Health overhaul tests Obama's political skills
Embarking on arguably his most complex political fight yet, President Barack Obama is using skills honed during his presidential campaign and lessons learned from past failures to try to overhaul the health care system.Updated: Mar 09, 2009 11:13 IST
Embarking on arguably his most complex political fight yet, President Barack Obama is using skills honed during his presidential campaign and lessons learned from past failures to try to overhaul the health care system. It's a feat none before him has achieved. As such, it would pay monumental dividends for a popular new president looking for history-making accomplishments ahead of his likely 2012 re-election campaign.
"Nothing is harder in politics than doing something now that costs money in order to gain benefits 20 years from now," Obama acknowledged last week.
That's exactly what he's trying as he seeks to ensure health care for everyone in a country with the world's costliest system and an estimated 48 million uninsured people. Unlike other developed countries, the United States does not have universal health care. In office since January 20, Obama has laid down an ambitious marker of one year to accomplish what the last Democratic president spectacularly failed to do in two. Bill Clinton made a series of tactical mistakes and was outmaneuvered by the opposition. "We soon learned that nothing was off limits in this war and that the other side was far better armed with the tools of political battle: money, media and organization," Hillary Rodham Clinton, who led the health care fight for her husband, said in her 2003 memoir. Obama is determined not to let that happen again. He and his advisers, including several who served in Clinton's White House, have studied what went wrong during 1993-1994, and are mindful to avoid the same miscalculations and missteps. In concert with the White House, the Democratic National Committee and Obama's campaign apparatus _ Organizing for America, with its 13 million-strong e-mail list and 2 million "super volunteers" _ will be intimately involved in promoting the plan as well as pressuring opponents. A paid TV ad campaign is all but certain.
Other advocates of revamping health care also have created a network of diverse coalitions. They are made up of strange bedfellows, such as labor unions and industry representatives, consumers and businesses. Others, like America's Agenda: Health Care for All, are composed of insurers and drug makers, including some that fought Clinton's plan. Those, too, now generally support an overhaul.
All are stockpiling cash and waiting to see how they will need to use it. Budgets and strategies are being closely held. Both Democrats and Republicans expect an expensive fight. They say it will dwarf the $30 million that the Health Insurance Association of America spent on its TV commercials featuring Harry and Louise, a couple who talked fearfully about the Clinton plan as they paid bills at their kitchen table.
This time the mountain of money is expected to come from well-funded Obama backers trying to create a climate for success; some already are airing ads to drum up support for major changes in general.
Last week, in a sign of what's to come, a group called Conservatives for Patients Rights began what it said would be a multimillion-dollar advertising campaign to promote "free-market" reform rather than a "Big Government takeover." A costly and complex proposition, revamping health care probably will be a much tougher task than anything Obama has faced so far as president.
It's an issue that touches everyone in the United States. There are thickets of competing interests among patients, doctors, drug makers, insurers, labor, businesses and others.
Any plan must get through a Democratic-controlled Congress, where most lawmakers are up for re-election next year. Also, there's an ideological fault line between Democrats and Republicans, and liberals and conservatives over the level of government involvement in health care.
Given all that, Democrats and Republicans contend Obama must use all tools available to ensure success.
"President Obama needs to invest everything he learned in winning the presidential campaign to get affordable health care for everybody. That's what it's going to take to trump the opposition," said Judy Feder, a senior health care official under Bill Clinton who now is at the Center for American Progress.
"It's extremely important for him to use his political skills," agreed Bill Gradison, a former Republican congressman from Ohio who headed the insurance association when it launched the anti-Clinton commercials. Still, Gradison added: "Bill Clinton had those same skills in a lot of ways. Both are excellent communicators and had strong organizational and political support behind them. And both had control of Congress."
But Clinton, who won a three-way race in 1992 with only 43 per cent of the popular vote, didn't have the mandate from voters that Obama now has after winning a clear majority with 52 per cent last fall. Clinton also didn't come into office inheriting a crisis that presents opportunity for change the way Obama has with the recession.
Nevertheless, Obama administration officials acknowledge that the push for an overhaul _ what Obama calls the linchpin to the country's future financial health _ will be complicated and contentious, even though the environment is now more amenable to it. The public overwhelmingly supports revamping the system, while businesses, insurers and drug makers that balked at Clinton in the 1990s are working with Obama.
For now at least, Obama is approaching health care much differently than did Clinton. He cut out Congress and interest groups, wrote his own legislation and threatened to veto any measure that didn't contain what he wanted.
Obama has chosen to be flexible. He's outlining broad principles and leaving the heavy lifting to Congress. He also is calling both allies and skeptics to the table to solicit ideas and advice. He's created a Web site, www.healthreform.gov, to keep people in the loop. Obama also is indicating he's willing to compromise. Obama has secured $19 billion in the economic stimulus package to convert medical records to electronic formats and proposed a budget that projects spending $634 billion over 10 years toward universal health care. He devoted a significant chunk of his first address to Congress on the matter, and is dispatching surrogates to hold regional forums on the issue.
At some point, he almost certainly will travel across the country to take the proposal directly to the people, using his rhetorical skills and charisma to keep people on the side of change _ and pressure lawmakers to get it done.