A French fighter jet Rafale prepares to take off on the aircraft carrier.(REUTERS FILE PHOTO)
A French fighter jet Rafale prepares to take off on the aircraft carrier.(REUTERS FILE PHOTO)

Rafale verdict: Government asks SC to correct error, says court misinterpreted wording

The error relates to a reference made about the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) report and Parliament’s Public Accounts Committee (PAC) in the Supreme Court verdict rejecting the petitions seeking a court-monitored probe into the Rafale fighter jet deal..
By HT Correspondent | Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON DEC 16, 2018 09:39 AM IST

The government on Saturday filed an application for a correction to be carried out in the Supreme Court order on the Rafale jet fighter deal.

The court’s ruling on Friday effectively vindicated the government’s stance that due process had been followed in reaching the Rs 59,000 crore deal, and said there was no reason to order a probe by the Central Bureau of Investigation, as demanded by the petitioners.

The order, however, contained some errors, the most significant one being its mention that the pricing details had been shared with the Comptroller and Auditor general of India, or CAG, that the government auditor had submitted a report to the Public Accounts Committee, and that redacted portions of the report were available in the public domain.

This error was picked up by some of the petitioners as well as opposition parties that claimed the government had, in its original submission to the court, misled it. Congress president Rahul Gandhi said at a press conference on Friday: “How does the Supreme Court judgment have this line that Rafale pricing has been examined by the PAC. Now, we have to ask the government, where is this CAG report?”

On Saturday, the defence ministry filed an application for a correction of that very paragraph.

The original paragraph in the order (paragraph 25) said: “The pricing details have, however, been shared with the Comptroller and Auditor General (hereinafter referred to as CAG), and the report of the CAG has been examined by the Public Accounts Committee… Only a redacted portion ...was placed before the Parliament and is in public domain.”

The defence ministry said in its petition that the court seems to have misunderstood its original submission, which was, it added, “in the form of bullet points”. According to the ministry, the “second bullet point” read: “The Government has already shared the pricing details with the CAG. The report of the CAG is examined by the PAC. Only a redacted version of the report is placed before the Parliament and in public domain”.

The petition argues that the use of the word “is” was “a description of the procedure usually followed” and asked the court to replace “has been” in paragraph 25, which seems to suggest that the act has already taken place, with “is”.

Ideally, of course, the governments original submission should have used “will be” instead of is to make things clear.

It isn’t clear when the court will correct the order. If the three judges of the bench who issued the order are in town, this could happen immediately, a government functionary said on Saturday.

It also isn’t clear whether the government’s submission in court will satisfy the opposition.

Ahead of the move on Saturday, Congress Lok Sabha floor leader Mallikarjun Kharge said: “”They have given wrong information to the court and on the basis of that information, the court has given its verdict. Now, I will request all the PAC panel members to fix a meeting to summon the attorney general and the Comptroller and Auditor General. We want to ask them when did they submit the Rafale report to the House and when did it come to the PAC, when did they come to give evidence, and when did we present the PAC report to Parliament?”

Kharge added that the date for the meeting will be scheduled after talking to other members. He also repeated the party’s demand for a Joint Parliamentary Committee to probe the Rafale deal.

Senior Congress leader Kapil Sibal also demanded at a press conference that the Rafale deal must be probed by a JPC.

Sanjay Singh, a Rajya Sabha MP from the Aam Aadmi Party and one of the petitioners in the case, said: “In Friday’s judgment, there are three inconsistencies. The first about the CAG report and PAC looking into it. Second, about the reservation by the Air Chief on sharing of pricing details with SC and the incorporation of Reliance (Defence) and its talks with Dassault since 2012. The government has to come clean on the issue. And for this, I have written to the chairman of the Rajya Sabha asking to summon the attorney general for India KK Venugopal in Parliament and ask him to explain the issue to the house

Meanwhile, officials familiar with the matter at CAG said on condition of anonymity that the government auditor would finalise its report into the Rafale deal by the end of January.

“CAG after drawing its conclusions gives the auditee a final chance for rebuttal in an exit conference. The exit conference with regard to the Rafale deal is yet to happen. It takes around a month more to finalise the report after the exit conference,” said one of the officials.

The official added that the CAG is looking into around a dozen defence deals and that the Rafale deal is part of the overall report into these procurements.

The official added that the Public Accounts Committee chairman Mallikarjun Kharge on Friday had checked with the Deputy CAG Ashwini Attri whether the audit watchdog had submitted any report on the Rafale deal to the Parliament. Attri’s answer was that it had not, this official said.

The Congress has over the past year raised the heat on the Modi government’s decision to enter an $8.7 billion government-to-government deal to buy 36 Rafale warplanes made by Dassault, which was announced in April 2015. This deal, signed a year later, replaced the previous United Progressive Alliance regime’s decision to buy 126 Rafale aircraft, 108 of which were to be made in India by state-owned Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd.

The Congress claims the earlier deal was scrapped and a new, more expensive one signed to provide businessman Anil Ambani’s Reliance Group an opportunity for an offset deal. Both the government and Reliance Group have repeatedly denied this. Reliance Group, which is one of many companies to benefit from the offset deal, formed a joint venture with Dassault Aviation.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
HT Image
HT Image

We were a preeminent economy, now we are a laughing stock: Rahul Gandhi targets

UPDATED ON JAN 19, 2021 02:39 PM IST
  • We were a preeminent economy, now we are a laughing stock: Rahul Gandhi targets govt over farm laws
Close
Representational Image. (File photo)
Representational Image. (File photo)

Government writes to WhatsApp, asks it to withdraw new privacy policy

By Deeksha Bhardwaj
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 02:23 PM IST
It has also issued a detailed questionnaire to WhatsApp seeking more details about its data-sharing protocols and business practices
Close
Congress leader Rahul Gandhi addresses a press conference at AICC office, in New Delhi. Photo by Sanjeev Verma
Congress leader Rahul Gandhi addresses a press conference at AICC office, in New Delhi. Photo by Sanjeev Verma

'Tragedy unfolding today in country': Rahul Gandhi on protest over farm laws

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Shivani
UPDATED ON JAN 19, 2021 02:34 PM IST
"There is a tragedy unfolding today in the country, govt wants to ignore the issue and misinform the country," Rahul Gandhi said while addressing a conference after the release.
Close
KPCC President D K Shivakumar during a press conference at the party office in Bengaluru, Karnataka.(PTI File photo)
KPCC President D K Shivakumar during a press conference at the party office in Bengaluru, Karnataka.(PTI File photo)

Supreme Court shouldn’t stay but scrap farm laws: Congress’s DK Shivkumar

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Kanishka Sarkar
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 02:04 PM IST
DK Shivakumar said that the Congress party will hold a big protest on Wednesday backing the farmers protesting against legislations enacted in September.
Close
India has 6.8 gigawatts of existing nuclear generation capacity, which accounts for roughly 2% of the nation’s total capacity.(AP representative image)
India has 6.8 gigawatts of existing nuclear generation capacity, which accounts for roughly 2% of the nation’s total capacity.(AP representative image)

India debuts largest nuclear reactor with more planned

Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 02:01 PM IST
India is counting on its nuclear program to help meet its Paris climate commitments to reduce the emissions intensity.
Close
Republic TV’s editor-in-chief Arnab Goswami. (File photo)
Republic TV’s editor-in-chief Arnab Goswami. (File photo)

Maharashtra mulls police action against Arnab in leaked chats case: State home minister

UPDATED ON JAN 19, 2021 01:59 PM IST
A delegation led by Maharashtra Congress general secretary Sachin Sawant met Deshmukh and demanded action in the leaked chats case. The delegation said the state government has every right to initiate action
Close
BJP leader and Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose's grandnephew Chandra Kumar Bose speaks to the media in Kolkata on Tuesday. (ANI)
BJP leader and Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose's grandnephew Chandra Kumar Bose speaks to the media in Kolkata on Tuesday. (ANI)

Subhas Chandra Bose’s birth anniversary to be celebrated as Parakram Diwas

PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 01:43 PM IST
In a gazette notification, the ministry stated that decision was taken to “honour and remember Netaji’s indomitable spirit and selfless service to the nation”
Close
A Covid-19 vaccination centre in Mumbai. (Satish Bate/HTphoto)
A Covid-19 vaccination centre in Mumbai. (Satish Bate/HTphoto)

Maharashtra resumes Covid-19 vaccination drive after delay over CoWin

UPDATED ON JAN 19, 2021 01:43 PM IST
The state intends to inoculate 28,500 people in a day through sessions at 285 centres across the state
Close
Saif Ali Khan plays a lead role in web series ‘Tandav’. (File photo)
Saif Ali Khan plays a lead role in web series ‘Tandav’. (File photo)

Fresh case filed in Greater Noida against makers of web series ‘Tandav’

By Shafaque Alam
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 01:11 PM IST
A BSP member filed the case for showing the UP Police in a bad light and hurting religious sentiments and social beliefs
Close
Rahul Gandhi posted on Twitter along with a newspaper clipping on the issue.(ANI)
Rahul Gandhi posted on Twitter along with a newspaper clipping on the issue.(ANI)

News updates from HT: Rahul Gandhi targets PM over Chinese village in Arunachal

By hindustantimes.com, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 01:00 PM IST
Here are today’s top news, analysis and opinion at 1pm. Know all about the latest news and other news updates from Hindustan Times.
Close
The scientists, including those from the University of California (UC) Irvine in the US, said this "sweeping shift" of the rain belt was disguised in previous studies that provided a global average of the influence of climate change.(PTI File Photo)
The scientists, including those from the University of California (UC) Irvine in the US, said this "sweeping shift" of the rain belt was disguised in previous studies that provided a global average of the influence of climate change.(PTI File Photo)

Climate change may change rainfall patterns in south India: Study

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 12:59 PM IST
The study, published in the journal Nature Climate Change, examined computer simulations from 27 state-of-the-art climate models, and measured the tropical rain belt's response to a future scenario in which greenhouse gas emissions continue to rise through the end of the current century.
Close
BJP national president JP Nadda. (PTI)
BJP national president JP Nadda. (PTI)

Why is Congress misleading farmers, surrendering to China: Nadda to Rahul

UPDATED ON JAN 19, 2021 01:47 PM IST
The BJP has also targeted the Congress for accepting donations for the Rajiv Gandhi Foundation (RGF) from the Chinese government
Close
Congress leader Rahul Gandhi .(PTI)
Congress leader Rahul Gandhi .(PTI)

Rahul Gandhi to release booklet to highlight pitfalls of farm laws today

ANI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 12:53 PM IST
Congress has been continuously demanding a repeal of the three laws and has also called a nationwide protest and a "Raj Bhavan Gherao" in all the states.
Close
Union minister Shripad Naik outside the Goa Medical College and Hospital on Tuesday.(ANI Photo)
Union minister Shripad Naik outside the Goa Medical College and Hospital on Tuesday.(ANI Photo)

Nearly 10 days after accident, minister Shripad Naik briefly brought out of ward

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Amit Chaturvedi
UPDATED ON JAN 19, 2021 02:26 PM IST
Naik, 68, was on his way from Yellapur to Gokarna in Karnataka on January 11 when the accident took place. The minister's wife Vijaya and personal assistant were killed in the accident.
Close
Many Indian officials believe that China's will not move out of the contested points in East Ladakh sector till President Xi Jinping delivers his address to mark 100 years of Communist Party of China (AFP)
Many Indian officials believe that China's will not move out of the contested points in East Ladakh sector till President Xi Jinping delivers his address to mark 100 years of Communist Party of China (AFP)

China’s PLA may ramp up military activity in Ladakh in 2 months

UPDATED ON JAN 19, 2021 01:33 PM IST
  • India does hope that the incoming Biden administration will stand by its commitments on China, South China Sea, Taiwan or Indo-Pacific at large but New Delhi is not dependent on the US for handling the PLA on land frontiers
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP