Complete Kanjurmarg dump hearing in 3 months: SC to HC

HT Image
HT Image
Published on Feb 16, 2020 01:30 AM IST
Copy Link
By, Mumbai

The Supreme Court (SC) on Friday directed the Bombay high court (HC), which has been hearing the Kanjurmarg dumpyard case for nine years, to complete the hearing within three months.

The SC was hearing a special leave petition (SLP), filed by environment group Vanashakti on January 17, challenging a December 5, 2019 HC order which allowed the expansion of the dumping ground to 121 hectares (ha), from 65ha. The petitioner claimed that the expansion was in violation of coastal regulation zone (CRZ) norms and would cause irreparable damage to the eco-sensitive zone (ESZ) of the Thane Creek Flamingo Sanctuary (TCFS).

The SC bench, comprising chief justice SA Bobde, and justices BR Gavai and Surya Kant, said the HC should consult expert groups such as Bombay Natural History Society (BNHS) and National Environmental Engineering Research Institute (NEERI) to assess the adverse effects of the expansion and its impact on TCFS and its ESZ. “We are of the view that the interest of justice would be best served if the HC disposes of the matter pending before it, as expeditiously as possible, preferably within a period of three months from today [February 14],” read the SC order published on Saturday. “We also consider it appropriate if the HC obtain the report of an expert body like BNHS and NEERI before taking a final decision,” the bench stated, disposing the SLP.

Stalin D, director, Vanashakti, said he hopes “NEERI and BNHS will submit a truthful scientific report on the issue”. “The [Bombay] HC’s December 5, 2019 judgment was shocking and preposterous, which opened the doors to the annihilation of mangroves and wetlands at Thane creek. It implied that Mumbai was legally permitted to dump unsegregated municipal garbage in CRZ areas,” he said.

Zaman Ali, counsel for Vanashakti, said that although scientific reports of the government on the matter have already been submitted to the HC since 2013, the SC’s order is welcome. “The SC order can add more scientific inputs on the mounting ecological damage at Thane creek for almost a decade now. Based on our submissions, the chief justice raised concerns on how the flamingo habitat may be affected, and how expert bodies shed throw more light on this,” said Ali.

Deepak Apte, director, BNHS said, “If the SC has asked us to provide scientific inputs, we will highlight the ecological importance of this sanctuary, which is Asia’s largest creek ecosystem.”

The HC has not yet passed its final judgement on three separate petitions filed by Vanashakti in the Kanjurmarg duping ground case. The first petition was filed in 2012 against the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) and other state and Central bodies for the dumping of municipal solid waste at Kanjur, in alleged violation of CRZ 2011 norms. The second petition in 2013 challenged the de-reservation of mangrove forests at Kanjur by the state instead of the Central government, an alleged violation of the Forest Conservation Act, 1980. In July 2019, Vanshakti filed its third petition challenging the expansion of Kanjur from a CRZ to a non-CRZ area, for which BMC acquired environment clearances from the Centre to carry out scientific waste processing on an additional 52.5-ha area, adjacent to the Kanjurmarg dumping site.

On December 5, an HC bench of justices SC Dharmadhikari and RI Chagala had lifted a September 19 stay on waste dumping at the 52.5-ha site. The order stressed that there was a lack of space for dumping and treating solid waste in the city as the Mulund dumpyard was shut in 2018, and the overburdened Deonar dumping ground was also proposed to be shut.

The petitioner, however, claimed that the sanctuary zone had become toxic with large-scale disappearance of fish species and a nauseating odour, especially at night, owing to waste dumping. “Permissions from the Maharashtra Coastal Zone Management Authority (MCZMA) and the environment ministry were issued only because the site lies in CRZ-3, which permits construction after first 100m from the high tide line. Also, waste from all CRZ areas in the city would be taken to this 52.6-ha patch for scientific processing, thus reducing the impact on overburdened landfills,” said a BMC official working on the case.

According to BMC, Mumbai generates 7,000 metric tons (MT) of waste per day, of which 5,500 MT is sent to Kanjurmarg, while 1,500 MT goes to Deonar.


    Badri Chatterjee is an environment correspondent at Hindustan Times, Mumbai. He writes about environment issues - air, water and noise pollution, climate change - weather, wildlife - forests, marine and mangrove conservation

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  •  (HT PHOTO)

    Cyber fraudster dupes naval official

    A fraudster duped a naval officer of 1.25 lakh by sending him an SMS saying that his account would soon be blocked as he had not updated his Know Your Customer details. To update the details, the officer clicked the link in January. Since the complainant was out working on a ship, he was unavailable to record his statement for five months. A First Information Report was later registered against the unidentified fraudster.

  • The allegations are of making appointments at Haryana State Warehousing Corporation in an illegal and arbitrary manner when senior Haryana IAS officer Ashok Khemka (in photo) served as its managing director 12 years ago. (HT file photo)

    Punjab and Haryana high court stays Khemka’s arrest in Panchkula case

    The Punjab and Haryana high court on Tuesday stayed the arrest of senior IAS officer Ashok Khemka in a case registered against him under the Prevention of Corruption Act in Panchkula. The FIR was registered on the complaint of the managing director of the Haryana State Warehousing Corporation, Sanjeev Verma, on April 26 at the Sector-5 police station in Panchkula.

  • Punjab farmers want to carry out paddy transplantation from June 10 instead of June 18. They also want the fee charged for increasing the power load to be decreased by the Bhagwant Mann-led AAP government. (Sameer Sehgal/HT)

    Farmer leaders meet Punjab CM over new paddy sowing schedule

    Members of 23 farmer unions of Punjab gathered at Amb Sahib Gurudwara in Phase-8 in Mohali on Tuesday morning to march towards Chandigarh as part of their protest against the paddy-sowing schedule announced by the Bhagwant Mann-led Aam Aadmi Party government. Also read: Farmer unions in Punjab slam wheat export ban All Mohali-Chandigarh borders, including the Yadavindra Public School roundabout, have been sealed as a precautionary measure since Monday night.

  • Bengaluru's new police chief C H Pratap Reddy is from the 1991 batch of the IPS.

    Who is CH Pratap Reddy - Bengaluru's new police commissioner?

    In a major shuffle, the Karnataka government on Monday appointed senior IPS officer CH Pratap Reddy as the new Bengaluru city police commissioner, replacing Kamal Pant, according to an official order. The 1991-batch IPS officer, Reddy previously served as an additional director general of police of the law and order department of Karnataka. A native of Guntur in Andhra Pradesh, Reddy is a B. Tech graduate. Usually, Bengaluru's police commissioners are replaced every year.

  • Digvijaya Singh (File Photo)

    On Neemuch violence, Digvijaya Singh's questions for district administration

    As Madhya Pradesh witnessed another episode of communal violence, this time in Neemuch, senior Congress leader Digvijaya Singh on Tuesday said he questioned the district administration about the incident. Singh's third query was if it was a crime to install idol on a government land, without permission; yes, he said was the response. “We will act on the basis of CCTV footage,” he quoted the officials as saying.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Tuesday, May 17, 2022