US Prez Obama stays the course despite ISIS advance

President Barack Obama's war strategy failed to stop Islamic State jihadists from overrunning Ramadi but he appears reluctant to change course despite the group's advances on the battlefield.
Updated on May 23, 2015 09:57 PM IST
Copy Link
AFP | By, Washington

President Barack Obama's war strategy failed to stop Islamic State jihadists from overrunning Ramadi but he appears reluctant to change course despite the group's advances on the battlefield.

The disastrous fall of the Iraqi city exposed the limits of Obama's policy, experts say, highlighting the sectarian divisions in Iraqi society exploited by the IS group and the American president's determination to avoid another protracted military occupation.

After the Iraqi army's embarrassing rout on Sunday, Obama struggled to defend his approach and insisted the collapse in Ramadi was merely a "tactical setback."

"I don't think we're losing," Obama said in an interview with The Atlantic.

Obama said the question was not whether or not to send in US ground troops but "how do we find effective partners" that can defeat the Sunni extremists in Iraq and Syria.

But, even inside his administration, the result in Ramadi was seen as damaging for both the Iraqi government and the US-led coalition backing it with air strikes since late last year.

Only days after Ramadi was overrun, the jihadists also seized the ancient city of Palmyra in Syria as well as a key border crossing, undercutting weeks of optimistic talk from the Pentagon that the extremists were "on the defensive."

With IS still on the move after more than 4,000 US-led air strikes in nine months in Iraq and Syria, the administration was taking a "hard look" at its strategy, a top US official told reporters.

More commandos?

In the wake of Ramadi's capture, US officials announced that 2,000 AT4 anti-tank weapons were on the way to Iraq to help Iraqi troops counter massive car bombs.

The move was part of an effort to ramp up the arming of Iraqi troops and Sunni tribesmen.

But both at home and abroad Obama's stance has been slammed as overly cautious.

The president faces growing calls for a dramatic overhaul of a campaign which has relied on American-led air power backing up US-equipped local forces.

Some lawmakers urged a major increase in US troops, at least several thousand or more, while former senior officials called for a bolder diplomatic calculus.

Senator John McCain and other voices on the right said Obama should deploy more special forces and stage more raids similar to an operation a week ago in which US commandos killed an IS financier in eastern Syria.

The elite special forces could be "forward deployed" across the battlefront to help call in air strikes, assist Iraqi troops and hunt down jihadist commanders, McCain argued.

"What we desperately need is a comprehensive strategy, the decisive application of an increased but still limited amount of US military power, and a concerted effort by the Iraqi government to recruit, train and equip Sunni forces," McCain said.

Critics also urged Washington to take a more forceful diplomatic stance to prevent the jihadists from taking advantage of divisions inside the international coalition and of the alienation of Sunnis in Iraq.

The US could no longer ignore the civil war in Syria and would have to take bolder action to help "moderate" rebels there, which might persuade Sunni governments to get more involved in the anti-IS fight, analysts said.

"The bottom line remains: the strategy isn't working and it can't work," said Richard Haass, a former senior diplomat.

It was unrealistic to treat Iraq as a single country, as it was irrevocably splintering into three parts -- Kurdish, Sunni and Shiite, said Haass, president of the Council on Foreign Relations.

As a result, Washington would have to channel military aid directly to local forces without working through the dysfunctional central government in Baghdad, he said.

"The time has come to accept that you can't put Humpty Dumpty back together again. The old multiethnic Iraq is over," Haass told Bloomberg television.

'Lying by omission'

The first step in salvaging Washington's strategy was to be honest about the course of the war, said Anthony Cordesman of the Center for Strategic and International Studies.

There were signs this week of some long overdue candor from an administration that has tended "to spin events, downplay risk and problems to the point of lying by omission," Cordesman wrote in a commentary.

For Obama, an outspoken opponent of the 2003 invasion of Iraq and the occupation that followed, an over-arching goal has been to steer clear of another major ground war in the Middle East.

But, Cordesman argued, "it is time the president's White House team learned that losing wars by default and inaction is scarcely a better historical record."

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Russian President Vladimir Putin.

    Russia defaults on foreign debt for first time in a century | 5 points

    Russia defaulted on its foreign-currency sovereign debt for the first time in more than a century, a result of its further alienation from the global financial system following West-led sanctions imposed over its war in Ukraine. “There is money and there is also the readiness to pay," Russian finance minister Anton Siluanov said last month. “This situation, artificially created by an unfriendly country, will not have any effect on Russians' quality of life.”

  • The UNODC report also noted that conflict could shift and disrupt drug trafficking routes, with suggestions that trafficking in Ukraine has fallen since early 2022.

    Ukraine war could boost illegal drug production: United Nations

    The war in Ukraine could allow illegal drug production to flourish, while the opium market's future hinges on the fate of crisis-wracked Afghanistan, the United Nations warned Monday.

  • Pakistan prime minister Shehbaz Sharif and Imran Khan,

    Shehbaz Sharif blames Imran Khan for rise of terror incidents in Pak: Report

    Pakistan prime minister Shehbaz Sharif on Sunday slammed the country's former government - led by Imran Khan - for its failure to implement the National Action Plan against terrorism. Slamming the Pakistani prime minister, Khan - during a meeting - reportedly referred to the rise in terrorism-related incidents during the last four years, against the backdrop of a 56 percent surge in the number of terror attacks in 2021.

  • Russian President Vladimir Putin. 

    As G7 bashes him, Putin to make 1st foreign trip since Ukraine war

    Russian president Vladimir Putin is set to make his first international trips since ordering the invasion of Ukraine on February 24 this year. Putin will be visiting Tajikistan and Turkmenistan, reported news agency Reuters, citing local media, adding that the Russian president will also meet Indonesian president Joko Widodo for talks in Moscow post the two visits.

  • Cannabis use has risen with legalization and Covid lockdowns: UN report

    Cannabis use has risen with legalization and Covid lockdowns: UN report

    Places including U.S. states that have legalized cannabis appear to have increased its regular use, while COVID lockdowns had a similar effect, raising the risk of depression and suicide, a U.N. report said on Monday. Various U.S. states have legalized non-medical use of cannabis, starting with Washington and Colorado in 2012. Uruguay legalized it in 2013, as did Canada in 2018. Others have taken similar steps but the report focused on those three countries.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Monday, June 27, 2022