724 trees cut for houses, golf course in Navi Mumbai; Cidco says plot not under litigation

HT Image
HT Image
Published on Jan 14, 2020 12:19 AM IST
Copy Link
By, Mumbai

Despite efforts by environmentalists to stop the cutting of trees in a proposed residential complex and golf course in Seawoods, Navi Mumbai, all 724 trees were hacked by the City Industrial Development Corporation Ltd’s (Cidco) contractor between Sunday and Monday. Protestors said bouncers were stationed outside the plot to stop them from gathering at the site which local residents claim is a wetland.

Local resident Sunil Agarwal, who has petitioned the Mumbai high court against the tree felling, said he will be filing a contempt petition in the Supreme Court (SC) which is slated to hear the matter on Tuesday.

Cidco’s tree authority granted the permission to its contractor on December 11, 2019, to cut 724 trees, transplant five, and retain 13 trees across two plots that form part of the project.

“The two plots are not under litigation before the Bombay high court (HC) or the SC where the residential complex will be built. Plots A, B and C are areas where no construction permissions have been issued yet, where the golf course has been planned. Trees permitted to be felled have been removed from the site and afforestation measures have commenced,” said a senior Cidco official requesting anonymity.

Cidco plans to develop 17 buildings with 1,564 flats, 20 offices, and an 18-hole golf course on the plot. HT had reported on Monday that contractors had begun tree felling on Sunday, and hacked over 500 trees until the local police stopped them by the afternoon, but on Monday all remaining trees were chopped, residents said.

While the project was proposed in 2002 by Cidco, plans were developed after the Maharashtra government issued a notification on October 5, 2016, which changed the land use of the area under Maharashtra Regional Town Planning (MRTP) Act for construction of the project across 67 of 80 hectares.

After local residents moved the HC in 2017 against the change of land use from a green zone to residential, a division bench of the HC on November 1, 2018 putting a stay on Maharashtra government’s notification. Cidco and the company building the project, challenged the order in the SC.

On July 19, 2019, the SC removed the stay imposed by the HC on the state’s notification (issued on October 5, 2016). However, it was not clear whether Cidco could commence construction for the project, as there was no such mention in the order. In subsequent hearings, petitioners submitted details about all plots recognised as important wetlands by the forest department, and will be submitting more details during the next hearing scheduled on Tuesday. In the interim, the trees were felled.

“Our petition clearly stated that all plots are under litigation. The residential complex is being built overlooking the golf course. This is a clear violation of HC guidelines,” said Agarwal. “Permission was never given to the builder to commence construction by the SC.”

As compensatory measure, the contractor was directed to plant 1,448 trees (twice the number felled) and an additional 168 trees to be planted at a plot in Kharghar, Navi Mumbai. The Cidco contracter, Mistry Construction, refused to comment on the issue.

Other environmentalists said there was no public notice, no public consultation nor any permission from other state agencies for tree cutting. “The action stands illegal,” said Zoru Bhathena, petitioner before the HC and the SC on several tree felling matters.

NMMC commissioner Annasaheb Misal said, “If this would have happened on NMMC land, the builder would have been booked and tree cutting stopped. Unfortunately the land belongs to Cidco, and their tree authority has the final decision. We will examine other options to protect green cover in Navi Mumbai.”


    Badri Chatterjee is an environment correspondent at Hindustan Times, Mumbai. He writes about environment issues - air, water and noise pollution, climate change - weather, wildlife - forests, marine and mangrove conservation

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar. (HT PHOTO)

    BJP to attend Nitish Kumar’s all-party meet on caste census

    The Bharatiya Janata Party will attend an all-party meeting Bihar chief minister Nitish Kumar has convened on June 1 to discuss the modalities for a state-level caste census even as it has faced criticism from its ruling National Democratic Alliance allies for trying to stall the exercise. On May 10, Rashtriya Janata Dal leader Tejashwi Yadav threatened to hold a foot march from Patna to Delhi in case the census is not conducted.

  • IKEA to open a store in Bengaluru in June.

    World Economic Forum meet: IKEA to open store in Bengaluru in June

    Bengaluru might soon get an IKEA store in June this year. Swedish furniture retailer IKEA would open its flagship store in Bengaluru in June. CEO of Ingka Group, of which IKEA is a part, Jesper Brodin on Wednesday met Karnataka Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai at the World Economic Forum Meet in Davos, Switzerland, and held discussions in the backdrop of the store-opening.

  • The bookstore, called Akhil Bharti, opens at 8 in the morning but there is no closing time.

    Delhiwale: A place for Premchand

    The shop consists of two rooms separated by a thin wall. One long shelf is devoted to the great Premchand. Along with his classic works like Gaban, Karmbhoomi, and Sevasadan, there is a huge selection of his short fiction, including the hauntingly titled Poos ki Raat.

  • The national average for Class 10 is 37.8%, while Delhi’s mean average is 45.4%, after students were assessed in mathematics, science, social science, English and a modern Indian language.

    NAS 2021: 'Delhi schools perform better in higher classes'

    The survey is a national-level large-scale assessment which examines the competencies developed by students in classes 3, 5, 8 and 10, and is conducted every three years to make an overall assessment of the school education system. In Delhi, 64, 049 students from 1,602 schools, both private and government, participated in the survey which took place last year.

  • Squadron Leader Ravi Khanna was among four Indian Air Force officials shot dead by car-borne militants of the Jammu and Kashmir Liberation Front, allegedly including Yasin Malik, on outskirts of Srinagar in January 1990. (AFP)

    Yasin Malik’s conviction: Many got relief today, but I am not at peace, says slain IAF officer’s wife

    Reacting to the life sentence awarded to Yasin Malik on Wednesday, the wife of slain Squadron Leader Ravi Khanna, Shalini Khanna, said, “Though many people would have got relief today, but I am not at peace”. Squadron Leader Khanna was among four Indian Air Force officials shot dead by car-borne militants of the Jammu and Kashmir Liberation Front, allegedly including Yasin Malik, on outskirts of Srinagar in January 1990.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Thursday, May 26, 2022