The National Education Policy, 2020, in its medical education component, lays emphasis on a holistic approach. (Representative Photo/HT)
The National Education Policy, 2020, in its medical education component, lays emphasis on a holistic approach. (Representative Photo/HT)

Why fusion of modern, alternative medicine is unfeasible

Mixopathy is unscientific, unrealistic, unreasonable, and an onslaught on the uniqueness of individual systems of treatment
By Dr AP Setia
UPDATED ON FEB 21, 2021 12:32 AM IST

Doctors across the country have decried the concept of ‘mixopathy’, which refers to the integration of different systems of medicine such as ayurveda, homeopathy, unani, siddha, yoga and naturopathy with allopathy (modern system of medicine).

The debate began when provisions under Section 50 of the National Medical Commission Act, 2020 mandated that educational modules for interface between the modern system of medicine, homeopathy and ayurveda be prepared through joint meetings of the Central Council of Indian Medicine, Central Council of Homeopathy and National Medical Commission. These provisions aim to promote pluralism in medical education.

The National Education Policy, 2020, in its medical education component, lays emphasis on a holistic approach. The government think-tank NITI Aayog is perusing through a variety of reform ideas in the health sector, including aligning traditional and modern approaches for the ‘larger good’, for which the Aayog has formed four committees. These committees are in the areas of medical education, clinical practice, public health, medical research and administration.

No common ground

However, this concept of integrating different systems of medicine raises serious questions about its practicability as each medical system has its own unique method of diagnosis, reasoning for causation and protocols for treatment.

The modern medicine system is an internationally recognised system of treatment whereas other systems have regional acceptance and dominance. Just as different regional languages cannot be integrated to make one language, it is similarly not possible to formulate one common system of treatment.

Case in point: How can the anti-microbial concept of modern medicine system be integrated with the ‘tridosha theory’ of Ayurveda? Or the homeopathic concept, which says dilution increases the potency of a biologically active substance be reconciled with modern pharmacology? The homeopathic principles that substances retain memory on dilution has not stood the scrutiny of biology, chemistry, physics and related sciences. It would be difficult to explain the logic of the yogic concept of alternate nostril breathing (anulom vilom) to a student of modern anatomy and physiology because both nostrils have identical structures?

More research needed

Furthermore, it is not possible to treat one patient with different systems simultaneously. Scientists and clinicians are yet to study drug interactions between medicines from different systems inside the complex human machine, which may be undergoing different metabolic changes due to the stress of trauma, operative procedure or recovery from anaesthetic agents apart from the onslaught of infections and immune factors. All such issues need to be sorted out through scientific research, both in experimental laboratories as well as in clinical practice before any type of integration exercise is put into action, by independent expert groups. Or else, we shall be putting the proverbial cart before the horse.

Unlike the modern system of medicine, the indigenous systems of therapy are not evidence-based. And hence, have no common grounds to meet and mix.

Shortage of qualified doctors has often been cited as one reason for such integration. However, as nearly 80,000 MBBS doctors are now being trained by 642 medical colleges every year such an argument may not be valid anymore. Rather, there may be many unemployed MBBS doctors few years from now. There is no dearth of postgraduate doctors too, 36,192 doctor of medicine (MD) and master of surgery (MS) seats were available for the year 2020-21. Over 44,000 specialist doctors are also being prepared by medical colleges and 60 exclusive post graduate medical institutes every year.

Better infrastructure needed in rural areas

Another argument made in favour of the integration is that doctors of the modern system of medicine are not keen on providing services in remote or underdeveloped areas. However, the non-availability of qualified doctors in rural areas can be attributed to non-availability of other essential services as well. Qualified doctors would love to serve the ailing masses in rural areas if infrastructure and social milieu to practice modern medicine is made available by the government.

Policy makers must work on correcting the basic lacunae in infrastructure first, rather than making stop-gap arrangements to meet the demand and supply gap, if any, by either integrating different systems of treatment or by imparting modern surgical training to ayurveda graduates, as per the CCIM notification, (Amendment Rules 2016) dated November,19 2020.

Let each system of treatment be developed in an individual manner by established scientific research methodology, to make it evidence-based and acceptable to those with scientific temperament. Mixopathy is unscientific, unrealistic, unreasonable, and an onslaught on the uniqueness of individual systems of treatment. Let diversity of different systems prevail and flourish.

Dr AP Setia is a former president of the Indian Medical Association of Haryana (HT File)
Dr AP Setia is a former president of the Indian Medical Association of Haryana (HT File)

(Views expressed are personal)

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
Sikander, who had undergone a renal transplant in 2016, passed away at 11.55 am at Fortis Hospital, Mohali, on Wednesday. (ht photo)
Sikander, who had undergone a renal transplant in 2016, passed away at 11.55 am at Fortis Hospital, Mohali, on Wednesday. (ht photo)

Sardool Sikandar laid to rest at ancestral village

By HT Correspondent, Fatehgarh Sahib
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 01:17 AM IST
Noted Punjabi singer-actor Sardool Sikandar (60) was laid to rest at his native Kheri Naudh Singh village in Fatehgarh Sahib on Thursday
Close
Workers readying a topiary for the 49th Rose Festival in Chandigarh on a sunny Thursday afternoon. (Keshav Singh/HT)
Workers readying a topiary for the 49th Rose Festival in Chandigarh on a sunny Thursday afternoon. (Keshav Singh/HT)

Chandigarh records hottest February day in 15 years, rain relief likely today

By Rajanbir Singh, Chandigarh
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 12:54 AM IST
The last warmest day in the month was recorded on February 23 in 2006, when the temperature had gone up to 32°C
Close
The commission suggested that the pre-board and final board examinations for classes 10 and 12 may be conducted in classrooms with strict compliance of standard operating procedures (SOPs) issued by the ministry of health and family welfare . (ht file)
The commission suggested that the pre-board and final board examinations for classes 10 and 12 may be conducted in classrooms with strict compliance of standard operating procedures (SOPs) issued by the ministry of health and family welfare . (ht file)

Child rights panel recommends online exams for nursery to Class 8 students

PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 12:54 AM IST
Since Covid cases are again showing a slight surge in Punjab, the commission received phone calls and email from parents and students, requesting online exams
Close
Shamsher Singh ‘Shera’ and his two aides in Police custody in Amritsar on Thursday. (ht photo)
Shamsher Singh ‘Shera’ and his two aides in Police custody in Amritsar on Thursday. (ht photo)

History-sheeter Shera, two aides held with heroin, guns in Amritsar

UPDATED ON FEB 26, 2021 12:48 AM IST
Shera was allegedly involved in heroin and weapon smuggling and facing nine criminal cases across Punjab
Close
Against a target of 24, 516, only 10,564 health workers have been immunised in Chandigarh since January 16. (HT File Photo)
Against a target of 24, 516, only 10,564 health workers have been immunised in Chandigarh since January 16. (HT File Photo)

Health workers’ vaccination wraps up in Chandigarh with 43% coverage

By Amanjeet Singh Salyal, Chandigarh
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 12:48 AM IST
Phase 2 comprising seniors and those over 45 with comorbidities to begin on March 1; frontline workers to be immunised till March 6
Close
JEE Main Day 3: Exam was easier than previous years, say students in Chandigarh
JEE Main Day 3: Exam was easier than previous years, say students in Chandigarh

JEE Main Day 3: Exam was easier than previous years, say students in Chandigarh

By HT Correspondent, Chandigarh
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 12:41 AM IST
Attendance continued to stay over 90% at centres in Chandigarh; the last exam in the February cycle of the JEE Main will be held on Friday
Close
After the MC General House had passed a resolution to the effect in 2018, the MC had notified in 2019 a sewerage cess of 30% of the water charges. (Getty Images/iStockphoto)
After the MC General House had passed a resolution to the effect in 2018, the MC had notified in 2019 a sewerage cess of 30% of the water charges. (Getty Images/iStockphoto)

Paying 30% cess on hiked water tariff a bane for Chandigarh residents

By Munieshwer A Sagar, Chandigarh
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 12:40 AM IST
The sewerage cess was introduced in June 2019, but with the recent water tariff hike, the real burden of the cess is being felt for the first time
Close
Having remained in political wilderness for all these months, Ashok Tanwar said that the Morcha will be an agent of positive changes and a platform to give voice to the voiceless. (HT FILE)
Having remained in political wilderness for all these months, Ashok Tanwar said that the Morcha will be an agent of positive changes and a platform to give voice to the voiceless. (HT FILE)

Former MP Tanwar launches Apna Bharat Morcha

By HT Correspondent, Chandigarh
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 12:40 AM IST
Fifteen months after he quit the Congress citing serious internal contradictions and existential crisis in the party, former MP Ashok Tanwar on Thursday launched Apna Bharat Morcha, a socio-political platform
Close
The HC also sought similar details from the district and sessions judges with stages of trials to ensure their speedy disposal. (Getty Images)
The HC also sought similar details from the district and sessions judges with stages of trials to ensure their speedy disposal. (Getty Images)

HC seeks details of criminal cases against MPs, MLAs from trial courts, govts

By HT Correspondent, Chandigarh
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 12:38 AM IST
The Punjab and Haryana high court on Thursday sought requisite information about criminal cases against MPs and MLAs in Punjab, Haryana and Chandigarh
Close
Last panchayat polls were held in Haryana in January 2016. (Getty Images)
Last panchayat polls were held in Haryana in January 2016. (Getty Images)

HC notice to Haryana on plea seeking panchayat polls

By HT Correspondent, Chandigarh
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 12:37 AM IST
The Punjab and Haryana high court on Thursday put the Haryana government on notice on a plea seeking panchayat polls
Close
The HC bench of justice Amol Rattan Singh, while acting on Yuvraj Singh’s plea seeking quashing of the FIR, has sought response by March 26. (HT FILE)
The HC bench of justice Amol Rattan Singh, while acting on Yuvraj Singh’s plea seeking quashing of the FIR, has sought response by March 26. (HT FILE)

No coercive action against ex-cricketer Yuvraj till further orders: HC to Haryana

By HT Correspondent, Chandigarh
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 12:35 AM IST
The Punjab and Haryana high court on Thursday asked the Haryana Police to not to take any coercive action against former Indian cricketer Yuvraj Singh in a criminal case registered in Hisar district earlier this month on allegations of making casteist remarks
Close
Haryana home minister Anil Vij had written to additional chief secretary, home, seeking a proposal containing names of IPS officers to be sent to the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) for consideration as the next DGP. (HT FILE)
Haryana home minister Anil Vij had written to additional chief secretary, home, seeking a proposal containing names of IPS officers to be sent to the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) for consideration as the next DGP. (HT FILE)

Row over DGP’s extension: Vij quotes tenure policy orders to defend his stance

By HT Correspondent, Chandigarh
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 12:27 AM IST
Defending his move to seek a new director general of police (DGP), Haryana home minister Anil Vij on Thursday said that incumbent DGP Manoj Yadava was repatriated by the central government for a period of two years as per the tenure policy for IPS on central deputation
Close
As many as 301 cases were registered in Shimla district and 229 in Mandi, while 221 cases were registered in Kullu and 206 in the police district of Baddi. (HT File)
As many as 301 cases were registered in Shimla district and 229 in Mandi, while 221 cases were registered in Kullu and 206 in the police district of Baddi. (HT File)

Year on, demand to cancel cases against Covid-19 guideline violators in HP

By Gaurav Bisht, Shimla
PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 05:19 PM IST
Though the BJP government is undecided, the issue is likely to come up in the budget session of the assembly, beginning on Friday
Close
Independent MLA from Meham Balraj Kundu's aide claimed he was being targeted for supporting farmers against the three farm laws .(Manoj Dhaka/HT)
Independent MLA from Meham Balraj Kundu's aide claimed he was being targeted for supporting farmers against the three farm laws .(Manoj Dhaka/HT)

Income Tax raids at Haryana MLA Balraj Kundu's homes, offices

By Sunil Rahar, Rohtak
PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 10:20 AM IST
  • A caretaker at Kundu's Rohtak office said the IT raids were politically motivated.
Close
Only the chief minister is authorised to take a call on a director general of police’s posting, say officials. (HT Photo)
Only the chief minister is authorised to take a call on a director general of police’s posting, say officials. (HT Photo)

CM Khattar unlikely to accede to Vij’s demand for change of DGP

By Hitender Rao, Chandigarh
UPDATED ON FEB 25, 2021 01:19 AM IST
Home department explains legal position on minimum tenure of two years, apex court’s rejection of Haryana’s amended law on tenure
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP