Sachin Tendulkar disagrees with Steve Bucknor.(Getty Images)
Sachin Tendulkar disagrees with Steve Bucknor.(Getty Images)

‘I gave a batsman out who was not out’: Steve Bucknor recalls umpiring decisions involving Sachin Tendulkar

Two of his most famous errors of judgement led to the dismissal of Indian cricket legend Sachin Tendulkar. Bucknor regrets those decisions in hindsight.
By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Yash Bhati | Hindustan Times, Delhi
UPDATED ON JUN 22, 2020 11:02 AM IST

Steve Bucknor was a top International Cricket Council (ICC) umpire in the 2000s. But some errors from his part led to his decline as a top umpire in international cricket. Two of his most famous errors of judgement led to the dismissal of Indian cricket legend Sachin Tendulkar. The first one happened during the Gabba Test in 2003 when he adjudged Tendulkar LBW on the bowling off Jason Gillespie despite the ball going above the wickets.

Then it was the infamous decision where he thought Tendulkar had edged an Abdul Razzaq delivery in 2005 at the Eden Gardens in Kolkata. The replays however showed that it had not touched the bat and Bucknor regrets those decisions in hindsight.

READ | No point poking the bear: David Warner not looking to sledge Virat Kohli on India’s tour to Australia

“Tendulkar was given out on two different occasions when those were mistakes. I do not think any umpire would want to do a wrong thing. It lives with him and his future could be jeopardised,” Bucknor said on Mason and Guests radio programme.

 Also Watch | ‘My brother & coach’: Sachin Tendulkar reveals the two most important people of his life

“To err is human. Once in Australia, I gave him out leg before wicket and the ball was going over the top. Another time, in India it was caught behind. The ball deviated after passing the bat but there was no touch. But the match was at Eden Gardens and when you are at the Eden and India is batting, you hear nothing.

“Because 100,000 spectators are making noise. Those were the mistakes and I was unhappy. I am saying a human is going to make mistakes and accepting mistakes are part of life,” he added.

Bucknor also talked about the introduction of technology in cricket and feels that the Decision Review System (DRS) has been introduced to make the sport better while correcting the wrong decisions from the umpires.

“I am not certain if it affects the confidence of umpires, but I know it has improved umpiring,” Bucknor said.

“It has improved umpiring because there was a time when we were saying the batsman was so-called playing down the line, therefore he is not going to be given out leg before, but if the technology is saying the ball is hitting, then you have to give him out. So, we learn from the technology.

“The umpires who do not enjoy having technology around, I hope that they have a rethink. What it does if you make a mistake it can be corrected on the field,” Bucknor said.

“Now thinking about when I was umpiring and I gave a batsman out who was not out, realizing I made a mistake it took a long time to fall asleep that night. Now you can fall asleep quickly because the correct decision is eventually given.”

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
Cricket - Third Test - England v Pakistan - Ageas Bowl, Southampton, Britain - August 24, 2020 England's Joe Root before the start of play, as play resumes behind closed doors following the outbreak of the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) Mike Hewitt/Pool via REUTERS/File Photo(REUTERS)
Cricket - Third Test - England v Pakistan - Ageas Bowl, Southampton, Britain - August 24, 2020 England's Joe Root before the start of play, as play resumes behind closed doors following the outbreak of the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) Mike Hewitt/Pool via REUTERS/File Photo(REUTERS)

Why did England pick four pacers for a spinning track?

By Sanjjeev K Samyal, Mumbai
PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 08:11 AM IST
  • In its brief history, day-night Tests have tended to assist fast bowlers. In the 15 day-night Tests that have been played around the world before the ongoing match, fast bowlers have taken 354 wickets at an average of 24.47, and spinners 115 wickets at 35.38.
Close
Joe Root in an argument with TV umpire.
Joe Root in an argument with TV umpire.

'Decisions made unusually quickly': Root & Silverwood approach match referee

UPDATED ON FEB 25, 2021 08:04 AM IST
  • "The England captain and head coach spoke with the match referee after play," an England team spokesperson said in the report.
Close
India's Axar Patel celebrates the dismissal during day one of the 3rd Test Match in the series between India and England at Narendra Modi Stadium, Motera in Ahmedabad on Wednesday. (ANI Photo/ICC Twitter)
India's Axar Patel celebrates the dismissal during day one of the 3rd Test Match in the series between India and England at Narendra Modi Stadium, Motera in Ahmedabad on Wednesday. (ANI Photo/ICC Twitter)

Axar reveals what helped him picking up 6 wickets against England in 3rd Test

PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 07:28 AM IST
  • It was his second five-for in just his second Test for Team India. By doing so, the 27-year-old spinner also became only the third Indian bowler to take a 5-wicket haul in his first two matches.
Close
File image of Sunil Gavaskar.(File)
File image of Sunil Gavaskar.(File)

'Wrong shot selection': Gavaskar weighs in on young India opener's dismissal

PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 07:22 AM IST
  • Gill shone bright in the series down under and scored a half century in the first innings of the first Test against England but has been guilty of giving his wicket away a couple of times in the series already.
Close
Axar Patel celebrates the dismissal during day one of the 3rd Test Match against England in Ahmedabad(BCCI/Twitter)
Axar Patel celebrates the dismissal during day one of the 3rd Test Match against England in Ahmedabad(BCCI/Twitter)

Axar sizzles with six on home turf as India take early command

PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 11:28 PM IST
India vs England: Patel and Ashwin set up the batsmen over after over with turn and variations. India ended the day on 99/3, trailing by 13 runs.
Close
File image of Mohammad Hafeez.(Getty Images)
File image of Mohammad Hafeez.(Getty Images)

Mohammad Hafeez declines PCB central contract offer

AP
PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 11:10 PM IST
The allrounder “politely turned down” a contract offer in category C for 2020-21, the cricket board said Wednesday.
Close
Ben Stokes' attempted catch of Shubman Gill on Day 1 of third Test against India in Ahmedabad(Twitter/Screengrab)
Ben Stokes' attempted catch of Shubman Gill on Day 1 of third Test against India in Ahmedabad(Twitter/Screengrab)

Ben Stokes dropped catch brings soft signal rule in focus

By Rasesh Mandani
PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 10:58 PM IST
  • The TV umpire overruled the “Out” soft signal (on-field umpires’ own call before technology adjudicates) and the incident renewed the debate whether soft signal can be an informed decision with very limited reaction time for the umpires on ground.
Close
India's Axar Patel celebrates the dismissal during day one of the 3rd Test Match in the series between India and England at Narendra Modi Stadium, Motera in Ahmedabad.(ANI)
India's Axar Patel celebrates the dismissal during day one of the 3rd Test Match in the series between India and England at Narendra Modi Stadium, Motera in Ahmedabad.(ANI)

3rd Test, Day 1: Axar, Ashwin put India on top as England bowled out for 112

PTI
UPDATED ON FEB 24, 2021 10:36 PM IST
Left-arm spinner Axar Patel snared six wickets while Ravichandran Ashwin took three as England collapsed to 112.
Close
Left-arm off-spinner Axar Patel snaps six wickets to help India bundle England for 112 on day 1 of the third India vs England Test in Ahmedabad.(BCCI)
Left-arm off-spinner Axar Patel snaps six wickets to help India bundle England for 112 on day 1 of the third India vs England Test in Ahmedabad.(BCCI)

India vs England, 3rd Test, Day 1: Action through images

PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 10:17 PM IST
India were 99 for three in reply to England's 112 all out on the opening day of the day-night third Test here on Wednesday.
Close
Ben Stokes caught applying saliva during India vs England 3rd Test
Ben Stokes caught applying saliva during India vs England 3rd Test

Ben Stokes caught applying saliva on the ball, umpires have a word

PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 09:50 PM IST
In what appeared to be an honest mistake, Stokes took the ball from Stuart Broad at the end of the 12th over in India's first innings and applied saliva to shine the ball, that too in front of on-field umpire Nitin Menon.
Close
Ben Stokes was trolled on Twitter for claiming Shubman Gil's catch
Ben Stokes was trolled on Twitter for claiming Shubman Gil's catch

Twitter comes down heavily on Ben Stokes for claiming Shubman Gill's catch

UPDATED ON FEB 25, 2021 07:31 AM IST
Shubman Gill was adjudged not out which left bemused Ben Stokes, who started shaking his head with a smirk on his face. Stokes’ reaction despite the correct decision did not go down well the fans as they took to Twitter to vent out their anger.
Close
Stuart Broad and Joe Root have an argument with the umpire(Twitter)
Stuart Broad and Joe Root have an argument with the umpire(Twitter)

Root, Anderson, Broad indulge in heated chat with umpire after Gill survives

UPDATED ON FEB 25, 2021 07:32 AM IST
England captain Joe Root, Stuart Broad the bowler and James Anderson were however not amused with the third umpire’s decision. The three senior cricketers were seen having an animated chat with umpire Chaudhary.
Close
Kedar Devdhar: File Photo(BCCI)
Kedar Devdhar: File Photo(BCCI)

Baroda continue winning streak, beat Hyderabad by 110 runs

PTI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 07:04 PM IST
This is Baroda's third win on the trot after they had defeated Goa and Tripura.
Close
Devdutt Padikkal(Twitter)
Devdutt Padikkal(Twitter)

Padikkal's career-best 152 hands Karnataka big win; Kerala consolidate lead

PTI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 06:51 PM IST
The 20-year-old opener smashed five sixes and 14 fours en route to his third List A century in his 16th game to propel Karnataka to 329 for five after being invited to bat at the KSCA Ground 3 in Alur.
Close
Axar Patel celebrates with R Ashwin other Indian cricketers(BCCI)
Axar Patel celebrates with R Ashwin other Indian cricketers(BCCI)

Axar, Ashwin make pink-ball tall, India bundle out England for 112

PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 06:31 PM IST
Axar Patel registered his career-best figures of 6 for 38 as India spinners called the shots in the first-ever day-night pink-ball Test between India and England in the world’s largest cricket stadium that has a capacity of 1 lakh 32 thousand.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP