It’s not unprecedented for WHO to publicly question its member states. It threatened to close its China office when the country was hiding cases during the SARS outbreak and loudly called for Nigeria to reverse its boycott of the polio vaccine in 2003(REUTERS)
It’s not unprecedented for WHO to publicly question its member states. It threatened to close its China office when the country was hiding cases during the SARS outbreak and loudly called for Nigeria to reverse its boycott of the polio vaccine in 2003(REUTERS)

Recordings reveal WHO’s analysis of Covid-19 pandemic in private

One of WHO’s central dilemmas is that it has no enforcement powers or authority to independently investigate epidemics. Instead, the agency relies on behind-the-scenes talks and countries’ cooperation.
By Associated Press | Posted by Nilavro Ghosh | Geneva
UPDATED ON NOV 11, 2020 03:38 PM IST

As the coronavirus exploded around the globe, scientists at the World Health Organization were sometimes privately frustrated by the mistakes made by some of their top donor countries but reluctant to say so publicly, leaked recordings of internal meetings show.

After sharp criticism for not taking a stronger role in curbing the pandemic, the UN health agency holds its annual meeting this week under intense pressure to reform. WHO is also hoping that US President-elect Joe Biden will reverse a decision by Washington to leave the organization made by the Trump administration in June.

One of WHO’s central dilemmas is that it has no enforcement powers or authority to independently investigate epidemics. Instead, the agency relies on behind-the-scenes talks and countries’ cooperation.

As the pandemic gained pace, WHO often shied away from calling out some of its biggest donors, including Japan, France and Britain. WHO scientists labelled some of their approaches as “macabre” and “an unfortunate laboratory to study the virus,” according to dozens of leaked recordings of internal WHO meetings and documents from January to April obtained by The Associated Press.

“By not speaking up when countries are doing questionable things, WHO is undermining its own authority while the planet burns,” said Sophie Harman, a professor of international politics at Queen Mary University in London.

Also Read: Taiwan says not invited to WHO meeting after China’s ‘obstruction’

Others said it would be politically unwise for WHO to be too outspoken unless countries give the agency more power.

“If Tedros was to take a very aggressive stance toward member countries, there would be repercussions,” said Suerie Moon, co-director of the Global Health Centre at the Graduate Institute of Geneva, referring to WHO Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus.

WHO spokeswoman Farah Dakhlallah said that since the beginning of the coronavirus outbreak, “WHO officials have had and continue to have, frank and open discussions with government counterparts. We are proud of an organizational culture that fosters candid discussions.”

It’s not unprecedented for WHO to publicly question its member states. It threatened to close its China office when the country was hiding cases during the SARS outbreak and loudly called for Nigeria to reverse its boycott of the polio vaccine in 2003.

WHO’s reticence to call out countries started with China, as the AP earlier reported. Despite a January meeting between Tedros and Chinese President Xi Jinping, information from Beijing was still sparse throughout February. Maria Van Kerkhove, WHO’s technical lead for Covid-19, noted that the agency lacked “enough detail to say what has worked and what hasn’t.”

WHO scientists soon grew concerned about Japan. On February 1, a passenger who disembarked the Diamond Princess cruise ship in Hong Kong tested positive for the coronavirus. At the ship’s next stop in Yokohama, authorities put all 3,711 people aboard under lockdown.

WHO emergencies chief Michael Ryan told reporters at the time: “Let’s be careful here not to overreact.” But on Feb. 10, the case count nearly doubled overnight.

“(That’s) not surprising given the nature of the response of the investigation,” Ryan said at an internal meeting, noting Japan had only assigned a small number of epidemiologists to investigate.

Dr. Thomas Grein, WHO’s chief of acute events management team, said they had failed to glean much information from their Japanese counterparts, calling it a “very, very sensitive issue.”

Although WHO was keenly aware the situation was deteriorating, scientists said the outbreak could help in understanding Covid-19 transmission.

“(It’s) unfortunate, but a useful opportunity to study the natural history of the virus,” Ryan said.

In late February, the virus also gained a foothold in Italy, turning Europe into the epicenter of the pandemic.

At WHO, Grein told his colleagues that WHO’s efforts to get more detail about the spiraling outbreaks in Italy and elsewhere had “spectacularly failed” as officials worried about the lack of action taken across Europe.

Yet on March 8, Tedros tweeted that “the government & the people of Italy are taking bold, courageous steps aimed at slowing the spread of the #coronavirus.”

Lawrence Gostin, director of the WHO Collaborating Center on Public Health Law and Human Rights at Georgetown University, said WHO should be obligated to report when countries are not sharing data, saying it was dangerous for the agency to be “flying blind.”

WHO also complained in private about Western countries hoarding scarce pandemic supplies.

“We had the terrible situation yesterday with (protective personal equipment) where all the supplies were requisitioned in France and we lost access,” Ryan told his colleagues.

As countries across Europe adopted social distancing measures and cancelled mass gatherings in early March, Ryan noticed one country did not: Britain.

“There isn’t a single sports event in Europe and yet all of the Premier League matches in the UK are to go ahead,” he said. Ryan described Britain’s pandemic strategy as “problematic” after hearing the UK’s chief scientific officer say the country was aiming for herd immunity.

“For that to happen, hundreds of thousands and millions of older people are going to become infected and there is just going to be so much death,” Ryan said. Still, he said the different approaches to tackling Covid-19 globally could prove to be “a massive ecological study” that would allow WHO to document what worked.

“It’s macabre in some ways, but it’s reality,” he said.

Going forward, WHO’s role trying to stop the pandemic will depend in part on the independent panel review. Harman, the expert from Queen Mary University, sympathized that WHO had enormous responsibility in the early months of COVID-19, but said even greater challenges loom now.

“With the next wave of the pandemic, I think the time for quiet diplomacy has passed,” she said.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
Moderna and Pfizer each are on track to deliver 100 million doses to the US by the end of March and another 100 million in the second quarter of the year.(AP)
Moderna and Pfizer each are on track to deliver 100 million doses to the US by the end of March and another 100 million in the second quarter of the year.(AP)

Why it's hard to make Covid-19 vaccines and boost supplies

AP
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 11:46 AM IST
Makers of Covid-19 vaccines need everything to go right as they scale up production to hundreds of millions of doses.
Close
On Tuesday, members of Khalistani separatist groups and others were seen in support of farmers outside the Indian embassy in Washington DC.(ANI)
On Tuesday, members of Khalistani separatist groups and others were seen in support of farmers outside the Indian embassy in Washington DC.(ANI)

Pro-Khalistani supporters vandalised Indian embassy in Rome on Republic Day

ANI, Rome
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 11:38 AM IST
The Indian government has been constantly raising its concerns with the Italian authorities and had done so recently as well in view of Republic Day, sources said.
Close
Vaccines are considered critical to eventually defeating Covid-19, which has continued to re-emerge even in nations where it was brought under control.(REUTERS)
Vaccines are considered critical to eventually defeating Covid-19, which has continued to re-emerge even in nations where it was brought under control.(REUTERS)

US demands 'robust' Covid-19 origin probe as pandemic surges worldwide

AFP
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 11:30 AM IST
The call came as coronavirus infections shot past 100 million and governments scrambled to get their hands on scarce vaccine doses, with a bitter row erupting between the European Union and Britain over the supply of AstraZeneca shots.
Close
China welcomed Biden's decisions to rejoin the Paris climate agreement and the World Health Organization.(AP)
China welcomed Biden's decisions to rejoin the Paris climate agreement and the World Health Organization.(AP)

Don't treat China as 'strategic rival', says China's ambassador to US

Reuters, Beijing
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 11:27 AM IST
Hong Kong, the western region of Xinjiang, the South China Sea and Taiwan were points of intensifying contention.
Close
A Holocaust survivor receives the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine against the COVID-19 disease, at a vaccination center on International Holocaust Remembrance Day in Vienna, Austria, Wednesday, Jan. 27, 2021. Hundreds of Holocaust survivors in Austria and Slovakia were poised to get their first coronavirus vaccinations on Wednesday to acknowledge their past suffering with a special tribute 76 years after the liberation of the Auschwitz death camp, where the Nazis killed more than 1 million Jews and others. The vaccinations were also offered to all other Jews in the area older than 85. (AP Photo/Ronald Zak)(AP)
A Holocaust survivor receives the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine against the COVID-19 disease, at a vaccination center on International Holocaust Remembrance Day in Vienna, Austria, Wednesday, Jan. 27, 2021. Hundreds of Holocaust survivors in Austria and Slovakia were poised to get their first coronavirus vaccinations on Wednesday to acknowledge their past suffering with a special tribute 76 years after the liberation of the Auschwitz death camp, where the Nazis killed more than 1 million Jews and others. The vaccinations were also offered to all other Jews in the area older than 85. (AP Photo/Ronald Zak)(AP)

Survivors receive coronavirus vaccine on Holocaust Remembrance Day

ANI, Viena
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 11:23 AM IST
The International Holocaust Remembrance Day is a memorial day on January 27, every year that commemorates the six million victims of the Holocaust, the genocide of European Jews by Nazi Germany between 1941 and 1945.
Close
Representational Image. (NYT)
Representational Image. (NYT)

Biden administration to let H-1B spouses work: What it means

By HT Correspondent | Edited by Sameer
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 10:58 AM IST
This comes as a relief for the Indian community in the US that lived with uncertainty after the Trump administration sought to take away their work authorisation as part of a larger effort to protect jobs for Americans
Close
The WHO has tried to manage expectations for the investigation.(via REUTERS)
The WHO has tried to manage expectations for the investigation.(via REUTERS)

WHO team in Wuhan set to leave quarantine in investigation of Covid origins

Reuters, Wuhan
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 10:42 AM IST
China's foreign ministry has also hinted on several occasions that the sudden closure of the US army laboratory at Fort Detrick in July 2019 is linked to the Covid-19 pandemic outbreak.
Close
India's external affairs ministry said that the two NSAs agreed to work closely to advance India-US relations(PTI)
India's external affairs ministry said that the two NSAs agreed to work closely to advance India-US relations(PTI)

US NSA dials Indian counterpart, discusses efforts to unite on global challenges

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Susmita Pakrasi, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 08:31 AM IST
The statement said that they discussed the importance of continuing close cooperation in the Indo-Pacific region, and promoting regional security.
Close
The approved resolution calls for removing names that honored historical figures with direct or broad ties to slavery, oppression, racism or the “subjugation” of human beings.(AP file photo. Representative image)
The approved resolution calls for removing names that honored historical figures with direct or broad ties to slavery, oppression, racism or the “subjugation” of human beings.(AP file photo. Representative image)

San Francisco to strip George Washington, Abraham Lincoln from school names

AP, San Francisco
UPDATED ON JAN 28, 2021 08:09 AM IST
The decision by the San Francisco Board of Education in a 6-1 vote Tuesday night affects one-third of the city's schools and came nearly three years after the board started considering the idea.
Close
The Imperial College London study found that the numbers infected with coronavirus are at their highest since the study began last May.(Bloomberg File Photo )
The Imperial College London study found that the numbers infected with coronavirus are at their highest since the study began last May.(Bloomberg File Photo )

English Covid-19 infections starting to fall, but prevalence still high: Study

Reuters, London
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 07:48 AM IST
British Prime Minister Boris Johnson on Wednesday indicated that the Covid-19 lockdown in England would last until at least March 8, dashing any lingering hopes that schools would be able to fully reopen in February.
Close
US President Joe Biden's focus on climate change has cheered international partners and environmental advocates, but upset Big Oil.(AP)
US President Joe Biden's focus on climate change has cheered international partners and environmental advocates, but upset Big Oil.(AP)

Joe Biden takes sweeping measures to curb climate change, vows job creation

Reuters, Washington
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 07:44 AM IST
Biden unveiled a "whole-of-government approach" to put climate change concerns at the center of U.S. national security and foreign policy as well as domestic planning.
Close
US President Joe Biden speaks at the White House
US President Joe Biden speaks at the White House

In multiple messsages, Joe Biden warns Beijing over expansionism

AFP
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 07:31 AM IST
  • That stance was echoed by Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin, who told Japanese counterpart Nobuo Kishi on Saturday that the contested islands were covered by the US-Japan Security Treaty.
Close
Violent rioters, loyal to President Donald Trump, storm the Capitol in Washington.(File Photo / AP)
Violent rioters, loyal to President Donald Trump, storm the Capitol in Washington.(File Photo / AP)

US terrorism alert warns of politically motivated violence

AP
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 07:05 AM IST
  • The department did not cite any specific plots, but pointed to “a heightened threat environment across the United States” that it believes “will persist” for weeks after Biden's Jan. 20 inauguration.
Close
A pedestrian walks past a billboard reading "Please believe these days will pass" on Broadway Market in east London.(AFP File Photo )
A pedestrian walks past a billboard reading "Please believe these days will pass" on Broadway Market in east London.(AFP File Photo )

UK high streets are emptying at the fastest pace on record

Bloomberg
UPDATED ON JAN 28, 2021 06:45 AM IST
UK retail landlords were already grappling with falling rents and values before lockdowns accelerated the shift to online shopping and forced more stores to close.
Close
Antony Blinken, US secretary of state, is sworn in during a ceremony at the White House in Washington, DC, US on Jan. 27, 2021. (Bloomberg File Photo )
Antony Blinken, US secretary of state, is sworn in during a ceremony at the White House in Washington, DC, US on Jan. 27, 2021. (Bloomberg File Photo )

US will join nuclear deal if Iran complies with provisions: Tony Blinken

PTI, Washington
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 06:33 AM IST
The Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA), popular as the Iranian nuclear deal, was one of the key foreign policy achievements of the Obama-Biden Administration. The Previous Trump Administration withdrew from it.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP