Ashes 2019: After Root, Aussies must nudge Smith to bat at No 3 | Cricket - Hindustan Times
close_game
close_game

Ashes 2019: After Root, Aussies must nudge Smith to bat at No 3

ByIan Chappell
Aug 04, 2019 11:53 AM IST

Would Australia be better off with Smith at three? Undoubtedly; it’s far better to avoid early collapses by short-circuiting them quickly

A productive batting order is not something that is reached by pulling names out of a hat or throwing darts at a board to decide each player’s position.

Cricket - Ashes 2019 - First Test - England v Australia - Edgbaston, Birmingham, Britain - August 3, 2019 Australia's Steve Smith in action(Action Images via Reuters)
Cricket - Ashes 2019 - First Test - England v Australia - Edgbaston, Birmingham, Britain - August 3, 2019 Australia's Steve Smith in action(Action Images via Reuters)

The ideal batting order is reached by the captain putting batsmen in the order that best suits their technique and style, as well as allocating them a slot where they feel comfortable. If a player’s style and technique is suited to a certain slot but he’s not comfortable batting there, then the skipper has to produce his most convincing argument to achieve what is best for the team.

Hindustan Times - your fastest source for breaking news! Read now.

In the first Ashes Test, both Joe Root and Steve Smith were capable of batting at number three. Both have been reluctant to hold down the first drop position but eventually Root decided it was best for the team if he batted three.

Also Read: Navdeep Saini shines as India win by four wickets in low-scoring opener

What Root did by batting at three at Edgbaston was effectively stabilise the England top order. His calm and proactive approach to batting finally ended England’s long running top-order collapses where they quickly slid to three down for less than fifty.

If Root stabilised the top order it was Rory Burns who, like Smith the day before, provided the solid foundation for the innings. Burns is like Smith in that he’s not pretty to watch and he’s leg-side oriented but he also emulated the ex-Australia skipper’s grit and determination to survive.

Burns finally shed his inhibitions and overcame the twin failures against Ireland to play a substantial Test innings. The difference between Burns against Ireland and the player who opened against Australia was palpable. It allowed England to prosper on a day when runs were hard-earned.

The previous day Smith had performed a similar yet even more difficult task as he resurrected the innings by hauling his team from the depths of 122/8 to a respectable 284 all out.

Also Read: Pant does a Dhoni, convinces Kohli for a successful DRS

Smith may no longer be captain but he’s made it clear his preference is to bat at four. He underlined his feelings by playing a great Test innings which eventually blossomed into a dominant one. In employing his quirky, ugly duckling (but highly successful) technique to amass more than half of Australia’s runs, he also amply displayed his grit and mental toughness. Smith is a highly successful international batsman because he understands his game and sticks to his guns no matter what anyone else says about his style.

Before his twelve months ban it appeared that international bowlers were at a loss as how to dismiss Smith. On the evidence of Edgbaston, the opportunity to spend a year plotting his downfall hasn’t led England to any meaningful conclusions.

Like England so many times before, Australia was quickly 35/3 in their first innings. Would Australia be better off with Smith at three? Undoubtedly; it’s far better to avoid early collapses by short-circuiting them quickly.

However, Tim Paine’s problem is producing the convincing argument that will cause Smith to overcome his misgivings and follow Root’s example. While Root will be disappointed that once again he didn’t convert a solid start, at least his innings will have helped eradicate any negative thoughts he might have held about elevating himself in the order.

There’s no doubt that both batting orders in this series are flawed and facing very good bowlers with a Dukes ball in their hand is going to be an on-going challenge. This suggests that runs are going to be at a premium throughout the series and that moderate scores could well be the order of the day.

If that does occur then more than likely it’ll be a tight series which will be great for the fans but a strenuous test for the players. With that in mind, it could be crucial to get the batsmen in their right order to maximise the team’s chances of victory. England, thanks to their captain, has taken the first step in the right direction.

Stay updated with the latest Cricket News, IPL Live Scores, and get exclusive insights with the RCB vs KKR Live Score, IPL 2024 Schedule, match highlights, and more. Explore a comprehensive Cricket Schedule, track the race for the Purple Cap and Orange Cap in IPL 2024, check Virat Kohli performance and stay ahead with all the cricket-related updates on the Hindustan Times website and app.
SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Share this article
SHARE
Story Saved
Live Score
OPEN APP
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Friday, March 29, 2024
Start 14 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now
Follow Us On