Sign in

27 years on, Aussie maintains controversial views on Tendulkar’s dismissal: ‘Sachin says I need to get my eyes checked'

That controversial decision on December 13, 1999 is still a matter of discussion.

Updated on: Mar 15, 2026, 08:44:34 IST
Share
Share via
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin
  • whatsapp
Copy link
  • copy link

As far as Glenn McGrath is concerned, Sachin Tendulkar was out that day. Even though the rest of the world thinks differently. The date was December 13, 1999 and the venue was the Adelaide Oval. India, in pursuit of 396 to win, fell by the wayside in their second innings with Tendulkar falling lbw to McGrath on the penultimate day of the Test match. The ball was short and hit Tendulkar on the shoulder, and umpire Daryl Harper raised his finger in the blink of an eye, to the utter dismay of Indian fans.

Come on, Glenn! Speak the truth. (AFP)
Come on, Glenn! Speak the truth. (AFP)

Also Read: Yuvraj Singh in high demand: why cricketers knock on his door in their hour of need?

Many have since given their verdict on the dismissal, and an overwhelming majority thinks Tendulkar was not out, including Pakistan legend Wasim Akram. But 27 years on, McGrath is adamant. At an event hosted by Sportstar, the former Aussie pacer not for a moment hesitated and asserted Tendulkar was out for sure.

If stubbornness had a name!

"Sachin had just come to the crease, I think he faced four balls. And I thought it was time to give him a bouncer. I ran in, bolted short, Sachin saw that it was short, and he ducked under it. The problem for Sachin was that the ball didn't bounce, it shot low, and it hit him in the shoulder.

"From where I was looking, I saw Sachin squat down. I could see the bails over the top of his head. So I thought that ball's clearly hitting the stumps. And it's, I think it was Daryl Harper. It was an Australian umpire, Daryl Harper, who actually gave it out, and Sachin and I have been discussing that dismissal for a long time," he said.

He added, "He thinks it was clearly going over the stumps by a good foot and a half. I still think the ball was tapering off and going to hit the stumps. And 18 months ago, I got the opportunity to do a TV commercial with Sachin here in India.

"And the whole part of the TV commercial is Sachin thinks I need to get my eyes checked because obviously that was clearly not out. No, it was having a bit of fun and, yeah, I still think that was out. Sachin still thinks it was clearly not out, and I think we'll continue to have that discussion."

India were whitewashed 3-0 in the Test series at a time when many thought skipper Tendulkar was at the height of his powers.

  • Prateek Srivastava
    ABOUT THE AUTHOR
    Prateek Srivastava

    Prateek Srivastava is a senior sports journalist having been in the profession for two decades now. He started his print career with the India Today Group and later also worked for the Asian Age.   In 2009, sensing the wind of change, he switched to the digital media and joined Mobile ESPN. There, he covered the 2011 Cricket World Cup and 2010 Hockey World Cup as a venue reporter. He did plenty of voice-over work too, over there.   After leaving Mobile ESPN, Prateek went on to work for Cricketnext, Gocricket and Cricbuzz. At Gocricket (Times Internet Limited), he covered the 2014 T20 World from Bangladesh. There he also received a team leadership award, given at the end of the month.   Prateek has also covered the 2016 T20 World Cup in India, this time working for Sportz Interactive. He also worked for Chinese giants Alibaba over two years and led their ""Short News"" content team at UC Browser.   While cricket is Prateek’s expertise, he has also done a lot of golf. In fact, he has covered India’s first two European Tour events back in the late noughties. He has also done extensive writing on football having been associated with the Indian Super League for three seasons. Finally, Prateek is a literature aficionado and swears by Philip Roth and Gabriel Garcia Marquez, and when he doesn’t joke, he is usually quiet and at work.Read More

Get live cricket scores, match updates, schedules, results and ICC rankings. Follow the latest news, statistics and performances of top teams and players on Hindustan Times.