At loggerheads, over Lord Buddha

Nepal banned the Bollywood movie, Chandni Chowk to China following protests over a scene suggesting that Lord Gautam Buddha was born in India, reports Anirban Roy.
HT Image
HT Image
Updated on Feb 21, 2009 01:29 PM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times | By, Kathmandu

Nepal banned the Bollywood movie, Chandni Chowk to China following protests over a scene suggesting that Lord Gautam Buddha was born in India.

Earlier, the Nepal government had to shelve plans to inscribe Lord Buddha’s picture on paper currencies (to replace the picture of Shah Kings) after the democratic transformation of the country.

Despite being a Hindu-majority state, Nepal seems to have a soft corner for Buddhism. Devotees were against the government’s move to ‘commercialise’ Lord Buddha’s image.

Surprisingly, people in Nepal are turning a blind eye to the large-scale abuse of Lord Buddha’s name in Nepal, especially in Kathmandu.

“How will one feel when tourists see that we have named our bars as Funky Buddha?” said businessman from Thamel, Ramesh Shrestha. Sadly, Lord Buddha’s statues and the Buddhist stupas in and around Kathmandu are also badly maintained.

Surprisingly, Buddhism also did not spread much in Nepal, his birthplace. Rather, it was accepted in faraway places.

Moreover, over 2,550 years of his birth later, at least two Nepalese ethnic groups — Newars and Tharus — debate that the great saint belonged to them. The Tharus, an ethnic group found in the south mid-western districts of Nepal, also claim that Lord Buddha belonged to their community.

Author of the book, The Great Sons of the Tharus: Sakyamuni Buddha and Emperor Ashoka, Subodh Kumar Singh claimed that the Tharus, since sixth century BC, were subjects of Sakya Dynasty of Kapilavastu (Lord Buddha’s Kingdom).

“It is totally wrong to claim that Lord Buddha did not belong to us,” said information officer of Lumbini Development Trust, Keshav Choudhury. The Newaris are people from the hills, and Lord Buddha was born amongst us in the plains.”

“The ruins around Tilaurakot (28 km west of Lumbini) was Kapilavstu (Lord Buddha’s capital),” Choudhury, who also belonged to Tharu community, said, adding that there has been a sinister design by some people to create confusion.

However, Newars, the indigenous ethic population of Kathmandu Valley, too claim that Lord Buddha belonged to their community. “There is no doubt that he (Lord Buddha) was a Newari,” said Ganesh Ballabh Pradhan (70), a veteran journalist.

While the Newars and Tharus are at loggerheads over Lord Buddha’s ethnic origin, people in Nepal are curious to know about the great sage’s origin.


    Anirban Roy is the Deputy Resident Editor of HT’s Bhopal and Indore editions. A journalist for last 22 years, he has reported from India’s north-east and closely covered the Maoists’ Peoples’ War in Nepal.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Russian President Vladimir Putin.

    Russia defaults on foreign debt for first time in a century | 5 points

    Russia defaulted on its foreign-currency sovereign debt for the first time in more than a century, a result of its further alienation from the global financial system following West-led sanctions imposed over its war in Ukraine. “There is money and there is also the readiness to pay," Russian finance minister Anton Siluanov said last month. “This situation, artificially created by an unfriendly country, will not have any effect on Russians' quality of life.”

  • The UNODC report also noted that conflict could shift and disrupt drug trafficking routes, with suggestions that trafficking in Ukraine has fallen since early 2022.

    Ukraine war could boost illegal drug production: United Nations

    The war in Ukraine could allow illegal drug production to flourish, while the opium market's future hinges on the fate of crisis-wracked Afghanistan, the United Nations warned Monday.

  • Pakistan prime minister Shehbaz Sharif and Imran Khan,

    Shehbaz Sharif blames Imran Khan for rise of terror incidents in Pak: Report

    Pakistan prime minister Shehbaz Sharif on Sunday slammed the country's former government - led by Imran Khan - for its failure to implement the National Action Plan against terrorism. Slamming the Pakistani prime minister, Khan - during a meeting - reportedly referred to the rise in terrorism-related incidents during the last four years, against the backdrop of a 56 percent surge in the number of terror attacks in 2021.

  • Russian President Vladimir Putin. 

    As G7 bashes him, Putin to make 1st foreign trip since Ukraine war

    Russian president Vladimir Putin is set to make his first international trips since ordering the invasion of Ukraine on February 24 this year. Putin will be visiting Tajikistan and Turkmenistan, reported news agency Reuters, citing local media, adding that the Russian president will also meet Indonesian president Joko Widodo for talks in Moscow post the two visits.

  • Cannabis use has risen with legalization and Covid lockdowns: UN report

    Cannabis use has risen with legalization and Covid lockdowns: UN report

    Places including U.S. states that have legalized cannabis appear to have increased its regular use, while COVID lockdowns had a similar effect, raising the risk of depression and suicide, a U.N. report said on Monday. Various U.S. states have legalized non-medical use of cannabis, starting with Washington and Colorado in 2012. Uruguay legalized it in 2013, as did Canada in 2018. Others have taken similar steps but the report focused on those three countries.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Monday, June 27, 2022