Is study on people's opinion on same-sex marriage cooked up?

The reputed Science Magazine has retracted a widely publicised study that contended people’s opinion on gay marriage could be swayed after brief face-to-face conversations with people having a stake in the matter.
Updated on May 31, 2015 12:21 AM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times | ByHarikrishnan Nair, New Delhi

The reputed Science Magazine has retracted a widely publicised study that contended people’s opinion on gay marriage could be swayed after brief face-to-face conversations with people having a stake in the matter.

The study, “When contact changes minds: An experiment on transmission of support for gay equality,” published in December 2014 was authored by Michael J LaCour, a political science PhD student at the University of California, and Donald P Green, a political science professor at Columbia University.

Previous research suggested that no matter how well a person might have argued the case, shifting a person’s political opinion was almost impossible. A person might succeed for a short while, but eventually people return to their original beliefs.

LaCour and Green’s study contended this was not true. They claimed that once canvassers had done their job in their study, the shift in opinion among respondents persisted for months.

The results were remarkable and received much attention, including from The New York Times and Washington Post. Jesse Singal wrote in Science of Us, “It rerouted countless researchers’ agendas, inspired activists to change their approach to voter outreach, generated shifts in grant funding, and launched follow-up experiments.”

But a close scrutiny by students David Broockman, Josh Kalla and political scientist Peter Aronnow showed how LaCour had not even conducted a survey for the study.

uSamp, the company hired to do the survey, told Broockman, Kalla and Aronnow that it was impossible for them to do the survey.
How then did LaCour manage it? Simple. He apparently cooked it all up.

They accused LaCour of blatantly lifting data from a Cooperative Campaign Analysis Project (CCAP). When Broockman contacted uSamp, the company confirmed that neither could it do the survey nor did an employee named Jason Peterson, who apparently kept in touch with LaCour, work with the company at any time.

Science reported that Green contacted the magazine and requested the retraction after the irregularities was brought to his notice. Reportedly, when Green requested the raw survey data, LaCour refused on the grounds that he had destroyed it “in the interest of institutional requirement”.

“In addition to these known problems, independent researchers have noted certain statistical irregularities in the responses,” Science editor-in-chief Marcia McNutt wrote.

“LaCour has not produced the original survey data from which someone else could independently confirm the validity of the reported findings."
On May 29, Michael J LaCour responded to the allegations on his website. He admitted the shortcomings and apologised for lying about the methodology of the study but said he stood by the study’s findings.

He admitted to have cooked up much of the funding sources to give the study credibility. What he did instead was lotteries as incentives to participate in the study.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Britain's Prime Minister Boris Johnson in London.

    Kremlin on UK PM Boris Johnson: 'Russia doesn't like him either'

    As Boris Johnson is expected to resign on Thursday, after over 50 ministers resigned from the UK government, the Kremlin said the British prime minister didn't like Russia and that Moscow didn't like him either. Speaking during a call with reporters, Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said: “He (Johnson) doesn't like us, we don't like him either.” Peskov said reports that Johnson would shortly resign as prime minister were of little concern for the Kremlin.

  • Penny Mordaunt (right) is tipped to succeed Boris Johnson as the UK's new premier. (

    As Boris stares at exit, Mordaunt, Sunak lead race to 10, Downing Street: Report

    With Boris Johnson's premiership in its definitive final stretch – the British media has reported that the embattled PM of the United Kingdom will step down today – all eyes will be on his successor, whose name is likely to be announced in a day or two. The London-based publication, citing data from Oddschecker, reported that Penny Mordaunt and Rishi Sunak, at 22% each, are bookies' favourites to be the 78th premier of the UK.

  • UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson.

    'Good news': UK's Labour party on PM Boris Johnson's expected resignation 

    The leader of Britain's main opposition Labour party, Keir Starmer, on Thursday said Boris Johnson's expected resignation as prime minister was "good news". Starmer, however, said just changing the leader of the Conservative party was not enough. Embattled PM Johnson agreed to step down as the Conservative Party leader, ending an unprecedented political crisis and triggering an election for a Tory leader who will go on to become the new premier.

  • Larry the cat walks outside of 10 Downing Street in London, on July 7, 2022. 

    What Boris Johnson's mouser said on cabinet exodus as he agrees to quit as UK PM

    Larry the Cat, the chief mouser of 10 Downing Street, the official residence of the British Prime Minister, took to Twitter to express its views on the current political crisis in the country. I'm not “Boris Johnson's cat” 2. Like all Prime Ministers, Boris Johnson's's only a temporary resident of Downing Street 3. When he finally goes, I stay 4. Larry has completed 11 years roaming around the corridors of 10 Downing Street.

  • UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson (File photo/Associated Press)

    UK's Boris Johnson agrees to quit, will be 'caretaker PM' till October

    British prime minister Boris Johnson is expected to remain as PM while the Conservative Party choose a new leader; an internal election will likely be in the summer, the BBC said, citing a 10, Downing Street source as saying a new leader should be in place by October. The PM will make a statement later today.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Thursday, July 07, 2022