Caught in a bit of a bind
A general, non-niche newspaper like the HT cannot completely evade wider social trends.
Today, you are reading a freshly designed page devoted to your concerns, one with several new features. Since it came in to being, this page has been instrumental in broadening and deepening Hindustan Times Mumbai’s engagement with its readers.
A letter that I received a month ago, before I went away on my annual vacation, indicated just how much this was the case. “I really appreciate Senior Editor Sumana Ramanan’s response to my grievance against the poor coverage given to B.R. Ambedkar’s 53rd death anniversary,” wrote G.G. Wankhede, a professor at the Tata Institute of Social Sciences. “After years of writing to various newspapers for their poor handling of any event, be it the death or birth anniversary of Ambedkar, this is the first and only response I have received.”
By citing this letter, I may sound like I am tooting my own horn. However, the letter praises not so much the content of the column but the fact that it exists.
In fact, in the letter, Professor Wankhede actually goes on to criticise my response, on December 13, to his initial complaint about HT’s poor coverage of Ambedkar’s death anniversary.
“I am disappointed that the Senior Editor of HT has enlisted reasons that do not specifically explore the cause of the oversight,” he wrote in his second letter.
He went on list several flaws in my response. Today, I will refer to only one. In my earlier column, I had said that the meagre coverage of the event might have been the result of a belief among the newspaper’s senior editors that it might not have resonated with a large number of readers.
“Admittedly, a large section of the public does [prefer] reading about Rahul Mahajan’s impending nuptials or Shah Rukh Khan detention at a US airport,” he wrote. “But it is almost insulting to the other section’s intelligence when such articles are given unnecessary coverage in the print and electronic media.”
In my earlier column, two senior editors had admitted that the event warranted much more space. But what is a newspaper to do about other, more trivial events that many readers seem to want to read about? Its editors may think that readers ought to be exercised about important issues, and solely about them, but what if they are not?
It is impossible for a general, non-niche newspaper entirely to evade wider social trends.
Just this week, John Kampfner, a British journalist and writer, spoke in Mumbai about his recent book Freedom for Sale: How We Made Money and Lost Our Liberty. Robert Cooper neatly summarises the book’s argument in his review of it in The Sunday Times, London. “Marx was wrong, according to John Kampfner,” Cooper writes. “It is not religion that is the opium of the people, but capitalism. Give them good shopping opportunities and they will forget about liberty, equality and fraternity, and cease to care about who governs them and how.”
Kampfner devotes an entire chapter to India, discussing not only the cocoon that its elite has tried to spin around itself but also the repercussions of this on the media and journalism.
“In the course of the 90s, as they sought profitability and increased circulation, most of the mainstream English-language newspapers and magazines — the ones catering to the aspiring middle classes — jazzed up and dumbed down.”
Is it possible to reverse this tide? Readers, you tell me.
Enter your email to get our daily newsletter in your inbox
- For the first time, junior commissioned officers (JCOs) and jawans are taking part in the top conference, as reported by Hindustan Times on Wednesday.
- According to the IMD's forecast, Friday and Saturday may see higher daytime temperatures that could rise to 39 degrees Celsius.
- A police officer said that the complainant's status as witness in the case of alleged sexual exploitation against former minister Ramesh Jarkiholi is also unclear.
- On Wednesday, the Centre had submitted a note prepared by Department of Financial Services (DFS) which did not agree with the Court’s suggestion to create additional courts as a solution to curb high pendency of Section 138 cases.
- Indore was ranked the ninth-best city among cities with over a million population.
- Pradhan, who has written at least three letters to Chief Minister Naveen Patnaik demanding immediate implementation of 27 per cent quota for OBC category, in a statement said that his demand for reservation in jobs and education remain unaddressed till date.
- General Bipin Rawat said the Indian armed forces face greater challenges than any other military in the world and India urgently needs to bring about structural reforms in higher defence and operational organisations.
- The bills passed by the assembly are the Arunachal Pradesh Civil Courts Bill, the Arunachal Pradesh Goods and Service Tax (Amendment) Bill, the Arunachal Pradesh Ease of Doing Business Bill and the Arunachal Pradesh Municipal Corporation (Amendment) Bill.