Criminal Justice review: It is virtually impossible to imagine Vikrant Massey as a murderous psychopath.
Criminal Justice review: It is virtually impossible to imagine Vikrant Massey as a murderous psychopath.

Criminal Justice review: Vikrant Massey, Pankaj Tripathi and a stunning Jackie Shroff are saving grace of Hotstar’s remake

Criminal Justice review: Hotstar’s latest ‘special’ relies on its actors to do the heavy lifting. Fortunately, Vikrant Massey, Pankaj Tripathi and especially Jackie Shroff, are tremendous. Rating: 3.5/5.
By Rohan Naahar | Hindustan Times
UPDATED ON APR 06, 2019 02:06 PM IST

Criminal Justice
Director - Tigmanshu Dhulia
Cast - Vikrant Massey, Pankaj Tripathi, Jackie Shroff
Rating - 3.5/5

 

It’s a good thing that Hotstar isn’t branding its own content as ‘Hotstar Originals’ anymore. Because the streaming service’s second show, Criminal Justice, is far from original. Not only is it literally a remake of a remake - the ‘original’ UK Criminal Justice was adapted in America as The Night Of - but it is narratively similar to so many murder mysteries we’ve seen before, all in a good way.

Three episodes were made available in advance, and this should be considered a review of those three episodes only. The hope is that Criminal Justice maintains the solid start, and doesn’t derail in later episodes, as the plot becomes more convoluted, and the twists more winding.

Watch the Criminal Justice trailer here

It takes around 10 minutes for it to be made abundantly clear that Criminal Justice can’t be compared to its ancestors - despite their common DNA. But once we’ve made peace with this, it can be enjoyed for what it is - an adaptation of a proven property, which makes the smart decision to retain what worked, and doesn’t make needless attempts to reinvent the wheel.

Director Tigmanshu Dhulia, through his unfussy handling of the material, often evokes memories of the previous shows by replicating moments - both visually and thematically. Often, Vikrant Massey’s central character, Aditya, is framed in a manner similar to how Riz Ahmed’s Naz was shown in The Night Of. And while there are obvious distinctions to be made between an immigrant Pakistani family living in New York, and a middle class Indian family in Mumbai - Dhulia and writer Shridhar Raghavan tap into the stories’ universal themes - corruption, bureaucracy, and class.

It isn’t clear how much ‘acting’ Jackie Shroff is doing, but whatever it is, it’s great.
It isn’t clear how much ‘acting’ Jackie Shroff is doing, but whatever it is, it’s great.

I am ashamed to admit the sheer pleasure I derived from watching Jackie Shroff in his element, sat there in his trademark neckerchief, with words like ‘bhidu’ and ‘darling’ flowing trippingly off his tongue, almost as if he uses them in regular life.

His performance is excellent, equal parts menacing and reassuring, much like Michael K Williams’ in The Night Of. And it’s a sign of Pankaj Tripathi’s dependability that even the show’s insistence on slotting his character as comic relief - he enters scenes, more often than not, accompanied by goofy background music - doesn’t get in the way of his nuanced performance. As always, Tripathi is rather understated, despite his character - the street-smart lawyer Madhav Misra - almost begging for an over-the-top portrayal, what with all his quirks, and the eczema.

Misra is perhaps the show’s most successful attempt at cultural translation. Unlike some of the other characters - and indeed, thematics - the amoral chicanery of Misra seems to be rooted in what some of you might have seen in our courtrooms.

Pankaj Tripathi is as wonderful as always in Criminal Justice.
Pankaj Tripathi is as wonderful as always in Criminal Justice.

While The Night Of, in particular, had strong political subtext - it was also a takedown of the American legal system, and a blunt critique of post 9/11 racism - Criminal Justice doesn’t quite make the most of the opportunity to discuss class in India, and the appalling lawlessness of our prisons, which can sometimes house dozens of inmates in the same cells.

So instead, the show is more heavily reliant on its actors than usual. While both the original UK show and The Night Of had other things going it their favour - bigger budgets, a grander scope, the honourable stamps of the BBC and HBO - the burden of maintaining Criminal Justice’s grip on the audience falls mostly on its trio of leading stars.

Vikrant Massey and his angelic face in a still from Hotstar’s Criminal Justice.
Vikrant Massey and his angelic face in a still from Hotstar’s Criminal Justice.

It’s nearly impossible to imagine Vikrant Massey as a murderous psychopath - even more so than the similarly angelic-looking Ben Whishaw and Riz Ahmed - but this is not a Jekyll and Hyde story. Instead, it deals with the same themes that director Konkona Sen Sharma attempted to unpack in her debut, A Death in the Gunj. I mention that film purely because it was also told through the perspective of Massey’s character, and dealt with the psychological unravelling of an introvert.

It would be unfair to criticise Criminal Justice for its rather on-the-nose storytelling. I suppose that is a part of the adaptation process. There is still a long way to go, but simply the fact that we’re now officially remaking stuff instead of shamelessly lifting material is a win.

Follow @htshowbiz for more
The author tweets @RohanNaahar

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
Eijaz Khan is currently out of Bigg Boss 14 for a shoot.(Colors)
Eijaz Khan is currently out of Bigg Boss 14 for a shoot.(Colors)

Bigg Boss 14: Eijaz Khan reveals his favourite nickname given by Pavitra Punia

PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 08:52 AM IST
In a Twitter session, Eijaz Khan revealed his favourite nickname that Pavitra Punia gave him and thanked fans for their love.
Close
Rakhi Sawant and Rubina Dilaik will be seen having yet another fight in the Bigg Boss 14 house.
Rakhi Sawant and Rubina Dilaik will be seen having yet another fight in the Bigg Boss 14 house.

Bigg Boss 14: Rakhi Sawant takes up Rubina Dilaik's duties without her consent

PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 08:16 AM IST
The promo for Bigg Boss 14's Tuesday episode shows Rubina Dilaik and Rakhi Sawant having a confrontation over who make the lunch.
Close
Disha Parmar will not enter Bigg Boss 14 during family week to support Rahul Vaidya.
Disha Parmar will not enter Bigg Boss 14 during family week to support Rahul Vaidya.

Disha Parmar says her entry in Bigg Boss 14 'will put pressure on' Rahul Vaidya

PUBLISHED ON JAN 25, 2021 05:45 PM IST
Disha Parmar said that she will not enter Bigg Boss 14 to support Rahul Vaidya. She said that he is ‘strong enough to fight his own battles’.
Close
Jasmin Bhasin and Aly Goni on Bigg Boss 14.
Jasmin Bhasin and Aly Goni on Bigg Boss 14.

Aly's sister says Jasmin's dad's comments about relationship were 'misconstrued'

PUBLISHED ON JAN 25, 2021 02:41 PM IST
  • Jasmin Bhasin's father's comments about her relationship with Aly Goni were 'misinterpreted', Aly's sister has said.
Close
Rakhi Sawant has been claiming to have fallen for Abhinav Shukla.(Colors)
Rakhi Sawant has been claiming to have fallen for Abhinav Shukla.(Colors)

Bigg Boss 14 promo: Rakhi Sawant writes 'I Love Abhinav' all over her body

UPDATED ON JAN 25, 2021 08:08 AM IST
In the promo, an angry Rubina Dilaik asks Rakhi Sawant to stop with her antics while Abhinav Shukla looked disgusted by her actions.
Close
Sonali Phogat is the latest one to be evicted from Bigg Boss 14.(Colors)
Sonali Phogat is the latest one to be evicted from Bigg Boss 14.(Colors)

Bigg Boss 14 day 110: Sonali Phogat is voted out of the show

PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 11:09 PM IST
Bigg Boss 14 Weekend Ka Vaar written update day 110: Salman Khan did not appear on the show this weekend. However, Sidharth Shukla was seen grilling the contestants.
Close
Adhvik Mahajan (Sourced photo)
Adhvik Mahajan (Sourced photo)

Adhvik Mahajan: Contracts push actors into uncertainty

By S Farah Rizvi
UPDATED ON JAN 25, 2021 11:54 AM IST
Known for his roles in ‘Naagin’, ‘Divya Drishti’ and as Angad in the film ‘Laxmii’, actor Adhvik Mahajan states that being contract bound does impede opportunities coming your way
Close
 Tinaa Dattaa and Rashami Desai will be seen on Bigg Boss 14 Weekend Ka Vaar on Sunday.
Tinaa Dattaa and Rashami Desai will be seen on Bigg Boss 14 Weekend Ka Vaar on Sunday.

Bigg Boss 14: Rashami Desai, Tinaa Dattaa make fun of contestants

PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 02:48 PM IST
New promos of Bigg Boss 14 Weekend Ka Vaar Sunday episode show former contestant Rashami Desai entering the show along with Tinaa Dattaa and making fun of contestants.
Close
Sidharth Shukla will appear on Bigg Boss 14 in Weekend Ka Vaar episode.
Sidharth Shukla will appear on Bigg Boss 14 in Weekend Ka Vaar episode.

Bigg Boss 14: Sidharth speaks on Rubina-Abhinav's advantage, schools Nikki, Aly

PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 12:47 PM IST
The new Bigg Boss 14 promos show previous season winner Sidharth Shukla entering the house and showing the mirror to Nikki Tamboli and Aly Goni about their conduct in the house.
Close
Neha Mehta had quit Taarak Mehta Ka Ooltah Chashmah last year.
Neha Mehta had quit Taarak Mehta Ka Ooltah Chashmah last year.

Neha Mehta reveals she turned down two TV shows after quitting Taarak Mehta

PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 10:50 AM IST
Neha Mehta, of Taarak Mehta Ka Ooltah Chashmah fame, turned down two TV show offers as she wasn't confident of playing those characters.
Close
Eijaz Khan recently stepped out of the show for prior commitments.(Colors)
Eijaz Khan recently stepped out of the show for prior commitments.(Colors)

Bigg Boss 14 day 109: Kamya says Eijaz is arrogant and over-confident

PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 11:22 PM IST
Bigg Boss 14 written update day 109: Rakhi Sawant, Abhinav Shukla and Rubina Dilaik discussed their married lives, while Eijaz revealed he was with Pavitra Punia.
Close
Bernie Sanders does seem unimpressed by the contestant.
Bernie Sanders does seem unimpressed by the contestant.

Rannvijay Singha clearly wins the Bernie Sanders edit with this Roadies meme

UPDATED ON JAN 23, 2021 09:08 PM IST
After multiple celebrities tried their hands at the Bernie Sanders edit, it was VJ Rannvijay Singha who clearly won. He shared a photo of Bernie, edited into a Roadies audition.
Close
Actor Avneet Kaur has done TV shows such as Hamari Sister Didi, Chandra Nandini and Aladdin - Naam Toh Suna Hoga. She recently featured in singer Akull’s song Faraar.
Actor Avneet Kaur has done TV shows such as Hamari Sister Didi, Chandra Nandini and Aladdin - Naam Toh Suna Hoga. She recently featured in singer Akull’s song Faraar.

Avneet Kaur on being body shamed: Trolls don’t deserve even a fraction of our attention

By Shreya Mukherjee, New Delhi
UPDATED ON JAN 23, 2021 07:47 PM IST
Dancer-actor Avneet Kaur agrees that social media is important, but she insists that it’s neither our life, nor does it define our existence, so one needs to maintain necessary distance.
Close
Teejay celebrated her birthday on Friday.(Instagram)
Teejay celebrated her birthday on Friday.(Instagram)

Teejay Sidhu celebrates birthday with newborn baby and Karanvir Bohra

PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 03:17 PM IST
Teejay Sidhu and Karanvir Bohra shares sweet messages on Instagram to mark her birthday on Friday.
Close
Audience will ask tough questions to contestants.
Audience will ask tough questions to contestants.

Bigg Boss 14 promo teases a power-packed Weekend Ka Vaar episode, watch

UPDATED ON JAN 23, 2021 12:28 PM IST
Bigg Boss Weekend Ka Vaar will see a number of ex-contestants grace the episode as well as few audience, some of whom will grill the current contestants. Rahul Vaidya, Abhinav Shukla and Rubina Dilaik will be asked some tough questions.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP