Finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman believes that the Rs 20 lakh crore economic package to lift the economy out of the slump caused by the pandemic will lay foundations for a stronger economy and spur growth. In this file picture, PM Modi along with Union finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman arrives to pay tribute at the War Memorial.(PTI)
Finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman believes that the Rs 20 lakh crore economic package to lift the economy out of the slump caused by the pandemic will lay foundations for a stronger economy and spur growth. In this file picture, PM Modi along with Union finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman arrives to pay tribute at the War Memorial.(PTI)

Economic package will have multiplier effect, says FM Nirmala Sitharaman

The union finance minister is confident that the relief measures will spur demand and will also provide much needed relief from the pandemic to small and large businesses.
By R Sukumar and Shishir Gupta | Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAY 18, 2020 04:24 PM IST

Over five days, Union finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman announced the specific contours of a Rs 20 lakh crore economic package to help the Indian economy overcome the immediate crisis caused by the pandemic and the lockdown imposed to control its spread, as well as lay the foundations for a “self-reliant India”.

Shortly after her announcement on Sunday, the finance minister, in a wide-ranging interview to R Sukumar and Shishir Gupta spoke about the rationale behind the measures; emphasised that credit to both businesses and individuals will help provide relief and spur demand; countered the criticism that the package did not have a strong enough fiscal component; acknowledged the crisis faced by migrant workers; and her hopes for the Indian economy in 2021. Edited excerpts:

Also Read: ‘Focus on where money is going’, says Nirmala Sitharaman

Now that the entire package has been announced, what is the status of the budget numbers?

One thing we took cognizance of even before we announced the package and that is the borrowing [the government enhanced its borrowing limit for this year by Rs 4.2 lakh crore]. That is why we issued a fresh schedule of borrowing. But the rest of it, I have to wait and see. Because revenue generation and disinvestment – it’s too early for me to make an assessment now. This is only May; we have 10 more months to go in the year, and what an extraordinary year it is already.

Have you modelled any revenue estimates?

In this Covid era, does any modelling help?

Also Read: In lockdown 4.0, Centre allows offices, factories to open with staggered timings

How about the funding? You have told us about the borrowing; will that be enough to meet any revenue shortfall? Or will you need to borrow even more?

We took a comprehensive assessment (of what we would need) and then went with this number (Rs 20,97,053 crore). At the time itself we were conscious that we were looking at this stimulus and also a fall in revenue. We have to see how it goes.

If there is a significant shortfall in revenue, which seems very likely now, what happens to the share of the states?

The collection is divided between the Centre and the states; that’s the formula. If the collection itself falls, the formula will only give what it can give. Then the GST compensation, the GST based division that happens. I’m committed to give the compensation from the collection that I have. Over and above, if there is a shortfall, the GST Council will have to take a call.

Click here for the complete coverage of the Covid-19 pandemic

What is the kind of fiscal deficit India is looking at this year?

It’s too early to comment; I’ll be able to say closer to RE (the time the revised estimates come out).

One of the criticisms of the package is the overemphasis on monetary and liquidity components in the package you have announced and that the fiscal cost is just 10-15%

It’s amazing that comparisons are made with what other countries have given. At this time, I would request everyone to focus on where the money is going. I think it is important to reach out to those sections (of the population) that need relief to even survive. And not just individuals. If additional money doesn’t reach small units, they can’t pay wages; they can’t buy raw material; and run their units to even 10-15% capacity. So I’m making sure that is where the money goes; wait for the multiplier effect it can create in its immediate ecosystem.

Even for small enterprises, which you have rightly said are the most vulnerable, what the package has is largely credit. You have steered clear of income protection and wage support. In the UK, for instance, even middle-class salaried employees who have been furloughed are eligible for three months of payments up to 2500 pounds a month. Why have you not thought of that? Do you think the lower middle class and middle class doesn’t need that support?

Is there any section about whom I can say that they don’t need it? Is it my business to even judge? Everyone needs help in this kind of environment – but to different degrees. But what amazes me is that the moment we compare, we compare with advanced economies, which also have the advantage of good data, which also have the advantage of a system that delivers. Now the system that delivers, after Narendra Modi became PM in 2014 created DBT – and so I can deliver cash; I can deliver gas cylinders; I can deliver fertilizer subsidy to farmers.

But do I have other data? Did anyone, before this crisis, have data on migrant workers? Has there been any political party or analyst or economist or public thinkers – did anyone know the size of the migrant labour population? In a way, I’m thankful that we are now discussing this in depth. Like we should. Whoever thought that it would take a pandemic like this to tell us that even migrant workers need to be registered? When we talked of wanting to give some insurance to such migrants – when we wanted to do this, the data on such workers from the states… Did anyone give us exhaustive data?

When we compare with others, when they have systems to deliver, which we have today, when they have data about workers, both organised and unorganised, and then given the size of that economy — I’m very different. So we have to adapt. I have to make sure taxpayers money has to be spent where it actually means something. This doesn’t mean I’m saying giving it to the poor won’t mean anything, but there’s a limitation. How do I identify the poor? I can give it to Jan Dhan account holders, which is what I tried. But many of these migrants don’t even have a ration card. States now have to go through the grind to see how they cover them all — in PDS, in Jan Dhan. In fact it is becoming clear that these visionary steps of PM Modi that are helping us now.

A lot of the reforms that have been announced are significant, even radical; but they will play out over the medium-term or long-term. But in the short-term, the two most important things are cash in the hands of people, to help them overcome the immediate crisis, and ways to revive demand. How do you think this can be done?

The term loans and the working capital loans that banks have now been asked to give automatically to everybody — unless the customer says they don’t want it, the banks have to give it. Now when money flows to that little unit, he is obviously taking it to give wages or buy raw material. That is spurring demand. So demand doesn’t just get spurred at the individual level — people getting money and going out and buying bread and milk and other things. It is also companies, however small, getting that extra loan, so that they can open up after the lockdown. Spurring demand can also happen at the institutional level.

We are also giving, through NABARD, additional money for small and marginal farmers. That money is going for the pre-kharif (monsoon crop) preparation. Post-rabi (winter crop) harvest, they are feeling the need for money – this will take care of that also. Isn’t that money in the hands of people? I want people to go through every one of the announcements to realise how many of them mean more money in hand — and money in hand will spur demand.

Also Read: NREGA outlay, cap on state borrowing hiked in fifth round

There are some sectors such as aviation, tourism, hospitality, entertainment, where even if you give them money in hand, even a year later, these companies are going to be struggling because there is no demand.

They will come under one or the other schemes we have brought in — with the banks (credit). So, nobody is going to be left untouched. But touched the way you want? I may not have done that. But they will have access to resources. And this is after a lot of discussion with banks. Their hesitation to lend is because they are worried that the money won’t come back; what if a business turns genuinely bad? What if a genuine (lending) decision ends up meeting a mala fide intention of the borrower? In order to egg the banks to give more, we have come up with a guarantee.

Did a potential downgrade by credit rating agencies hold your hand when it came to more fiscal stimulus, or did you decide to just focus on doing what was needed?

We did discuss the rating agencies. But all of us agreed that India wasn’t singly or uniquely facing this problem. It is a global problem. Rating agencies rate you if you alone are not doing well in a world that is otherwise rosy. With a global pandemic, with every economy being affected….Ratings can’t be done in isolation. I’ve thought about it, and it doesn’t worry me. Look at the strengths of India: we are less affected; our foreign exchange reserves and macroeconomy are strong; we have had a six-year tenure of PM Modi who has handled the economy responsibly; our debt to GDP ratio has come down. Why would the rating agencies treat us badly? Rabi (the winter harvest), we have had a wonderful crop; and to the credit of the states, they have managed to get the harvest done, the procurement almost done.

A lot of the reforms that have been announced in these packages will need executive orders, notifications. Can we expect them in the next few days?

Yes. And some will happen through ordinance.

You pointed out in the course of the presentation today that the states are not borrowing enough. Why is this? Is it because they are anticipating very poor revenues? Or do they want the Centre to bail them out?

I don’t know. They have been writing to the PM, the chief ministers; and the finance ministers have been writing to me. It also came up with the meeting of the PM with the CMs, that they be allowed to borrow more. So we allowed that, but also put out the factual position on their current borrowings [around 14% of what is permissible].

When you look at big business, the formal sector, business has been non-existent. And other than credit, there is not much for them. Some of the companies I’ve spoken to were expecting some sort of scheme — a wage protection one like what France has done for instance. In the absence of this, there will be layoffs even in the formal sector.

Again, comparing with France is very different. There are limitations to that approach; but we have ensured that every one of these businesses has access to bank credit. Without new or additional collateral, we have said they should be given term loans and working capital loans — only because they have to tide over this crisis, over this particular problem.

Also Read: Lockdown 4.0: Delhi traders welcome Centre’s decision to open markets

Where do you see the Indian economy in March 2021?

I am confident that Indian entrepreneurs, like Indian farmers, can weather any storm. I am not saying I will therefore leave them to their lot. No, I will keep facilitating them. But that spirit in them is giving me hope.

The PM Garib Kalyan Yojana you announced in March had measures to provide cash and food to the most vulnerable. Do you think that is adequate? I know you have extended the food scheme to migrant workers, but do they need more?

I will have to assess it.

And if your assessment is that they do?

Of course, we are willing to give more. Nothing is closed.

How would you sum up the package in one sentence?

In fact, that’s why I quoted the Prime Minister. He said the package would focus on land, labour, liquidity and laws — we have done that. At the same time, every sector has been helped. I think this is a reasonably exhaustive package. And it approaches every section — perhaps in our own way, not in a way people wanted us to. There is hope for everyone to be benefit from this.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
With the assembly elections due in four months, Kerala finance minister TM Thomas Issac presented the last budget of the Pinarayi Vijayan government for now(PTI)
With the assembly elections due in four months, Kerala finance minister TM Thomas Issac presented the last budget of the Pinarayi Vijayan government for now(PTI)

Kerala earmarks fund for mental health

PUBLISHED ON JAN 16, 2021 12:39 AM IST
The state has earmarked Rs.64 crore for mental health programmes, usually a neglected sector. According to a survey conducted by the state mental health department last year, at least 15% of the youth between 18 and 25 years suffered from depression and other mental health problems.
Close
Former Meghalaya CM Dr Mukul Sangma receiving a report from West Jaintia Hills deputy commissioner Dykes detailing the identified stock of fresh coal identified at the spot.(HT photo)
Former Meghalaya CM Dr Mukul Sangma receiving a report from West Jaintia Hills deputy commissioner Dykes detailing the identified stock of fresh coal identified at the spot.(HT photo)

Ex-CM accuses ruling Meghalaya govt of encouraging illegal coal mining

By HT Correspondent, Shillong
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 12:15 AM IST
  • Sangma said the mineral, weighing truckloads, which were dumped in a scattered manner, were being tallied.
Close
The police have seized two big consignments of Nepalese cigarettes in less than a month in Champawat. (FILE PHOTO) (Image used for representation).
The police have seized two big consignments of Nepalese cigarettes in less than a month in Champawat. (FILE PHOTO) (Image used for representation).

Smuggled Nepalese cigarette brand dominates border areas of Uttarakhand

PUBLISHED ON JAN 16, 2021 12:01 AM IST
  • ‘Khukuri’ a brand of Nepalese cigarette has captured the market in the border areas of US Nagar, Champawat and Pithoragarh. Over 90% of smokers prefer to purchase and smoke this not due to taste but its cheap prices, said an official.
Close
Screen grab of a video showing fight between fake buffaloes at a village in Sivasagar district of Assam on Friday.
Screen grab of a video showing fight between fake buffaloes at a village in Sivasagar district of Assam on Friday.

Assam village sets example, holds fake buffalo fight to uphold SC ban

By Utpal Parashar | Edited by Sparshita Saxena
UPDATED ON JAN 15, 2021 11:58 PM IST
  • In 2016, the Supreme Court had placed a ban on animal fights during religious and cultural festivals.
Close
HT Image
HT Image

After protests, Goa CM announces relocation of IIT project from Melaulim

By Gerard de Souza
PUBLISHED ON JAN 15, 2021 11:47 PM IST
PANAJI: Goa chief minister Pramod Sawant on Friday announced that the Indian Institute of Technology (IIT)-Goa campus that was to be set up at Melaulim village would be shifted to another place in the state
Close
HT Image
HT Image

CBI ‘bribe-for-relief’ racket was running since 2018, finds probe

By Neeraj Chauhan, New Delhi
UPDATED ON JAN 15, 2021 11:47 PM IST
The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) has found that a “bribe-for-relief” racket was being run in the agency since 2018 by leaking confidential case related information to some companies being investigated for bank fraud, people familiar with the development said
Close
HT Image
HT Image

Construction work on New Parliament begins

PUBLISHED ON JAN 15, 2021 11:45 PM IST
New Delhi: Construction work on the foundation of the New Parliament building officially began on Friday, officials aware of the development said adding that some of the work had already begun on an alternative site to make up for the delay in the construction
Close
Both day and night also turned pleasant on Friday as temperatures dropped significantly in the city providing relief from week-long heat conditions. The Colaba observatory of the Indian Meteorological Department (IMD) recorded a minimum temperature of 21 degrees Celsius. (ANI PHOTO).
Both day and night also turned pleasant on Friday as temperatures dropped significantly in the city providing relief from week-long heat conditions. The Colaba observatory of the Indian Meteorological Department (IMD) recorded a minimum temperature of 21 degrees Celsius. (ANI PHOTO).

Mumbai logs AQI of 190, breathes cleanest air so far this year

PUBLISHED ON JAN 15, 2021 11:44 PM IST
  • Air quality had remained in the poor to very poor category since the beginning of January owing to low temperatures. On January 8, the AQI was the worst at 317 (very poor) for this year.
Close
Satabdi Roy, the three-time Lok Sabha member from Birbhum, told the media that she would fly to Delhi on Saturday. This led to rumours that she would possibly meet Union home minister Amit Shah. (ANI PHOTO).
Satabdi Roy, the three-time Lok Sabha member from Birbhum, told the media that she would fly to Delhi on Saturday. This led to rumours that she would possibly meet Union home minister Amit Shah. (ANI PHOTO).

TMC MP Satabdi Roy voices dissent, Abhishek Banerjee steps in to solve crisis

PUBLISHED ON JAN 15, 2021 11:27 PM IST
  • For the first time, TMC’s youth unit president and chief minister Mamata Banerjee’s nephew Abhishek Banerjee stepped in to solve the crisis. He sent party spokesperson Kunal Ghosh to bring Roy to his office on Camac Street in south Kolkata and held a two-hour meeting on Friday.
Close
As many as 97 vaccination centres have been set up for the launch on Saturday.(Reuters)
As many as 97 vaccination centres have been set up for the launch on Saturday.(Reuters)

Woman sanitation worker to get first vaccine jab in Chhattisgarh

PTI
UPDATED ON JAN 15, 2021 11:23 PM IST
The vaccination drive will cover over 2.67 lakh healthcare personnel and frontline workers in its first phase, state's mission director for the National Health Mission Priyanka Shukla said.
Close
Tezpur: A worker arranges boxes containing Covishield vaccine doses for their dispatch across the Sonitpur district, in Tezpur, Friday, Jan. 15, 2021. A countrywide COVID-19 vaccination drive is set to rollout from January 16, 2021. (PTI Photo) (PTI01_15_2021_000220B)(PTI)
Tezpur: A worker arranges boxes containing Covishield vaccine doses for their dispatch across the Sonitpur district, in Tezpur, Friday, Jan. 15, 2021. A countrywide COVID-19 vaccination drive is set to rollout from January 16, 2021. (PTI Photo) (PTI01_15_2021_000220B)(PTI)

Is Covid-19 vaccine mandatory?: All your FAQs about vaccination drive answered

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Shivani
PUBLISHED ON JAN 15, 2021 11:00 PM IST
Healthcare workers, both in government and private sectors including Integrated Child Development Services(ICDS) workers, will receive the vaccine during this phase, the health ministry said in a statement.
Close
Union home minister Amit Shah is scheduled to attend programmes in Bengal on January 30 and 31. The party also wants to plan a rally to be addressed by Prime Minister Narendra Modi in the coming weeks. (ANI FILE PHOTO).
Union home minister Amit Shah is scheduled to attend programmes in Bengal on January 30 and 31. The party also wants to plan a rally to be addressed by Prime Minister Narendra Modi in the coming weeks. (ANI FILE PHOTO).

Bengal BJP leaders meet Amit Shah in Delhi, discuss poll preparedness

UPDATED ON JAN 15, 2021 10:56 PM IST
  • To meet Shah’s target of winning more than 200 of Bengal’s 294 assembly seats in 2021, the BJP has put together its biggest election machinery in the eastern state.
Close
The standoff between India and China along the LAC in Ladakh has entered its seventh month.(Representative Photo)
The standoff between India and China along the LAC in Ladakh has entered its seventh month.(Representative Photo)

Ladakh soldiers among first set of army personnel to get Covid-19 vaccine

UPDATED ON JAN 15, 2021 11:29 PM IST
  • More than 12,000 doses of the vaccine have reached Ladakh of which around 4,000 have been earmarked for armed forces personnel to protect them from Covid-19, the officials said speaking on condition of anonymity.
Close
Odisha health workers who under the banner of Odisha State Male and Female Multipurpose Health Workers'/Health Supervisors’ United Association.(HT Photo)
Odisha health workers who under the banner of Odisha State Male and Female Multipurpose Health Workers'/Health Supervisors’ United Association.(HT Photo)

Thousands of Odisha's healthcare workers say no to Covid-19 vaccine, here's why

By Debabrata Mohanty, Bhubaneswar
PUBLISHED ON JAN 15, 2021 09:54 PM IST
  • MPW workers demand promotion and cadre-restructuring.
Close
Choudhury also blamed the Trinamool Congress for allowing the BJP to strengthen its base in the state.(Sanjeev Verma/ Hindustan Times)
Choudhury also blamed the Trinamool Congress for allowing the BJP to strengthen its base in the state.(Sanjeev Verma/ Hindustan Times)

Join Congress to defeat BJP: Adhir Ranjan repeats invite to Mamata Banerjee

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Shankhyaneel Sarkar, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON JAN 15, 2021 09:49 PM IST
  • Choudhury's comments came after the TMC had on Wednesday said the Congress and the Left should support Banerjee in her fight against the BJP, a suggestion rejected by the two parties.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP