Hry refers fungicide purchase probe to CVC without any justification

Updated on Jul 26, 2015 11:31 PM IST
Almost three months after it took the decision, the Haryana government on July 24 finally referred the matter pertaining to alleged irregularities in the purchase of Raxil fungicide by the previous Congress regime to the Central Vigilance Commission (CVC) for a probe, but without citing any justification or grounds for doing so.
Hindustan Times | By, Chandigarh

Almost three months after it took the decision, the Haryana government on July 24 finally referred the matter pertaining to alleged irregularities in the purchase of Raxil fungicide by the previous Congress regime to the Central Vigilance Commission (CVC) for a probe, but without citing any justification or grounds for doing so.

Neither the July 24 communication sent by special secretary, agriculture, to chief vigilance commissioner, CVC nor the file notings annexed with it mention any justification or grounds for a CVC probe into the fungicide purchase. Haryana chief secretary Deepinder Singh Dhesi had also asked the state agriculture department on July 9 to spell out the reasons for making a reference to CVC for initiating a probe into alleged irregularities in fungicide purchase.

Even though the CVC Act clearly says that the commission has no jurisdiction over the state government organisations and can probe the matter involving IAS and IPS officers serving with the central government, Haryana agriculture minister OP Dhankar had in April recommended a CVC probe into the purchase, taking the argument that it involved central funds and Parliamentary Committee on Agriculture recommended necessary action in the matter.

LEGAL OPINION NOT TAKEN

Since there were inconsistencies in the views of the agriculture department and the minister, it was also suggested by the department that advice of the legal remembrancer or advocate general may be obtained regarding the jurisdiction of the CVC in the matter and as to whether the approval of the Punjab and Haryana High Court was required before referring the matter to the CVC as it was sub-judice.

GROUNDLESS REFERENCE

The communication sent to CVC reads: "State government had taken a decision for 100% treatment of certified wheat seed with Raxil 2 DS for rabi 2010-11 on the professional recommendation of Haryana Agricultural University. The programme for 100% treatment of certified wheat seed is still continuing in the state. A case regarding this is sub-judice in the High Court and a petition having similar issues regarding treatment of wheat seed was dismissed in 2011 by the High Court. You are requested to conduct an inquiry into the matter as per the decision of the state government and CVC Act.''

'NO CASE MADE OUT FOR CVC PROBE'

The file noting appended with the communication also nowhere mentions reasons or grounds for making a reference to CVC. On the contrary, the noting says that no case is made out to refer the matter to the CVC.

"The decision for wheat seed treatment with Raxil was taken at the highest level and no irregularities have been committed in the implementation of the seed treatment programme. The decision was to use Raxil for treatment of certified wheat seed and not for treating any particular disease of wheat crop… As per the Act, the CVC has no jurisdiction to inquire into the case.

The matter is sub-judice in the High Court and referring it to CVC without the prior approval of the court may amount to contempt of court..,'' reads the file noting by additional director, agriculture department. The observations on the file were not overruled, rejected or disproved by any senior official of the department while sending the reference to the CVC.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • The Jammu and Kashmir Congress on Tuesday took out ‘Azadi Ki Gaurav Padyatra’ from Bhour camp to Satwari chowk in Jammu with its working president Raman Bhalla reiterating the demand for restoration of statehood to the erstwhile state. (Twitter)

    Cong takes out ‘Padyatra’ in Jammu; seeks restoration of statehood to J&K

    The Jammu and Kashmir Congress on Tuesday took out 'Azadi Ki Gaurav Padyatra' from Bhour camp to Satwari chowk here with its working president Raman Bhalla reiterating the demand for restoration of statehood to the erstwhile state. The 'Padyatra' was organised as part of the 75th anniversary of India's independence to recollect the sacrifices of martyrs and spread the message of communal harmony, Bhalla, who was leading the foot march, said.

  • Sub-inspector Rishi Pal said that they got information about a drug smuggler in the Nissing area of Karnal. During the raid, the police team recovered 1.10kg of opium from him. (HT Photo/ Representational image)

    Drug peddler held with 1.10 kg opium in Karnal

    The Karnal police have arrested a drug peddler and recovered 1.10 kg of opium from his possession. The police said that the accused, Kuldeep of Bansa village of the district was arrested from Nissing on Tuesday evening. Sub-inspector Rishi Pal said that they got information about a drug smuggler in the Nissing area. During the raid, the police team recovered 1.10kg of opium from him.

  • The highly contagious lumpy skin disease (LSD) has now infected thousands of cattle in Haryana. (HT File Photo)

    Lumpy skin disease: Herders a worried lot as nearly 6,000 cases in Haryana, northern districts worst-hit

    The highly contagious lumpy skin disease (LSD) has now infected thousands of cattle in Haryana. As per the ground reports, in the beginning, the infection was reported in a few foreign breed cows in the Radaur block of Yamunanagar district. But the virus has now been reported in almost all northern districts of the state. The maximum cases are from Yamunanagar, Ambala, Kurukshetra and Sirsa districts.

  • Asked to climb a rope and run with weight during a physical fitness test, 10 of the 24 contractual firemen were left huffing and puffing. (Biswajit Debnath/HT)

    No fitness fire in Mohali firemen’s belly

    Physical fitness, among the primary requirements for firefighters, seems to be on the bottom of the checklist when it comes to the contractual firemen of the Mohali fire department. Recruited two years back, the 24 contractual firemen at the department recently underwent a physical fitness test, pre-planned by the municipal corporation, and were expected to come out with flying colours. But 10 of the 24 flunked majorly.

  • Haryana Speaker Gian Chand Gupta, Leader of the Opposition BS Hooda and all the MLAs applauded the players for bringing laurels to the state and the country at the Commonwealth Games. (Getty Images/iStockphoto/ Representational image)

    Haryana to give cash award to players finishing fourth at Commonwealth Games

    The Haryana government will give a cash award of Rs 15 lakh each to sportspersons who finished fourth at the Birmingham Commonwealth Games, minister of state for sports, Sandeep Singh told the assembly on Tuesday. The minister said an equal amount of hard work is put in by the players who finish fourth in any competition. The assembly on Tuesday applauded sportspersons from the state for their excellent performance in the Birmingham CWG.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Wednesday, August 10, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now