Shivraj Chouhan’s CM question at rally in MP triggers unease in BJP

“Should Mama (as he is popularly called) become chief minister or not?” Chouhan asked the crowd on Friday

Updated on: Oct 8, 2023, 05:33:29 IST

By Ranjan, Shruti Tomar

Prefer HTon Google

Share via

Copy link

Bhopal Should Shivraj Singh Chouhan become the chief minister of Madhya Pradesh again? This question when asked by the leader himself during a public event has created an unease of sorts within the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), which has decided not to declare a CM face in the state ahead of the crucial assembly elections scheduled for later this year.

Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan (PTI)

Read here: Should I become chief minister again or not: CM Shivraj Chouhan asks people

“I want to ask you whether I am running a good government or a bad government. Should this government move ahead or not? Should Mama (as he is popularly called) become chief minister or not?” Chouhan asked the crowd on Friday while addressing a programme in tribal-dominated Dindori district.

In the same vein, he also asked if Narendra Modi should become the Prime Minister again or not. The crowd replied to both the questions with screams of “yes”.

Chouhan, who is the longest-serving chief minister of Madhya Pradesh having helmed the post since 2005 — barring an 18-month period between 2018 and 2020 when the Congress was in power — has been making an emotional pitch to voters, occasionally even shedding tears. Last week during an event in his home district Sehore, he made an appeal to women voters, saying: “You will not find a brother like me. You will remember me a lot when I am no longer around.”

Elections to the 230-member Madhya Pradesh assembly polls are scheduled for later this year.

The BJP central leadership has decided to contest the elections in the name of Prime Minister Narendra Modi while withholding the party’s chief ministerial candidate — something that the party has done before several state elections in the past. Senior leaders, including Union home minister Amit Shah and his cabinet colleague and party’s state poll panel convener Narendra Singh Tomar have said in public that the next chief minister will be decided by the party after the elections.

In the three lists of candidates declared by the BJP for the upcoming polls, the party has not named Chouhan. Incidentally, the 78 names include heavyweights Union ministers such as Tomar, Prahlad Singh Patel and Faggan Singh Kulaste besides national general secretary Kailash Vijayvargiya and several senior legislators, all of whom are seen as possible contenders for the CM’s post.

Addressing a gathering in Indore recently, Vijayvargiya had said: “I have not come here to just become an MLA. The party will give me a bigger responsibility than that.”

A senior BJP functionary, requesting anonymity, said unlike 2008, 2013 and 2018 assembly elections, when Chouhan led the party singlehandedly, strategy is different this time.

“The party has decided to showcase a collective leadership in Madhya Pradesh. This may be because after the 2018 assembly defeat and surveys showing strong anti-incumbency against Chouhan, the party has realised it can’t bank on Chouhan’s leadership anymore,” he said.

Read here: Height of disrespect’: Congress jabs BJP, CM Shivraj Chouhan over candidates list

A second BJP said the party seems to be in a mood to break the monotony of established leadership not only in Madhya Pradesh but in Rajasthan and Chhattisgarh also, given its vision for the next 20-25 years. “This is not without any reason that not only PM Narendra Modi but other central leaders also have not mentioned any schemes launched by Chouhan in their speeches, not even Ladli Behna, which we think can be a game changer for the party,” the leader said, also declining to be named.

State BJP secretary Rajneesh Agarwal, however, said speculations in the media over the chief minister have nothing to do with the reality. “Our leaders have already made the party’s stand clear. There should not be any doubt in anyone’s mind regarding leadership,” he added.

Political analyst and author Deepak Tiwari said the BJP leadership seems to be confused this time. “The fact is Shivraj Singh Chouhan is one of the prominent BJP leaders in north India, who made the BJP a party of the masses...” Tiwari said. “Chouhan’s statement comes from his present position in the party as he has been pushed to the wall.”

ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Ranjan
Ranjan Srivastava leads HT’s coverage from Bhopal. He has spent more than two decades in journalism in Uttar Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh, covering political and other affairs. For the past 16 years, he has been working in Madhya Pradesh.Read More
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Shruti Tomar
I have spent over a decade chronicling Madhya Pradesh’s political and social landscape, covering politics, investigative journalism, crime, human interest, and government policy, blending sharp insight with ground‑level depth. I have closely tracked three assembly elections, three Lok Sabha elections, leadership transitions in MP while exposing governance lapses, tender irregularities, and flawed policy rollouts. My reports have revealed gaps in the Cheetah project, irregularities in medical education, rigging in recruitment exams, and loopholes in policy implementation. In crime reporting, I have moved beyond FIRs to map systemic patterns — from organised crime networks and gender‑based violence to custodial accountability — balancing urgency with sensitivity. My journalism is defined by a commitment to human interest. I have profiled the marginalised Bancchda community, documented atrocities against tribal groups, and highlighted efforts to preserve their culture through heritage liquor and revival of spiritual practices. I have reported on farmers struggling with failed MSP promises, giving voice to those often reduced to statistics in policy files. Passionate about field reporting, I have reported on rampant sand mining in Chambal and Narmada, pharmaceutical companies supplying medicines under altered names, the dire condition of schools and colleges, the plight of commercial sex workers, and skewed sex ratios in specific districts. Beyond deadlines, and as HT’s state correspondent and assistant editor in Madhya Pradesh, I engage with ministers, farmers, students, and activists, believing the best policy stories begin with a single human voice. A postgraduate in Journalism and Mass Communication, I also hold a diploma in sports journalism.Read More

Get the latest India News, breaking headlines and real-time updates from across the country. Stay informed about politics, government policies, crime, weather and major national developments.