Representative photo of human DNA. The union cabinet is likely consider a bill to create national DNA database of all those in conflict with law including suspects and volunteers. The bill that aims to provide legal backing to use of DNA in criminal and civil suits is slated for introduction in the monsoon session of Parliament. (Photo credit: Shutterstock)
Representative photo of human DNA. The union cabinet is likely consider a bill to create national DNA database of all those in conflict with law including suspects and volunteers. The bill that aims to provide legal backing to use of DNA in criminal and civil suits is slated for introduction in the monsoon session of Parliament. (Photo credit: Shutterstock)

DNA profiling: A bill that reads more like science fiction

The proposed legislation on human DNA profiling has many loopholes and can give the State far too much power writes Menaka Guruswamy
By Menaka Guruswamy
UPDATED ON AUG 20, 2015 12:52 AM IST

In the din of Vyapam, boycotts and demands for resignations, the just-concluded monsoon session of Parliament did not see the tabling of the Human DNA profiling bill, 2015.

Deoxyribonucleic acid, or DNA, carries most of the genetic instructions used in the functioning and reproduction of all living beings. Hence, an individual’s DNA can provide insights into his or her parentage, familial matrixes, medical history, race, ethnicity and a whole gamut of identity markers.

Popular culture, especially television crime shows, and the 2015 bill believe that DNA is the ultimate truth. The reality is otherwise.
The 2015 bill wrongly believes that DNA ‘establishes the biological relationship, if any, between two individuals, living or dead, without any doubt’.

It states that the ‘DNA found at the scene of the crime, of the victim or the offender will be used to establish identity’. The bill is wrong in assuming that DNA establishes the biological relationship ‘without doubt’.

Usha Ramanathan, who was on the committee to vet the 2012 version of the DNA bill, writes about the challenges of DNA profiling. These include false hits, cross-contaminating samples, mislabelling samples, misrepresenting test results, typing errors and intentionally planting DNA.

Ramanathan writes about a few RTI requests that reveal instances of error due to mislabelling samples.

There is also the possibility of simply jumping to wrong conclusions. The DNA recovered from a crime scene need not belong to the offender or accused.

Instead, it might belong to an unrelated party present, before or after the crime.

In early June this year, the Washington Post reported that the US’s Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) had notified crime labs that it had discovered errors in the data used by forensic experts in thousands of cases ‘to calculate the chances that the DNA found at a crime scene matches a particular person’.

This pertained to the FBI’s 13-million DNA profile database. According to the Washington Post, the FBI, due to the discovery of errors, was transitioning from 13 or more specific locations on chromosomes test, called 13 loci, to 20 loci. In a sample study conducted by the FBI on 1,100 profiles, 33 had errors.

Similarly, the British Home Office has reported that between 2001 and 2006, 27.6% of the matches from their database were to more than one person.

These multiple-match cases arose largely due to the crime-scene profiles being partial in nature. This points to two important aspects about DNA profiling.

First, like all science, it depends on methodology and interpretation. Second, due to human handling, there can be errors, intentional and unintentional. Therefore, the extraction of DNA, securing systems to store the samples, and the weight attached to DNA evidence must be carefully calibrated to take these imperfections into account.

The 2015 bill does the opposite. It expands the potential extraction pool to include every Indian.

The bill provides that every DNA Data Bank shall maintain DNA from seven categories of sources: a crime scene index, a suspects index, an offenders index, a missing persons index, unknown deceased persons index, a volunteers index and, rather ambiguously, ‘such other DNA indices as may be specified by regulations’.

The bill states that the DNA data bank manager, the person who administers the Bank, shall have the powers to not only compare DNA profiles but also ‘communicate for the purposes of investigation or prosecution in a criminal offence’ the DNA-related information to a ‘court, tribunal, law enforcement agency or DNA laboratory in India’.

Therefore, non-judicial, non-medical, non-forensic personnel will take the decision to share one’s genetic information, with or without reasonable cause, and minus any mediation by the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC).

By excluding these invasions of our person from the protections of the CrPC, the new bill removes the checks that the law has traditionally afforded.

Our legal system has always allowed for an ‘examination of the human body’.

For instance, Sections 53 and 53A of the CrPC allow for such examination (including DNA profiling) if there are ‘reasonable grounds’ for believing that such ‘examination’ of a person who is ‘arrested’ will afford evidence on the commission of an offence.

However, the request must be made by a police officer and the examination must be conducted by a registered medical practitioner. Similarly, Section 53A of the CrPC allows for the examination of one arrested for rape.

What is clear from both provisions is that there are safeguards including reasonable grounds for the examination — the person should be arrested, and finally, the examination must be conducted by a registered medical practitioner.

The 2015 bill has none of these checks.

Meanwhile, as an offender, one’s DNA gets into the database and it will be retained permanently.

Upon acquittal one needs to send a certified copy of the order to the data bank manager to get the record expunged.

Most troubling is that the bill provides that the DNA profiles will be made available for identification in criminal cases during judicial proceedings to enable decisions in criminal prosecution for the defence of the accused and, rather strangely, ‘for the creation and maintenance of a population statistics Data Bank that is to be used … in identification research, protocol development or quality control...’.

As if this were not enough, the DNA information can also be used for ‘any other purposes’ as may be prescribed.

The idea that the State can assemble a population data base, not simply a census but a blood history of its citizens, so as to enable identification research or even quality control, is anathema to a constitutional, democratic India.

This bill, when worked in tandem with the Aadhar regime, has the potential to profile, rather intimately, every Indian.

In fact, this bill reads like very bad science fiction, one in which the State runs amok and bad science leads to little truth, many lies and an abuse of our DNA.

Menaka Guruswamy is a Supreme Court lawyer
The views expressed are personal

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
The massive sacrifice of hundreds of Secret Service officers of Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose’s Indian National Army remains a secret and an enigma. On the 125th anniversary of Netaji’s birth, I appeal to the nation to document and recognise these sacrifices (HT PHOTO)
The massive sacrifice of hundreds of Secret Service officers of Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose’s Indian National Army remains a secret and an enigma. On the 125th anniversary of Netaji’s birth, I appeal to the nation to document and recognise these sacrifices (HT PHOTO)

The secrets of Netaji’s secret service

By Amit Mitra
PUBLISHED ON JAN 22, 2021 06:49 PM IST
The Indian National Army’s Secret Service men remain unrecognised, despite their sacrifices during the freedom struggle. We must revere them
Close
Prime Minister Imran Khan has contended that Pakistan's economy has made a remarkable turnaround.(Facebook/ImranKhanOfficial)
Prime Minister Imran Khan has contended that Pakistan's economy has made a remarkable turnaround.(Facebook/ImranKhanOfficial)

Imran Khan jumped the gun. This time, over Pakistan’s economic turnaround

UPDATED ON JAN 22, 2021 03:51 PM IST
  • Pakistan's GDP growth had slowed down much before the coronavirus outbreak, growing by 1.9% in 2019 as compared to a decade-high of 5.8% the previous year when Imran Khan's Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf came to power.
Close
While social media has the ability to democratise politics, it can also silence voices. This is troubling (AFP)
While social media has the ability to democratise politics, it can also silence voices. This is troubling (AFP)

The democratic dilemma posed by social media

By Manjari Chatterjee Miller
UPDATED ON JAN 22, 2021 06:20 AM IST
The banning of Trump and others from Twitter and Facebook, and the shutdown of Parler made clear that the power to silence voices, whether of the one or of millions, lies with just three men on the planet – Mark Zuckerberg of Facebook, Jack Dorsey of Twitter, and Jeff Bezos of Amazon. No wonder defending democracy will be a huge and unenviable task for President Biden’s team.
Close
The Supreme Court, in 2019, acknowledged that internet access is integral to the right to freedom of speech and expression while adding that any restriction on internet access must pass the test of proportionality, and suggested the evolution of a rules-based mechanism to govern the internet. (Getty Images/iStockphoto)
The Supreme Court, in 2019, acknowledged that internet access is integral to the right to freedom of speech and expression while adding that any restriction on internet access must pass the test of proportionality, and suggested the evolution of a rules-based mechanism to govern the internet. (Getty Images/iStockphoto)

Putting the consumer at the centre of Digital India

By Lloyd Mathias
UPDATED ON JAN 22, 2021 06:21 AM IST
One way to empower consumers is by creating mechanisms to ensure inter-operability, by making it easier to switch services from one platform to another. In telecom, interoperability is implemented. However, in the internet space, and more prominently in the app space, consumers do not have this choice.
Close
Project finance economies have different imperatives from working capital economies. They need investment to fill the gaps in their infrastructure and lack the resources to do so (Pratik Chorge/HT PHOTO)
Project finance economies have different imperatives from working capital economies. They need investment to fill the gaps in their infrastructure and lack the resources to do so (Pratik Chorge/HT PHOTO)

The working of a ‘project finance economy’

By Janmejaya Sinha
UPDATED ON JAN 22, 2021 06:19 AM IST
It is time to question neo-classical economic precepts on deficit and inflation for an economy of India’s nature
Close
Their success highlights the depth and strength of talent in the country (PTI)
Their success highlights the depth and strength of talent in the country (PTI)

Courage, calibre, character: India’s greatest series win

By Ayaz Memon
PUBLISHED ON JAN 20, 2021 08:07 PM IST
The experienced pros and newcomers combined to prove a point to themselves, the opponents and the world. And created history
Close
The Centre ensured the supply of drugs with equitable and integrated access (REUTERS)
The Centre ensured the supply of drugs with equitable and integrated access (REUTERS)

Managing drug security effectively in times of a pandemic

By Sudhansh Pant
UPDATED ON JAN 20, 2021 09:19 PM IST
The Centre’s strategy to ensure sufficient access, monitor stocks and distribution, issue approvals, maintain seamless supply chain of drugs, effectively communicate with stakeholders, and evolve a dynamic Clinical Management Protocol (CMP) has contributed significantly to India’s Covid-19 management success
Close
A new report by Chatham House describes India as UK’s ‘rival’ or ‘at best, an awkward counterpart’ on par with Russia, Turkey and Saudi Arabia. It also weighs in against the idea of expanding G7 to include India (Getty Images)
A new report by Chatham House describes India as UK’s ‘rival’ or ‘at best, an awkward counterpart’ on par with Russia, Turkey and Saudi Arabia. It also weighs in against the idea of expanding G7 to include India (Getty Images)

Is ‘Global Britain’ inimical to India?

By Syed Akbaruddin
UPDATED ON JAN 20, 2021 09:10 PM IST
There are disturbing signals from both segments of British polity and civil society. India will need to assess the UK’s position carefully
Close
Pakistan's opposition parties had united last year under the aegis of Pakistan Democratic Movement to launch coordinated attacks on Prime Minister Imran Khan(AFP)
Pakistan's opposition parties had united last year under the aegis of Pakistan Democratic Movement to launch coordinated attacks on Prime Minister Imran Khan(AFP)

Imran Khan gets squeezed between shrinking economy and proactive opposition

UPDATED ON JAN 20, 2021 05:48 PM IST
  • Differences between China and Pakistan over funding of CPEC's biggest railway project spotlights the growing pressures on PM Imran Khan on the economy front
Close
There is evidence to indicate that the PLA's work and engineering force deployed to upgrade infrastructure in occupied Aksai Chin moved back after completion of work last month
There is evidence to indicate that the PLA's work and engineering force deployed to upgrade infrastructure in occupied Aksai Chin moved back after completion of work last month

India should be wary of Chinese mind games

UPDATED ON JAN 13, 2021 12:31 PM IST
  • Withdrawal from the vast Tibetan and Xinjiang military region means little in an era of stand-off weapons and long-range missiles. The Chinese PLA has capacity to deploy troop divisions within a week with metalled roads and optical fibre cables up to the last military post and advanced landing grounds (ALGs) all along the LAC.
Close
President Xi Jinping, unconcerned about China's isolation, is expected to take steps that raise tensions ahead of the 100th anniversary of the communist party
President Xi Jinping, unconcerned about China's isolation, is expected to take steps that raise tensions ahead of the 100th anniversary of the communist party

Xi Jinping is preparing for a special birthday party. It has repercussions

UPDATED ON JAN 10, 2021 02:26 PM IST
  • The 100th-anniversary celebrations of the Chinese communist party would be projected as a strong counter to the so-called ‘century of humiliation’ that the Chinese empire and the Republic of China faced between 1839 and 1949 at the hands of western powers, Russia and Japan.
Close
Oli has been emboldened to stick to power even by breaking the party. In the process, the shallowness of Oli’s opportunistic and politically driven anti-Indian nationalism has been exposed(AFP)
Oli has been emboldened to stick to power even by breaking the party. In the process, the shallowness of Oli’s opportunistic and politically driven anti-Indian nationalism has been exposed(AFP)

What India should, and shouldn’t, do in Nepal

By SD Muni
UPDATED ON JAN 08, 2021 07:59 PM IST
Irrespective of whether Nepal has elections or witnesses the restoration of Parliament, a prudent course for India would be to let Nepal cope with its internal political mess
Close
India is currently the world’s third largest consumer of oil with growing demand and limited domestic supplies. Import in 2019-20 was 1.6 billion barrels and will increase as its economy expands.(REUTERS)
India is currently the world’s third largest consumer of oil with growing demand and limited domestic supplies. Import in 2019-20 was 1.6 billion barrels and will increase as its economy expands.(REUTERS)

To secure India’s energy future, create a sovereign wealth fund and invest

By Amit Bhandari
UPDATED ON JAN 07, 2021 07:43 PM IST
Norway is an example of prudent management of the windfall from high oil prices of the past, with which it set up a rainy day fund — now one of the most powerful and successful in the world. India is witnessing a similar windfall, in reverse, due to low oil prices — and needs to plan for the time when prices will be higher. That time is now.
Close
Health workers conduct a dry run of Covid-19 vaccination programme, New Delhi, January 6, 2021(Sanchit Khanna/HT PHOTO)
Health workers conduct a dry run of Covid-19 vaccination programme, New Delhi, January 6, 2021(Sanchit Khanna/HT PHOTO)

Devising a vaccine strategy for India

By Reuben Abraham and Anup Malani
UPDATED ON JAN 07, 2021 07:43 PM IST
Focus on allocation, distribution, financing, communication and certification
Close
The white supremacist disregard for the sanctity of law has been on the increase during the Trump presidency and the contrast with how Washington dealt with peaceful protests by African-Americans in recent months is illustrative of the deep racial fissures that still fester in US society.(AP)
The white supremacist disregard for the sanctity of law has been on the increase during the Trump presidency and the contrast with how Washington dealt with peaceful protests by African-Americans in recent months is illustrative of the deep racial fissures that still fester in US society.(AP)

January 6: A black day for US democracy

By C Uday Bhaskar
UPDATED ON JAN 07, 2021 07:41 PM IST
The erosion of democracy in the US, led by a defeated president, emboldened by his white supremacist base, will have both domestic and geopolitical consequences
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP