Mere acceptance of Iraqi militant leader as Caliph not enough, says HC while granting bail to Parbhani ISIS module accused

Published on Jun 27, 2022 08:05 PM IST
The court also discarded evidence of some of the prosecution witnesses who revealed that the group used to have regular discussions on incidents involving Muslims across the world
The bench also took into consideration that Ahmed was already granted bail by the high court and that the prosecution intended to examine about 550 witnesses (Getty Images/iStockphoto)
The bench also took into consideration that Ahmed was already granted bail by the high court and that the prosecution intended to examine about 550 witnesses (Getty Images/iStockphoto)

Mumbai Observing that mere declaration accepting the late Iraqi militant leader Abu Bakr Al Baghdadi as the ‘Caliph’ of Muslims cannot be considered as incriminating circumstance, the Bombay high court on Monday granted bail to Mohammad Raisuddin Mohamman Siddique, arrested in connection with the Parbhani ISIS module in July 2016.

Siddique was arrested on July 16, 2016 by the Maharashtra Anti-Terrorism Squad (ATS) along with others, claiming that they were associated with ISIS, committed unlawful acts and recruited people for the banned terrorist organisation.

The ATS claimed to have found an advanced explosive device being assembled on an electricity board in the house of one of the accused in the case, Iqbal Ahmed. The police allegedly also found an ‘Oath’ or declaration written in Urdu in Ahmed’s house, declaring their allegiance to the Iraqi militant leader. Subsequent investigation had revealed that the declaration was written by Siddique, who worked as a teacher at Hingoli at the relevant time, and was arrested in the case.

The division bench of justice Revati Mohite-Dere and justice VG Bisht, however, refused to believe that making and signing of the mere declaration was an incriminating circumstance – to charge a person under sections of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act.

“A perusal of the Oath (Baith), allegedly written by the appellant, at the highest appears to be a declaration of the acceptance of one Abi Bakar Al Baghdadi Al Hussaini Al Quraishi (Abu Bakr Al Baghdadi) as the ‘Caliph’ of the Muslims,” said the bench. “Prima-facie, a perusal of the said Oath (Baith) does not appear to be incriminating,” the bench added.

The court also discarded evidence of some of the prosecution witnesses who revealed that the group used to have regular discussions on incidents involving Muslims in India, Palestine and such other places.

“A perusal of statements of the aforesaid witnesses even if taken at its face value, would only indicate that the accused persons and the said witnesses would have regular discussions over threats to Islam: real, perceived or imaginary,” the bench said in this regard.

“It is the perception of the witnesses that the said accused persons had jihadi leanings or were fundamentalists. Prima-facie, there is no material to indicate that the appellant instigated the commission of any offence or insurgency, nor that the appellant advocated violent reactions,” the bench added.

The bench also took into consideration that Ahmed was already granted bail by the high court and that the prosecution intended to examine about 550 witnesses. Hence, Siddique, who was already incarcerated for about six years, cannot be kept behind bars any longer.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
  • ABOUT THE AUTHOR

    Special Correspondent. I have spent over a decade covering courts in Mumbai, primarily the Bombay High Court, and including several important trials like trial of 120 accused in March 1993 Mumbai bombings, 26/11 case - trial of Ajmal Kasab.

Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • The threat calls were made to a phone number of Sir HN Reliance Foundation Hospital that is run by the Reliance Foundation (Mint File Photo)

    Mumbai man who made 9 calls threatening Mukesh Ambani is a 56-yr-old jeweller

    A 56-year-old jeweller in north Mumbai was arrested on Monday on charges that56-year-old jeweler, Vishnu Vidhu Bhowmik, who has a jewelry shop in south Mumbaie made nine threat calls to the Sir HN Reliance Foundation Hospital in south Mumbai and threatened to harm Reliance Industries Limited chairman Mukesh Ambani and members of his family. The phone calls were made between 10:39am and 12.04pm on Monday. Police earlier said it appeared that the nine calls were made by the same person.

  • Anand Mohan (right).

    6 cops suspended for providing special treatment to ex-MP and convict Anand Mohan

    Six police personnel, including a sub-inspector (SI), were suspended for allegedly providing 'special treatment' to convicted gangster-turned-politician Anand Mohan Singh when he appeared at a Patna court on August 12. Saharsa superintendent of police Lipi Singh took the action on Monday, including four DAP jawans and an SAP driver, and ordered departmental proceedings against them. Anand Mohan was accused of inciting a mob to lynch the young Dalit IAS officer on December 5, 1994.

  • A Shivneri bus HT Archives

    Shivneri buses to Pune from Thane and Borivali to be replaced with low-cost Shivai

    Come October, commuters headed to Pune from Thane and Borivali will have a low-cost, yet comfortable transport facility. The Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation is planning to replace the iconic Shivneri buses on this route with electric Shivai buses. However, the Shivneri buses will continue to ply between Dadar and Pune. Currently, Shivneri buses charge ₹450 per passenger.

  • Students in the process of getting admission at Miranda House College in New Delhi. The admission process is on for the new academic session in Delhi University. (Photo by Sushil Kumar/Hindustan Times)

    Only 20% FYJC aspirants confirm admission in four days, deadline on Wednesday

    Mumbai: Blame it on the long weekend and travel plans or students refusing to alter their college preference, just 20% first-year junior college (FYJC) aspirants from the second merit list have confirmed admissions until Monday. College principals have attributed this low admission acceptance to students travelling during the long weekend. The second merit list was released by the office of the deputy director of education (DyDE) on August 12, where 69,691 students were allotted seats.

  • On the day of the incident, the couple had a heated exchange of words at night and after which Mukhtar fled from the area. Since he is absconding, it appears that he had killed his wife, said the police officer, adding that there are strangulation marks on her neck. (HT Photo)

    Man strangulates wife over petty issue, flees

    Mumbai: A 33-year-old man allegedly killed hMukhtar'swife by strangulating her over a trivial issue in wee hours on Sunday and fled from the house. JJ Marg police have launched a manhunt for him. According to the police, the deceased was identified as Manzila Shaikh, 30, who was staying in Imamwada area along JJ Marg along with her husband, Sukhchand Shaikh alias Mukhtar, 33.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Monday, August 15, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now