Harivansh took charge at Parliament on Thursday.(HT Photo)
Harivansh took charge at Parliament on Thursday.(HT Photo)

Parliament should be home of healthy debate, not disruption: Rajya Sabha deputy chairman

Harivansh, a Janata Dal (United) Rajya Sabha member, was elected deputy chairman of the Upper House on Friday. He spoke to Hindustan Times
By Kumar Uttam and Prashant Jha | Hindustan Times, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON AUG 14, 2018 07:03 AM IST

Harivansh, a Janata Dal (United) Rajya Sabha member, was elected deputy chairman of the Upper House on Friday. A former journalist, Harivansh spoke to Kumar Uttam and Prashant Jha about his elevation, the role of Rajya Sabha, and his priorities. Excerpts:

When you were approached to be the candidate of the National Democratic Alliance, what was your first response?

It was entirely unexpected. I am someone who takes up any responsibility with a degree of seriousness. I was in several committees. I tried to ensure that I went into any committee with adequate preparation. I noticed that a lot of work that should happen in Parliament does not happen, but that work does get done in the committees to some extent. But I had a particular vision of Parliament before I came in. This is a site where stalwarts and the best debaters of their times – Bhupesh Gupta, Chandrashekhar, Atal Bihari Vajpayee, Prakash Vir Shastri, Nath (Bapu) Pai – discussed key national issues. There was a certain tradition in the house – when someone got up to speak, no one shouted. We have a strong memory of the idealism that drove politics from Gandhi till the time of Jayaprakash Narayan (JP).

But after coming to the House, I saw that this Parliament has travelled a long distance since then. I was often disappointed. In 2016, I wrote a piece lamenting what had happened. I felt that if we do not make it fruitful, fulfil the purpose for which the Upper Chamber was constituted, people will begin to ask about the rationale of Parliament. I tried to ensure I met my responsibilities seriously. I asked over 500 questions and participated in all debates whenever my party gave me an opportunity. I tried to speak about problems and solutions, and conduct myself in keeping with the traditions of the House. You would not have seen me in the Well, make any noise, disrupt proceedings.

When this proposal came my way, I was first apprehensive about whether I would be able to meet this responsibility in today’s environment. It is also true that my political experience is of only four years, though my experience of observing politics closely as a journalist is for over four decades. And I have been attracted to politics since my times as a student. I have been attracted to the ideological worldview of JP ji, (Ram Manohar) Lohia ji, Chandrashekhar, and later Nitish Kumar ji and have had relations with them. So the offer did seem like a challenge. But I thought that seniors in Parliament will guide me, and like I have worked seriously as an MP, I will try to work with commitment in this position.

There is a view that disruptions are a legitimate parliamentary tactic.

I have a different view on this. After becoming an MP, I travelled to a college in Arra (in Bihar). A student asked me, ‘we adopted the Westminster model, practiced in UK, US or Autralia. You will not see a single such instance there. We have an unprecedented situation in Parliament today. India has a rich tradition of debate and you will find it in Jain texts, Mahabharata, Nyay Sutra and other such texts. Frankly speaking, people’s faith in politics and leaders has declined. We have to restore that faith. I believe finally it is politics that changes society and country. We do not discuss issues related to farmers, construction labourers, hawkers, tribals and others. Why not raise issues related to the last man about whom Gandhi spoke? There will be differences of opinion. But there will be a point where we will have to find out a way.

Some leaders argue that the Rajya Sabha should not act as roadblock to a House elected by the people.

Dr (Sarvepalli) Radhakrishnan (the second president of India) said a second chamber is needed. It is believed (that) if Lok Sabha takes decisions under public pressure, then the Upper House, where there are people with creative thinking, would think over it cooly and correct the hasty decision. (MA) Ayyangar (former Lok Sabha speaker) defined it further, saying we should not be a clog. We feel it (Rajya Sabha) is necessary. I have seen brilliant discussion in the House.

Do you think federalism has got strengthened or weakened in recent times?

It is expected from us to raise issues related to states. But we mostly raise issues related to fights these days. There is little debate on how to strengthen the relationship. Regional disparity has increased for historical reasons. There is need for serious debate. This country can progress only when states are empowered. Only an empowered Centre is not sufficient.

Should political parties be more cautious in choosing their members in the Rajya Sabha?

The kind of selection started after 1980s was not there earlier. The challenge before us is to increase the level of debates in the context of development happenings around us, and find a solution to the problems faced by the country. There is debate over jobs – some say promise has not been fulfilled, the other side gives figure. There is debate over artificial intelligence and how it can create job losses. You cannot stop technology. Earlier, ideologies used to change the world, now it is technology. We will soon overtake China in terms of population. No country has been able to find a job model for such a big population; a growth model that can absorb all. Shouldn’t we discuss these issues? Did we discuss it ever? Was there any debate on global warming issues, on missing rivers and drinking water problems?

Do you think there is a rise in communalism and there should be debate on this too?

Anger has increased across all sections. Limited employment opportunity is the main reason. TV has brought a huge change. Advertisement teaches us how materialistic life is good. And when people do not get means to achieve (it), it leads to deep frustration. Today tribals are agitated. The poor are agitated.Young people in Uttar Pradesh, Bihar and Tamil Nadu are agitated. It is because of the mad race that we have got into. Everyone wants a good life. World is moving towards consumerism. Economist JK Galbraith was the first to warn us about the challenge. We have to address these issues.

Do you see any contradiction in getting elected to the chair with BJP’s support considering that you come from a socialist background and have been critical of the party in the past?

There was a purpose behind forming the NDA. Because of the chair that I occupy now, I do not want to comment on the situation leading to it. But, at least we see a serious effort to address the issues confronting the nation. I think the best we can contribute towards it, we should.

Do you see any challenge for the socialist parties?

Ideologically, you will not find sharper politicians than socialists. I am reading a book by James Crabtree called The Billionaire Raj (on inequality). Socialist thought is most relevant today. The era of politics of ideology is going to return. Without ideology, the economic disparity in the society cannot be addressed.

Critics believe Indian democracy has weakened and its institutions have been attacked...

Not at all. We have seen Emergency. We felt democracy will not return if elections are held. It was only because of this that people in power during that time called elections. Our people are very mature. When they are awake, democracy cannot get weakened. I feel technology - there are some side effects of social media too - also has a positive impact. They keep an eye on everything.

As deputy chairman, what is your expectation from the Centre?

The chairman (M Venkaiah Naidu) gave a slogan - responsive government, responsible opposition. I want the same. PM (Narendra) Modi also told MPs to put so much pressure on the ministers that works, issues that skip their sight are done. House is for this.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
Police said six men have been arrested for the murder.(Representational Photo/Getty Images)
Police said six men have been arrested for the murder.(Representational Photo/Getty Images)

TMC worker shot dead in north Bengal, another leader dies of heart attack

PUBLISHED ON JAN 20, 2021 12:06 AM IST
  • The family of the man who was shot dead alleged that he was a victim of infighting in the local unit of the Trinamool Congress.
Close
HT Image
HT Image

Covaxin recipients under stricter watch, says Centre

PUBLISHED ON JAN 20, 2021 12:03 AM IST
New Delhi The central government on Monday spelt out a detailed policy of monitoring Covid-19 vaccine recipients for adverse responses and assured people that the immunisation programme, which has been dogged by fears of side-effects and hesitancy, is safe
Close
**EDS: FILE PHOTO** New Delhi: In this undated Aug. 31, 2005 file photo, renowned oncologist and chairperson of the Adyar Cancer Institute Dr V Shanta. Shanta passed away at the age of 93 on Tuesday, Jan. 19, 2021. (PTI Photo)(PTI01_19_2021_000038B)(PTI)
**EDS: FILE PHOTO** New Delhi: In this undated Aug. 31, 2005 file photo, renowned oncologist and chairperson of the Adyar Cancer Institute Dr V Shanta. Shanta passed away at the age of 93 on Tuesday, Jan. 19, 2021. (PTI Photo)(PTI01_19_2021_000038B)(PTI)

‘To her, patients always came first’: Cancer care pioneer dies at 93

By Divya Chandrababu, Chennai
PUBLISHED ON JAN 20, 2021 12:02 AM IST
V Shanta was on the WHO Advisory Committee on Cancer till March 2005. She was a recipient of several national and international awards including the Ramon Magsasay award for public service, Padma Shri (1986), Padma Bhushan (2006) and Padma Vibhushan (2016).
Close
HT Image
HT Image

Tests for MPs; Zero, Question hours back in Budget session

PUBLISHED ON JAN 20, 2021 12:01 AM IST
New Delhi: A full, hour-long Question Hour, a separate slot for Zero Hour— both key for MPs seeking answers from the government—will return in the upcoming budget session of Parliament, which is expected to see the opposition attacking the ruling dispensation over the controversial farm laws and the WhatsApp chats of journalist Arnab Goswami
Close
“In addition to the list of beneficiaries sent to us by the Co-WIN platform, we were allowed to vaccinate people who are already registered but were not on the list." said Dr DS Rana(HT_PRINT)
“In addition to the list of beneficiaries sent to us by the Co-WIN platform, we were allowed to vaccinate people who are already registered but were not on the list." said Dr DS Rana(HT_PRINT)

Govt tweaks app to allow walk-ins, experts want wider access to shots

By Rhythma Kaul, Abhishek Dey, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 11:37 PM IST
A Union health ministry official confirmed the tweak in the app on Tuesday to allow health care workers not scheduled for jabs on a particular day to get the shots.
Close
The data showed that from January 1 to December 31, 2020, 148 murder cases were registered, whereas the number in 2019 was 165. (Getty Images/iStockphoto)
The data showed that from January 1 to December 31, 2020, 148 murder cases were registered, whereas the number in 2019 was 165. (Getty Images/iStockphoto)

Retired police officer arrested for vandalising RSS office in Indore

UPDATED ON JAN 19, 2021 11:36 PM IST
  • Shrikant Sharma, a retired deputy commandant of Special Armed Force of the Madhya Pradesh police, had earlier objected to the setting up of an office of the RSS for the Ram Temple fund collection drive in his neighborhood.
Close
Tuesday’s 54% vaccination rate was only marginally better than the 50% seen till Monday.(Satish Bate/Hindustan Times)
Tuesday’s 54% vaccination rate was only marginally better than the 50% seen till Monday.(Satish Bate/Hindustan Times)

Vaccination lagging, govt appeals against hesitancy

By Rhythma Kaul, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 11:18 PM IST
The remarks were made at the government’s weekly briefing on Covid-19, which was opened by Union health secretary Rajesh Bhushan, who said three regions – Tamil Nadu, Puducherry and Punjab – vaccinated fewer than 40% of their targets.
Close
There are 100,744 prisoners lodged in 72 jails in Uttar Pradesh, including 72,372 undertrial prisoners and 28,372 convicted inmates, as per the February 2020 data of UP Prison Administration and Reform Services.(Representative image/Shutterstock)
There are 100,744 prisoners lodged in 72 jails in Uttar Pradesh, including 72,372 undertrial prisoners and 28,372 convicted inmates, as per the February 2020 data of UP Prison Administration and Reform Services.(Representative image/Shutterstock)

No kidnapping, no conversion, went on my own to Karnataka, says Gorakhpur woman

PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 11:13 PM IST
  • The woman's father had earlier lodged a First Information Report (FIR) against the youth from Karnataka for allegedly kidnapping his daughter and forcing her to change religion.
Close
Jharkhand high court in Ranchi.(HT File Photo)
Jharkhand high court in Ranchi.(HT File Photo)

HC vacates stay as Jharkhand Speaker ends Babulal Marandi’s anti-defection trial

PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 10:15 PM IST
  • The Speaker had initiated proceedings under anti-defection laws to decide if the merger of Jharkhand Vikas Morcha-Prajatantrik (JVM-P) led by Babulal Marandi into the BJP in February, 2020, was valid.
Close
A doctor poses after receiving a dose of the Bharat Biotech's coronavirus disease (Covid-19) vaccine at a government-run hospital in New Delhi on Tuesday. (Reuters)
A doctor poses after receiving a dose of the Bharat Biotech's coronavirus disease (Covid-19) vaccine at a government-run hospital in New Delhi on Tuesday. (Reuters)

9 states, UTs among better performing areas during Covid-19 vaccination drive

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Meenakshi Ray
UPDATED ON JAN 19, 2021 10:47 PM IST
The government said 631,417 people have been vaccinated by the end of the fourth day of its mammoth inoculation drive, with only nine taken to hospitals after complaining of side effects.
Close
AAP leader Raghav Chadha addresses media during a press conference. (PTI)
AAP leader Raghav Chadha addresses media during a press conference. (PTI)

AAP leader Raghav Chadha underlines need for monitoring water leakages

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 10:09 PM IST
The DJB has initiated projects for the installation of flow meters and the setting up of a SCADA Centre, a high-tech monitoring system which allows the utility to detect where and how much water is being leaked or tapped.
Close
VK Sasikala is serving a four-year jail term in a disproportionate assets case.(PTI FILE PHOTO)
VK Sasikala is serving a four-year jail term in a disproportionate assets case.(PTI FILE PHOTO)

Sasikala to be released from jail on Jan 27, Palaniswami rules out her return

By Divya Chandrababu | Edited by Sparshita Saxena, Chennai
UPDATED ON JAN 19, 2021 11:20 PM IST
  • “There is no chance of her joining. She is not in the AIADMK party,” Palaniswami told reporters.
Close
The Congress party was forced to fall back on the 77-year-old Oommen Chandy after the high command felt that his “inactive role” and “indecisive attitude” of the present leadership had affected the party’s prospects in the recent local body elections in Kerala. (HT FILE PHOTO)(HT File Photo)
The Congress party was forced to fall back on the 77-year-old Oommen Chandy after the high command felt that his “inactive role” and “indecisive attitude” of the present leadership had affected the party’s prospects in the recent local body elections in Kerala. (HT FILE PHOTO)(HT File Photo)

Congress falls back on Oommen Chandy to retrieve party prospects in Kerala

PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 09:24 PM IST
  • The party leadership had reportedly told three senior leaders (Chandy, Chennithala and Ramachandran) who were summoned to Delhi two days ago that winning the election was top priority and to give more importance to the party than factions.
Close
Nepal had indicated its desire to review various issues related to trade and transit arrangements during foreign secretary Harsh Shringla’s visit to Kathmandu last month.(PTI)
Nepal had indicated its desire to review various issues related to trade and transit arrangements during foreign secretary Harsh Shringla’s visit to Kathmandu last month.(PTI)

Indo-Pacific region guided by norms an article of faith for India: Foreign Secy

PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 09:15 PM IST
  • Against the backdrop of China’s assertive actions amid the Covid-19 pandemic, India has stepped up cooperation with its partners to oppose unilateral actions and protect the freedom of navigation and overflight across the Indo-Pacific.
Close
Leaders of the six parties at the press meet to announce the formation of the alliance at Guwahati on Tuesday. (TWITTER).
Leaders of the six parties at the press meet to announce the formation of the alliance at Guwahati on Tuesday. (TWITTER).

Assam Congress to join hands with AIUDF, AGM, 3 Left parties for assembly polls

PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 09:09 PM IST
  • Newly-formed Anchalik Gana Morcha (AGM) of journalist-turned-politician and Rajya Sabha MP Ajit Kumar Bhuyan and three Left parties, CPI, CPI-M and CPI-ML, will also be part of this pre-poll tie up.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP