HT reviewed Twitter’s disclosures to the Lumen database — a nonprofit repository meant to track online censorship — on the Indian government’s requests and found that the company had removed 702 URLs in all.(AP)
HT reviewed Twitter’s disclosures to the Lumen database — a nonprofit repository meant to track online censorship — on the Indian government’s requests and found that the company had removed 702 URLs in all.(AP)

Tussle intensifies: Twitter, govt at odds over blocking

  • A government official, who asked not to be named, said Twitter cannot pick and choose which accounts to block.
By Deeksha Bhardwaj, Binayak Dasgupta, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 11, 2021 05:22 AM IST

Twitter on Wednesday said that it complied partially with the government’s requests to block access to accounts, but let others — particularly those by journalists, activists and politics — remain since the directions were “not consistent with Indian law”, prompting the government to express “disappointment” during a meeting with top executives of the social media company later in the day.

Twitter’s blog, which gave details of its actions, said: “...we do not believe that the actions we have been directed to take are consistent with Indian law.” And, it added, “in keeping with our principles of defending protected speech and freedom of expression, we have not taken any action on accounts that consist of news media entities, journalists, activists, and politicians. To do so, we believe, would violate their fundamental right to free expression under Indian law.”


The statement, released on Wednesday morning, prompted an initial response from the ministry of electronics and information technology (Meity) — significantly, on Koo, a home-made social media website meant to rival Twitter — and appeared to signal an escalation of a confrontation brewing for over a week.

Throughout the day, several government officials expressed dismay with Twitter’s actions, echoing remarks from last week when the government said the company was not in a position to judge its directions and had to follow them.

Representatives from the ministry and Twitter’s global policy and safety teams met later, where the Meity “secretary expressed his deep disappointment” about Twitter’s response. “He took this opportunity to remind Twitter that in India, its Constitution and laws are supreme. It is expected that responsible entities not only reaffirm but remain committed to compliance to the law of land,” Meity said in a statement after the meeting in the evening.

A government official, who asked not to be named, said Twitter cannot pick and choose which accounts to block. A second official, who asked not to be named, however, was more reconciliatory, saying that the company appeared to have “taken down 95% of the accounts and posts” the government flagged.

HT reviewed Twitter’s disclosures to the Lumen database — a nonprofit repository meant to track online censorship — on the Indian government’s requests and found that the company had removed 702 URLs in all. These included posts as well as accounts.

The government is believed to have handed over a list of 1,300 URLs (for accounts as well as posts) in its two orders.

The first government official quoted above said: “We respect freedom of expression, but it comes with reasonable restrictions. Hesitatingly taking action or begrudgingly taking down accounts is unacceptable.” The government, this person said, was seeking legal options while exercising restraint.

On its part, Twitter too said that it was seeking legal option. “We will continue to advocate for the right of free expression on behalf of the people we serve. We are exploring options under Indian law — both for Twitter and for the accounts that have been impacted,” it said.

The confrontation between the two sides started in the aftermath of the January 26 violence in the Capital during the farmers’ protests. The government first ordered Twitter to block 257 accounts citing emergency powers under section 69A of the IT Act, targeting accounts that it said were inciting violence during the protests.

On Wednesday, it elaborated further on why it defied the government orders and only partially restricted accounts: “Out of these (orders), two were emergency blocking orders that we temporarily complied with but subsequently restored access to the content in a manner that we believe was consistent with Indian law,” it said.

Legal experts say that at the heart of this dispute could be the nature of section 69A, which is opaque. “Under section 69A, and particularly rule 16, a company is under obligation of confidentiality, so we don’t actually know what reasons were cited by the government in its orders. It is not untenable for a private company to refuse to comply with directions under this section if it believes the direction is not consistent with law,” said Amber Sinha, technology lawyer and executive director of Centre for Internet and Society.

Sinha added that the government has broad powers under Section 69A, and there is a lack of clarity around the functioning of a Review Committee that is meant to evaluate the proportionality of emergency orders issued by invoking this section.

While the action has been partial, the company has still taken down hundreds of accounts, its blog post said.

The company said it took three steps to partially address the government’s directions: it reduced the visibility of certain hashtags “containing harmful content”, took enforcement action – “including permanent suspension” against over 500 accounts, and blocked from access in India several of the others identified by the government.

A Twitter spokesperson said the company had no further comment when asked to share details of what hashtags it acted against, which accounts it blocked on its own for misuse of its rules, and which accounts had been withheld in India.

Internet freedom activists said Twitter has typically pushed back strongly against governments in refusing to censor content, at times even defying laws in the United States, where the company is based. “There are a couple areas where they are much less restrictive than others, for example, when it comes to so-called terrorist content like the Hezbollah that US considers a terror group, and nudity and sex work. These are areas where they are not as restricting and these particular examples are interesting because they are pushing up against US law,” said Jillian C York, director for International Freedom of Expression at the Electronic Frontier Foundation, in an interview to HT.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
Police line tape. Crime scene investigation. Forensic science.(Getty Images)
Police line tape. Crime scene investigation. Forensic science.(Getty Images)

Mumbai man dies by suicide after killing father, grandfather, say police

By Vijay Kumar Yadav
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 02:29 PM IST
  • Police said the young man who murdered his father and grandfather was mentally unstable.
Close
HP chief minister Jai Ram Thakur addressing during the budget session of the state assembly in Shimla on Tuesday. (ANI)
HP chief minister Jai Ram Thakur addressing during the budget session of the state assembly in Shimla on Tuesday. (ANI)

HP MLAs to get full salary from April, MLALAD fund fully restored

PTI
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 02:27 PM IST
  • The state government had last year decided to cut 30 per cent salaries of its MLAs and suspend the MLALAD fund for two years to fight the COVID-19 pandemic.
Close
The ruling CPI(M)’s state secretary, Kodiyeri Balakrishnan, Monday said nobody attempted to settle the rape allegation levelled against his son.(PTI File Photo)
The ruling CPI(M)’s state secretary, Kodiyeri Balakrishnan, Monday said nobody attempted to settle the rape allegation levelled against his son.(PTI File Photo)

CPI (M) leader Kodiyeri’s wife summoned by Customs for builder’s smartphone gift

PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 02:11 PM IST
  • The smartphone gift has links to the gold smuggling case that the Customs busted last July.
Close
Supreme Court. (HT Archive.)
Supreme Court. (HT Archive.)

Supreme Court to commence hybrid physical hearings from March 15

PTI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 01:53 PM IST
The apex court has issued the standard operating procedure (SOP) for the hybrid physical hearings.
Close
India's total COVID-19 active cases have reached 1,80,304, comprising 1.61 per cent of the country’s total number of infections.(Reuters)
India's total COVID-19 active cases have reached 1,80,304, comprising 1.61 per cent of the country’s total number of infections.(Reuters)

15 lakh people vaccinated against Covid-19 on March 5, highest in a day: Centre

Posted by Joydeep Bose | PTI, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 06, 2021 02:00 PM IST
The countrywide Covid-19 vaccination drive was rolled out on January 16 with healthcare workers (HCWs) getting inoculated. The vaccination of frontline workers (FLWs) had started on February 2.
Close
Farmers block Western Peripheral Expressway near Rohtak on 100th day of protest, in Haryana.(Sanjeev Verma/Hindustan Times)
Farmers block Western Peripheral Expressway near Rohtak on 100th day of protest, in Haryana.(Sanjeev Verma/Hindustan Times)

100 days of farm laws protest: Farmers block major expressways. See pictures

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Deepali Sharma, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 06, 2021 01:25 PM IST
To mark the 100th day of the landmark protest, protesting farmers' unions decided to observe March 6 as the 'Black Day'.
Close
A police team which rushed to scene of fighting between the two group also came under attack. (Representational photo/Getty Images)
A police team which rushed to scene of fighting between the two group also came under attack. (Representational photo/Getty Images)

3 killed, 9 injured as dispute over land turns violent in Bihar’s Munger

PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 01:07 PM IST
  • Two groups had been trying to build a wall around a plot of land that is said to belong to a mutth.
Close
Farmers block Western Peripheral Expressway near Rohtak on 100th day of protest, in Haryana.(HT photo)
Farmers block Western Peripheral Expressway near Rohtak on 100th day of protest, in Haryana.(HT photo)

Farmers gather at western peripheral expressway as agitation completes 100 days

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Shivani, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 06, 2021 01:06 PM IST
As the capital braces for scorching summers and the harvesting season begins, farmers gathering on Saturday asserted that they had no plans to turn back until their demands were met.
Close
Rajya Sabha MP and Shiv Sena leader Sanjay Raut(HT file)
Rajya Sabha MP and Shiv Sena leader Sanjay Raut(HT file)

News updates from HT: Mumbai police capable of probing Mansukh Hiren's death

PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 12:56 PM IST
Here are today’s top news, analysis and opinion. Know all about the latest news and other news updates from Hindustan Times.
Close
Dinesh Trivedi joined the BJP on Saturday in Delhi in the presence of party chief JP Nadda and Union minister Piyush Goyal. (ANI)
Dinesh Trivedi joined the BJP on Saturday in Delhi in the presence of party chief JP Nadda and Union minister Piyush Goyal. (ANI)

'Now, he is in the right party': Nadda welcomes Dinesh Trivedi to BJP

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON MAR 06, 2021 02:49 PM IST
The former Trinamool MP said it was the golden moment he had been waiting for. BJP president J P Nadda said Trivedi was the right person in the wrong party
Close
Twenty-five nations across the world have already received Made-in India vaccines and forty-nine more countries will be supplied in the coming days, ranging from Europe, Latin America and the Caribbean to Africa, South-East Asia and the Pacific Islands. (Representative Image)(AFP)
Twenty-five nations across the world have already received Made-in India vaccines and forty-nine more countries will be supplied in the coming days, ranging from Europe, Latin America and the Caribbean to Africa, South-East Asia and the Pacific Islands. (Representative Image)(AFP)

India airlifts Covid-19 vaccines to Somalia

ANI
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 12:36 PM IST
Under the Vaccine Maitri initiative, India has been providing coronavirus vaccines to its neighbouring countries.
Close
Shiv Sena Rajya Sabha MP Sanjay Raut. (HT File Photo)
Shiv Sena Rajya Sabha MP Sanjay Raut. (HT File Photo)

Mumbai police capable of probing Mansukh Hiren's death, says Shiv Sena

PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 12:22 PM IST
  • Shiv Sena's Sanjay Raut dismissed the opposition's demand for an investigation into Mansukh Hiren's death by the NIA
Close
It is being speculated that Mithun Chakraborty and Sourav Ganguly may attend PM Modi's Brigade rally tomorrow.
It is being speculated that Mithun Chakraborty and Sourav Ganguly may attend PM Modi's Brigade rally tomorrow.

PM Modi's Brigade rally: BJP clarifies about Mithun Chakraborty, Sourav Ganguly

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON MAR 06, 2021 12:17 PM IST
West Bengal BJP has neither denied nor accepted the speculations, which intensifies the suspense.
Close
Actor Taapsee Pannu is currently shooting for her film Loop Lapeta.(HT_PRINT)
Actor Taapsee Pannu is currently shooting for her film Loop Lapeta.(HT_PRINT)

'According to our finance minister': What Taapse Pannu said on 2013 I-T raids

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON MAR 06, 2021 12:58 PM IST
The raids were also to search her memories of the 2013 raid that happened at her properties, Taapsee Pannu said on Saturday.
Close
Odisha Chief Minister Naveen Patnaik.(HT photo)
Odisha Chief Minister Naveen Patnaik.(HT photo)

Odisha: State govt to increase funds for MSMEs, says CM Patnaik

ANI
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 10:45 AM IST
While inaugurating the MSME Trade fair 2021 through Video conferencing, the Chief Minister said "In the next financial year, the budget of MSME Department is being substantially increased.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP