Did Kejriwal choose the wrong cause to make the right point?

On the face of it, the trigger for the latest round of controversy was the appointment of the acting chief secretary, something so routine that in past chief secretaries travelling out of the country have nominated their colleague on their own.
Updated on May 20, 2015 06:39 PM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times | By, New Delhi

As the Arvind Kejriwal-Najeeb Jung tussle over the power to post bureaucrats reached Rashtrapati Bhavan on Tuesday, Kejriwal government may have selected the wrong cause to possibly make the right point.

On the face of it, the trigger for the latest round of controversy was the appointment of the acting chief secretary, something so routine that in past chief secretaries travelling out of the country have nominated their colleague on their own.

But chief secretary KK Sharma went on leave without nominating anyone and there was no consensus on the acting CS.

The Law

The law, and the Constitution is clear on the powers of the chief minister and his cabinet. The power to appoint senior civil servants is not one of them.

Under Article 239AA inserted into the Constitution by Parliament that gave the Capital a legislative assembly in 1991, the elected government in Delhi that he leads does not have the mandate to appoint or post officers.

“The fact is that Delhi may have an elected chief minister but it is still a Union Territory, a centrally administered territory. Full stop,” a senior government official – familiar with the rules governing allocation of powers – said. “And the control over the civil service in union territories is wielded by the home ministry, and the Lt Governor”.

That the rules say the chief minister should be consulted before the appointment of the chief secretary is only a concession granted by the Centre.


But it was former deputy prime minister LK Advani who had stressed that the consultation was not just a formality in 2002 when then chief minister Sheila Dikshit asked Shailaja Chandra be appointed to the top post.

The then Lt Governor Vijai Kapoor had someone else in mind and conveyed his views to the Centre. Home ministry officials processed Kapoor’s nominee and sought Advani’s approval.

A former home ministry official recalled how the veteran politician rejecting the Lt-Governor’s nominee, pointing to officials that an elected chief minister should have the right to select his, or her team of officials.

Tussle is a symptom, not the root cause

Sources in the Kejriwal government, indicate that there had been some discomfort within the elected government at Raj Niwas taking too much of an interest in areas that were the primary responsibility of the elected government. “This is the root cause of the problem,” Delhi government sources said. Kejriwal's letter to the Prime Minister Narendra Modi makes the same point.

Indeed, the power structure in Delhi is complicated at the best of times. The chief minister heads the elected government but it is the Lt-Governor who has the last word. And then, there are union ministries that too have a say.

Right Point

“The multiplicity of authorities has been a long felt problem in Delhi. And the Kejriwal government would have received public support if it had stood for a point that improved the quality of lives of the people who elected him,” said a retired government official. “Instead, it chose to run down its officers in public and tarnish their reputation,” the official added.

It is a charge the AAP government vehemently denies, arguing that Raj Niwas precipitated the situation when it got acting chief secretary Shakuntala Gamlin, a 1984-batch IAS officer, to send across a formal complaint against the CM's office. Somehow, the letter – written by Gamlin to the Lt-Governor and the Home Ministry – was leaked within hours. "We only acted to defend the government," an official said.

No end in sight​

But as the Centre got down to the task of clarifying the legal position on the CM and the Lt-Governor's powers, the tussle continued in Delhi.

In a letter to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Kejriwal went beyond the dispute over the appointment of the acting chief secretary and complained that the Centre was trying to run the Delhi government "unconstitutionally through the Lt-Governor. Let Delhi government function independently".


wrote back

listing his constitutional powers in appointment of officers.


    Aloke Tikku has covered internal security, transparency and politics for Hindustan Times. He has a keen interest in legal affairs and dabbles in data journalism.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • The cinema takes its name from the family that ran it.

    Delhiwale: This way to Golcha

    As part of our 'Walled City dictionary' series that explores the names of Old Delhi places. Despite being a mere courtesan, Anarkali dares Emperor Akbar with a spunky dance. Golcha cinema, in Daryaganj, is screening the digitally coloured version of the classic Mughal-e-Azam. The single-screen hall shut down six years ago (last movie screened was Kahani 2). Golcha came up in 1954. The theatre is now a ghost of its recent past.

  • The territory of Jammu and Kashmir has been selected by the ministry for external affairs (MEA) for G-20 meetings during the summit of the high-profile grouping to be hosted by India in 2023. (HT File Photo)

    Jammu and Kashmir to host G20 summit next year, 5-member panel formed

    The Jammu and Kashmir government has constituted a five-member high-powered panel for overall coordination of G20 meetings to be held in the union territory next year. Acting upon a communique from the Union ministry of external affairs dated June 4, the principal secretary to the J&K government, Manoj Kumar Dwivedi accorded sanction for the constitution of the five-member panel.

  • NIA conducts searches in Jalalabad bomb blast case

    NIA conducts searches in Jalalabad bomb blast case

    The National Investigation Agency on Friday conducted searches at multiple locations in Punjab in the last year's Jalalabad bomb blast case. The NIA conducted searches at 6 locations in the districts of Ferozepur, Fazilka and Tarn Taran and digital devices (mobile phones, SIM cards, memory cards, DVRs) , ammunition and other incriminating documents/materials were seized.

  • “For only the 2nd time since 1947, J&K will have no assembly members to vote in the Presidential poll. The last time this happened was during the dark days of the early 90s, 1992 to be precise,” tweeted former Jammu and Kashmir chief minister and NC vice-president Omar Abdullah. (ANI File Photo)

    ‘Last time this happened in 1992’: Omar on Jammu and Kashmir assembly missing Prez poll

    Former J&K chief minister Omar Abdullah said that after the Independence of the country, only for the second time assembly members from J&K can't take part in the presidential elections scheduled for next month. Earlier in 1992, when militancy was at its peak and J&K was under Governor's rule, the erstwhile state had no assembly then so legislators from J&K couldn't participate in the elections for the country's President.

  • The officers apprised the L-G, Manoj Sinha, of the overall security situation while threadbare discussions were held on various arrangements related to Amarnath Yatra. (PTI File Photo)

    Ahead of Amarnath Yatra, L-G Manoj Sinha reviews security scenario

    With barely six days to go for the annual Amarnath Yatra, lieutenant governor Manoj Sinha reviewed the security arrangements and preparations for the ensuing pilgrimage at a unified command meeting in Srinagar on Thursday, said officials here. The meeting was attended by the chief secretary and senior security officers from the home department, J&K Police, army, intelligence agencies, CRPF, and others. It will conclude on August 11 on the festival of Raksha Bandhan.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Saturday, June 25, 2022