Mangrove cutting for sea link: SC sends petition back to HC

The HC, on February 8, had allowed Maharashtra State Road Development Corporation (MSRDC) — the agency implementing the rupees 11,332-crore project — to cut 1,585 mangrove trees on around 3 hectares. It was the final clearance MSRDC required to begin work on the project.
The Apex Court was hearing a special leave petition filed by Khar resident and environmentalist Zoru Bhathena on March 25.(HT PHOTO)
The Apex Court was hearing a special leave petition filed by Khar resident and environmentalist Zoru Bhathena on March 25.(HT PHOTO)
Published on Apr 02, 2019 07:46 AM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times, Mumbai | By

The Supreme Court (SC) on Monday sent back the matter of felling mangrove trees for the Versova-Bandra Sea Link (VBSL) project to the Bombay high court (HC). The Apex Court was hearing a special leave petition filed by Khar resident and environmentalist Zoru Bhathena on March 25.

The HC, on February 8, had allowed Maharashtra State Road Development Corporation (MSRDC) — the agency implementing the rupees 11,332-crore project — to cut 1,585 mangrove trees on around 3 hectares. It was the final clearance MSRDC required to begin work on the project.

“The SC bench of justice Nageshwar Rao and justice MR Shah said how could the HC pass an order where 2.9907 hectare of mangroves can be permitted to be cut. The environment ministry’s CRZ permission in 2013 [for the project] was subject to only 150 square metres mangrove felling for a bridge to be built on stilts,” said Jatin Zaveri, counsel for the petitioner.

“We told the SC bench that the State Environment Impact Assessment Authority nod for the project mandated that no mangroves be destroyed. In such circumstances, MSRDC’s dem-and for 30,000 sqm of mangroves is unnecessary and akin to environmental destruction.”

A senior MSRDC official, who did not wish to be named, explained why there has been a change in mangrove area lost to the project. “CRZ area and deemed reserved forest are two different zones,” he said. “While we received CRZ clearance [150 sqm] long ago, the other permission [30,000 sqm] pertained to forest clearance was given by the mangrove cell of the forest department. Earlier, our consultant had done a feasibility study that recorded 150 sqm [of mangrove loss] for the project. However, since there are sparse mangroves in some areas and no trees in others, the clearance by forest department recorded the total mangrove area that will be lost.”

“Based on this explanation, we got clearance from HC. We will explain the same [in HC] again.”

State government sources, who were involved in the clearance process, said the MSRDC proposal read that 2.9907 hectares of mangroves would be lost. “We do not decide how much mangrove area is lost. We only assess and ensure there is least possible damage,” said an official.

Bhathena, meanwhile, thanked the SC. “We are grateful the SC took note of our complaint, and allowed us to go back to HC to resolve the issue,” he said.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
  • ABOUT THE AUTHOR

    Badri Chatterjee is an environment correspondent at Hindustan Times, Mumbai. He writes about environment issues - air, water and noise pollution, climate change - weather, wildlife - forests, marine and mangrove conservation

Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • The new cases in Chandigarh were reported from Sectors 8, 11, 19, 21, 22, 23, 25, 26, 44, 48 and 38 (West), Daria, Khuda Lahora, Manimajra and PGIMER campus. (HT File Photo)

    Chandigarh’s Covid cases shoot up to 23

    As many as 23 people tested positive in Chandigarh on Thursday, highest in three months. It was on February 26 last that the city had recorded 25 infections, following which their number crossed the 20 mark only once on May 11, when 22 people were found infected. The new cases were reported from Sectors 8, 11, 19, 21, 22, 23, 25, 26, 44, 48 and 38 (West), Daria, Khuda Lahora, Manimajra and PGIMER campus.

  • HT Image

    Cop loses mobile phone to snatcher in Mohali

    A snatcher took away the mobile phone of an assistant sub-inspector (ASI) from Cheema Chowk in Industrial Area's Phase 8. Investigating officer Swaranjit Singh said Ravinder Kumar, who is posted at Police Lines, was talking to one of his family members on Wednesday night, when the bike-borne snatcher struck. In another case, two youths snatched the purse of one Rashi Srivastva in Chandigarh's Sector 44.

  • In an attempt to escape, the Thar driver sped up, dragging the victim and his scooter along for nearly 500 metres before the vehicle’s front wheel broke, forcing it to stop, said Chandigarh Police. (Keshav Singh/HT)

    Chandigarh: Thar claims newspaper delivery man’s life in early morning mishap

    A 50-year-old newspaper delivery man was killed after a Mahindra Thar rammed into Balbir's scooter at the Sector 17/18 traffic lights on early Thursday morning. The victim was identified as Balbir Singh Rana, who hailed from Uttarakhand and lived with his family in Kishangarh village, Chandigarh. Police said while he was approaching the Sector 17/18 light point, a speeding Mahindra Thar, bearing a Chandigarh registration number, hit his Honda Activa from behind.

  • Earlier this week, the Punjab and Haryana high court had directed the central government to consider conversion of Panjab University into a central university. (HT Photo)

    Stakeholders divided over central status for Panjab University

    Punjab and Haryana high court's directions to the central government to consider conversion of Panjab University into a central university has evoked mixed reactions from various stakeholders related to the university. Panjab University Teachers Association president Mritunjay Kumar said they were awaiting the outcome of HC's direction, as PUTA's focus was also on bringing PU teachers under Central Service Rules, which were already applicable for teachers at UT colleges.

  • A custom official said the nearly <span class='webrupee'>₹</span>4,000 per gm difference in gold price between India and Dubai was pushing the illegal trade. (Bloomberg)

    Two passengers from Dubai nabbed with 4 kg smuggled gold at Chandigarh airport

    The customs department on Thursday caught two passengers with 4,142 gm gold, which was being illegally smuggled at the Chandigarh International Airport. Both passengers had arrived in the Indigo flight from Dubai at 4.30 pm. Customs officials also frisked another passenger from the same flight and recovered 142 gm gold in the form of five chains, which were concealed in clothes inside a backpack.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Friday, May 27, 2022