Sign in

Agarkar, Gambhir set for KL Rahul vs Shubman Gill debate as India stare at fresh line-up vs England without Rohit, Kohli

Here's a look at how the batting line-up could shape up in England in the absence of Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma

Updated on: May 12, 2025, 13:43:17 IST
By
Share
Share via
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin
  • whatsapp
Copy link
  • copy link

It was always hard to fathom an Indian Test team without Sachin Tendulkar and the rest of the Fab Five. But rarely did the likes of Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma, Cheteshwar Pujara, and Ajinkya Rahane allow their absence to be felt. As India rose through the ranks and touched the ultimate highs—joining the echelons of the greatest Test teams in history—these players blossomed from being the Next-Gen into greats of the format, eventually ushering in a transition phase.

Who will replace Rohit Sharma as opener in India Test XI? (AP)
Who will replace Rohit Sharma as opener in India Test XI? (AP)

India moved on from Rahane and Pujara two years ago. But a bigger test awaits the selectors and team management as India transition into a new era without Kohli and Rohit. The latter announced his sudden retirement from Test cricket on May 7 via a social media post. Days later, reports indicated that Kohli had already informed the BCCI that "he's done" with the format. He eventually announced it officially on Monday, also on Instagram.

With both developments unfolding just weeks before the scheduled selection meeting for the five-match Test series in England—a country where India haven't won a series in over a decade—the Ajit Agarkar-led committee and head coach Gautam Gambhir find themselves in a muddle. But India do have a solid pool of reserves to draw from. Here's a look at how the batting line-up could shape up in England in the absence of the two star batters.

Who will replace Rohit Sharma as opener?

Yashasvi Jaiswal, who has featured in 19 Tests, scoring 1798 runs at 52.88, will be a certainty for the series. He has four centuries to his name, two of those away from home, with one in Australia, where he averaged 43.44 in his debut tour last season. However, Jaiswal has yet top prove himself in the seaming conditions in England.

To replace Rohit, India could recall Shubman Gill, who had willingly taken up the No. 3 responsibility after Pujara. He proved his worth in the position, scoring three centuries in the last 15 months, all of which came at home. On overseas soil, the 25-year-old averages just 19 in 12 innings with no half-century score. On the contrary, he averages 31.54 away from home as an opener, with two fifties. Although he does not have a very pleasant memory of facing the brand-new duke ball in England, managing just 88 runs in six innings.

India could hence retain Gill, reportedly set to be the next captain, at No. 3 and try out the experienced KL Rahul, who averages 34 as an opener in England, with two hundreds, and will head into he series after a decent show in Australia in the role.

The other possibility could be trying Abhimanyu Easwaran, who has long been knocking on the selection door and was also part of the squad during the entire Australia tour last season. The Bengal batter will be travelling to England for the India A series. Sai Sudharsan is also an option. The left-hander also has experience of English conditions, having played the County Championship last year, where he scored a century for Surrey batting at No. 6. He also scored a double century for Tamil Nadu in the previous Ranji Trophy season.

Who will replace Virat Kohli?

While India have seen a few too many openers in Test cricket over the last decade, No. 4 has been a position of no headache for the management for the last 12 years until now. With Kohli's potential departure, India could move trust Rahul with the role, who is the only batter in the line-up with experience of playing at all the top four spots. The other possibility is having Sudharsan at No. 4 and retaining Rahul as opener or, pushing Rishabh Pant to the fourth spot and slotting in Sudharsan at No. 6 after Ravindra Jadeja.

Not to forget, Karun Nair, who will be travelling to England for the India A series after a stupendous Ranji Trophy season, could be entrusted with the No. 4 role. He does have County experience as well, averaging 49 in the last season, where he scored a century and three fifties.

Other options include Shreyas Iyer, who had a decent Ranji campaign last season, and Devdutt Padikkal, who batted at No. 3 and 4 in his two Test outings for India, scoring 25 and 65, respectively.

Possible India batting line-up for England tour: KL Rahul, Yashasvi Jaiswal, Shubman Gill, Sai Sudharsan/Karun Nair, Rishabh Pant, Ravindra Jadeja, Nitish Kumar Reddy.

Back ups: Abhimanyu Easwaran, Dhruv Jurel, Shreyas Iyer, Devdutt Padikkal, Rajat Patidar, Washington Sundar, Axar Patel, Sarfaraz Khan

  • Aratrick Mondal
    ABOUT THE AUTHOR
    Aratrick Mondal

    Aratrick Mondal is a senior sports journalist based in New Delhi. In his eight years as a sports writer, Aratrick has worked at leading media organisations, including The Times of India, Times Now, Zee, India TV and currently works at a senior position at Hindustan Times Digital. He writes on cricket, football, pickleball and tennis, among other sports. He has extensively covered India's evolving cricket landscape, the country's new-found love for private leagues such as Indian Pickleball League (IPBL), Ultimate Kho Kho League (UKK), Rugby Premier League (RPL) and several tennis leagues. He has closely covered emerging sports such as pickleball. His coverage of major franchise events lends an atmospheric flavor to his ground reports. His recent story on how SA20 (the domestic cricket league of South Africa) had opened up its grounds to create a carnival-like fan experience garnered major international attention, including appreciation from major cricketers. Tennis holds a special place in his heart. Aratrick has built a strong niche in analytical tennis stories—ranging from Grand Slam narratives and player profiles to tactical breakdowns and ranking trends. His long-form features often decode grand slams, career highs and lows of tennis greats and the upward trajectory of emerging stars. He also closely follows India's tennis landscape, having covered the Davis Cup, Bengaluru Open and Tata Open, among others. His reporting is backed by strong data capabilities, with hands-on experience using tools like Python, Tableau, and Excel to produce visually rich, insight-led stories. This data-first approach enhances accuracy, transparency, and trust. In leadership roles, he has managed editorial shifts, overseen homepage strategy, optimised SEO workflows, and mentored peers to deliver consistent, high-traffic journalism. He recently won the HT DigiStar award for the third quarter of financial year 2025-26. Aratrick is trusted for his balanced reportage, sound sourcing, and ability to translate complex sporting events into engaging narratives that speak to a wide audience. He believes sports is for everyone, not just for the enthusiasts and has a unique ability to bring people together - just like the sumptuous meals you'll often find him cooking on a weekend evening.Read More

Get live cricket scores, match updates, schedules, results and ICC rankings. Follow the latest news, statistics and performances of top teams and players on Hindustan Times.