Singers acting good... and bad
Pop singers love to try their hand at acting, but some of them really shouldn’tmusic Updated: Jun 20, 2012 01:17 IST
Pop singers love to try their hand at acting, but some of them really shouldn’t
All natural and unshowy, Mariah Carey was a genuine revelation in the film Precious (2009). But sadly, no one has made it more than three minutes into Precious without running out of the theatres.
To be fair, he has only ever really played himself — although a mumbling, monotone version, in 8 Mile. But playing yourself can be harder than it looks.
Nobody could have guessed that an American Idol reject would win an Oscar for her raw performance in Dreamgirls. Or, admittedly, follow it up with a drab role in the Sex and the City film.
It’s easy to pick on Britney Spears for starring in Crossroads (2002), but that’s because watching Crossroads was like performing dental surgery on yourself with a tinfoil drill. Her place here is well deserved.
Rihanna wasn’t given an awful lot to do in Battleship, but she still managed to fail hopelessly. Your mum, given the chance, could grunt at a Transformer more convincingly.
While in Bollywood...
The trend of musicians taking up acting has not been a success, even when it comes to our desi singers. Musicians like Himesh Reshammiya, Sonu Nigam, Lucky Ali and Shruti Haasan have all fizzled behind the camera, despite trying their luck as actors in films like Aap Ka Suroor, Karzzz, Jaani Dushman, Kaante, Sur, and Luck, respectively.
Pakistani singer Ali Zafar has been the only success story, both behind the mic, and on-screen as well, with films like Tere Bin Laden, Mere Brother Ki Dulhan and London Paris New York to his credit.