Somaru Nag, a journalist who ran a news agency for Rajasthan Patrika, is accused of keeping a watch on the movements of police for the maoists.(Arun Sharma/ HT Photo)
Somaru Nag, a journalist who ran a news agency for Rajasthan Patrika, is accused of keeping a watch on the movements of police for the maoists.(Arun Sharma/ HT Photo)

Pen or gun: Journos in Chhattisgarh stuck between cops and Maoists

The detention of Santosh Yadav and Somaru Nag which their supporters see as unlawful and an act of intimidation, is snowballing into a faceoff between journalists and authorities as violation of human rights and free speech have come under the spotlight in this insurgency-riddled Chhattisgarh.
By Furquan Ameen Siddiqui | Hindustan Times, Bastar, Chhattisgarh
UPDATED ON DEC 16, 2015 06:25 PM IST

The one who brings unwelcome news holds a losing office, Shakespeare had written it in his 16th century play Henry IV. Journalists who bear bad news face a similar situation in Chhattisgarh’s Bastar region that lies at the heart of a festering conflict between Maoist rebels and government forces. Each side tries to shoot the messenger when the news is not to their liking.

This time around, the messengers are journalists Santosh Yadav and Somaru Nag who have been jailed for allegedly providing information to the Maoists.

Yadav, who reported for newspapers Dainik Chhattisgarh and Dainik Navbharat, was picked up by the police on September 29 and slapped with charges under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act and Chhattisgarh Special Public Security Act (CSPSA). Nag, who ran a news agency for Jaipur-headquartered Hindi daily Rajasthan Patrika and wrote for them as well, was arrested on July 16 from his shop in Tirathgarh, about 310 km south of state capital Raipur. He is accused of keeping a watch on the movements of the police while Maoists burnt down a crusher plant used for construction of roads in the area.

Lingaram Kodopi, fixer/freelance journalist, Dantewada

In September 2009, Lingaram Kodopi, a tribal from Dantewada, was detained by the police allegedly forcing him to become a Special Police Officer. He was arrested again for allegedly facilitating Essar’s payment for protection money to the Maoists. He was trained as a video journalist after his release. He distributes news, information and videos with local journalists. (Arun Sharma/HT Photo)
In September 2009, Lingaram Kodopi, a tribal from Dantewada, was detained by the police allegedly forcing him to become a Special Police Officer. He was arrested again for allegedly facilitating Essar’s payment for protection money to the Maoists. He was trained as a video journalist after his release. He distributes news, information and videos with local journalists. (Arun Sharma/HT Photo)

The detention of Yadav and Nag, which their supporters see as unlawful and an act of intimidation, is snowballing into a faceoff between journalists and authorities as violation of human rights and freedom to express once again come under spotlight in this insurgency-ridden tribal state.

Journalists from across Chhattisgarh are planning a Jail Bharo Andolan on December 21. “If the state considers both the journalists as Naxals, they should also come and arrest us all, for supporting Naxals,” said Kamal Shukla, who heads the newly formed Patrakar Suraksha Kanoon Sanyukt Sangharsh Samiti that is demanding a law to protect journalists. Maoists are often called Naxals as their ideology and politics has its roots in a leftwing poor peasant uprising in Naxalbari, West Bengal – in the late 1960s.

Mangal Kunjam, CGNet Swara, Bailadila

The 24-year-old adivasi journalist reports news events from the Bailadila area of Dantewada. Being a tribal, Kunjam has been accused of having ties with Naxal. While Naxals have accused him of being a police supporter for writing about development issues. (Arun Sharma/HT Photo)
The 24-year-old adivasi journalist reports news events from the Bailadila area of Dantewada. Being a tribal, Kunjam has been accused of having ties with Naxal. While Naxals have accused him of being a police supporter for writing about development issues. (Arun Sharma/HT Photo)

On October 10, shortly after Yadav was arrested, the Samiti held a protest outside chief minister Raman Singh’s residence, asking the administration to provide proof of allegations against the two journalists within a month or set them free. Neither has happened.

“The usual system or law, that we are used to, stops short of conflict areas,” said Anil Mishra, a Raipur-based journalist with Hindi daily Nai Dunia.

Mishra, who spent 10 years in Bastar before he had to move to Raipur for his safety, recalls an incident when he and his colleague from Delhi met the state’s police chief in connection with a story on Binayak Sen. “I was shocked by his first reaction when I introduced myself. He said ‘Weren’t you..Naxals..’ and then he stopped,” Mishra said. “So clearly he had an impression that I was a Naxalite.”

Mukesh Chandrakar, Sahara Samay, Bijapur

Mukesh Chandrakar, 25, and his brother Ukesh have been a victim of harassment from both sides. Three months ago when they went to cover the death of three jawans, they were abused and told to leave, while in another incident the brothers were interrogated by Naxals at gun point for venturing into their area. (Arun Sharma/HT Photo)
Mukesh Chandrakar, 25, and his brother Ukesh have been a victim of harassment from both sides. Three months ago when they went to cover the death of three jawans, they were abused and told to leave, while in another incident the brothers were interrogated by Naxals at gun point for venturing into their area. (Arun Sharma/HT Photo)

The administration outside Bastar, according to Mishra, entirely depends on the feedback they get from the local police and hence form an opinion about the journalists. They are either with them or with the enemy.

When 24-year-old Somaru Nag, whose father is a farmer and who has been behind bars for more than four months along with two more accused of involvement in the attack on the crusher plant, was brought to the Jagdalpur district court on December 3, he appeared clueless about his crime.

“I was at my shop when the policemen came up and asked me to take a walk with them. I fail to understand why they arrested me. I don’t even know the other two accused,” said Nag before he was whisked away by policemen flanking him.

Anil Mishra, Nai Dunia, Raipur

Mishra, a news editor with the Hindi daily Nai Dunia, has spent 10 years reporting from Bastar. He was one of the ‘go to journalists’ for reporters parachuting from outside the state before he was forced to move to Raipur after death threats. Due to his hard hitting reports exposing police claims, Mishra was accused of being a Naxal supporter. (Arun Sharma/HT Photos)
Mishra, a news editor with the Hindi daily Nai Dunia, has spent 10 years reporting from Bastar. He was one of the ‘go to journalists’ for reporters parachuting from outside the state before he was forced to move to Raipur after death threats. Due to his hard hitting reports exposing police claims, Mishra was accused of being a Naxal supporter. (Arun Sharma/HT Photos)

In contrast, 28-year-old Santosh Yadav has been a victim of police harassment for some time. It started in 2014, when he was the first to reach the spot when a Maoist attack took place in Jiram Ghati in Bastar. The police presumed Yadav had prior information from the rebels, which meant he worked for them. The allegations against him, however, are that he used to supply materials and shared information with Maoists. He was arrested and his name was added to a case where 18 other villagers from Darbha were arrested a month earlier for their alleged involvement in a police-rebel encounter in August where a policeman was killed.

On an earlier occasion, Yadav -- a matriculate by education and now a father of three children -- “had been detained at a local thana, tortured and even offered money to become a police informer which he refused,” said Isha Khandelwal, a lawyer with a Jagdalpur-based all-women legal aid group called Jag-LAG. Yadav’s father and brothers are in government service. While local lawyers expect Nag to be released early, Yadav who faces the more draconian UAPA and CSPSA is probably in for a long haul.

Read: Spare a child from each family for rebellion, Maoists tell villagers

Intimidation by government forces is not new to journalists here. They understand that getting threats and harassed comes with the job. The worst they faced was when Salwa Judum – a campaign under which the state armed tribal youths to fight the Maoists – was at its peak. It was a time when journalists reported on widespread human rights abuses and the impunity with which the forces operated. It was also a period when several journalists were harassed, some even receiving death threats.

Journalists from different districts assembled near Chhattisgarh chief minister Raman Singh’s official residence in Raipur to protest against the arrests of journalists and the high-handedness of IG in Bastar. (HT Photo)
Journalists from different districts assembled near Chhattisgarh chief minister Raman Singh’s official residence in Raipur to protest against the arrests of journalists and the high-handedness of IG in Bastar. (HT Photo)

Salwa Judum, which means peace march in local dialect Gondi, was later declared illegal and unconstitutional by the Supreme Court.

Kamlesh Painkra, one of the rare Adivasi journalists that Bastar produced, was witness to this. In 2006, his story on Judum cadres burning villagers’ home didn’t go down well with the police. He was threatened and asked to write an apology. He refused. Later his brother was arrested on charges of sheltering a Maoist and his sources told him he could be killed. Painkra had to flee with his family to take refuge in Dantewada. He now works for an NGO in Bijapur.

Local journalists have been repeatedly beaten up by members of Salwa Judum. In 2010, 24-year-old Mangal Kunjam, another adivasi journalist in Bailadila, Dantewada, who reports for the voice-based portal CGNet Swara, was threatened with a staged encounter by the local police after he reported the death threat on the three journalists. Three prominent senior journalists, including Anil Mishra, were threatened with “a dog’s death” if they continued to carry Maoist statements by a pro-state vigilante organisation called Danteshwari Adivasi Swabhiman Manch.

Truth has two versions in Bastar, one that fits the official narrative and the other that suits the Maoists. It is difficult to ascertain who is manufacturing what news.

Prabhat Singh, Patrika, Dantewada

Based in Dantewada, Singh, runs an agency of Rajasthan Patrika and has been writing for the Hindi newspaper for the past three years. He has two case registered against him by the police, which he claims is a result of his news reports. (Arun Sharma/HT Photo)
Based in Dantewada, Singh, runs an agency of Rajasthan Patrika and has been writing for the Hindi newspaper for the past three years. He has two case registered against him by the police, which he claims is a result of his news reports. (Arun Sharma/HT Photo)

Just last week, there was news of surrender of 26 Maoists. Reportedly SRP Kalluri, inspector general of police for Bastar range, spoke of forces killing 15 rebels in a separate encounter last month. Two bodies were recovered. “The only way to check these claims is to go inside the jungle, to the villages where the incidents have happened. In my experience, most of the time that I went to check such claims the police’s version turned out to be a lie,” said Mishra.

In the war that goes on here and has claimed close to 1,000 lives in the past five years, neither side can afford to upset the media. But they won’t let it report fairly.

Read: Chasing stories to death

“A press conference in Bastar is usually a quiet affair, journalists just record what is said or take the handout and regurgitate it on the paper. No one dares ask a question,” said Prabhat Singh, a journalist for Rajasthan Patrika based in Dantewada – a Maoist stronghold bordering Telangana. Singh was singled out by Bastar IG SRP Kalluri when he asked about a missing person in one such conference. Kalluri’s removal featured among demands journalists submitted to CM Raman Singh during their protest in October. He has been accused of creating an environment where journalists can’t work freely.

Ganesh Mishra, Nai Dunia, Bijapur

The 32-year-old reporter from Bijapur, Ganesh feels the state has used them whenever they want them as mediators or to get kidnapped jawans rescued. In April 2011, when a greyhound soldier was killed in an encounter with Naxals, Mishra was sent by the police to pick up his body from the jungle. (Arun Sharma/HT Photo)
The 32-year-old reporter from Bijapur, Ganesh feels the state has used them whenever they want them as mediators or to get kidnapped jawans rescued. In April 2011, when a greyhound soldier was killed in an encounter with Naxals, Mishra was sent by the police to pick up his body from the jungle. (Arun Sharma/HT Photo)

Kalluri declined to comment on the charges. His senior, additional director general of police RK Vij who heads anti-Maoist operations in the state, said “personal behavior” of any officer is beyond his control. Vij also denied there was any infringement of journalists’ rights, although he won’t comment on Yadav and Nag as the matter is subjudice. “Generally speaking, I have seen no such allegations or complaints that they (journalists) have not been able to write what they wished to,” he told HT.

However, it is not just the fear of the police or arrest. In 2013, killings of two senior journalists Sai Reddy and Nemi Chand Jain by the Maoists terrorised local scribes. They refused to cover any Maoist statements, prompting the rebels to issue an apology and admit that the killings were a mistake. More recently, two young journalists, brothers Mukesh and Ukesh Chandrakar who work for Sahara Samay and India News respectively, were interrogated at gun point by the Naxals when they went to the villages for a story.

“A reporter here is scared of both sides. Police is capable of manufacturing any case against you; Santosh [Yadav] is an example. And if you go into (the Maoists’) area without permission there is a chance you might get killed,” said Ganesh Mishra, another Nai Dunia journalist based in Bijapur that also is a part of the conflict zone.

“At the end of the day when we sit down to write, we first think of the consequences. The situation is such that the pen is in our hands but someone else is writing for us.”

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
Kejriwal, whose party had scored a zero in the state in the 2014 Lok Sabha elections, was visiting Gujarat for the first time in seven years.(PTI)
Kejriwal, whose party had scored a zero in the state in the 2014 Lok Sabha elections, was visiting Gujarat for the first time in seven years.(PTI)

In Surat, Delhi CM Kejriwal hails AAP’s poll performance

By Darshan Desai, Ahmedabad
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 04:17 AM IST
In the recently concluded civic body polls, the AAP won 27 of 120 seats in the Surat Municipal Corporation in its debut appearance, thereby emerging the main opposition party against the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), which won 93 seats.
Close
On Friday, Azad arrived in Jammu on a three-day visit and was received by party workers.(ANI file photo)
On Friday, Azad arrived in Jammu on a three-day visit and was received by party workers.(ANI file photo)

23 Cong letter writers plan drive to ‘save idea of India’

By HT Correspondent, New Delhi, Jammu
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 03:58 AM IST
The series of rallies and public meetings will kick off on Saturday in Jammu, where former Rajya Sabha member of Parliament Ghulam Nabi Azad, one of the 23, has invited his colleagues.
Close
External affairs ministry spokesperson Anurag Srivastava said there were selective leaks of the opinion of WGAD on Michel’s case.(Reuters )
External affairs ministry spokesperson Anurag Srivastava said there were selective leaks of the opinion of WGAD on Michel’s case.(Reuters )

India rejects United Nations panel report on Christian Michel

By Rezaul H Laskar, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 03:55 AM IST
The United Nations Working Group on Arbitrary Detention (WGAD), which operates under the UN high commissioner for human rights, said that Michel, who has been held in India since December 2018 after being extradited from United Arab Emirates, should be immediately released, according to conclusions reported by AFP.
Close
“We cannot allow sexual harassment complaints to be brushed under the carpet this way,” a three-judge bench headed by Chief Justice of India S A Bobde said.
“We cannot allow sexual harassment complaints to be brushed under the carpet this way,” a three-judge bench headed by Chief Justice of India S A Bobde said.

Can’t ignore complaints of sexual harassment: Supreme Court

By Abraham Thomas, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 02:51 AM IST
In her complaint in March 2018, the female judicial officer had accused the former principal district judge of Sheopur of sending lewd messages on WhatsApp.
Close
The bench emphasised that when the career and reputation of a spouse were severely damaged because of the conduct of the other partner, it could not be expected of the former to reconcile and agree to live together again.
The bench emphasised that when the career and reputation of a spouse were severely damaged because of the conduct of the other partner, it could not be expected of the former to reconcile and agree to live together again.

Harming reputation ground for divorce, says Supreme Court

By Utkarsh Anand, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 02:48 AM IST
An SC bench, headed by justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul, held that such demeanour by a wife will certainly amount to inflicting cruelty on the man, and will be grounds for divorce under marital laws.
Close
To be sure, the Indian economy will still face its largest ever contraction in the current fiscal year.(AP file photo. Representative image)
To be sure, the Indian economy will still face its largest ever contraction in the current fiscal year.(AP file photo. Representative image)

India out of recession as GDP expands 0.4% in Q3

By Roshan Kishore, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 02:43 AM IST
India’s gross domestic product (GDP) grew at 0.4% on a year-on-year basis in the quarter ending December 2020, according to data released by the National Statistical Office (NSO) on February 26.
Close
Jaishankar added that once disengagement is completed at all friction points, the two sides “could look at broader de-escalation of troops in the area”.(HT_PRINT)
Jaishankar added that once disengagement is completed at all friction points, the two sides “could look at broader de-escalation of troops in the area”.(HT_PRINT)

‘Peace on LAC must to mend ties’: Jaishankar tells Chinese counterpart

By Sutirtho Patranobis, Shishir Gupta, Rezaul H Laskar, Beijing, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 02:39 AM IST
EAM Jaishankar’s blunt message was conveyed to his Chinese counterpart Wang Yi during a 75-minute phone conversation on Thursday — the first formal contact between the two ministers since they met on the margins of a Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) meeting in Moscow last September.
Close
According to experts, the liquor business in Delhi is shrouded in opacity and controlled by a handful of individuals or groups.(File photo. Representative image)
According to experts, the liquor business in Delhi is shrouded in opacity and controlled by a handful of individuals or groups.(File photo. Representative image)

Business of liquor needs a major detox

By Abhishek Dey, Sweta Goswami
UPDATED ON FEB 27, 2021 02:31 AM IST
In 2019-20, the city government pegged its revenue from the liquor business at 5,500 crore -- roughly 11% of its total revenue of 51,000 crore. Among major states, an HT analysis showed only in Karnataka and Telangana, liquor revenue formed a bigger percentage of the state’s revenue.
Close
Earlier in the state assembly, Tamil Nadu CM Palaniswami announced waiving gold loans up to six sovereigns taken from cooperative banks by the poor and farmers.
Earlier in the state assembly, Tamil Nadu CM Palaniswami announced waiving gold loans up to six sovereigns taken from cooperative banks by the poor and farmers.

Sops galore hours before poll schedule out

By Divya Chandrababu, Chennai, Kolkata
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 02:10 AM IST
Most number of sops came from Tamil Nadu chief minister E Palaniswami, who is trying to beat 10 years of incumbency. The state assembly unanimously passed a bill providing 10.5% reservation for influential Vanniyar community within the existing quota of 20% for the Most Backward Classes (MBC).
Close
Arora said the nationwide vaccination drive made the situation more conducive to conduct elections.(PTI )
Arora said the nationwide vaccination drive made the situation more conducive to conduct elections.(PTI )

Crucial election cycle in 5 states to start on March 27

By Deeksha Bhardwaj, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 01:39 AM IST
Votes in Assam, West Bengal, Tamil Nadu, Kerala and Puducherry will be counted on May 2, said chief election commissioner Sunil Arora. All Covid-19 election guidelines, including limiting the number of electors, regulating physical campaigning and road shows and sanitising booths and personnel, will be in place, he added.
Close
The states of Kerala, Tamil Nadu and Assam account for 13% out of the 543 seats in Lok Sabha.(File photo. Representative image)
The states of Kerala, Tamil Nadu and Assam account for 13% out of the 543 seats in Lok Sabha.(File photo. Representative image)

Five charts that explain the upcoming elections

By Abhishek Jha, Roshan Kishore
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 01:22 AM IST
Three out of the four states going to polls; Assam, West Bengal and Kerala are also the top three states by share of Muslims in the population. With 26.7% Muslims and 16.6% Christians, Kerala has the lowest share of Hindus -- to be sure, they are still a majority – among India’s important states.
Close
Referring to some of the new acquisitions, experts said IAF’s fighter, helicopter and transport fleets played a crucial during the Ladakh standoff that began last May.(PTI file photo)
Referring to some of the new acquisitions, experts said IAF’s fighter, helicopter and transport fleets played a crucial during the Ladakh standoff that began last May.(PTI file photo)

IAF adds muscle to firepower in 2 yrs since Balakot

By Rahul Singh, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 27, 2021 01:06 AM IST
Indian Air Force's (IAF’s) Mirage-2000s struck targets in Balakot in response to the Pakistan-backed Pulwama suicide attack in Kashmir in which 40 CRPF troopers were killed on February 14.
Close
Celeste goes on to add how, in a meeting with Pakistan PM Nawaz Sharif shortly after this, Clinton asked him to “withdraw troops” from Kargil.(ANI file photo. Representative image)
Celeste goes on to add how, in a meeting with Pakistan PM Nawaz Sharif shortly after this, Clinton asked him to “withdraw troops” from Kargil.(ANI file photo. Representative image)

When Pakistan failed to get support during Kargil

By Sunetra Choudhury, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 12:54 AM IST
In a new book, Life in American Politics & Diplomatic Years in India published by Har-Anand Publications, Richard Celeste, the US ambassador to India between 1997 and 2001, reports a visit he received from Pakistan’s Ambassador to India, Ashraf Qazi.
Close
The court further asked Kaur to maintain restraint while on bail to ensure that no law and order issue arises due to her actions.
The court further asked Kaur to maintain restraint while on bail to ensure that no law and order issue arises due to her actions.

‘Did not break any law’: Nodeep Kaur after HC grants bail

By HT Correspondent, Chandigarh/karnal
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 12:39 AM IST
Addressing mediapersons, Kaur said, “I did not break any law and cannot think of doing so in future. But I raise voice against exploitation of labourers and farmers by the big corporate houses. Such influential people cannot tolerate this and try to suppress their voice.”
Close
Wildlife activist Sangeeta Dogra said in her petition that villagers arranged a felicitation function for the shooter, a professional hunter, on November 14, 2018.(HT file photo. Representative image)
Wildlife activist Sangeeta Dogra said in her petition that villagers arranged a felicitation function for the shooter, a professional hunter, on November 14, 2018.(HT file photo. Representative image)

SC rejects contempt plea, says tigress Avni killed in accordance with order

By Abraham Thomas, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 12:19 AM IST
The Court issued notices to Maharashtra principal secretary Vikas Kharge, principal chief conservator forests (Nagpur), deputy conservator forests (Nagpur), deputy conservator forests (Pandharkawada) and member secretary, NTCA, on February 10 on a petition filed by a wildlife activist Sangeeta Dogra.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP