A view of Supreme court in New Delhi(Amal KS/HT PHOTO)
A view of Supreme court in New Delhi(Amal KS/HT PHOTO)

No obligation on government to provide reservation, says Supreme Court

The top court also said that an individual does not have a fundamental right to claim reservation, and it is for the government to decide whether reservations are required in appointments and promotions.
By Murali Krishnan | Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 09, 2020 12:42 PM IST

The government is not bound to provide reservation for appointments and promotions to public posts, and courts cannot give directions compelling states to reserve jobs or positions for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (SC/STs), the Supreme Court has said in a judgment.

The top court also said that an individual does not have a fundamental right to claim reservation, and it is for the government to decide whether reservations are required in appointments and promotions.

“…there is no doubt that the state government is not bound to make reservations. There is no fundamental right which inheres in an individual to claim reservation in promotions. No mandamus can be issued by the Court directing the State Government to provide reservations”, the February 7 judgment by justices L Nageswara Rao and Hemant Gupta said.

The court, therefore, set aside an Uttarakhand high court ruling quashing a 2012 state government decision to fill up all posts in public services in the state without providing any reservations to SC/STs.

The court reaffirmed the law in this regard, holding that constitutional provisions contained in Article 16 regarding reservation are only enabling provisions, and it is up to the government to decide whether it should provide reservations in exercise of those powers under the Constitution.

“Article 16 (4) and 16 (4-A) empower the State to make reservation in matters of appointment and promotion in favour of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes if in the opinion of the State they are not adequately represented in the services of the State. It is for the state government to decide whether reservations are required in the matter of appointment and promotions to public posts of the State”, the judgment said.

The court held that the state, while deciding whether to provide reservation or not, can form its own opinion on the basis of the material it has in its possession already or it may gather such material through a commission, committee, person or authority.

However, the court also said that if the government wishes to exercise its discretion and make provisions for reservation for a class of people, it has to collect quantifiable data showing the inadequacy of representation of that class in public services. If the decision of the state government to provide reservations in promotion is challenged, the state concerned shall have to place before the court the requisite quantifiable data and satisfy the court that such reservations were necessary on account of inadequacy of representation.

The top court placed reliance on its earlier judgments in the Indra Sawhney (1992), Ajit Singh (1999), M Nagaraj (2006) and Jarnail Singh (2018) cases, in which it had ruled that Articles 16 (4) and 16 (4-A) are enabling provisions and the collection of quantifiable data showing inadequacy of representation of SC/STs in public service is essential for providing reservations in promotions.

Such data, the court said, needs to be collected only when the government is providing for reservation, and is not required when the state government has decided not to provide reservation.

“Not being bound to provide reservations in promotions, the State is not required to justify its decision on the basis of quantifiable data, showing that there is adequate representation of members of the Scheduled Castes and Schedules Tribes in state services,” the judgment stated.

Thus, the court held that even if the underrepresentation of SC/STs in public services is brought to the notice of the court, no direction can be issued by the court to the state government to provide reservation.

Therefore, the court also set aside the direction by the high court that the state government should first collect data regarding the adequacy or inadequacy of representation of SC/STs in government services on the basis of which it should decide whether or not to provide reservation in promotion.

The issue of reservation for SC/STs has been a contentious topic. A petition arguing that the “creamy layer” among SC/STs should be excluded from the benefits of reservation available to those communities is pending in the Supreme Court.

The petitioner in that case, NGO Samta Andolan Samiti, has contended that benefits accorded to SC/STs in reservation and other government schemes do not reach people who are actually in need of the benefits and are restricted to the “creamy layer” of those communities.

The central government opposed the petition, arguing that the creamy layer principle should not be applied to SCs/STs since they have been disadvantaged for centuries. It added that the principle, which is based on economic parameters, need not necessarily translate into sociocultural upliftment.

In 2018, the Supreme Court, in the judgment in Jarnail Singh & Ors. v Lachhmi Narain Gupta & Ors. had held that the principle of creamy layer, previously applicable to Other Backward Classes (OBCs), should be applied to SC/ST communities as well for reservation in promotions.

For OBCs, the creamy layer comprises households with annual income in excess of ~8 lakh a year.

The central government has requested the Supreme Court to re-examine the Jarnail Singh judgment.

“The object of reservation is to do away with sociocultural discrimination that SC/ST communities have faced for the past thousands of years. Even today, we see that many students from SC/ST communities who are not in financially disadvantaged position face systemic discrimination in prestigious public educational institutions. In such a scenario, the request by the Centre to reconsider Jarnail Singh cannot be faulted,” assistant professor at National Law University, Delhi, Sophy KJ, told HT.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
India and Pakistan on Thursday announced that they have agreed to strictly observe all agreements on ceasefire along the Line of Control (LoC) in Jammu and Kashmir and other sectors. (Representative Image)(HT Representative Photo)
India and Pakistan on Thursday announced that they have agreed to strictly observe all agreements on ceasefire along the Line of Control (LoC) in Jammu and Kashmir and other sectors. (Representative Image)(HT Representative Photo)

India-Pak ceasefire agreement rekindles hope for peace among border residents

PTI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 04:03 PM IST
For the past few years, Pakistan has engaged in shelling and firing along the LoC and the International Border (IB) resulting in casualties, damage to houses, schools, health centres and religious places.
Close
Smriti Irani rode a scooter on Friday in West Bengal taking part in BJP's campaign.
Smriti Irani rode a scooter on Friday in West Bengal taking part in BJP's campaign.

A day after Mamata Banerjee, Smriti Irani rides scooter in Bengal

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Poulomi Ghosh
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 03:54 PM IST
While Mamata's scooter ride was a symbolic protest against the fuel price rise — she was riding an e-scooter — Smriti on Friday took part in her party's roadshow in the district bordering Kolkata
Close
"Containment zones continue to be demarcated carefully. Prescribed containment measures are strictly being followed within these zones and Covid-appropriate behaviour is being promoted and strictly enforced," a government release said.
"Containment zones continue to be demarcated carefully. Prescribed containment measures are strictly being followed within these zones and Covid-appropriate behaviour is being promoted and strictly enforced," a government release said.

MHA extends existing Covid guidelines till March 31

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Prashasti Singh
UPDATED ON FEB 26, 2021 04:12 PM IST
All states and Union Territories have also been advised to speed up the vaccination of the target population in order to break the chain of virus transmission.
Close
File photo of a Maoist camp.
File photo of a Maoist camp.

Why Maoist violence has gone down in Chhattisgarh in last two years

UPDATED ON FEB 26, 2021 03:51 PM IST
The number of gunbattles came down to 84 last year compared to 121 in 2019, 166 in 2018, 198 in 2017, and 211 in 2016 even as officials cautioned against reading too much into the data
Close
Panchayat libraries in Jamtara have given youth hope of a better future.(HT Photo)
Panchayat libraries in Jamtara have given youth hope of a better future.(HT Photo)

India’s cyber crime hub Jamtara scripting new story with public library mission

By Sanjoy Dey, Ranchi
UPDATED ON FEB 26, 2021 03:49 PM IST
  • As many as 88 libraries have been made functional in 88 panchayat. All the panchayats of the district will have a library in the next fortnight. The libraries came as blessing for the poor and deprived students, who dream to crack examinations of various government services
Close
Chief election commissioner Sunil Arora. (File photo)
Chief election commissioner Sunil Arora. (File photo)

Assembly Election 2021 full schedule: When, where and how to watch

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Karan Manral, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 26, 2021 03:30 PM IST
The Election Commission of India (ECI) will hold a press conference at 4:30pm to announce the poll schedule for Assam, Kerala, Puducherry, Tamil Nadu and West Bengal.
Close
The United Nations refugee agency had raised the alarm earlier this week over the missing boat, which had left Cox's Bazar on Feb. 11. REUTERS/Navesh Chitrakar/File Photo(REUTERS)
The United Nations refugee agency had raised the alarm earlier this week over the missing boat, which had left Cox's Bazar on Feb. 11. REUTERS/Navesh Chitrakar/File Photo(REUTERS)

Indian coast guard rescue 81 Rohingya refugees adrift at sea, 8 dead

Reuters, Kolkata/dhaka
UPDATED ON FEB 26, 2021 03:17 PM IST
  • The Indian government was in discussions with Bangladesh to agree for the safe return of the vessel, which was found drifting in international waters.
Close
Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey has said Twitter is not alone in facing a trust deficit.(REUTERS)
Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey has said Twitter is not alone in facing a trust deficit.(REUTERS)

Day after govt's social media rules, Twitter says, 'Many people don't trust us'

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON FEB 26, 2021 03:18 PM IST
Centre has announced a host of rules according to which social media platforms will have to act quickly if some content is flagged by the government.
Close
Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla. (ANI)
Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla. (ANI)

Local self-government symbol of democracy, development, says Lok Sabha speaker

ANI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 02:37 PM IST
The Lok Sabha Speaker's comments came at the inauguration of outreach and familiarisation programme for local bodies of North-Eastern States in Shillong.
Close
Police said that she was rushed to a nearby hospital where she died during treatment.
Police said that she was rushed to a nearby hospital where she died during treatment.

Woman beaten to death by son's friend, 20, for resisting molestation: Cops

PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 02:36 PM IST
The incident took place on Wednesday night in a village under Basna police station area of the district.
Close
Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Friday highlighted India's effort in assisting neighbouring countries in the fight against the coronavirus pandemic. (PTI)(HT_PRINT)
Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Friday highlighted India's effort in assisting neighbouring countries in the fight against the coronavirus pandemic. (PTI)(HT_PRINT)

Govt has a clear vision for India’s financial sector’: PM Modi

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Ayshee Bhaduri, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 02:33 PM IST
  • The Prime Minister praised the role played by fintech in making financial services accessible during the pandemic last year and predicted that the sector “is likely to grow to 6 lakh crore”.
Close
A man receives Bharat Biotech's Covid-19 vaccine called COVAXIN, at a vaccination centre, in New Delhi, India.(REUTERS)
A man receives Bharat Biotech's Covid-19 vaccine called COVAXIN, at a vaccination centre, in New Delhi, India.(REUTERS)

India plans 2-day halt in vaccinations for Co-Win upgrade to widen campaign

Reuters, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 02:24 PM IST
Co-Win is being widely used to fix vaccination appointments, allow health authorities to monitor supplies and download proof of immunisation.
Close
The services that will now be chargeable on the opt-in basis include preferential seating, meal or snacks or drinking charges, charge for using airline lounges..(Stock image: Getty)
The services that will now be chargeable on the opt-in basis include preferential seating, meal or snacks or drinking charges, charge for using airline lounges..(Stock image: Getty)

DGCA allows airlines to offer concessions in fares to passengers with no baggage

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Deepali Sharma, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 26, 2021 02:25 PM IST
The aviation regulator said in a circular the government has decided to unbundle certain services and make them chargeable on an opt-in basis.
Close
Ghulam Nabi Azad. (HT file)
Ghulam Nabi Azad. (HT file)

Congress leader Ghulam Nabi Azad arrives in Jammu on 3-day visit

UPDATED ON FEB 26, 2021 03:31 PM IST
Former legislative assembly speaker Tara Chand, former J&K Congress president Peerzada Mohammad Sayed, former minister GM Saroori, Jugal Kishore, Ghulam Nabi Monga, Subhash Gupta and Naresh Gupta had lined up on the airport road to welcome Azad
Close
Himachal Pradesh governor Bandaru Dattatraya(HT File)
Himachal Pradesh governor Bandaru Dattatraya(HT File)

Congress MLAs allegedly manhandle Himachal Pradesh Governor after Assembly

PTI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 02:14 PM IST
The Assembly, which was adjourned till 2 pm on Monday earlier in the day, was reconvened at 1 pm on Friday to consider the motion moved by Bhardwaj.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP