A group of government-appointed advisors has recommended sweeping changes to India's outdated and overburdened bankruptcy system, aiming to modernise a process that takes several years and costs investors and taxpayers billions.(REUTERS Photo)
A group of government-appointed advisors has recommended sweeping changes to India's outdated and overburdened bankruptcy system, aiming to modernise a process that takes several years and costs investors and taxpayers billions.(REUTERS Photo)

Govt eyes bankruptcy reform to end decades of gridlocked projects

A group of government-appointed advisors has recommended sweeping changes to India’s outdated and overburdened bankruptcy system, aiming to modernise a lengthy process that takes several years and costs investors and taxpayers billions.
By HT Correspondent | Reuters, Mumbai
UPDATED ON OCT 30, 2015 12:56 PM IST

A group of government-appointed advisors has recommended sweeping changes to India’s outdated and overburdened bankruptcy system, aiming to modernise a lengthy process that takes several years and costs investors and taxpayers billions.

The changes would be the most ambitious overhaul to date of rules governing the liquidation or revival of companies in India, a country with no single bankruptcy code and where competing laws, unclear jurisdictions and inadequate resources can leave cases languishing for decades.

The proposals, to be handed to the Finance Ministry as early as Monday, will impose deadlines for the first time and establish a network of insolvency professionals to lighten courts’ workload and tackle delays, TK Viswanathan, chairman of the Bankruptcy Law Reform Committee, told Reuters.

Under current rules, even deciding whether to save or liquidate an ailing company can take years, leaving it in the hands of managers who can - and do - strip assets with impunity. Under the proposed changes, a decision would have to be reached in 180 days - even 90 days for fast-track applications, Viswanathan said.

“The whole essence of our exercise is that everything is done within time,” he said.

Foreign and domestic investors say the difficulty in exiting ventures can deter them from entering.

Cases such as the protracted collapse of liquor tycoon Vijay Mallya’s Kingfisher Airline empire have burnt investors. The airline was grounded in 2012 with some $1.5 billion in debt and its shares are now worthless, but creditor banks seized his former Mumbai headquarters only this year. The fate of his Goan villa is stuck in a prolonged court tussle.

India ranks 130 out of 189 in the World Bank’s Ease of Doing Business report, below Lesotho and Cameroon, not least because of its poor performance in resolving insolvency.

The World Bank says it takes 4.3 years on average, more than twice as long as in China, with an average recovery of 25.7 cents on the dollar, one of the worst among similar size economies.

‘Dead Horses’

Troubled companies in India, or their creditors, largely turn to the Official Liquidator, a government-appointed officer attached to the country’s high courts, who administers assets and oversees liquidation.

Banks can also turn to separate Debts Recovery Tribunals (DRT), partly staffed by officials on assignment from the banks themselves and overseen by the Ministry of Finance.

The Finance Ministry is aiming to streamline and modernise the country’s archaic bankruptcy regulations as part of wider efforts to make it easier to do business in India. (HT Photo)
The Finance Ministry is aiming to streamline and modernise the country’s archaic bankruptcy regulations as part of wider efforts to make it easier to do business in India. (HT Photo)

Both are overstretched; on visits to their offices in India’s financial capital, Mumbai, computers were often off and always outnumbered by teetering pillars of files.

In the cramped Mumbai office of the DRT, a tribunal considered far speedier than the courts, a Ministry of Finance letter on the notice board urged officials to move faster, as cases were “in many cases taking more than four years”. Inside, officials complained they had little power to draw a line under languishing cases.

“They are all dead horses,” said one, gesturing to the day’s case list. “They are never going to run any races, but you have to keep the dead stock.”

Chief among the problems is that for a single troubled company, creditors and owners can all initiate competing proceedings in different courts, tribunals and states.

Current legislation - especially the Sick Industrial Companies Act of 1985 - is geared towards reviving companies, so appeals frequently follow a wind-up order, resulting in virtual paralysis.

“The Official Liquidator system is a disaster. It takes a minimum of five years and can take 10 years, by which point there is virtually no value left in the asset,” said Bahram Vakil, partner with law firm AZB & Partners in Mumbai and a member of the reform committee. “There is a crying need (for change). That system has completely broken down.”

Another committee member, MR Umarji, a consultant at the Indian Banks’ Association and former central bank official, said staffing constraints meant it could take 15 to 20 years to wind up a company: “There are very limited numbers of persons available and there are hundreds, thousands of companies to be wound up.”

Proposed changes will scrap the Official Liquidator and introduce a system of registered insolvency practitioners, with a regulatory body, working under a company law tribunal. Practitioners, lawyers and drafters of the law hope it will professionalise the process, committee members said.

The changes, which would probably go to parliament next year, must first overcome a mindset that is geared to avoiding, not hastening, failure.

They also need to provide the means to speed it up, through initiatives to take courts online and generate a corps of insolvency practitioners.

“The law can give the principles, but it requires enabling infrastructure for it to be implemented effectively,” said Debanshu Mukherjee, of the Vidhi Centre for Legal Policy, a think-tank that advised the committee.

“Even an efficient judge cannot work without a support system.”

Read More:

Bankruptcy law likely to give investors easy exit options

India’s World Bank rank on ‘ease of business’ will improve: Jaitley

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
Gopinath, in response to a question on the new farm laws, said: “These particular farm laws were in the area of marketing."(File photo)
Gopinath, in response to a question on the new farm laws, said: “These particular farm laws were in the area of marketing."(File photo)

India’s new agri laws have potential to raise farm income: IMF's Gita Gopinath

PTI, Washington
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 11:24 PM IST
There are multiple areas where the reforms are needed, including infrastructure, the Chief Economist of the Washington-based global financial institution said on Tuesday.
Close
A total of 56.01 per cent children were found to have no access to smartphones, the study said.(Unsplash)
A total of 56.01 per cent children were found to have no access to smartphones, the study said.(Unsplash)

Chinese smartphone brands expanded India market share in 2020: Report

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 08:25 PM IST
Chinese brands commanded 75% of India's smartphone market last year, up from 71% in 2019 and the highest since at least 2014.
Close
Goyal said that the strong growth of startups could transform India from a screwdriver economy to technology-driven economy.(PTI File Photo)
Goyal said that the strong growth of startups could transform India from a screwdriver economy to technology-driven economy.(PTI File Photo)

Business should dedicate portion of their wealth to fund startups: Goyal

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 07:07 PM IST
He suggested that business persons can come together and pool their resources, "may be an initial 10,000 crore fund," which is domestically driven and professionally managed, with no role of government in it.
Close
FDI is a major driver of economic growth and an important source of non-debt finance for the economic development of India.(Reuters)
FDI is a major driver of economic growth and an important source of non-debt finance for the economic development of India.(Reuters)

FDI into India up 37 percent to USD 43.85 billion during April-November 2020

PTI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 06:32 PM IST
Total FDI inflows during the eight-month period of the current fiscal grew by 22 per cent to USD 58.37 billion.
Close
In the four straight sessions, the benchmark has fallen by 2,382.19 points or 4.78 per cent.(PTI)
In the four straight sessions, the benchmark has fallen by 2,382.19 points or 4.78 per cent.(PTI)

Investors' wealth plunge over 8 lakh crore in 4 days

PTI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 06:25 PM IST
In the broader market, the smallcap and midcap indices fell up to 1.38 per cent.
Close
“CBDT issues refunds of over Rs. 1,81,336 crore to more than 1.74 crore taxpayers between 1st April, 2020 to 25th January, 2021,” the department tweeted. (Representative Image)(Mint Photo)
“CBDT issues refunds of over Rs. 1,81,336 crore to more than 1.74 crore taxpayers between 1st April, 2020 to 25th January, 2021,” the department tweeted. (Representative Image)(Mint Photo)

Income Tax refunds worth 1.81 lakh cr issued so far in FY21

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 06:21 PM IST
Of this, personal income tax refunds of 62,231 crore have been issued to over 1.71 crore taxpayers and corporate tax refunds of 1.19 lakh crore have been issued in 2.12 lakh cases.
Close
Indigo Paints is the fifth-largest company in the paint industry in terms of the revenue from operations for fiscal year 2020.(iStock)
Indigo Paints is the fifth-largest company in the paint industry in terms of the revenue from operations for fiscal year 2020.(iStock)

Indigo Paints IPO allotment to be announced on January 28

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Mallika Soni
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 06:17 PM IST
The IPO which is worth 1170 crore included fresh issue of shares worth 300 crore and offer-for-sale (OFS) of up to 58.40 lakh equity shares by private equity firm Sequoia Capital and promoter Hemant Jalan.
Close
A man wearing a protective mask, amid the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) outbreak, stands in front of an electric board showing Nikkei index outside a brokerage in Tokyo, Japan January 21, 2021. REUTERS/Kim Kyung-Hoon(REUTERS)
A man wearing a protective mask, amid the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) outbreak, stands in front of an electric board showing Nikkei index outside a brokerage in Tokyo, Japan January 21, 2021. REUTERS/Kim Kyung-Hoon(REUTERS)

World shares turn lower on pandemic concerns, ahead of Fed

AP
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 06:04 PM IST
Markets have meandered since last week as investors weighed solid corporate earnings results against renewed worries that troubles with Covid-19 vaccine rollouts and the spread of new variants of coronavirus might delay a recovery from the pandemic.
Close
The Bombay HC has ruled that private entities such as Facebook, Twitter and Instagram should not carry political ads 48 hours before voting in general elections.(Reuters File /)
The Bombay HC has ruled that private entities such as Facebook, Twitter and Instagram should not carry political ads 48 hours before voting in general elections.(Reuters File /)

Facebook investors shrug off election woes, look for 'social commerce' payday

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 05:48 PM IST
The world's biggest social media company is poised to reap a windfall from that gambit, analysts say, bolstered by a return in ad growth rates to pre-Covid levels and a holiday shopping boost from its new "social commerce" features.
Close
A customer hands Indian currency notes to an attendant at a fuel station in Mumbai, India.(Reuters)
A customer hands Indian currency notes to an attendant at a fuel station in Mumbai, India.(Reuters)

Rupee settles 2 paise higher at 72.92 against US dollar

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 04:35 PM IST
Meanwhile, the dollar index, which gauges the greenback's strength against a basket of six currencies, advanced 0.25 per cent to 90.39.
Close
The benchmark S&P BSE Sensex gained 0.6% to 49,177.99 by 0353 GMT.(Mint file photo)
The benchmark S&P BSE Sensex gained 0.6% to 49,177.99 by 0353 GMT.(Mint file photo)

Indices close in red: Sensex falls 937 points, Nifty below 14,000

By hindustantimes.com
UPDATED ON JAN 27, 2021 04:22 PM IST
Sensex sheds 937 points; Nifty ends below 14,000 dragged by banks, metal stocks
Close
Under an adverse economic scenario considered by the IMF, the world’s banks would fall $420 billion below regulatory capital requirements.(Reuters file photo)
Under an adverse economic scenario considered by the IMF, the world’s banks would fall $420 billion below regulatory capital requirements.(Reuters file photo)

IMF favours extension of pandemic support, thrust on infra investment in Budget

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 03:32 PM IST
On Tuesday, the IMF projected an impressive 11.5% growth rate for India in 2021. While this is attributable to the stronger than expected recovery, Gopinath said India still has some distance to go.
Close
European Union (EU) flags outside the Berlaymont building in Brussels, Belgium.(Bloomberg)
European Union (EU) flags outside the Berlaymont building in Brussels, Belgium.(Bloomberg)

European economy lags behind China and US on pandemic recovery

Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 03:23 PM IST
  • That was the upshot of the International Monetary Fund’s forecasts on Tuesday, which downgraded the growth outlook for 2021 across Europe and underscored a generally poorer performance compared with China and the US.
Close
The European Commission in its 2014 decision said Goldman Sachs, as the parent company, had decisive influence over Prysmian. A lower EU tribunal in 2018 backed its argument.(REUTERS)
The European Commission in its 2014 decision said Goldman Sachs, as the parent company, had decisive influence over Prysmian. A lower EU tribunal in 2018 backed its argument.(REUTERS)

Goldman Sachs loses legal fight against EU cartel fine

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 03:15 PM IST
Its penalty included a joint fine of 37.3 million euros with Goldman Sachs, which had acquired the Italian company via one of its private equity funds in 2005 but has since sold its holding.
Close
It is worthwhile to appreciate the full achievement of TCS. In 2000, TCS was not a listed company. It was not even the segment leader in India. By 2010, its market cap had grown to a creditable $25 billion and it had become the segment leader in India(REUTERS)
It is worthwhile to appreciate the full achievement of TCS. In 2000, TCS was not a listed company. It was not even the segment leader in India. By 2010, its market cap had grown to a creditable $25 billion and it had become the segment leader in India(REUTERS)

TCS third most valued IT services brand globally: Brand Finance

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 03:06 PM IST
TCS has celebrated strong revenue growth as demand grows for its core transformation services and through winning deals - worth over $6.8 billion in the fourth quarter of 2020 alone, it added.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP