Aarey tree cutting row: BMC tree panel split wide open; 2 experts resign

The panel had given its nod for felling 2,646 trees – 2,185 to be cut and 461 to be transplanted – in a meeting on Thursday, when of the 18 members, eight voted for the proposal, six voted against it, two abstained and two were absent.
Citizens hold a protest march at Aarey Milk Colony on Saturday against the decision to cut trees for the Metro-3 project.(HT Photo)
Citizens hold a protest march at Aarey Milk Colony on Saturday against the decision to cut trees for the Metro-3 project.(HT Photo)
Updated on Sep 01, 2019 03:44 AM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times, Mumbai | By, Mumbai

Two experts from the civic body’s 18-member tree authority resigned on Saturday, as the row over the panel’s approval to cut 2,185 trees at Aarey Colony for constructing the Metro-3 car shed further escalated.

The tree authority comprises five external experts and corporators from the BJP (4), Shiv Sena (6), Congress (2) and NCP (1).

The panel had given its nod for felling 2,646 trees – 2,185 to be cut and 461 to be transplanted – in a meeting on Thursday, when of the 18 members, eight voted for the proposal, six voted against it, two abstained and two were absent.

However, on Friday, two of the three experts, who had voted in favour of cutting the trees, said they were not aware that their vote was for approving the proposal. The remaining two experts were not present at the meeting.

While Shashirekha Sureshkumar, associate professor and head of department of botany, Mithibai College, said the process to approve tree felling was wrong and she was confused about the meeting’s proceedings as they happened in Marathi, Chandrakant Salunkhe, scientist from Bhabha Atomic Research Centre, said the entire process was rushed. Both said they had sent their resignations to the BMC’s garden superintendent, other officers, and committee members on Saturday morning.

HT has a copy of Sureshkumar’s resignation while Salunkhe refused to share a copy of his letter. “Since the time of my nomination to the committee, no due process has been followed for the assessment of the site and decisions have been taken in haste. As an expert, I have been allowed to visit some limited portions of the site in question, only twice, which is not sufficient time to make a decision regarding such an issue,” read Sureshkumar’s resignation letter.

“Most of our recommendations on the issue have not been considered by the committee while making the decision. I wish to clearly and strongly state that I have never recommended the felling of 2,700 trees and I do not endorse the decision in any way.”

Salunkhe, meanwhile, said the only way left for them to redeem themselves of accusations (of bribery by political parties) was to resign. “In our report, nowhere is it mentioned that we are supporting tree cutting. The project happening or not is not our purview; our expertise is towards how best we can maintain the green cover and that is our mandate. The entire voting process was politically charged, and we cannot handle such a situation. We are academic and scientific people who do not need to spend time in this toxic environment,” he said.

Meanwhile, another expert member Subhash Patne, BSC in agriculture, who said he was satisfied with Thursday’s voting process, said he will be filing a case against Shiv Sena members who alleged expert members were bribed into voting for tree felling.

The two expert members who were not present at the meeting were Manohar Sawant, PhD physical chemistry, and Deepak Apte, director, Bombay Natural History Society.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
  • ABOUT THE AUTHOR

    Badri Chatterjee is an environment correspondent at Hindustan Times, Mumbai. He writes about environment issues - air, water and noise pollution, climate change - weather, wildlife - forests, marine and mangrove conservation

Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • A family on a motor bike during rains. 

    Karnataka rain: Amid red alert, holiday for schools, colleges in these districts

    Owing to continuous rain, educational institutions in several parts of Karnataka will remain shut on Thursday. Top officials in the 4 districts of Karnataka - namely Udupi, Kodagu, Hassan and Uttara Kannada -- have declared holiday for Anganwadi schools and colleges amid the 'red alert' issued by the weather department. The Indian Meteorological Department has predicted extremely heavy rain, ranging above 204.5 mm for these 4 cities.

  • Karnataka Animal Husbandry Minister Prabhu B Chavan.

    ‘Do not sacrifice cattle for Bakrid festival,’ says Karnataka Minister

    Karnataka Animal Husbandry Minister Prabhu B Chavan appealed to people not to sacrifice cattle for the Bakrid festival while warning of stern action against the offenders. The Minister emphasised the Cow Slaughter Prohibition Act has already been in force in Karnataka. Generally, during the Bakrid festival, there is a tradition of sacrifice, for which livestock such as cow, ox, calf and camels are also used, said Chavan.

  • Chandigarh administrator Banwarilal Purohit on Wednesday gave in-principle approval for a synthetic running track at Sukhna Lake. (HT PHOTO )

    Synthetic running track on Sukhna Lake gets Chandigarh administrator’s nod

    Chandigarh Chandigarh administrator Banwarilal Purohit on Wednesday gave in-principle approval for a synthetic running track at Sukhna Lake. UT adviser Dharam Pal, said, “The Chandigarh Heritage Conservation Committee had earlier given its go-ahead for the proposal. Next, the detailed plan and cost estimates will be prepared; and then, tenders will be floated for the project.” A UT official said the proposed track is part of the administration's efforts to give Sukhna Lake a major facelift.

  • The National Highway Authority of India (NHAI) has approved two over-bridges, which are likely to reduce travel time between Kalka and Zirakpur and alleviate traffic jams on the stretch by next year. (HT PHOTo)

    Soon, 2 over-bridges to cut travel time between Kalka, Zirakpur

    The National Highway Authority of India has approved two over-bridges, which are likely to reduce travel time between Kalka and Zirakpur and alleviate traffic jams on the stretch by next year. NHAI has already floated tenders for the 60-m wide over-bridges, which will be constructed at a cost of ₹50 crore. It has invited bids for the “construction and site improvement of the four-lane national highway (NH-22) on the Zirakpur-Parwanoo junction.”

  • Fifteen students had a narrow escape after their school bus skidded into a waterlogged open drain in Daulat Singhwala village in Phabat area of Zirakpur. (HT Photo)

    Close shave for 15 students as bus skids into waterlogged ditch in Zirakpur

    Fifteen students had a narrow escape after their school bus skidded into a waterlogged open drain in Daulat Singhwala village in Phabat area of Zirakpur. The bus, which was ferrying students of Blue Bird High School, Sector 16, Panchkula, was making way for another school bus when it skidded into the overflowing drain. The bus tilted in the drain, but passersby and parents were able to rescue the children through the driver's window.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Thursday, July 07, 2022