Dance no bar in Mumbai: SC restores jobs to 75,000 performers

Chandni Bar may soon be back in action, with dancing girls, stuffy interiors and sweaty clients, but, hopefully, without the same masters - the crafty owner, the grubby criminal and the typical policeman. Manoj R Nair reports. Dance Dynamics | The rule book | Back on the dance floor | What bars may have to do
Updated on Jul 19, 2013 02:06 AM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times | By, Mumbai

Chandni Bar may soon be back in action, with garish lights, dancing girls, stuffy interiors and sweaty clients, but, hopefully, without the same masters - the crafty owner, the grubby criminal and the typical policeman.

That is, if dance bars are back in business with some regulations that the performers and activists want, following the Supreme Court ruling on Tuesday upholding a Bombay high court order lifting the ban imposed on dance bars in Maharashtra in August 2005.

The apex court's ruling may have brought cheer to an estimated 75,000 people who were bar girls in Mumbai and an equal number of others associated with the trade that flourished since the 1980s. Though many of the women who were pushed to harsher lives to sustain themselves and their families may not be able to return to the bars, many might and many others might be able to find another narrow avenue of employment.


But that is not yet clear. While the Maharashtra government's response to the apex court's order has been vague and murmurings of moving a review petition in the apex court have been heard in the corridors of power, the organisation formed by the Mumbai Bar Owners Association is planning to wait awhile and then move the Supreme Court to urge it to issue directions to the state government to implement its order.

The apex court and the high court rejected the state government's argument that dance bars encouraged prostitution and corrupted society, saying there was no evidence of this and that the ban impinged on a citizen's right to employment.



Former dance bar owners say the ban revealed the government's hypocrisy. "In 30 years, the government issued licences and the number of such bars grew from one to 700. Then suddenly they call us hubs of crime and prostitution dens," said Manjit Singh Sethi, president of the Mumbai Bar Owners Association.

"The bars were not brothels. I did not meet anybody who was trafficked. The women had come to Mumbai seeking employment, and working in these bars was an option they exercised," said advocate Flavia Agnes, who represented the bar girls in the high court.

Agnes, however, said that if dance bars are to make a comeback, they should be regulated. "I don't think the issue is about morality. It's a question of the women's safety," she said.

"The women face harassment from bar owners, police and customers. They need the protection of laws like those on sexual harassment in workplaces," she said.

Varsha Kale, president of the Bharatiya Bar Girls Union, said the dancers should have a say in the new regulations.

"They may not want to dance to obscene songs. There should also be rules on the kind of clothes they wear. Also, instead of throwing currency notes at dancers, customers should be asked to add tips to the bill. But since views on these issues can be subjective, public opinion can be sought on what is acceptable," she said.

Bar owners say they are not averse to new regulations.

"We are ready to be brought under labour laws. But at the same time, if the government is going to create regulations for workers, dance bars should be recognised as an industry and given access to facilities that are allowed to a legitimate trade, like finance," said Sethi.

Read more:Khar, Bandra ask cops to curb pubs; fear return of dance bars

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
  • ABOUT THE AUTHOR

    Manoj R Nair is part of Hindustan Times’ nationwide network of correspondents that brings news, analysis and information to its readers.

Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • The Manohar Lal Khattar-led BJP-JJP government has set a lofty target to diversify at least one lakh acre land under paddy cultivation to crops such as pulses, cereals, cotton and maize every year to check Haryana’s rapidly deleting ground water table (Representative Image/HT File)

    Haryana’s money-linked diversification drive:Area under paddy cultivation reduced by 10% in 2021

    Two years after it was rolled out, the Haryana government's financial incentive-linked diversification drive, has gained some ground with area under water-guzzling paddy reducing by 10% in 2021. As per official data, during the kharif season in 2021 crop diversification took place on 51,878 acres. As many as 62,562 farmers were paid 53.34 crore as incentive for opting for crop diversification. It came down to 14.60 lakh acre in 2021.

  • On Tuesday, the chief secretary, Arun Kumar Mehta chaired a high-level meeting about recruitments being made through the J&K Public Service Commission, Jammu and Kashmir Service Selection Board (J&K SSB), J&K Police Recruitment Board and J&K Bank in the UT. (PTI File Photo/ Representational image)

    Jammu and Kashmir SSB registers highest-ever recruitment in 2021-22

    The J&K SSB registered the highest-ever recruitment in 2021-22, since its inception, said the J&K government. On Tuesday, the chief secretary, Arun Kumar Mehta chaired a high-level meeting about recruitments being made through the J&K Public Service Commission, J&K Service Selection Board, J&K Police Recruitment Board and J&K Bank in the UT. “Previously, the J&K Service Selection Board recruited 8,580 and 8,115 candidates in 2009 and 2015, respectively.”

  • When Bhagwant Mann inducted Vijay Singla, a dentist, as the Punjab health minister, he was a surprise pick over several two-time legislatures and eight other doctor MLAs with higher qualifications than him. Singla was sacked over graft charges by CM Bhagwant Mann on Tuesday. (Ravi Kumar/HT)

    Punjab minister sacked over graft charges: A dentist, green warrior & social crusader: Singla is ‘Mr Clean’ in hometown Mansa

    For the 52-year-old first-time AAP legislator and a dental surgeon Vijay Singla, who created history by winning the Mansa assembly seat by a record margin of 63,323 votes on the plank of 'political honesty', the downfall was as unexpected as his rise --- all this, in just two months after his induction in the Bhagwant Mann-led cabinet in Punjab. Singla had defeated the Congress nominee and popular Punjabi rapper Shubhdeep Singh alias Sidhu Moosewala.

  • The track is part of the 1,875-km Dankuni-Son Nagar-Ludhiana section, which has been termed as the Eastern Corridor. (HT Photo)

    Punjab section of freight corridor likely to be operational by year-end

    An 82-kilometre-long section of the Eastern Dedicated Freight Corridor, extending from Sahnewal to Shambhu in Punjab, is expected to become operational by the end of the year. The 175km single-track section is spread across Ludhiana, Fatehgarh Sahib, Patiala, Ambala, Yamunanagar and Saharanpur districts of Punjab, Haryana and Uttar Pradesh under the Ambala and Ferozepur divisions of the Northern Railways. It extends from Sahnewal in Punjab to Pilkhani in Uttar Pradesh.

  • A cop salutes during the wreath-laying ceremony of slain constable Saifullah Qadri in Srinagar on Tuesday. Police said that the cop identified as Saifullah Qadri was attacked by militants near Anchar when he was walking on the road along with his daughter outside his house. (Waseem Andrabi/ HT)

    Constable shot dead; daughter injured in Srinagar terror attack

    Militants on Tuesday attacked an off-duty police constable killing him and injuring his nine-year-old daughter at Anchar in Srinagar. Police said that the cop identified as Saifullah Qadri was attacked by militants near Anchar when he was walking on the road along with his daughter outside his house. “The terrorists involved in the killing of the cop will be identified and neutralised soon,” inspector general of police Vijay Kumar said.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Wednesday, May 25, 2022