HT Image
HT Image

SC slams HPSC for destroying answer sheets, orders retest

Upholding a woman scheduled caste candidate's plea that answer sheets were deliberately destroyed by authorities to favour certain candidates, the Supreme Court has directed Haryana Public Service Commission to conduct fresh written test and interviews to recruit Hindi lecturers.
By HT Correspondent | PTI, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAY 03, 2012 08:14 PM IST

Upholding a woman scheduled caste candidate's plea that answer sheets were deliberately destroyed by authorities to favour certain candidates, the Supreme Court has directed Haryana Public Service Commission to conduct fresh written test and interviews to recruit Hindi lecturers.

A bench of justices GS Singhvi and SJ Mukhopadhaya agreed with the complaint of Poonam Rani that the commission had mala fide intentions in destroying the answer sheets of the examination held in October 2008 to avoid judicial scrutiny of the selection process.

Noting that the destruction of the answer sheets was contrary to the apex court's earlier judgment and a resolution passed by the commission, the bench rejected the authorities' plea that the scripts were destroyed due to certain confusion and inadvertence.

"The explanation given by the secretary for not preserving the answer sheets for three months is frivolous and wholly unacceptable because it is neither the pleaded case of the commission nor the counsel appearing on its behalf argued that the concerned officers were not aware of resolution dated October 1, 1994.

"Therefore, the action of the officers of the commission to destroy the record cannot but be termed as wholly arbitrary and unjustified.

"The sole object of this exercise appears to be to ensure that in the event of challenge to the result of the selection, the court may not be able to scrutinise the record for the purpose of finding out whether the selection was fair and objective or the candidates had been subjected to invidious discrimination," Justice Singhvi writing the judgment said.

The commission had earlier declined to select Poonam for the post of Hindi lecturer in the SC category on the ground that she had secured 117 out of 225 marks as against 119 marks secured by the last selected candidate of Scheduled Caste female category.

Her plea through the RTI for furnishing the answer sheets failed to get favourable response, upon which she moved the Punjab and Haryana high court which too declined to interfere with the commission's order following which she appealed in the apex court.

In Pritpal Singh vs State of Haryana (1994) case, the apex court had considered a similar issue and held that "the answer papers having been destroyed, it becomes impossible to ascertain what marks each candidate had secured".

At that time, it had directed the Haryana Subordinate Services Selection Board to preserve the answer papers of the candidates and the tabulation of marks made by the examiners for at least three months after the declaration of the result of the selection.

In the present case, the bench said the affidavit filed by the secretary of the commission clearly shows that within a few days of declaration of the result of the selection, answer sheets of the written examination held in June 2008 were destroyed.

This was done in blatant violation of resolution (Commission) dated October 1, 1994, in terms of which the answer sheets could be destroyed after three months from the date of declaration of the result of the selection.

The apex court also found fault in the manner in which the single judge and later a division bench of the high court refused to interfere with the plea of the candidate.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
Haryana DGP Manoj Yadava (HT Photo)
Haryana DGP Manoj Yadava (HT Photo)

Dealing with protesting farmers tightrope walk : Haryana DGP

PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 03:30 PM IST
State police chief Manoj Yadava says managing farmers’ protest on Delhi borders through dialogue, better intelligence and preventive steps.
Close
Farmers at Tikri border headed for Delhi on tractors on Tuesday morning. (HT Photo)
Farmers at Tikri border headed for Delhi on tractors on Tuesday morning. (HT Photo)

Farmers remove police barricades at Singhu, Tikri to begin tractor march before schedule

By Sunil Rahar
PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 12:13 PM IST
Shower petals on police as long queue of tractor-trolleys, cars and motrocycles gets rolling on Ambala-Delhi and Rohtak-Delhi highways.
Close
Many vehicles were freshly painted and decorated with flowers, with the Tricolour affixed on one side and carrying ration, mattresses and other essentials.(Sanjeev Sehgal/HT Photos)
Many vehicles were freshly painted and decorated with flowers, with the Tricolour affixed on one side and carrying ration, mattresses and other essentials.(Sanjeev Sehgal/HT Photos)

Thousands leave for Delhi ahead of rally from Punjab, Haryana

By HT Correspondent, Hindustan Times, Amritsar/jalandhar/karnal/rohtak
PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 03:34 AM IST
  • In the Haryana districts of Rohtak, Jind, Hisar, Fatehabad, Bhiwani and Dadri, villages emptied out as farmers drove to Delhi in tractors-trailers, cars, SUVs and motorbikes.
Close
Balwant Singh Rajoana main accused in former Punjab Chief Minister Beant Singh murder case.(HT File photo)
Balwant Singh Rajoana main accused in former Punjab Chief Minister Beant Singh murder case.(HT File photo)

SC gives Centre two weeks to decide on Rajoana mercy plea

By Abraham Thomas, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 03:22 AM IST
  • Rajaona was convicted over the assassination of former Punjab chief minister Beant Singh in August 1995.
Close
Mandeep Singh (captain) (HT File Photo)
Mandeep Singh (captain) (HT File Photo)

Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy: Punjab to take on Karnataka in quarters

By HT Correspondent, Chandigarh
PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 12:34 AM IST
After a successful run in the league stage, Punjab will now be facing defending champions Karnataka in the quarter-final tie to be played at Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel Stadium, Ahmedabad, on Tuesday.
Close
The Chandigarh municipal corporation says it has spent crores and purchased 425 vehicles for lifting the segregated waste. (Representational picture)
The Chandigarh municipal corporation says it has spent crores and purchased 425 vehicles for lifting the segregated waste. (Representational picture)

Chandigarh MC says it’s committed to protecting waste lifters’ livelihood

By HT Correspondent, Chandigarh
PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 12:24 AM IST
Garbage collectors are aggrieved at change in waste collection norms in the city; had sought HC directions to junk the system
Close
Chandigarh DSP gets President’s Police Medal
Chandigarh DSP gets President’s Police Medal

Chandigarh DSP gets President’s Police Medal

By HT Correspondent, Chandigarh
PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 12:22 AM IST
Deputy superintendent of police (DSP) (east) Gurmukh Singh has been awarded President’s Police Medal for his distinguished service, on the occasion of Republic Day
Close
Chandigarh transport buses to run at full occupancy
Chandigarh transport buses to run at full occupancy

Chandigarh transport buses to run at full occupancy

By HT Correspondent, Chandigarh
PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 12:21 AM IST
Chandigarh Transport Undertaking (CTU) buses will now be allowed to run at full seating capacity
Close
Farmers prepare for a tractor rally against the newly passed farm laws ahead of Republic Day at Singhu border near New Delhi. (REUTERS)
Farmers prepare for a tractor rally against the newly passed farm laws ahead of Republic Day at Singhu border near New Delhi. (REUTERS)

Farmer leaders deploy volunteers to check rumour-mongering during tractor parade

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 12:20 AM IST
Farmers from several parts of Punjab and Haryana on Monday continued to head towards Delhi to join the tractor parade against the Centre's three new agriculture laws.
Close
PU has already conducted exams for final-year students and reappear examination in various categories in online mode. (HT FILE PHOTO)
PU has already conducted exams for final-year students and reappear examination in various categories in online mode. (HT FILE PHOTO)

Panjab University to hold online exams for odd semesters from Feb 15

By HT Correspondent, Chandigarh
PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 12:15 AM IST
The decision on the mode of examination was announced on Monday after more than a month of deliberations
Close
Last year, the civic body had received only <span class='webrupee'>₹</span>425 crore against its demand of <span class='webrupee'>₹</span>1,076 crore in grant-in-aid from the administration. (HT FILE PHOTO)
Last year, the civic body had received only 425 crore against its demand of 1,076 crore in grant-in-aid from the administration. (HT FILE PHOTO)

Chandigarh MC seeks 1,058 crore from admn for 2021-2022

By Munieshwer A Sagar, Chandigarh
PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 12:12 AM IST
The municipal corporation has demanded 1,058 crore from the UT administration in its proposed budget of 1,590 crore for the financial year 2021-2022
Close
Panchkula leads with 61.6%, while Chandigarh and Mohali have achieved around 50% on an average.
Panchkula leads with 61.6%, while Chandigarh and Mohali have achieved around 50% on an average.

Panchkula leads in meeting Covid vaccination target in tricity

By HT Correspondent, Chandigarh
UPDATED ON JAN 25, 2021 11:34 PM IST
However, in absolute numbers, Mohali leads with 3,614 health workers inoculated so far, followed by 2,557 in Panchkula and 2,037 in Chandigarh
Close
Apni mandis set to reopen in Chandigarh
Apni mandis set to reopen in Chandigarh

Apni mandis set to reopen in Chandigarh

By HT Correspondent, Chandigarh
PUBLISHED ON JAN 25, 2021 11:31 PM IST
Apni mandis are set to reopen in Chandigarh after a span of nine months
Close
Police stopping protesters from stepping on to the road during a demonstration against farm bills at Matka Chowk in Chandigarh on Monday. (Ravi Kumar/HT)
Police stopping protesters from stepping on to the road during a demonstration against farm bills at Matka Chowk in Chandigarh on Monday. (Ravi Kumar/HT)

3,000 cops on vigil in and around Chandigarh on R-Day

By HT Correspondents, Chandigarh/mohali/panchkula
PUBLISHED ON JAN 25, 2021 11:28 PM IST
Apprehending protest by farmer unions, Panchkula police have imposed prohibitory orders near the parade ground
Close
Principal investigator of the project, Shahzad Aasim, a musicologist, said the study will be testing the neuro-acoustic mechanism among patients in Kashmir, which is a hotspot for mental disorders owing to conflict and other issues. (HT Photo)
Principal investigator of the project, Shahzad Aasim, a musicologist, said the study will be testing the neuro-acoustic mechanism among patients in Kashmir, which is a hotspot for mental disorders owing to conflict and other issues. (HT Photo)

J&K hospital, musicologist study if music helps treat mental disorders

By Ashiq Hussain, Srinagar
UPDATED ON JAN 26, 2021 07:47 AM IST
The research, being undertaken by SKIMS-MC and Shahzad Aasim, will study the effect of acoustics, sound and music on mental disorders such as anxiety and depression.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP