Yangtze tragedy: After reports of propaganda machinery overdrive, China says 'no cover-up'
China's propaganda machinery has gone into top gear after a ship disaster, extolling the official response while dousing any public criticism and tightly controlling foreign media.world Updated: Jun 04, 2015 22:10 IST
China's propaganda machinery has gone into top gear after a ship disaster, extolling the official response while dousing any public criticism and tightly controlling foreign media, even though Beijing says there will be no 'cover up' attempt in the probe.
Thousands of police, soldiers and rescue workers were dispatched to the banks of the Yangtze, where the "Eastern Star" capsized Monday evening with more than 450 people on board. But with only 14 survivors found, there is little hope for the rest. Premier Li Keqiang has been the omnipresent face of the rescue operation since Tuesday morning.
"The sleeves-rolled-up, megaphone-in-hand image of the premier directing rescue efforts at the scene has become a recurring feature of China's domestic media coverage of disasters," said Nicholas Dynon, an expert in Chinese media at Macquarie University in Sydney. The Chinese media on Wednesday also gave prominent coverage of the "miraculous" rescue of Zhu Hongmei, who was pulled from the upturned hull of the boat.
The 65-year-old woman was shown being hoisted to safety in a concerted effort by divers and rescue workers.It was a scene perfectly in keeping with the communist line of society coming together to support each other in times of trouble.
Chinese Premier Li Keqiang speaks to officers as he inspects the rescue operations of the sunken ship. (Reuters)
In contrast, the New York Times ran a photograph of a corpse fished from the river on the front page of its international edition, a more jarring image suggesting that the toll will be high.Communist Party leaders are well aware that missteps over a major disaster can quickly turn to criticism of their effectiveness at governing.
A deadly high-speed train crash in July 2011 triggered a torrent of criticism that authorities had compromised safety in their rush to expand the network. Deadly floods in Beijing in 2012 and a stampede which killed 36 people at last New Year's Eve in Shanghai also stirred a barrage of criticism of the authorities. And Beijing is aware of the serious repercussions from the sinking of the Sewol ferry in South Korea -- a disaster with many parallels -- which saw the prime minister resign.
No cover up
However, China has pledged that there would be "no cover-up" into the investigation of the sunken cruise ship, as angry families gathered near the rescue site to demand answers.
Earlier on Thursday, President Xi Jinping convened a special meeting of the ruling Communist Party's Politburo Standing Committee, the apex of power in the country, to discuss the disaster, Xinhua said.
Man is pulled up to a boat after rescuing 21-year-old crew member Chen Shuhan, at the scene of a capsized ship at the Jianli section of the Yangtze River. (Reuters Photo)
Authorities are investigating the crew members who were rescued from the Eastern Star, which capsized in a freak tornado on Monday night, and were "gathering evidence", Xu Chengguang, the spokesperson for the ministry of transport, said.
"We will never shield mistakes and we'll absolutely not cover up (anything)," Xu told a news conference on Wednesday night, adding a preliminary investigation had begun.
'Managing domestic emotions'
Unsurprisingly under these conditions, Chinese media have been told to use only the official Xinhua news agency and state CCTV television as their sources to cover the tragedy, according to instructions aired by China Digital Times, a website that monitors Chinese media and Internet.The leaked statement included instructions to recall journalists who were already at the site of the disaster.
Authorities have largely limited official access for foreign journalists to brief trips along the river, and roadblocks are sited about two kilometres (1.2 miles) from the capsized vessel."Media at the scene of the sinking has been restricted, including foreign media, which is unsurprising," Dynon said.
"For Beijing, this is an exercise in managing domestic emotions, which means controlling unequivocal messaging around who exactly are the heroes and who are the villains," he said.At the main press briefing Wednesday, no questions were taken and no figures on deaths or survivors were given -- but Guan Dong, one of the divers who brought two survivors out of the water, gave his gripping account of the rescue.
An aerial view shows rescue workers searching on the sunken ship at Jianli section of Yangtze River in China (Reuters Photo)
Li's activism has taken centrestage. Over the course of 24 hours he was seen holding a crisis meeting on his plane, poring over a map, then giving orders to rescue workers in front of the largely submerged hull of the capsized vessel.Reports on Wednesday also showed Li, wearing a hospital gown, at the bedside of a survivor.
The message to the masses is clear: the top leadership of the party oversees operations down to the last detail and the victims are not forgotten."While there clearly has been no news blackout as such, there has been a careful coverage management favouring stories about the rescue effort, the role of political leaders and the measures taken by the state to swiftly respond," Dynon said.
The propaganda drive was illustrated in a report by qianlong.com, the news portal run by the Beijing city party commission, on a Weibo post that was reposted more than 100,000 times in one day. It quoted a news report saying that authorities had limited the water flow coming out of the Three Gorges Dam to reduce the speed downstream, where rescue work was ongoing.
"(I) could see the responsibility and capability of leading the whole country to prioritise people's life," the post by netizen Dong Mai Ying read. "I really doubt any other country than China has such determination and capability to do this."
The report has been reposted by mainstream media outlets including Xinhua and CCTV's websites.Yet on Wednesday, "Eastern Star" was the most censored term on Weibo, according to Free Weibo, which copies and republished censored Weibo posts.
From a wider perspective, whenever disaster strikes China the authorities seek to sweep aside any negative elements that could tarnish the reputation of the one-party state, such as suggestions of unsafe public transport, lax security or standards not being respected."Ultimately, Beijing's primary audience is its citizens, and satisfying international media demand comes a very distant second," said Dynon.
Rescuers race against clock to find survivors
China's Yangtze river: A dangerous attraction for tourists