Creamy layer: Wealth test, socio-economic status to be criteria for exclusion from BC quota

Specifying a fresh income and wealth criteria for identifying persons in the ‘creamy layer’ among the backward classes (BC) to exclude them from the purview of reservation in public employment and educational institutions, the Haryana government has ordered that children whose parents have a gross annual income of 6 lakh and above or who possessed wealth above 1 crore for last three consecutive years will not be entitled for BC reservation
The fresh criteria have been notified on directions of the SC which had quashed a Haryana government notification from August 17, 2016 pertaining to identification of creamy layer from backward classes solely on the basis of economic criterion. (IStock)
The fresh criteria have been notified on directions of the SC which had quashed a Haryana government notification from August 17, 2016 pertaining to identification of creamy layer from backward classes solely on the basis of economic criterion. (IStock)
Published on Nov 24, 2021 01:02 AM IST
Copy Link
By, Chandigarh

Specifying a fresh income and wealth criteria for identifying persons in the ‘creamy layer’ among the backward classes (BC) to exclude them from the purview of reservation in public employment and educational institutions, the Haryana government has ordered that children whose parents have a gross annual income of 6 lakh and above or who possessed wealth above 1 crore for last three consecutive years will not be entitled for BC reservation. Income from all sources will be clubbed to arrive at the gross annual income.

The fresh criteria have been notified on directions of the Supreme Court which on August 24 had quashed a Haryana government notification from August 17, 2016 pertaining to identification of creamy layer from backward classes solely on the basis of economic criterion.

The new criteria are broadly on the lines of recommendations made by the National Commission for Backward Classes in its 2015 review of income criteria for creamy layer.

The 2016 notification also did sub-classification of backward classes which was held arbitrary and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution by the Punjab and Haryana high court. Besides, fixing income criteria as 6 lakh for identifying and excluding the BC ‘creamy layer’, the 2016 notification divided the remaining BCs who were eligible for reservation into two groups on the basis of their annual.

The first group comprised persons whose gross annual income was up to 3 lakh and the other whose income was between 3-6 lakh.

The new creamy layer

The Haryana welfare of scheduled castes and backward classes department, in a November 17 notification, has also excluded sons and daughters of Class 1 and 2 officers of central, state and all India services from the purview of BC reservation.

Children of officers holding equivalent or comparable posts in public sector undertakings, banks, insurance organisations, universities have also been excluded from the BC quota.

As per the notification, children of armed forces personnel, including paramilitary forces whose either or both parents are in the rank of major or above, and children whose family owns land more than the permissible limit under the land ceiling law have also been excluded from the BC quota.

Children of constitutional personalities or persons holding constitutional posts including MPs and MLAs have been excluded from the purview of reservation.

BC sub-classification held arbitrary by the HC

The August 2016 ‘creamy layer’ notification, held arbitrary by the high court, had sub-classified the BCs stating that children of persons having gross annual income up to 3 lakh shall first of all get benefit of reservation in services and admission in educational institutions.

The left-out quota shall go to that class of BC citizens who earn more than 3 lakh but up to 6 lakh per annum. The sections of backward classes earning above 6 lakh per year shall be considered ‘creamy layer’ as per the 2016 notification.

While directing the state government to issue a fresh creamy layer criteria within three months, the apex court said a notification issued by the Haryana government on June 7, 1995 was in tune with the SC judgement in Indira Sawhney case.

The 1995 notification excluded certain persons who held constitutional posts and those who were in employment of the state and the Centre in higher posts from the benefit of reservation.

In addition, the social advancement of other categories was taken into account for the purpose of including such categories in ‘creamy layer’.

The apex court said according to the August 2016 notification, the identification of ‘creamy layer’ among backward classes was strangely restricted on the basis of economic criteria only.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Noida: Fire broke out at an ATM kiosk, engulfed multi-storey building.

    Fire at ATM kiosk engulfs multi-storey building in Noida | Video

    A fire suspected to have started at an ATM kiosk in Noida Friday night engulfed the four-storey building, news agencies reported. The fire broke out around 10pm at a multi-storey residential-cum-commercial building in the crowded Bhangel area, prompting the deployment of firefighters, reported PTI citing officials. A short circuit at the ATM is believed to have triggered the fire, spreading into the other floors of the four-storey building.

  • Mukesh's cart stands outside the bus terminus in Delhi’s Anand Vihar, and is decked with ears of the golden corn.

    Delhiwale: Bhutta returns, in a new chulha

    Very many of the bhutta vendors, who will soon pop up through the Delhi region, source their bhuttas from Azadpur Sabzi Mandi. But Mukesh gets his directly from a region where they are grown in great quantity, he says, close to his native Moradabad.

  • A view of the Amar Jawan Jyoti memorial at India Gate, in New Delhi. (Jasjeet Plaha/HT Archive)

    Symbol to honour martyrs shifted from India Gate to War Memorial

    Prime Minister Narendra Modi inaugurated National War Memorial (NWM) three years ago, on February 25, 2019, and since then, millions of people have visited the memorial and paid homage to the country’s fallen heroes whose names are inscribed on its walls.

  • The maximum temperature at five of the 11 weather stations in Delhi breached the 40°C mark on Friday. (Raj K Raj/HT PHOTO)

    Heatwave not likely in Delhi for a few days, says IMD

    Delhi's maximum temperature rose by three degrees on Friday to settle at 39.3 degrees Celsius (C), which, according to the India Meteorological Department, was still a degree below what is considered the normal for this time of the year. The officials added that no heatwave conditions are expected in the national capital for the next five days. The maximum temperature at five of the 11 weather stations in Delhi breached the 40C mark on Friday.

  • A view of the under constructed site after it collapsed, at Phirni Road, Mundka, in New Delhi, India, on Friday, May 27, 2022. (HT Photo)

    1 dead, 2 hurt as building falls in outer Delhi

    Deputy commissioner of police (outer) Sameer Sharma identified the deceased man by his first name as Manas, a resident of Prem Nagar, and the injured as Gareeb Shah (54) and his son Sachin Kumar (age unknown), residents of Bhagat Singh Park area.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Saturday, May 28, 2022