Babatdor Dkhar says song lyrics do not have the same artistic value as poetry and novels.(Bobdylan/Facebook)
Babatdor Dkhar says song lyrics do not have the same artistic value as poetry and novels.(Bobdylan/Facebook)

Why Bob Dylan didn’t deserve Nobel Prize for Literature

Babatdor Dkhar argues why Bob Dylan should not have been awarded the Nobel Prize for Literature. He should be competing with Paul McCartney and Bruce Springsteen. He has no business competing with the likes of Salman Rushdie, he says.
By Babatdor Dkhar | Hindustan Times
UPDATED ON OCT 14, 2016 02:50 PM IST

The Swedish Academy, in its citation, while awarding the Nobel Prize in Literature to the American musician Bob Dylan credited him with “having created new poetic expressions within the great American song tradition”.

Yes, the general consensus is that Bob Dylan is a great musician, and probably one of the greatest.

While I may not share in the sentiment of his genius as an artist, this is not a critique of his musical abilities. But a slight bewilderment at the decision of the Nobel Committee to award Mr Robert Allen Zimmerman the Nobel Prize in Literature.

While the laureates for the Nobel Peace Prize have raised many an eyebrow, a lingering hope was that prize in literature remains just that -- a most exclusive prize for people whose contributions to language and literature have been life-ling endeavours.

And with the awarding of the Nobel Prize in Literature to a musician, an individual whose life-long works were anything but the pursuit of literature, the elevated meaning of the prize feels rather stained.

“But who are you to call what Bob Dylan created not literature?” I am asked.

A fan and lover of literature is a most simple reply. An admirer who knows that what Dylan has produced artistically falls short of its very strict definition, let alone be in the same ballpark as the works of previous winners like Gunter Grass, Orhan Pamuk, Doris Lessing and VS Naipaul. There are many more writers whose works dwarf Dylan’s. It makes me cringe to even write that because its apples and oranges. Never once would I argue for a Julian Barnes’ novel to win the Grammy Award for Best Record, and using the same line of reasoning, a Nobel Prize in Literature for Bob Dylan is laughable, and downright lazy on the part of a committee that thought this was a good idea.

(File) Author Salman Rushdie won the Booker Prize for his book Midnight’s Children. (AP)
(File) Author Salman Rushdie won the Booker Prize for his book Midnight’s Children. (AP)

Tim Stanley, in writing for The Telegraph, goes a step further and argues that it seems to be a dumbing down of culture, and that a world that gives Bob Dylan a Nobel Prize in Literature is a world that nominates Donald Trump for President. Harsh words, I must say, but I understand that annoyance behind it. This need to be so popular, so over-and-beyond the fringes that what we get out of, is the most insane.

Where do we draw the line? Would Chetan Bhagat for the Man Booker Prize be a step too far? He writes books, and more people in India read Bhagat more than they do Thayil! Should an actor or celebrity win a sporting award because he/she has been at the forefront of efforts to popularise and commercialise that sport?

The New York Times wrote that in choosing a popular musician for the literary world’s highest honour, the Swedish Academy, which awards the prize, dramatically redefined the boundaries of literature, setting off a debate about whether song lyrics have the same artistic value as poetry or novels.

And the answer is a resounding no. Song lyrics do not have the same artistic value as poetry and novels. Different art-forms require different aptitude and creative talent. The construction of characters and plots differs from what it takes to write a song.

“Isn’t all creative output literature?”

Not really, a music album is not literature, and a novel is not music. The fallacy of such a question and argument is that if everything is an entity, then nothing is.

Bob Dylan should be in contention for prizes with Paul McCartney and Bruce Springsteen. He has no business competing with the likes of Salman Rushdie, Don DeLillo and Ian McEwan.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
Singer Akhil’s latest song Dooja Pyaar has been garnering good response from the audience.
Singer Akhil’s latest song Dooja Pyaar has been garnering good response from the audience.

Singer Akhil: Favouritism in Bollywood is reason why many singers lose out on opportunities

By Shreya Mukherjee, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 04:15 PM IST
Singer Akhil talks about his latest song Dooja Pyaar and why he didn’t take up any other work in Bollywood after his debut with Duniyaa in Luka Chuppi in 2019.
Close
Singer Adele arrives at the 58th Grammy Awards in Los Angeles, California.(REUTERS)
Singer Adele arrives at the 58th Grammy Awards in Los Angeles, California.(REUTERS)

Adele comes to agreement over her $190 million fortune in divorce settlement

PUBLISHED ON JAN 22, 2021 09:24 PM IST
  • Adele has reached a divorce settlement with her estranged husband, Simon Konecki. At stake is her $190 million fortune.
Close
Singer Sukhbir Singh’s latest song Nachdi has been getting good response.
Singer Sukhbir Singh’s latest song Nachdi has been getting good response.

Sukhbir: Misleading listeners with fake likes and views doesn’t make a song hit

By Shreya Mukherjee, New Delhi
UPDATED ON JAN 22, 2021 07:43 PM IST
Singer Sukhbir Singh, who released his latest song Nachdi online, suggests young musicians to follow the same procedure and not wait for music labels to give them the platform to start their journey.
Close
Singer Narendra Chanchal passed away in Delhi due to age-related issues.
Singer Narendra Chanchal passed away in Delhi due to age-related issues.

‘Superstar’ of bhajans Narendra Chanchal no more, mourned by fans and stars

By Shreya Mukerjee & Nikita Deb
UPDATED ON JAN 22, 2021 05:42 PM IST
Celebrated bhajan singer Narendra Chanchal, 80, passed away on Friday
Close
Narendra Chanchal has died at the age of 80.
Narendra Chanchal has died at the age of 80.

Bhajan singer Narendra Chanchal dies at 80, tributes pour in

UPDATED ON JAN 22, 2021 03:30 PM IST
Popular devotional songs singer Narendra Chanchal has died. The 80-year-old breathed his last in Delhi on Friday.
Close
Akull’s new song Faraar in collaboration with Mellow D has garnered over 14 million views on YouTube.
Akull’s new song Faraar in collaboration with Mellow D has garnered over 14 million views on YouTube.

I hope we can start live performances by the second half of this year: Akull

By Nikita Deb
PUBLISHED ON JAN 22, 2021 12:21 PM IST
The year 2020 was a difficult one for celebrities and the common man alike
Close
Gigi Hadid with her daughter Khai.
Gigi Hadid with her daughter Khai.

Gigi Hadid, Zayn Malik finally reveal daughter's name. Here's what it means

PUBLISHED ON JAN 22, 2021 10:53 AM IST
Gigi Hadid and Zayn Malik found a very subtle way to reveal the name of their daughter. The baby was born last year and the couple have been keeping her face hidden on social media.
Close
Neha Kakkar and Rohanpreet Singh got married in October last year after a whirlwind romance.
Neha Kakkar and Rohanpreet Singh got married in October last year after a whirlwind romance.

Neha Kakkar warns Rohanpreet Singh’s ex-girlfriend not to call him. Watch video

PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 12:52 PM IST
Neha Kakkar, via an Instagram post, jokingly warned her husband Rohanpreet Singh's ex-girlfriend to stay away from him and not call him.
Close
Ustad Ghulam Mustafa Khan was also a Padma Vibhushan awardee.
Ustad Ghulam Mustafa Khan was also a Padma Vibhushan awardee.

Ustad Ghulam Mustafa Khan dies: AR Rahman, Lata Mangeshkar pay tributes

PUBLISHED ON JAN 17, 2021 07:00 PM IST
AR Rahman, Lata Mangeshkar, Hansal Mehta and many others have paid their tributes as legendary singer Ustad Ghulam Mustafa Khan died on Sunday.
Close
Ustad Ghulam Mustafa Khan(HT ARCHIVE)
Ustad Ghulam Mustafa Khan(HT ARCHIVE)

Padma Vibhushan awardee Ustad Ghulam Mustafa Khan passes away at 89

PTI
UPDATED ON JAN 17, 2021 05:15 PM IST
  • Indian classical musician and Padma Vibhushan awardee Ustad Ghulam Mustafa Khan passes away at 89
Close
Javed Akhtar got birthday wishes from his wife Shabana Azmi and son Farhan Akhtar.
Javed Akhtar got birthday wishes from his wife Shabana Azmi and son Farhan Akhtar.

Farhan, Shabana Azmi, Alia Bhatt wish Javed Akhtar on his birthday. See pics

PUBLISHED ON JAN 17, 2021 03:10 PM IST
Javed Akhtar celebrated his 76th birthday on Sunday and his family and friends shared the loveliest wishes for him on social media.
Close
Singer-composer Kailash Kher (Sourced photo)
Singer-composer Kailash Kher (Sourced photo)

Kailash Kher: Our vaccine anthem is for entire mankind!

By Deep Saxena
PUBLISHED ON JAN 17, 2021 03:04 PM IST
Singer-composer Kailash Kher recently lent his magical voice to anthem ‘Jeet Ki Tayyari’ that has been released in wake of nation-wide Covid-19 vaccination drive that kick-started on Saturday.
Close
Priyanka Chopra has been working from home on her new book.
Priyanka Chopra has been working from home on her new book.

Priyanka Chopra gives peek inside quirky blue bedroom as she works on Unfinished

PUBLISHED ON JAN 15, 2021 08:44 AM IST
Actor Priyanka Chopra is in London and working on her upcoming autobiography, Unfinished. She is currently in the process of recording the audiobook version, right at home.
Close
Adnan Sami has tweeted in defence of Lata Mangeshkar.
Adnan Sami has tweeted in defence of Lata Mangeshkar.

Adnan Sami slams person who said Lata Mangeshkar doesn't have a good voice

UPDATED ON JAN 15, 2021 07:52 AM IST
Singer Adnan Sami has reacted strongly to a Twitter user who said that Indians have been 'brainwashed' into believing that Lata Mangeshkar is a good singer.
Close
Sachet Tandon and Parampara Thakur are loving married life.
Sachet Tandon and Parampara Thakur are loving married life.

Sachet-Parampara on being happily married: It added so much to us professionally

By Juhi Chakraborty
PUBLISHED ON JAN 13, 2021 05:41 PM IST
Music composer and lyricist duo, Sachet Tandon and Parampara Thakur say their days are growing beautifully and both are enjoying their married life.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP