Govt-Oppn wound yet to heal

The debate in Lok Sabha on the motion on setting up a JPC saw a verbal duel that showed the ties between the government and opposition were tenuous. The thaw that ended the two-month-old stalemate seemed weak.

The debate in Lok Sabha on the motion on setting up a JPC saw a verbal duel that showed the ties between the government and opposition were tenuous. The thaw that ended the two-month-old stalemate seemed weak.

HT Image

As PM Manmohan Singh, Congress chief Sonia Gandhi and NDA working chairman LK Advani watched the duels, the government side seemed upset that the JPC was forced on them, largely on account of a threat to disrupt Parliament again.

The opposition took umbrage at the government’s attack. It accused the latter of being “not being gracious enough” when it had conceded to their demand, pointing to the enormity of the 2G scam and charges involving former minister A Raja.

Winding up the four-hour debate, Mukherjee, however, said, “We will be accommodative. We will travel the extra mile to ensure that these unfortunate events do not recur. We shall have to collectively sort it out.” The House adopted the Motion with a voice vote.

Mukherjee also recalled the NDA had refused a JPC on Tehelka expose and Arun Jaitley as then law minister had said “a group of MPs sitting in a JPC cannot substitute debate on the floor of the House.”

Swaraj criticised Mukherjee for dubbing the Opposition as “Maoists” recently. Mukherjee denied he had called the opposition Maoists but admitted he thought the Opposition’s stance could affect Parliament.

Swaraj asked, “Was our demand (for JPC) violent or unconstitutional that you compared us with the Maoists?” Mukherjee reminded Swaraj “either JPC or no Parliament” was not a democratic proposition.

Swaraj also questioned Sibal’s stand that there was “zero loss”. Sibal said she was good at “turning lies into truth and truth into lies.” An angry Opposition, however, forced him to withdraw his remark and apologise. At one point, BJP leader Yashwant Sinha said, “...We don’t want JPC, we don’t want charity...”