Conspiracy theorists falsely identify NYC subway victim as 'Amelia Carter', who is she?
While NYC police are yet to confirm the identity of the victim, a post made on X on December 23 claimed the victim was Amelia Carter.
As NYC subway horror has drawn massive attention of netizens, with many blasting Democrats for the surge in crime in the city, a post falsely claiming the identity of victim has gone viral on social media.

While police are yet to confirm the identity of the victim, a post made on X on December 23 claimed the victim was Amelia Carter. The hoax post has garnered over2.4 million views so far.
A woman was burned alive early on the NYC subway on December 22. She was declared dead at the spot. In the case, Sebastian Zapeta has been listed as a suspect and was arrested shortly after the woman's death.
Zapeta, a citizen of Guatemala, entered the country illegally in 2018. It is still unclear how he returned to the country after being deported by the Trump administration. He has been charged with first and second degree murder and arson.
Who is Amelia Carter?
“This is Amelia Carter,” claimed a post on X that misidentified the victim. Sharing a fuzzy picture of a woman, the post further said, “She was burned alive on the subway yesterday. This is Joe bidens America.”
Meanwhile, the X community note clarified, “This is a hoax. This photo is AI. No verified news sources as of 23/12/2024 have given a victim name or statement.”
This did not stop conspiracy theorists from making the baseless claim. “Amelia Carter. 29. Penn grad student. I hope you did not suffer too much Angel,” one X user wrote.
“Amelia Carter is a fabricated identity; the photo was generated with artificial intelligence to create a cryptocurrency scam. The police have not disclosed the identity of the woman,” another X community note highlighted.
One website published an article about Amelia Carter, giving the imaginary character a whole biography. It said that she was a nurse at Mount Sinai Hospital in New York and also worked as an intern on Bernie Sanders' 2016 presidential campaign, Newsweek reported.
NYC subway horror
The victim was apparently napping on a F train in Brooklyn early on Sunday morning when the alleged culprit approached him. According to surveillance footage, the suspect walked towards her before setting her on fire.
The victim, according to the police, was entirely engulfed in flames in a matter of seconds. The man quietly sat on a bench on the station's platform and watched the burning woman.
ABOUT THE AUTHORShweta KukretiShweta Kukreti has over 8 years of experience in covering Indian and world politics. She joined the Hindustan Times in 2024 and is primarily assigned to the US desk. She currently works as Deputy Chief Content Producer and reports on a wide range of topics, including US politics, immigration issues (especially H-1B visa) and major global events. Shweta strongly emphasizes team operations, which encompasses monitoring news, delegating tasks, editing, developing comprehensive coverage strategies, and crafting engaging, and data-informed narratives. She received the Digi Star Award at the Hindustan Times within a year of joining for her broad coverage of US politics. In 2025, she earned both a promotion and a redesignation, a significant achievement recognising her contributions and the strong value she brings to the team. She has previously worked with the Indian Express, HTDS, ANI and Republic World. Seniors in all the media organisations recognised her work. Regarding education, she earned a BA (Hons.) in Political Science and a master's degree from Delhi University, and she pursued a PG Diploma in English Journalism from the Indian Institution of Mass Communication (IIMC). She also holds a diploma in Women's Empowerment and Development from IGNOU University and a French certification course from Alliance Française de Delhi. If not working, you can find her exploring the hills and engaging in adventurous activities in Rishikesh and Himachal Pradesh. She loves to play badminton, volleyball, and chess, and spend time with her friends and family. She also enjoys spiritual activities.Read More

E-Paper


