Panic, policy cuffs could force new recession: analysts
Another punishing week in stock markets has left European and US leaders looking less and less able to staunch fears of recession that analysts say could turn into a self-fulfilling prophecy.business Updated: Aug 21, 2011 10:22 IST
Another punishing week in stock markets has left European and US leaders looking less and less able to staunch fears of recession that analysts say could turn into a self-fulfilling prophecy.
While economists said that the world's mature industrial countries had not yet completely stalled, increasingly they were using the term "negative feedback loop" to define their worry.
In layman's terms panic in financial markets is scaring consumers and businesses into locking up spending, forcing a new economic contraction two years after the "Great Recession" ended.
Governments, themselves under the gun from bond markets and political pressure to cut spending, have diminishing kits of tools to counter the pessimism, they said.
Last week brought new worries into the picture:
- new data showing eurozone growth crawling at 0.2% in the second quarter, and Germany only at 0.1%;
- warnings, most notably from Morgan Stanley, that the US and Europe were on the precipice of a new recession;
- the failure of the German and French leaders to offer markets a convincing fix to the eurozone debt problems at their summit Tuesday.
That combination sent share markets plummeting, putting the broad-based S&P 500 index of US stocks down 4.7% for the week and 15.3% lower after a month of economic turmoil.
Britain's FTSE 100 is now down 12.9% over a month; France's CAC 40 18.4%; and Germany's DAX has been hit even harder, off 9.8% for the week and 23.8% in a month.
With trillions of dollars lost in paper wealth, sellers have moved their money into the safest havens they can find -- US Treasury bonds, Swiss francs, Japanese yen and others -- meaning it does not help growth.
Economists on both sides of the Atlantic slashed their growth projections.
"Our revised forecasts show the US and the euro area hovering dangerously close to a recession -- defined as two consecutive quarters of contraction -- over the next 6-12 months," investment bank Morgan Stanley said.
"A negative feedback loop between weak growth and soggy asset markets now appears to be in the making in Europe and the US. This should be aggravated by the prospect of fiscal tightening in the US and Europe," it said.
"In the absence of appropriate policy intervention from the European Central Bank (ECB), the Federal Reserve and the US government, it is entirely possible the current downward spiral in the economy and financial markets will become self-reinforcing," said John Silvia, chief economist for Wells Fargo bank.
Governments and central banks are increasingly boxed in on policy, said economists.
In Europe and the United States there is almost no room to lower interest rates to stimulate growth; central banks can fine-tune policy to try to push banks into putting more money into the commercial market, but that it is not clear that it will stimulate economies.
In Europe, where bailouts of Greece, Portugal and Ireland have already strained the richer governments, politicians and the public are reticent to pump more money out that they do not have.
The ECB does not have the power to print money to fuel recovery; and Tuesday's meeting between French President Nicolas Sarkozy and German chancellor Angela Merkel ruled out allowing it to issue region-backed eurobonds to raise money for growth and bailouts.
That was a big disappointment for markets.
"We still need a more meaningful solution in Europe," said Chris Low of FTN Financial. "The ECB is not equipped to solve the debt crisis on its own."
Meanwhile there was pressure on Europe's still-liquid governments to pare deficits by mainly cutting spending, especially France, the eurozone's second largest economy.
The same was true in the United States, where some are calling for an industry-building program on par with the World War II effort that pulled the country finally out of the Great Depression.
But given the August 5 credit downgrade of the government by Standard & Poor's over its growing deficit, and the refusal of conservative Republicans to allow spending, that is a non-starter -- though President Barack Obama is expected to reveal some modest growth initiatives in the next few weeks.
The Federal Reserve has hinted it still has tools to boost growth, and all eyes are on a speech next Friday by Fed chairman Ben Bernanke, expected to reveal what it might do.
(And even that could prove difficult: Republican presidential hopeful Texas governor Rick Perry declared last week that it would be "treasonous" if Bernanke is seen "printing more money.")
Goldman Sachs warned Friday that already-programmed spending cuts would cut US GDP by more than one% over the next year.
"Just offsetting the expiration of existing (stimulus) measures looks like a challenge, let alone enacting policies that exert a net positive influence on growth in 2012."