Deepika Padukone plays the titular character of Rani Padmini in Sanjay Leela Bhansali’s Padmaavat.
Deepika Padukone plays the titular character of Rani Padmini in Sanjay Leela Bhansali’s Padmaavat.

Padmaavat: Behind all the grandeur lies a regressive message, lack of objectivity

Now, that Padmaavat is out and pitched battles have been fought over it, many of those who fought for Bhansali are also disillusioned. The film propagates the same old gender, religion and caste divides and venerates one community while demonising another with impunity.
By Sweta Kaushal | Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON JAN 30, 2018 05:24 PM IST

A queen so beautiful that her face, to appropriate a line, launched a thousand ships. A king so brave that he will fight to save her honour till death. And a barbaric marauder who wants to acquire her for she is “naayab”.

The story is as old as stories themselves. So, what made Sanjay Leela Bhansali’s Padmaavat such a hot button topic that it had the self-appointed custodians of a particular community protesting for months and women threatening self-immolation while liberals fighting with the same vigour to ensure Bhansali have his say? It was perhaps the particular queen, Padmini, that the auteur chose as his muse, or it was the fight for freedom -- freedom to tell the story you chose, tell it the way you want to in a society -- from censorship by the mob.

Now, that the film is out and pitched battles have been fought over it -- on streets and in newsrooms, on Twitter and in living rooms -- many of those who fought for Bhansali are also disillusioned for the Ranveer Singh, Deepika Padukone and Shahid Kapoor-starrer propagates the same old gender, religion and caste divides. It venerates one community and demonises another with impunity. Women are shown as nothing more than a sum of their gender -- to be guarded, acquired and sacrificed depending on how their menfolk are faring. While the film’s detractors accept that the film will have the ethos of the time it has been set in but they are surprised that Bhansali’s lens wasn’t modern enough to showcase it all through the prism of today.

Bollywood actor Swara Bhaskar has already talked about the unwarranted glorification of jauhar and sati in her open letter to Bhansali. Here, we take a look at a few other pain points in Padmaavat...

The flag-bearer of Rajputana shaan
Over the past one year, the Karni Sena raised several objections to the film -- it distorts history and casts aspersions on Rajput valour. The film, ironically, is a lyrical ode to the ‘Rajputana shaan’ made, if reports are to be believed, at the cost of almost Rs 180 crore. The number of times we are told about how a Rajput would rather die than break rules makes it sound like an advertisement for the same organisation -- only one which is aesthetically more pleasing.

Was this how Bhansali always wanted to film Padmaavat or did he give in to the protests? That is hard to say but if it is indeed the latter than it is disappointing indeed.

So much talk about the Rajput pride reminds one of Kay Kay Menon’s character Bana in Anurag Kashyap’s Gulaal. Another custodian of Rajput pride, he waxes eloquent about what the community stands for but as audience, his misplaced pride is not venerated even once in the film. He and his beliefs are placed in the proper perspective, something Padmaavat absolutely fails to do.That is a responsible depiction of things as they exist, not glorifying past mistakes and failures.

Suppressed, mute women
If there is one remarkable thing about Sanjay Leela Bhansali’s films apart from the grandeur, it is the women characters. Be it Rani’s never-say-die spirit in Black or the ruthless matriarch played by Supriya Pathak in Ramleela - Goliyon Ki Raasleela, Bhansali’s women have always been full of life who refuse to bow down to adversities. Having set such a high standard for himself, Padmaavat is a major letdown. Be it the mute spectator Mehrunisaa (Aditi Rao Hydari) or Deepika’s Padmavati or even the badi rani in the Rajput house (essayed by Anupriya Goenka), every woman lacks agency in this film. Their life itself depends on the men around them.

Incidentally, there are token ‘progressive’ dialogues given to each of these characters. But when a wife continues to strive for the husband’s happiness just a moment after chiding him for having killed her father, it is nothing more than tokenism. Perhaps, this is an edited version to satiate the protesters, but the fact that Bhansali has presented all the misogyny in a glorified form, without even a frame or gaze criticising the attitude is disappointing.

Alauddin Khilji - the monster

via GIPHY

A day before the release of the film, Ranveer Singh called his character in the film a monster. And that is indeed what the actor plays -- from the way he eat to the way he behaves with women. After watching the film, historian Rana Safvi said, “The rulers followed the exact code of conduct and etiquette as in Persia. It would have been very formal — the eating, dining and sartorial choices.” Ranveer’s Khilji is quite the opposite - loud, no respect for rules or people around him and almost an animal like demeanour. Interestingly, even Jayasi, whose poem is the official basis of the film, did not portray Khilji as a barbarian.

The ‘Bollywood’ Hindi
Bollywood has often displayed special love for the Hindustani language - Hindi spoken with a heavy dose of Urdu words. Both Shahid and Deepika - who play Hindu royals in the film - use Urdu-heavy language in their speeches, conversations and especially songs. Words like ‘khoobsurat’ and ‘haadsa’ are not originally Hindu but were adapted in the language later. The words, ‘sundar’ and ‘durghatna’ would be used instead if the person speaking is not yet influenced by the Urdu language. The language in the film is more reminiscent of the 70s Bollywood films than the historical/mythical story of Padmini.

Follow @htshowbiz for more

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
Varun Dhawan at the wedding venue.
Varun Dhawan at the wedding venue.

Varun Dhawan arrives at venue ahead of wedding with Natasha Dalal

PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 01:40 PM IST
Ahead of his wedding with Natasha Dalal, Varun Dhawan was seen arriving at his wedding venue, The Mansion House, in Alibaug on Saturday. See pictures here.
Close
Kareena Kapoor in a glimpse from the photo shoot.
Kareena Kapoor in a glimpse from the photo shoot.

Kareena Kapoor is all about style and glamour in an all-black photo shoot. Watch

PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 01:22 PM IST
Kareena Kapoor has shared a video from one of her glamourous photo shoots. She is seen dressed in a black gown with a thigh-high slit.
Close
Taapsee Pannu has shared a post about her 2015 film Baby.
Taapsee Pannu has shared a post about her 2015 film Baby.

Taapsee Pannu recalls the 7 minutes that changed the direction of tide for her

UPDATED ON JAN 23, 2021 01:14 PM IST
Taapsee Pannu has talked about her short role in Akshay Kumar's 2015 film Baby. She said it changed the direction of tide for her.
Close
Akshay Kumar has shared a new still from Bachchan Pandey.
Akshay Kumar has shared a new still from Bachchan Pandey.

Akshay Kumar announces Bachchan Pandey release date with new still

PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 11:23 AM IST
Akshay Kumar has booked Republic Day holiday in 2022 for his upcoming film, Bachchan Pandey. He plays a dreaded gangster in the film.
Close
Here are top entertainment news stories.
Here are top entertainment news stories.

Jasmin Bhasin may return on Bigg Boss 14, Nick Jonas praises The White Tiger

PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 11:01 AM IST
From news reports about Jasmin Bhasin returning to the Bigg Boss 14 house to Priyanka Chopra's The White Tiger earning praise from her husband Nick Jonas, here are top entertainment news stories.
Close
Hrithik Roshan has shared his new look.
Hrithik Roshan has shared his new look.

Hrithik Roshan shares bearded look from new commercial, see pic

PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 10:44 AM IST
Hrithik Roshan has shared the advertisement of a beard grooming brand which features him in a bearded avatar, enough to be declared as the 'sexiest don alive'.
Close
Salman Khan has been shooting for Antim for some time now.(Varinder Chawla)
Salman Khan has been shooting for Antim for some time now.(Varinder Chawla)

Salman Khan, Mahesh Manjrekar spotted post Antim shoot, see here

PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 10:32 AM IST
Actor Salman Khan, Pragya Jaiswal and actor-filmmaker Mahesh Manjrekar were spotted in Mumbai, after the shoot of Salman's upcoming film, Antim. See pictures here.
Close
Alia Bhatt had been shooting for Gangubai Kathiawadi and RRR towards the end of 2020.
Alia Bhatt had been shooting for Gangubai Kathiawadi and RRR towards the end of 2020.

Alia Bhatt sets the mood for the weekend: 'Can't get out of bed kinda day'

PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 09:22 AM IST
Alia Bhatt shared a new selfie of herself while still lazing in the bed. She had been in news recently for her reported hospitalization.
Close
Priyanka Chopra has been promoting her new film, The White Tiger for the last couple of days.
Priyanka Chopra has been promoting her new film, The White Tiger for the last couple of days.

Priyanka Chopra thanks Nick Jonas for The White Tiger praise and the wine

UPDATED ON JAN 23, 2021 10:52 AM IST
Actor Priyanka Chopra and husband Nick Jonas celebrated the release of her film, The White Tiger. She took to Instagram to thank him. See her response here.
Close
Rajeev Khandelwal spent lockdown at home in Goa with his wife.
Rajeev Khandelwal spent lockdown at home in Goa with his wife.

Rajeev Khandelwal on Remo disowning his film: 'Didn't ask for explanation'

PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 07:08 AM IST
  • Rajeev Khandelwal has spoken about the time when Remo D'Souza publicly denied having any involvement with a film they made.
Close
Disha Patani shared a dance video on Instagram.
Disha Patani shared a dance video on Instagram.

Disha Patani dances up a storm to Saweetie's Tap In. Watch video

PUBLISHED ON JAN 22, 2021 09:21 PM IST
Disha Patani shared a video of herself performing a choreographed dance routine to Saweetie's Tap In. Watch it here.
Close
Sara Ali Khan is holidaying in the Maldives with Ibrahim and their mother, Amrita Singh.
Sara Ali Khan is holidaying in the Maldives with Ibrahim and their mother, Amrita Singh.

Sara drops appreciation post for 'bhaiya mere' Ibrahim, goes on bike ride

PUBLISHED ON JAN 22, 2021 08:43 PM IST
  • Actor Sara Ali Khan shared a special appreciation post for her brother, Ibrahim. Check it out here.
Close
Actor Gurmeet Choudhary will see seen in horror film, The Wife.
Actor Gurmeet Choudhary will see seen in horror film, The Wife.

Gurmeet Choudhary’s 2021 plans: My goal is to do five films this year

By Juhi Chakraborty
UPDATED ON JAN 22, 2021 08:05 PM IST
Actor Gurmeet Choudhary says he wants to be more visible and needs to work back-to-back for his fans. He further adds that with OTT platforms, there’s a lot of scope.
Close
Renuka Shahane is working on a book, which is a tongue-in-cheek look at the life in the 80s and is writing two screenplays too. (Photo by Sarang Gupta/Hindustan Times) (Hindustan Times)
Renuka Shahane is working on a book, which is a tongue-in-cheek look at the life in the 80s and is writing two screenplays too. (Photo by Sarang Gupta/Hindustan Times) (Hindustan Times)

Renuka Shahane: I want my women to talk about things not related to men or romance!

PUBLISHED ON JAN 22, 2021 08:01 PM IST
She feels OTT platforms push the envelope contentwise, without thinking about the economic viability
Close
Be it Alia Bhatt and Ranbir Kapoor or Hrithik Roshan and Deepika Padukone, there are a number of fresh pairing on screen that film lovers are looking forward to.
Be it Alia Bhatt and Ranbir Kapoor or Hrithik Roshan and Deepika Padukone, there are a number of fresh pairing on screen that film lovers are looking forward to.

Fresh on-screen pairings in Bollywood to look out for in 2021

By Shreya Mukherjee, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 22, 2021 07:48 PM IST
From Ananya Panday-Vijay Deverakonda, Rajkummar Rao-Bhumi Pednekar, Akshay Kumar-Manushi Chhillar to Mrunal Thakur-Shahid Kapoor, check out the fresh on-screen couples that would be seen on the big screen this year.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP