Stadium Sunday, March 7, 2021. (AP)

Roma beat Genoa 1-0 to move into Champions League places

AP
PUBLISHED ON MAR 07, 2021 08:15 PM IST
  • Genoa remained seven points above the relegation zone after its second loss in three matches. It had only lost one of the previous 10 since Davide Ballardini replaced Rolando Maran as coach.
Close
Robert Lewandowski celebrates his hat-trick. (Getty Images)
Robert Lewandowski celebrates his hat-trick. (Getty Images)

Lewandowski hat-trick steers Bayern past Dortmund 4-2

Reuters, Munich
PUBLISHED ON MAR 07, 2021 09:03 AM IST
  • Bayern Munich roared back from two goals down to beat Borussia Dortmund 4-2.
Close
Juventus moved to 52 points. (Juventus FC/Twitter)
Juventus moved to 52 points. (Juventus FC/Twitter)

Morata double fires Juventus to comeback win over Lazio

Reuters, Turin
PUBLISHED ON MAR 07, 2021 08:58 AM IST
  • Morata helped Juventus come from behind to beat Lazio 3-1 in Serie A.
Close
Lionel Messi set up goals scored by Jordi Alba and teenager Ilaix Moriba.(Getty Images)
Lionel Messi set up goals scored by Jordi Alba and teenager Ilaix Moriba.(Getty Images)

Messi grabs two assists as Barcelona march on with victory at Osasuna

Reuters, Estadio El Sadar, Pamplona
PUBLISHED ON MAR 07, 2021 08:01 AM IST
  • Messi helped Barca take the lead on the half-hour mark when he carved open Osasuna's defence with a superb cross-field ball to Alba, who controlled before blasting into the roof of the net.
Close
Daniel Amartey of Leicester City celebrates with Youri Tielemans after scoring the team's second goal. (Getty Images)
Daniel Amartey of Leicester City celebrates with Youri Tielemans after scoring the team's second goal. (Getty Images)

Leicester turn up heat in top-four race

Reuters, Brighton
PUBLISHED ON MAR 07, 2021 07:49 AM IST
  • Daniel Amartey's 88th-minute header completed a comeback win for Leicester who stretched their unbeaten away run to 10 games.
Close
NortEast vs ATK Mohun Bagan(ISL)
NortEast vs ATK Mohun Bagan(ISL)

Sylla’s late intervention keeps NorthEast level against Bagan

By Bhargab Sarmah
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 10:56 PM IST
  • The draw also extended NorthEast unbeaten run this season to 11, with 10 of those coming under interim head coach Khalid Jamil. The 43-year-old Indian coach made three changes to the side that had won 2-0 against Kerala Blasters in their last league game of the campaign.
Close
FILE PHOTO: Soccer Football - La Liga Santander - Real Madrid v Getafe - Estadio Alfredo Di Stefano, Madrid, Spain - February 9, 2021 Real Madrid's Karim Benzema celebrates scoring their first goal REUTERS/Sergio Perez/File photo(REUTERS)
FILE PHOTO: Soccer Football - La Liga Santander - Real Madrid v Getafe - Estadio Alfredo Di Stefano, Madrid, Spain - February 9, 2021 Real Madrid's Karim Benzema celebrates scoring their first goal REUTERS/Sergio Perez/File photo(REUTERS)

Benzema back for Real in time for derby showdown at Atletico

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 08:05 PM IST
Benzema has been out since injuring a muscle after scoring in a 2-0 win over Valencia on Feb. 14. Real have managed only one goal per game in the three matches he has missed, failing to score in the first half each time and relying on players such as Casemiro and Ferland Mendy to score instead.
Close
Arsenal manager Mikel Arteta: File photo(Pool via REUTERS)
Arsenal manager Mikel Arteta: File photo(Pool via REUTERS)

Improving Arsenal have long way to go, says Arteta

Reuters
UPDATED ON MAR 06, 2021 12:48 PM IST
Arsenal have turned their season around after a torrid start, winning seven of their last 12 Premier League games and netting 22 goals, having managed just 12 goals in their first 14 fixtures.
Close
Liverpool's Roberto Firmino reacts after missing a scoring chance during the English Premier League soccer match between Liverpool and Chelsea at Anfield stadium in Liverpool.(AP)
Liverpool's Roberto Firmino reacts after missing a scoring chance during the English Premier League soccer match between Liverpool and Chelsea at Anfield stadium in Liverpool.(AP)

Champions Liverpool keep sinking after fifth Anfield defeat in a row

By Bhargab Sarmah, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 08:01 AM IST
  • Chelsea dominated Thursday’s game and could have had more goals to add to Mason Mount’s exquisite first-half strike that turned out to be the match-winner.
Close
FC Goa vs Mumbai City FC
FC Goa vs Mumbai City FC

ISL semi-final: FC Goa draw with Mumbai City in the first leg

PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 12:01 AM IST
  • FC Goa attacked Dessai through Saviour Gama before twinkle-toed Jorge Ortiz tested him. By the 17th minute, Dessai had been caught out thrice; the last time because of a poor pass which Alexander Jesuraj intercepted needing a tackle from Vignesh Dakshinamurthy that could have been a penalty.
Close
The 52-year-old Juergen Klinsmann(REUTERS)
The 52-year-old Juergen Klinsmann(REUTERS)

Thomas Muller role model for Bayern Munich: Klinsmann

By Bhargab Sarmah
PUBLISHED ON MAR 05, 2021 09:57 PM IST
  • Muller wouldn’t feature regularly that season but he went on to score in the Champions League knockout stages coming on as a substitute against Sporting Lisbon.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP