Change UPSC interview process: panel
A parliamentary panel believes that the Union Public Service Commission’s (UPSC) current practice of conducting Civil Services interviews separately for general, OBC, SC and ST candidates may prejudice the interview board against candidates belonging to reserved categories.
“We are studying the report of a recent seminar in Madras University and will forward it to the Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT) and the UPSC. Many reserved category candidates have complained that segregation by category prejudices the board against them. The candidates should be called alphabetically or in order of merit and not by category. The board should assess candidates on performance alone and not on category,” E.M.S. Natchiappan, chairman of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Personnel, Public Grievances, Law and Justice told Hindustan Times.
The Chennai seminar report says: “A member of the interview board knows whether the interview is conducted for OC, OBC, SC or ST category. Conducting interviews separately on communal order might lead to a prejudiced opinion among the members of the Board, especially towards candidates belonging to OBC, SC and ST.” The report also suggests video recording of all interviews, which is expected to make the board more sensitive while dealing with students from marginal groups and enable authorities to counter-check whether candidates were correctly judged.
A random sample survey of interview marks of candidates from different categories done by some OBC bureaucrats shows that general candidates perform better than reserved candidates in the interview. The average difference between the general and OBC candidates’ interview marks is five per cent while the over-all difference in the Mains cut-offs of the two categories is less than one per cent. Similarly, between general and SC candidates, the overall Mains cut-off difference is about two per cent but the average difference in interview marks of the sample candidates is eight per cent. This, many reserved category bureaucrats say, is evidence of the bias at play during interviews.
Moreover, while 29 per cent of the general candidates in the sample scored more than 200 — out of a maximum of 300 — in the interview, only three per cent OBCs scored above 200.
Enter your email to get our daily newsletter in your inbox
- The BKU said committee will tour US Nagar district to ensure farmers participation with their tractors in Delhi on Republic Day .
- The BJP leader said the Congress is not interested in resolving the issues pertaining to the farmers and Gandhi’s media address a day before the government and the farmers’ meet shows that the party does not want the talks to be successful.
- The rhino had moved out of the Kaziranga National Park and Tiger Reserve on January 16 at Jakahalabandha area of Kaliabor.
- The glitches in the CoWIN application have affected the vaccination drive in Rajasthan. The second day of the inoculation program saw 11,288 health workers of the 68.7% of targeted beneficiaries, which works out to 5 percentage points less than the first day.
- Biotic interference in Nongkhyllem Wildlife Sanctuary has been significantly reduced, zonation has been done in terms of core and buffer zones and it has a duly notified eco-sensitive zone