A woman goes through the process of eye scanning for Unique Identification (UID) database system at an enrolment centre at Merta district in Rajasthan February 21, 2013.(REUTERS)
A woman goes through the process of eye scanning for Unique Identification (UID) database system at an enrolment centre at Merta district in Rajasthan February 21, 2013.(REUTERS)

Privacy upheld as fundamental right: What term means for you, what’s govt view

What is individual privacy? How does the government view it? Is it only for elites?
By Samarth Bansal | Hindustan Times
UPDATED ON AUG 24, 2017 02:18 PM IST

A nine-member bench of the Supreme Court on Thursday delivered a landmark judgment unanimously declaring the right to privacy a fundamental right under the Constitution.

Privacy had emerged as a contentious issue while the apex court was hearing a batch of petitions challenging the Centre’s move to make Aadhaar mandatory for government schemes.

The privacy debate is not easy to follow. Distinctions are made between what individual privacy means when it comes to the government as opposed to private players such as Google and Facebook.

Here is a nine-point primer on the right to privacy and the Indian government’s view of it:

1. What is Privacy?

Not everyone understands what privacy means, which makes the privacy debate even more difficult. And those who do may interpret it differently.

One of the earliest definitions comes from Warren and Brandeis, who, in a 1890 paper, described privacy as the “right to be left alone”. In that sense, privacy is not necessarily about hiding something or keeping stuff secret.

In 1975, Altman describes privacy as “selective control of access to the self”. This implies that privacy concerns an individual’s ability to control what personal information is disclosed, to whom, when and under what circumstances.

Some suggest that the social context and culture determines the meaning of privacy: what is considered private in one part of the world may not be so in the other. Helen Nissenbaum proposed the idea of contextual integrity wherein boundaries allow individuals to control the transfer of personal information. But there are multiple boundaries, not one, which she calls “context based boundaries.”

2. Privacy from government

Traditionally, privacy has been understood in terms of surveillance by the state. Given that the government enjoys influence over the state machinery and have coercive powers related to law enforcement, mass surveillance is in a contest with the basic tenets of a liberal democracy.

“The right of privacy against the State is thus premised on the idea of personal freedom.”

3. Privacy from private actors

In recent years, with the onset of the data science revolution, private companies like Google and Facebook are able to collect and store large volumes of data about their billions of users. Their business model relies on processing the troves of data and monetising the “free” service by selling advertisements.

“The right to privacy against private actors is founded on principles of contract law, most prominently involving notice and consent.”

4. It’s a trade-off

Privacy is often at loggerheads with national security and the benefits of big data. Governments justify surveillance programmes by claiming that the information gathered about citizens would help in fighting terrorism. But that comes at the cost of their privacy.

Given that both “national security” and “privacy” are vaguely defined, advocates Vrinda Bhandari and Renuka Sane in their document on privacy framework in the age of internet point out that “there is no clarity on when one gives way to the other, and it is undeniably the rhetoric of national security that invariably overwhelms privacy.”

5. Indian government’s contradictory views

The Indian government argues that privacy concerns by private bodies should be viewed differently than by the government. In the Whatsapp Case, for instance, the Union government had said that the right to privacy is an integral part of Article 21 of the Constitution, which provides for the right to life and personal liberty. But in the case of Aadhaar, the government contradicts this view, arguing that privacy is not constitutionally inherent. Basically, they asked the court to view the right to privacy on a case by case basis.

6.What’s the impact of privacy invasion?

Identify theft: your personal information can be used to get phone numbers or credit cards in your name.

The motive could be financial fraud or to take part in illegal activities. Further, acquired information can be used to manipulate an individual in ways that they don’t even know. Your data can be used to get you to buy something online, try to get you to act in a certain way or to believe in something in a particular way. For instance, targeted political advertising, where campaigners spend money to show separate content to people with differing political beliefs.

7. Is privacy only for the elites?

When people say “In India, privacy doesn’t matter”, some point towards the lack of awareness and sensitivity to privacy issues, others toward cultural attitudes.

But one of the most common points is that privacy is only the preserve of the rich and the elite. They care about privacy, supporters of this view argue, as they already have access to basic services which the poor need. Privacy comes at the cost of development, as has been argued in the case of Aadhaar.

But as Alok Prasanna Kumar puts it, such an argument misunderstands the right to privacy and underplays its role in allowing individuals to make free choices. Privacy-is-for-elite argument is that of a “paternalistic and patriarchal state that knows what’s good for you and won’t let you make your own choices,”

8. “I have nothing to hide”

“I don’t care about privacy as I have nothing to hide” is quite regularly heard. Implicit in this argument is that only those who have something to hide—because they have done something wrong—are concerned about privacy invasion. And if that’s not the case, how can an individual’s information be used against her?

But experts say that this argument wrongfully equates privacy with secrecy, which are two distinct concepts. “Privacy is about exercising the choice to withhold information, which others have no need to know,” Bhandari and Sane wrote in an op-ed, while secrecy “is about withholding information that people may have a right to know.”

Question: If you have nothing to hide, will you share your Facebook/Gmail password with your friends?

9. Orwellian Reminder

Does the spread of technology mean that privacy is dead? If you think so, George Orwell’s classic novel 1984 will set alarm bells ringing. He talked about a surveillance state where people were aware that they could be monitored by the government at any given moment. And in such a society, where privacy shrinks to zero, Orwell said people can’t have unconventional thoughts, which is the way to a totalitarian society.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
BJP's Shahnawaz Hussain (left) will replace Sushil Modi in the legislative council after the latter's election to the Rajya Sabha while VIP chief Mukesh Sahni (right) will replace Vinod Narayan Jha who had won the assembly election.(HT PHOTO)
BJP's Shahnawaz Hussain (left) will replace Sushil Modi in the legislative council after the latter's election to the Rajya Sabha while VIP chief Mukesh Sahni (right) will replace Vinod Narayan Jha who had won the assembly election.(HT PHOTO)

Shahnawaz Hussain, Mukesh Sahni set to become Bihar MLCs unopposed

PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 05:00 PM IST
  • No other person has filed nomination against Shahnawaz Hussain and Mukesh Sani in view of the obvious majority of the National Democratic Alliance in the state legislature
Close
A teacher takes a class in a Delhi school. Schools in the national capital reopened for students of classes 10 and 12 on Monday. (PTI)
A teacher takes a class in a Delhi school. Schools in the national capital reopened for students of classes 10 and 12 on Monday. (PTI)

Scale down deployment of teachers on Covid-19 duty: Delhi dy CM Manish Sisodia

UPDATED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:54 PM IST
As schools in the Capital reopened, several principals had expressed concerns of managing classes as teachers remained deployed on Covid-19 duty
Close
Bharatiya Janata Party leader Ram Kadam and supporters blackening the face of actors of Amazon Web Series Tandava's poster during a protest in Mumbai.(ANI Photo)
Bharatiya Janata Party leader Ram Kadam and supporters blackening the face of actors of Amazon Web Series Tandava's poster during a protest in Mumbai.(ANI Photo)

News updates from Hindustan Times: FIR against makers of web series Tandav

By hindustantimes.com
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:52 PM IST
Here are today’s top news, analysis, and opinion. Know all about the latest news and other news updates from Hindustan Times
Close
Many lawyers practicing in district courts welcomed the decision and said that it will heal the lawyers of trial court who had suffered financially due to limited hearing in the courts.(HT archive)
Many lawyers practicing in district courts welcomed the decision and said that it will heal the lawyers of trial court who had suffered financially due to limited hearing in the courts.(HT archive)

Physical hearing on alternate basis resumes in Delhi district courts

ANI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:51 PM IST
The subordinate Courts have also been permitted to record evidence (except in those cases where the accused is in custody) while scrupulously adhering to the norms of social distancing when holding Courts physically.
Close
Arrested computer hacker and cyber criminal with handcuffs, close up of hands (Getty Images/iStockphoto)
Arrested computer hacker and cyber criminal with handcuffs, close up of hands (Getty Images/iStockphoto)

Man arrested for running fictitious firms to aid businesses evade GST: Officials

PTI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:47 PM IST
Investigation conducted so far has revealed 46 firms to be fictitious which were being controlled by Kumar and his associate.
Close
Taking note of the submission, the court disposed of the petition as not pressed.(HT File Photo)
Taking note of the submission, the court disposed of the petition as not pressed.(HT File Photo)

Amitabh Bachchan voice removed from Covid-19 awareness caller tune: HC told

PTI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:39 PM IST
The submission was made before a bench of Chief Justice D N Patel and Justice Jyoti Singh by the petitioner who said that with the removal of the actor's voice from the caller tune his plea has become infructuous.
Close
Tandav has a big star cast with actor Saif Ali Khan playing one of the lead roles. (File photo)
Tandav has a big star cast with actor Saif Ali Khan playing one of the lead roles. (File photo)

FIR registered in UP against makers of web series ‘Tandav’

By HT Correspondents | Edited by Smriti Sinha
UPDATED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:41 PM IST
A case has also been registered against the producer of web series ‘Mirzapur’ and Amazon Prime for hurting religious sentiments and social beliefs in Mirzapur district of eastern UP
Close
Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) volunteers perform a salute towards the RSS flag. (Representational photo/HT)
Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) volunteers perform a salute towards the RSS flag. (Representational photo/HT)

RSS decision-making body to hold annual meet in Bengaluru

PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:13 PM IST
The annual meeting, which will have in attendance the RSS brass and leaders of its 40-plus affiliates including the Bharatiya Janata Party president, was cancelled last year on account of the pandemic
Close
Union minister Nitin Gadkari interacts with media after a meeting on the ongoing projects in Maharashtra, in Mumbai, (PTI)
Union minister Nitin Gadkari interacts with media after a meeting on the ongoing projects in Maharashtra, in Mumbai, (PTI)

Before 2025, we aim to bring down road accidents by 50%: Nitin Gadkari

ANI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:12 PM IST
Highlighlight the achievements of the Ministry, he said, "We have achieved the target of constructing 30 kilometres of road per day. I believe that by the end of March, perhaps we will achieve the target of constructing 40 kilometres of road per day."
Close
Police said that the family has not filed any case yet.(HT representative photo )
Police said that the family has not filed any case yet.(HT representative photo )

16-year-old girl's body with throat slit found in Rajasthan's Barmer

PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:10 PM IST
Family members and locals have alleged that the minor was raped, but police said it could be confirmed only after the post-mortem.
Close
Shyam Saran Negi, believed to be India's oldest voter at 103 years of age, shows his inked finger after casting vote for Panchayat elections, at Kalpa in Kinnaur.(PTI)
Shyam Saran Negi, believed to be India's oldest voter at 103 years of age, shows his inked finger after casting vote for Panchayat elections, at Kalpa in Kinnaur.(PTI)

India's first voter, ex-school teacher: Shyam Saran Negi has never missed an ele

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Mallika Soni
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:07 PM IST
Negi has voted in every general election since 1951 and is believed to be India's oldest voter.
Close
Representational image. (Getty Images/iStockphoto)
Representational image. (Getty Images/iStockphoto)

Uttarakhand: Man arrested for drowning two children in a canal

PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:03 PM IST
The man, who started living with a woman and her two children after her husband died two years ago, told police that he thought of the children, aged 6 and 7, as “obstacles”
Close
Women supporting the farmers' agitation reach Rohtak toll plaza on Rohtak-Delhi road, in Haryana on January 17. (Manoj Dhaka/Hindustan Times)
Women supporting the farmers' agitation reach Rohtak toll plaza on Rohtak-Delhi road, in Haryana on January 17. (Manoj Dhaka/Hindustan Times)

SC tells Delhi Police to decide on farmers’ Jan 26 tractor rally

By Abraham Thomas
UPDATED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:27 PM IST
The apex court said the decision should be taken by the Delhi Police as the entry of farmers into the national Capital was a law and order problem
Close
The Bombay high court.
The Bombay high court.

Malicious reporting on SSR case: HC directs digital media to follow press council rules

By K A Y Dodhiya
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 03:47 PM IST
The court also accepted a suggestion of the petitioners that Mumbai Police should appoint an officer to act as a link between the media and investigators and conduct weekly briefings
Close
West Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee. (PTI)
West Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee. (PTI)

West Bengal assembly election: Mamata Banerjee to contest from Nandigram

UPDATED ON JAN 18, 2021 03:44 PM IST
TMC MLA from Nandigram and former minister Suvendu Adhikari shifted to the Bharatiya Janata Party on December 19, 2020
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP