It is important, however, to tread with caution and for governments to understand that they must adopt a systematic and transparent process to track air quality improvements over the years.(HT image)
It is important, however, to tread with caution and for governments to understand that they must adopt a systematic and transparent process to track air quality improvements over the years.(HT image)

AQI tracking needs sound analysis, transparent process

The difficulty in credibly tracking air quality arises from problems with the underlying data.
By Santosh Harish, Kurinji Selvaraj and Mandakini Chandra | New Delhi
UPDATED ON SEP 13, 2019 08:00 PM IST

Slowly but surely, air pollution is becoming a politically salient issue, at least in the national capital. Advertisements featuring the Delhi chief minister claiming a 25% reduction in five years have been followed by an inevitable push back from the Opposition on who deserves credit. Air quality may have finally become an election issue! In July, the Union environment minister had claimed improved air between 2016 to 2018.

It is important, however, to tread with caution and for governments to understand that they must adopt a systematic and transparent process to track air quality improvements over the years.

The difficulty in credibly tracking air quality arises from problems with the underlying data. One set of data relies on manual monitoring, and has been the basis of submissions to Parliament. Another set is based on continuous and automated monitoring, which is more reliable, but incomplete. We discuss the use and pitfalls of each of these below.

Comparing CPCB’s manual monitors

The first is the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) data submitted in the Parliament that come from the manual monitoring stations of the National Air Quality Monitoring Programme (NAMP). Chart 1 illustrates the annual averages of PM 2.5 (the main pollutant) for Delhi, using data submitted to the Parliament for 2014-2018, supplemented for 2012 and 2013 by information from CPCB’s 2013-14 annual report.

 

Contrary to a reduction, PM2.5 levels have nearly doubled from 2012 to 2018. However, the data used to compute annual NAMP averages is not available publicly, and are therefore hard to verify, and readings are taken infrequently. Therefore, this is unlikely to be a robust basis for tracking Delhi’s air quality.

Comparing CPCB’s continuous monitors

The parallel continuous monitoring network has more official monitoring stations, greater transparency, and much greater frequency of measurement. However, here the challenge for comparisons across years is to ensure continuous unbroken data from a consistent set of monitors, because air quality levels can vary substantially across a city like Delhi, and over the course of the year. Publicly available data has several data gaps that make like-for-like comparisons very difficult. This is precisely the challenge in Delhi, as can be seen from Chart 2. Even for a recent period like 2016-2018, these data issues inhibit any straightforward claims on air quality improvements.

 

For earlier years, the number of monitors with reliable data are paltry. In 2011, we would have to rely on one monitor – at ITO. Between, 2012-2014, we have 1-3 reliable monitors, but often with additional issues such as entire months missing. If we had to compare ITO data in 2011 with 2018, PM2.5 levels see a modest 12% reduction. But can we confidently make strong claims on air quality improvement on the basis of such scarce information? Unambiguously, no.

Urgent need for assessment protocol to track progress

On the positive side, Delhi’s monitoring network had become more robust in 2018, and will serve as a good basis for comparison in the future. With the National Clean Air Programme, the monitoring network in Delhi and 121 other cities will be expanded further, and cities have a 20-30% reduction target to achieve by 2024. However, without a well-defined assessment process established up front, we risk future debate about progress achieved. Such a process needs three components.

One, an assessment method that specifies monitors to consider, reliability criteria, and statistics (annual average, extreme events etc) to use. Two, transparency in official reporting with analysis steps outlined, and all underlying data being publicly accessible. Three, results must be replicable, so that any interested citizen should be able to repeat the analysis with the data and find the same results if the same steps are followed.

Agencies such as CPCB have stated that air quality levels have improved in the last few years. As residents of Delhi, we hope that the air has indeed become cleaner, and urge the government to use reliable regulatory data available to them to assess and report this in a systematic, transparent, and replicable manner. This is not an issue around which we should allow lingering doubts and guesswork.

Harish is a fellow at the Centre for Policy Research (santosh@cprindia.org). Selvaraj is a research analyst at the Council on Energy, Environment and Water (kurinji.selvaraj@ceew.in). Chandra is a research assistant at the Centre for Policy Research (mandakini@cprindia.org)

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
Around 40,000 trade associations have extended their support to the call for the bandh.(Ravindra Joshi/HT file photo)
Around 40,000 trade associations have extended their support to the call for the bandh.(Ravindra Joshi/HT file photo)

Farm unions, traders to join Bharat Bandh today

By HT Correspondent, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 03:21 AM IST
Issuing a statement, the Confederation of All India Traders (CAIT) — the umbrella body which has called for the strike — said that all commercial markets across the country will remain closed on February 26 against rising fuel prices, the new e-way bill and the goods and services tax (GST).
Close
Altogether, HT is aware of five NIC domain addresses – four with @gov.in suffixes and the fifth an @nic.in one – that have been used to launch cyber attacks.(File photo. Representative image)
Altogether, HT is aware of five NIC domain addresses – four with @gov.in suffixes and the fifth an @nic.in one – that have been used to launch cyber attacks.(File photo. Representative image)

Officials targeted in new phishing bid via govt IDs

By Anisha Dutta, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 26, 2021 01:30 AM IST
The attack, which took place on Monday, prompted the government’s IT departments to send out an alert the following day to large groups of officials, according to emails seen by HT.
Close
Tandav is facing at least 10 FIRs for hurting religious sentiments, intending to disturb caste and communal amity – charges punishable under Sections 153A and 295 of Indian Penal Code (IPC) with a maximum jail term of three years.(MINT_PRINT)
Tandav is facing at least 10 FIRs for hurting religious sentiments, intending to disturb caste and communal amity – charges punishable under Sections 153A and 295 of Indian Penal Code (IPC) with a maximum jail term of three years.(MINT_PRINT)

Tandav controversy: Amazon Prime executive’s bail plea rejected by Allahabad HC

By JItendra Sarin, Prayagraj
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 12:57 AM IST
A single-judge bench of justice Siddharth rejected the application of Amazon Prime Video’s Aparna Purohit in connection with the ongoing investigation against Tandav for allegedly outraging religious feelings and showing Hindu gods in poor light.
Close
The deceased are yet to be identified after a blast in a a firecracker factory in Tamil Nadu killed five people. (Getty Images).
The deceased are yet to be identified after a blast in a a firecracker factory in Tamil Nadu killed five people. (Getty Images).

5 dead, 19 injured in blast at firecracker factory near Tamil Nadu's Sivakasi

PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 12:18 AM IST
  • Fire engines and rescue teams were pressed into service and the injured are being treated at the Sivakasi government hospital.
Close
Karnataka chief minister BS Yediyurappa despite the threat to his own chair, has taken it upon himself to bring the BJP back to power with an absolute majority in the 2023 assembly elections. (FILE PHOTO).
Karnataka chief minister BS Yediyurappa despite the threat to his own chair, has taken it upon himself to bring the BJP back to power with an absolute majority in the 2023 assembly elections. (FILE PHOTO).

CM Yediyurappa, the recalcitrant conformist, turns 78

By Sharan Poovanna
UPDATED ON FEB 26, 2021 12:57 AM IST
  • A Bengaluru-based political analyst said that Yediyurappa's supporters may want to go in for low-key birthday celebrations even though detractors may post as many ads as possible to remind everyone of his age.
Close
Whale sharks are protected under the Wildlife Protection Act and are ‘endangered’ species in the International Union for Conservation of Nature. (HT PHOTO).
Whale sharks are protected under the Wildlife Protection Act and are ‘endangered’ species in the International Union for Conservation of Nature. (HT PHOTO).

Huge whale shark washes up on Odisha coast; locals push it back into the sea

By Debabrata Mohanty
PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 11:42 PM IST
  • Officials said some local youths spotted the big fish lying lifeless on the Sonapur coast on Thursday afternoon.
Close
The depth of the earthquake was 30-km, the NCS said.(File photo. Representative image)
The depth of the earthquake was 30-km, the NCS said.(File photo. Representative image)

Earthquake of 3.6 magnitude jolts Assam's Guwahati

Posted by Harshit Sabarwal | PTI
UPDATED ON FEB 26, 2021 12:07 AM IST
The earthquake took place at 10.33 pm and the epicentre was in Kamrup district near Guwahati, the National Center for Seismology said.
Close
The highest maximum day temperature in February in the last 10 years was recorded on February 20, 2016 when the mercury climbed to 40.9 degree Celsius. (HT FILE PHOTO).
The highest maximum day temperature in February in the last 10 years was recorded on February 20, 2016 when the mercury climbed to 40.9 degree Celsius. (HT FILE PHOTO).

Bhubaneswar records maximum day temperature pan-India for 2nd consecutive day

By Debabrata Mohanty
PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 10:56 PM IST
  • Officials in Bhubaneswar's Regional Meteorological Centre said the maximum temperature of 38 degrees Celsius in Bhubaneswar on Wednesday too was highest on that day.
Close
World's highest railway bridge over Chenab river in Reasi district will provide all-weather connectivity.(ANI File Photo)
World's highest railway bridge over Chenab river in Reasi district will provide all-weather connectivity.(ANI File Photo)

'Infrastructural marvel' Chenab bridge completes important milestone

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Amit Chaturvedi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 10:47 PM IST
The length of the Chenab bridge will be 1,315 metres with 17 spans, of which the span of the main arch across Chenab river will be 467 metres. The viaduct portion comprises a straight and curved portion.
Close
Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan addresses a press conference through video conferencing.(ANI)
Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan addresses a press conference through video conferencing.(ANI)

MP CM Shivraj Singh Chouhan urges people to avoid travelling to Maharashtra

PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 10:36 PM IST
  • In MP, the positivity rate increased to 2.3% on Thursday and there are 2,435 active cases in the state.
Close
Indian children wearing face masks as a precaution against Covid-19. (AP)
Indian children wearing face masks as a precaution against Covid-19. (AP)

'375 mn Indian children may suffer due to Covid-19 pandemic': CSE report

By HT Correspondent, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 25, 2021 11:00 PM IST
  • CSE’s director general Sunita Narian said Covid-19 had made the world’s poor poorer.
Close
Baba Ramdev releases the scientific research papers on the Patanali medicine for COVID-19, during a press conference in New Delhi,(PTI/ File photo)
Baba Ramdev releases the scientific research papers on the Patanali medicine for COVID-19, during a press conference in New Delhi,(PTI/ File photo)

Coronil row: Patanjali condemns IMA for seeking explanation from Health min

ANI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 10:27 PM IST
The Indian Medical Association (IMA) on Monday demanded an explanation from Union Health Minister Dr Harsh Vardhan for promoting Patanjali's Coronil Ayurvedic medicine.
Close
External affairs minister S Jaishankar. (HT archive)(HT_PRINT)
External affairs minister S Jaishankar. (HT archive)(HT_PRINT)

Jaishankar talks to Chinese counterpart Wang Yi, reviews disengagement on LAC

By Rezaul H Laskar | Edited by Sohini Sarkar
PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 10:04 PM IST
  • This was the first formal contact between Jaishankar and Wang since they met on the margins of a Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) meeting in Moscow on September 10 last year, and it came days after India and China pulled back frontline troops from strategic heights around Pangong Lake.
Close
File photo: Amazon Prime Video's content chief Aparna Purohit.(Twitter/@aparna1502)
File photo: Amazon Prime Video's content chief Aparna Purohit.(Twitter/@aparna1502)

Tandav row: HC denies anticipatory bail to Amazon Prime Video's commercial head

By JItendra Sarin
UPDATED ON FEB 25, 2021 09:51 PM IST
  • Aparna Purohit was accused of the inappropriate depiction of UP police personnel, Hindu deities and adverse portrayal of a character playing the PM.
Close
Union finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman at an event in Ahmedabad on Thursday.(ANI Photo)
Union finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman at an event in Ahmedabad on Thursday.(ANI Photo)

When will petrol and diesel prices be reduced? 'It's a dharam sankat', says FM

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Amit Chaturvedi
UPDATED ON FEB 25, 2021 09:56 PM IST
Earlier in the day, Reserve Bank of India (RBI) Governor Shaktikanta Das had said there is a need for coordinated action between the Centre and state governments to reduce taxes on petrol and diesel prices.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP