Nestle baby food row: Company found at wrong foot, still let off with warning

Updated on Jul 25, 2014 11:40 AM IST
Pronouncing the verdict in 2012 baby food samples of Nestle India Limited seized by district health authorities after the company attempted to sell it in the market by declaring health benefits for kids indirectly suggesting it a replacement of breastfeeding, the court of adjudicating officer-cum-additional deputy commissioner RC Birdhan last week disposed of the case with a mere warning.
HT Image
HT Image
Hindustan Times | BySat Singh, Rohtak

Pronouncing the verdict in 2012 baby food samples of Nestle India Limited seized by district health authorities after the company attempted to sell it in the market by declaring health benefits for kids indirectly suggesting it a replacement of breastfeeding, the court of adjudicating officer-cum-additional deputy commissioner RC Birdhan last week disposed of the case with a mere warning.

Notably, a health department team led by food safety officer on August 3, 2012, had raided the premises of Manmohan Kumar and Swanmal Amirchand and seized 50 cartons of tin-packed Nestle Lactogen 1(infant formula milk powder) of 450gm each.

The samples of seized product were sent to a food analyst, Chandigarh. According to the report of the analyst, the labels on baby food claimed health benefits such as growth and development, easy digestion, brain development, healthy vision etc.

The containers also had pictures of two baby birds with a mother bird with nest displayed on it apart from the Nestle logo to give an impression that the product was equivalent to the mother's milk.

The report said that all the declarations were in contravention of 2.3.1:3 of the Food Safety and Standards (Packaging and labelling) Act, 2011, hence the sample was misbranded and substandard. After an appeal by respondents, the samples were sent to Referral Food Laboratory, Ghaziabad (UP), which concluded their report on the similar lines.

ADC RC Birdhan in 2013 in a press interaction had claimed to take serious note of the violations of Food Safety Act done by Nestle India Limited and said that heavy fine may be imposed on the respondents.

Now, according to his verdict (in possession of HT), he said: "I have come to the conclusion that the company has made mistake by displaying picture of two baby birds with a mother bird with nest but the company did not increase its saleability during the period under dispute. The company has given in writing that they would not repeat such mistake. Hence, under the provision section 52(2)1, I issue the directions to the Nestle India Limited to rectify their mistake. The case is disposed of and warning is issued to the respondents."

Another case pending

It is noteworthy, that another probe is pending against Nestle India Limited under Infant Milk Substitute Act (IMS)(2013) which is of more grievous nature, wherein samples worth crores of rupees were sealed by Food and Drug Administration, Haryana, from the Nestle factory at Samalkha in Panipat in 2012. Surprisingly, no action has been taken so far against Nestle in the said case.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • A gunfight erupted between militants and security forces in Kandra Hill area of Rajouri, officials said on Sunday. (ANI image for representational purpose)

    Gunfight breaks out with terrorists in Rajouri

    A gunfight erupted between militants and security forces in Kandra Hill area of Rajouri, officials said on Sunday. Defence spokesperson Lt Col Devender Anand said, “Today, around 7.30pm, an operational contact was established by troops of Indian Army, Rashtriya Rifles and SOG with terrorists at Kandra Hill in Rajouri.” A senior police officer said that a team of police and army launched a cordon and search operation in Kandra Hill on a specific input.

  • Final touches being given to a multiplex ahead of its opening, in Srinagar on Sunday. (PTI)

    Kashmir’s first multiplex set to open early next monthin Sonawar

    Come September and film aficionados in Kashmir will be able to watch the latest movies on the big screen as the Valley's first multiplex is set to open in the Sonawar area here. The multiplex, being developed in collaboration with leading theatre chain INOX, will have three movie halls with a total capacity of 520 seats, its owner Vijay Dhar told PTI. It will house several food courts, where Dhar plans to promote local cuisine.

  • The Clock Tower at Lal Chowk illuminated on the eve of 75th Independence Day in Srinagar on Sunday. (Waseem Andrabi / Hindustan Times)

    J&K enthusiasm breaking all records: LG Manoj Sinha on Har Ghar Tiranga drive

    A walkathon was organised on the banks of Dal Lake in Srinagar on Sunday in which Lieutenant Governor Manoj Sinha, along with many senior civil, security officials and hundreds of security personnel, besides people marched holding Tricolour in hands. The walkathon, a part of the 'Har Ghar Tiranga' campaign, was organised by the Border Security Force from the Lalit Ghat to the Botanical Garden.

  • DGP Dilbag Singh on Sunday said that attempts were being made from the other side of the Line of Control (LoC) to push dormant militants into the union territory as a part of a conspiracy. (Image for representational purpose)

    Situation in J&K much better now: DGP Dilbag Singh

    Srinagar Jammu and Kashmir director general of police Dilbag Singh on Sunday said that attempts were being made from the other side of the Line of Control (LoC) to push dormant militants into the union territory as a part of a conspiracy. The DGP, however, said the infiltration has been very negligible. The DGP said that J&K's security situation is much better now.

  • Dairy farmers of Punjab on Saturday threatened to stage an indefinite dharna in front of Verka Milk Plant, Ludhiana, on August 24 against the non-implementation of the economic package announced by state government. (Shutterstock)

    Punjab dairy farmers to go on indefinite dharna from Aug 24

    Dairy farmers of Punjab on Saturday threatened to stage an indefinite dharna in front of Verka Milk Plant, Ludhiana, on August 24 against the non-implementation of the economic package announced by state government. “We had high expectations from the new government, but on the contrary, after the formation of the government, difficulties of dairy farmers have increased,” said progressive dairy farmers association president Daljit Singh Sadarpura.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Monday, August 15, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now