The machismo of killing frail old men and women

Must these young men necessarily have to physically eliminate frail old men and women they cannot combat intellectually?
Published on Aug 15, 2018 12:36 AM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times | By

Narendra Dabholkar, an old man in his 70s, was out for a morning walk in Pune when two young, presumably able-bodied, men riding motorbikes got within striking distance of him and fired at point blank range, killing him on the spot. So was Govind Pansare — an old man in his 70s — out for a morning constitutional with his wife in Kolhapur. The same modus operandi was used against him. MM Kalburgi was also an old man in his 70s, sitting in his drawing room with a cup of morning coffee and a newspaper when two young men rang his doorbell, were let in by his wife, and shot him dead at point blank range. Come to think of it, even Mahatma Gandhi was an old man in his 70s leaning on two women he called his walking sticks when the 32-year old Nathuram Godse shot him dead at point blank range. Talking of women, Gauri Lankesh was a frail 55-year-old, letting herself inside her gate when Sanatan Sadhaks shot her dead at point-blank range.

I have always wondered at these macho men of the saffron brigade who think nothing of targeting unarmed, unguarded old men and women and continue to believe in their muscular policy of a Hindu Rashtra. Does Hinduism really sanction killing harmless old men and frail middle-aged women? Even the worst kinds of gangsters refrain from such personal targeting.

The Karnataka police investigating the Gauri Lankesh murder has revealed that the Sanatan Sanstha (SS) had at least 20 more people on target, including Girish Karnad (again in his 70s) and other writers and intellectuals whose ideologies they are unable to overcome with reasonable arguments. Must these young men necessarily have to physically eliminate frail old men and women they cannot combat intellectually?

Looking at the SS, whose sadhak has been arrested for making crude bombs, it appears to merely be a cult established by a hypnotherapist, Dr Jayant Athawale, who used hypnotism to good effect to lure people into his organisation. For example, he would make people scribble the names of their family deities thousands of times and make them believe that the gods had appeared in person before them out of those scribbles. Being a hypnotist, he also knew how to lure young gullible boys into his cult. Parents of those children have been desperate to get them back and many have now even petitioned the high court for their custody.

The SS, thus, is very different from the Sangh Parivar, which does not lure its pracharaks through hypnotism or psychotropic drugs, as the Sanatanis are accused of doing with young boys and girls, but rather convinces them irrevocably at a young impressionable age of their Hindutva orientations. But there is another very significant difference between the Sanatani terrorists and those associates of the Sangh accused of indulging in such activities. The Sanatan Sadhaks have so far targeted only Hindus, the Sangh-associated people, whatever the status of their cases today, clearly had Muslim targets in their crosshairs — Malegaon, Samjhauta Express etc.

There is also the misconception that these Sanatan Sadhaks are supported by the Sangh Parivar – they may have the common goal of a Hindu Rashtra in mind but are bitter critics of Narendra Modi, Manohar Parrikar (the bulk of their activities are in Goa) and Mohan Bhagwat. None of these leaders, however, gave any leeway to the Sanatan Sanstha. That blame must lie at the doors of the late RR Patil, as the then home minister of Maharashtra, and the NCP.

Highly informed sources have told me that while Dabholkar was killed in August 2013, the Maharashtra Police knew by December that year of the involvement of the Sanatan Sanstha in the killing. But with the Lok Sabha elections five months away, both the Congress and the Nationalist Congress Party (NCP) were afraid of targeting any organisation that would make them appear anti-Hindu. So even then union home minister Sushil Kumar Shinde did not act on the proposal to ban the Sanatan Sanstha, then chief minister Prithviraj Chavan complained he was never kept in the loop by his junior Patil and, of course, Patil had the blessings of his top leadership who were not uncomfortable with practising soft Hindutva.

So as the Sanatan Sanstha grew under their watch (even in Goa, Digambar Kamat of the Congress was wary of banning them despite the fact they targetted Margao on Diwali in 2009), these macho young men killed frailer old men and women. I am sure they will regret this misplaced concept of manhood but someone needs to de-hypnotise them first!


    I wonder if the Sena and the AIMIM know that Bal Thackeray was the first person ever in India to lose his voting rights and that to contest elections for hate speeches he had made during a 1987 byelection to Vile Parle.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • The Centre on Friday appointed 1998 batch IAS officer Gyanesh Bharti as the new commissioner of unified Municipal Corporation of Delhi

    Gyanesh Bharti appointed Municipal Corporation of Delhi commissioner

    The Centre on Friday appointed 1998 batch IAS officer Gyanesh Bharti as the new commissioner of unified Municipal Corporation of Delhi, the ministry of home affairs said. The Centre has appointed 1992 batch IAS officer Ashwani Kumar as the special officer in the unified MCD.

  • Even people who say they like to work, don’t really like to work. Because? Well, because work is work. It is hard. It is repetitive. It becomes boring after the novelty wears off. (REPRESENTATIVE PHOTO)

    Global Village Idiot: 1,001 secrets to an engaged work life!

    I meet many people during a typical day. Of late, I seem to be meeting quite a few people in India who are giving up jobs to start ventures. Because? Well, because work is work. Practice at all levels, all the time. What is otherwise called “being in the zone”. Do you know why? Because the average human being doesn't find their own work exciting. And this is true even for work you lovvvvvve doing.

  • Suspended IAS officer Pooja Singhal was arrested on May 12.

    Jharkhand: Suspended IAS officer Pooja Singhal's ED custody extended by 5 days

    A local court on Friday extended the Enforcement Directorate custody of suspended IAS officer Pooja Singhal by five more days, news agency ANI reported. Pooja Singhal was arrested by the probe agency on May 12 in connection with a money laundering case linked to alleged embezzlement of MGNREGA funds in Khunti district of Jharkhand. The agency had reportedly recovered 17 crore from the residence of Suman Kumar.

  • Sushil Modi further said that Yadav owned 141 land plots and 30 flats, besides having a dozen houses, whose proof was available in 'Lalu Leela', a book written by Modi.

    BJP’s Sushil Modi shares Lalu Yadav’s ‘modus operandi’ as CBI conducts searches

    As the Central Bureau of Investigation carried out raids on properties linked with Lalu Prasad Yadav on Friday, Bharatiya Janata Party leader Sushil Modi said the Rashtriya Janata Dal president's modus operandi was to lure people seeking jobs in exchange for land. The Rajya Sabha MP further said that Yadav owned 141 land plots and 30 flats, besides having a dozen houses, whose proof was available in 'a book written by Modi', Lalu Leela.

  • Indonesian artist Zabylla performed at the cultural tech event, Techsrijan, held at the MMMUT Gorakhpur campus on May 14 night.

    Ruckus at Gorakhpur campus over Indonesian artist Zabylla’s programme

    LUCKNOW: Activists of the Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad staged a demonstration at Madan Mohan Malaviya University of Technology Gorakhpur campus on Thursday as they alleged university has “spread obscenity” by inviting an Indonesian artist who is more of a porn star at a programme held on the campus. The university officials with the help of their students attacked them. But the university official alleged that Gorakhpur Mahanagar, Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad created a ruckus.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Friday, May 20, 2022