Can’t recover contract payments as land revenue arrears, says HC

HT Image
HT Image
Published on Dec 28, 2019 11:43 PM IST
Copy Link
ByKanchan Chaudhari, Mumbai

The Bombay high court (HC) recently held that payments arising out of contractual arrangements cannot be recovered by revenue officials as arrears of land revenue. The court invoked provisions of the Maharashtra Land Revenue Code (MLRC) and struck down a notice issued by a tehsildar demanding 19.36 crore from a firm that used to run Grant Medical College Gymkhana on Marine Drive.

The firm, Samani Decorators Private Limited, had approached the HC after the tehsildar on August 30, 2019, issued the notice demanding commercial rent for purported unauthorised use of additional land at Gymkhana for eight years – from November 2011 to August 2019.

The student association of the Grant Medical College along with Sir JJ Group of Hospitals run the Gymkhana, a ground-plus-one storey structure with open space. The firm was roped in and was allotted exclusive right to provide decoration and catering service at the gymkhana.

On February 1, 2019, the firm was served a termination notice on grounds of breach of agreement and was asked to pay mesne profits (profits received by a tenant in wrongful possession) for unauthorised use of the space for private businesses.

A bench of chief justice Pradeep Nandrajog and justice Bharati Dangre, however, held that the amount arose out of contractual agreement and therefore could not be recovered as arrears of land revenue. The bench has, however, granted the medical college the liberty to recover the amount by other legally permissible means.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • The Bangalore University, known to be short of funds, is now hoping to make revenue out of the jackfruit trees grown on its campus. (Representative Image)

    Cash-strapped Bangalore University wants to make money. By selling jackfruit

    Bangalore University, which has more than 650 affiliated colleges, has decided to auction off the 50-odd jackfruit trees on its 1,000-acre Jnanabharathi campus ahead of the upcoming jackfruit season. The varsity had tried to auction off the trees last year but did not gain any revenue due to the lack of demand and buyers. The auction is set to take place on May 31 and the university has some rules in place.

  • Security duties being assigned at the Ridge on Friday in the run-up to Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s visit to Shimla on May 31. (Deepak Sansta/HT)

    Shimla schools prepone vacation in view of PM Modi’s May 31 rally

    Anticipating a huge gathering for Prime Minister Narendra Modi's rally at the Ridge in Shimla on May 31, the district administration has asked schools to prepone their summer vacation to avoid traffic congestion on Tuesday. Also read: Seven soldiers killed after army vehicle falls into Shyok river in Ladakh Modi will hold a roadshow in Shimla followed by the rally to celebrate the BJP-led NDA government's eight years in office at the Centre.

  • Delhi lieutenant governor Vinai Kumar Saxena (left) with CM Arvind Kejriwal (

    ‘We decided to work together…’: Delhi CM Kejriwal meets new LG Vinai Saxena

    Delhi chief minister Arvind Kejriwal on Friday met the Union territory's 22nd lieutenant governor, Vinai Kumar Saxena, a day after the latter took oath of office. Speaking after the meeting, Kejriwal told reporters they both decided to work together for the 'betterment of people.' Saxena posted images on Twitter of his interaction with the chief minister.

  • Rajvardhan Singh Parmar of the Hindu outfit, Maharana Pratap Sena, has written a letter to Rajasthan chief minister Ashok Gehlot demanding ASI survey of the Ajmer Dargah. (PTI File Photo)

    Hindu outfit claims Ajmer Dargah was a temple, demands ASI survey

    A Hindu outfit, Maharana Pratap Sena, has claimed that the Ajmer Dargah of Sufi saint Moinuddin Chisti was a temple, and demanded a survey of it by the Archaeological Survey of India. The dargah committee and the body of Khadims have refuted such claims. Rajvardhan Singh Parmar of Maharana Pratap Sena claimed that Hindu symbols were there on the walls and windows of the dargah and sought an ASI survey.

  • A three-year-old child was killed on Thursday noon as a water tanker ran over her while reversing near Sarjapur road in Bengaluru. (for representational purposes) (HT FILE PHOTO)

    Bengaluru: Toddler run over by reversing tanker while playing outside apartment

    A three-year-old girl was killed after Pratiksha Bhat, a native of Nepal was run over by a water tanker while it was reversing near an apartment on Sarjapur road in Bengaluru on Thursday. The young girl has been identified as a native of Nepal, Pratiksha Bhat. Pratiksha was playing nearby as the driver began reversing but he did not see her and the toddler was knocked down. Pratiksha's body was shifted to St John's Medical College Hospital for post-mortem procedures.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Friday, May 27, 2022