Since the early 2000s, Irshad Ali of Delhi worked for India’s intelligence agencies. He got into trouble when he started refusing to be a police informer.(Photo: Athar Rather / HT)
Since the early 2000s, Irshad Ali of Delhi worked for India’s intelligence agencies. He got into trouble when he started refusing to be a police informer.(Photo: Athar Rather / HT)

Irshad Ali was a police informer. Until the police framed him

How intelligence officials caught their own informer and said he was a terrorist
By Paramita Ghosh | Hindustan Times
UPDATED ON FEB 27, 2017 03:30 PM IST

Irshad Ali’s problem was that he had the wrong film in his head. He thought he was Salman Khan of Ek Tha Tiger when he was not even Sarabjit Singh. And by the end of 2005, after four years of intelligence work, he was on his way to meet his handler, an Intelligence Bureau (IB) official, to pick up his last salary. He had already told him he wanted out.

Ali, 40, a Delhi slumboy who worked in a factory, had been a police informer since his 30s. In the food chain of security networks, a police informer is a small fry chasing other small fry. And small fry cannot claim loyalty in return. Or say they want to retire. When they do, there are consequences.

***

On December 12, 2005, a car pulled over on a road in front of one of Delhi’s poshest hotels. Ali, who had been waiting for the pick-up, got in. He greeted the IB officer he had been reporting to from early 2000s, and found he had to take the middle seat. Two people were already sitting on either side of the seat. For a second, he felt something amiss but told himself perhaps they wanted the window seat. A second later, a black mask was slipped over his head, and the car sped towards Red Fort.

A long road to Justice: the story of Irshad Ali

“ ‘Your brain’s turned. We’ve fattened you enough!’ I heard the IB officer say,” Ali says, recalling the incident as we meet in a coffee shop a few months after his acquittal. “For two months after that, I was detained in houses in the city used by the IB and the Special Cell as interrogation rooms.” The IB handed him over to the Special Cell, and on February 9, 2006, along with Qamran (another police informer who was Ali’s cousin), they were packaged before the media as Al-Badr terrorists caught in north Delhi.

Ali was in Tihar Jail from 2006 to 2009. He was acquitted in December 2016 of charges under the Explosive Substances Act and under Section 120B, 121 and 122 of the Indian Penal Code and Section 25 of the Arms Act. He and Qamran were out on bail in 2009 after the High Court heeded the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) report that proved the terror allegations levelled against them by the Special Cell were false.

Irshad Ali and his wife Shabana at their home in a slum in northwest Delhi. “Shabana was also detained for two days in illegal police custody,” says Ali. (Photo: Athar Rather / HT)
Irshad Ali and his wife Shabana at their home in a slum in northwest Delhi. “Shabana was also detained for two days in illegal police custody,” says Ali. (Photo: Athar Rather / HT)

An officer of the investigating team, who had questioned Ali’s handler, says on condition of anonymity, that he had “admitted to Ali being his agent, but not that he had been framed”.

Ali says both cannot be true - if he was a secret agent and it had been admitted as such by the police, he cannot have been a terrorist. “So if I have been punished without a crime, then it should follow that those who put me behind bars, be deemed criminals.”

Read: Are cops following procedure or giving painstaking probe the go-by?

Good cops investigating bad cops, or any other public servant, have to deal with a condition called The Consensus - so as to least disturb the status quo. “Everyone realised at some point that Ali was innocent and should be discharged but the Special Cell, however, could not be indicted. The Police’s Morale, Consensus, whatever you call it,” says the cop to HT.

The selection of Irshad Ali

Why did Irshad Ali agree to become a secret agent in the first place?

From 2001 to 2006, Ali had been working for the IB and the Special Cell. A cab driver, he needed to supplement the family income. Residents of a slum near Rithala, the one-room shack in which he lives stands on uneven ground; garbage lies all around. His father when alive, worked in an attache factory.

“I have six sisters. My brother who is serving a life sentence, worked for the cops from inside the jail, and I, from outside,” he says. “We felt the pressure to do it. My brother passed on letters of convicts, the police wanted to know more about, to me and I passed it on to the cops.”

“With a brother in jail on a murder charge, you have to be grateful if the police say they want you to work for them,” says Ali. The IB, with whom he went to work first, is interested in your psyche, he says. They take time to figure out who you are. “If the local police catch you for a wrongdoing they will go through your pockets. The IB will go through your diary. But they work together.”

A lonely fight for justice. Ali was acquitted in December 2016 of charges under the Explosive Substances Act and under Section 120B, 121 and 122 of the Indian Penal Code and Section 25 of the Arms Act. (Photo: Athar Rather / HT)
A lonely fight for justice. Ali was acquitted in December 2016 of charges under the Explosive Substances Act and under Section 120B, 121 and 122 of the Indian Penal Code and Section 25 of the Arms Act. (Photo: Athar Rather / HT)

There is danger in intelligence work. But because of the police association, Ali thought there was security. He also brought in a couple of his friends and some members of his family such as Qamran, and engaged them in intelligence work. Qamar did not want to speak to the media.

A free man now, Ali says he has no problem speaking out. Friends on Whatsapp afraid of his safety have been telling him “not to make so much noise”.

“I have nothing to lose,” says Ali. His voice is steady, his eyes are still. Once in a while he breaks his narrative to look around and says gesturing towards a man sitting in another corner of the coffee shop: “I could go and chat with him and he will open up to me…. I learnt how to do it…. I was picked up because I had guts, they knew I was of their level.”

Read: Kashmir alienated by Delhi police picking the wrong man

End of honeymoon

Ali’s case is ironic in more ways than one. This was not a case of the police picking up the wrong man. He was the IB’s man. And the Special Cell who, alongwith some IB officers, “fixed Ali knew that”, says one of the cops who probed the frame-up. “He had been refusing his assignments, he didn’t want to cross the border and be trained as a militant so as to infiltrate their ranks. They just weren’t ready to let him go,” he says.

“I have worked for both the IB and the Special Cell,” says Ali. “I was being paid a monthly salary of Rs 7,000.” But he began to be filled with a sense of wrong. Ali, who had half-completed a maulvi’s education in a madrassa, was being asked to indoctrinate people and then squeal about them to the police. “Even if the police said that after laying the trap they would let me get away.… I didn’t want to be the hand that helped them get medals.” In other words, he was developing a conscience. Or maybe he was just plain tired.

“My wife Shabana didn’t want me to cross the border. We had become parents,” says the father of two. His daughter died when he was in jail.

Ali believes he was finally made the “scapegoat for the Cell’s inability to catch the people behind the Delhi blasts of 2005”. Besides, his days of being useful as an intelligence gatherer were also over. The intelligence officials he had worked with had told him often enough: “If a lime dries up, make use of its peels.” But he didn’t believe they were talking about him.

Thoda dhamki, thoda maafi (a little bit of threatening and a little bit of cajoling),” he says, had been part of his relationship with intelligence officials. Police informers like him were told they had “saved these many lives, stopped this or that disaster with the news we got. I felt I was contributing….” But they held him on a tight leash. It was classic carrot and stick. He had four years in jail to arrive at these conclusions.

Ali was out on bail in 2009 after the CBI filed a report recommending that he be discharged as the Special Cell’s charges against him were inconsistent with existing evidence. “Due to Santosh Kumar, the investigating officer of the CBI, I am a free man today,” says Ali. Kumar was part of an eight-member team investigating the Special Cell’s allegations.

“Due to Santosh Kumar (above), investigating officer of the CBI, I am a free man,” says Ali. The CBI team exposed that the charges levelled by the Special Cell against Ali were a sham. (Photo: Central Bureau of Investigation)
“Due to Santosh Kumar (above), investigating officer of the CBI, I am a free man,” says Ali. The CBI team exposed that the charges levelled by the Special Cell against Ali were a sham. (Photo: Central Bureau of Investigation)

Fighting back

In January 2017, he filed a case in the Delhi High Court urging it to order the CBI to re-open their closure report in which they had recommended that police officers who had framed him be booked for criminal conspiracy. The hearing is due in March.

It’s not personal, but about justice, says Ali. But is it surprising, if it’s a bit of both ?

Ali’s revelations give a glimpse into the smoke and mirrors that shroud intelligence operations​, “​a​nd the ​gross impunity with which men from the minority community ​can be first forced into becoming the agencies’ foot soldiers​, and then disposed off when their use is over,” says Manisha Sethi of the Jamia Teachers​’​ Solidarity Association (JTSA). The JTSA report​s​​ (in 2012 and 2015) ​ had, in fact, brought to the fore the ​methodical ​fabrication of evidence against ​Muslims, mainly Kashmiris, by ​the Special Cell in the name of fighting terror ​through the past two decades. “It also points to ​how the media unquestioningly ​repeated ​the police versions as truth, until years later courts acquitted these unfortunate men,” says Sethi.

A bomb blast ripped through a crowded Sarojini Nagar market in Delhi on October 29. (Photo: Ajay Aggarwal / HT)
A bomb blast ripped through a crowded Sarojini Nagar market in Delhi on October 29. (Photo: Ajay Aggarwal / HT)

Ali is no longer in shock but speaks with a quiet outrage. Did he ever speak out thus in court? “In the eyes of the law, I was a criminal…. If you tried to speak, it could be considered contempt of court,” he says without any sense of irony. “You could only speak through your lawyers.” At a fast-track court, a sessions judge once told him: “ ‘Admit to your guilt and I’ll free you now…’. In other words, end of case, end of police scrutiny.”

***

“So will Ali’s be a cautionary tale for cops not to force people to continue with intelligence gathering if they don’t want to?” I ask another cop following the case.

“You can’t use force that’s for sure,” he agrees. “Otherwise, you will have a case like Ali’s in your hands.”

“So will there be outrage now that people know?”

“No. People will forget.”

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
Mamata Banerjee had on Saturday declined to speak at an official programme at the lawn of Victoria Memorial Hall to celebrate Subhas Chandra Bose's birth anniversary(File photo)
Mamata Banerjee had on Saturday declined to speak at an official programme at the lawn of Victoria Memorial Hall to celebrate Subhas Chandra Bose's birth anniversary(File photo)

Mamata Banerjee hails from 'demoness' culture, has faulty DNA: BJP MLA in UP

PTI
UPDATED ON JAN 24, 2021 04:00 PM IST
The BJP claimed that Banerjee's reaction reflected her mindset of appeasement politics, while the ruling Trinamool Congress said no one can teach lumpens to be dignified.
Close
Since the beginning of farmers' 'Dilli Chalo' protests, Delhi CM Arvind Kejriwal and Punjab CM Amarinder Singh have engaged in a bitter war of words.
Since the beginning of farmers' 'Dilli Chalo' protests, Delhi CM Arvind Kejriwal and Punjab CM Amarinder Singh have engaged in a bitter war of words.

Farmers protest: AAP ups ante, quotes RTI document to slam Amarinder Singh

Written by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON JAN 24, 2021 03:56 PM IST
The party on Sunday produced RTI documents claiming Punjab CM Amarinder Singh was part of a high-powered committee of chief ministers for 'Transformation of Indian Agriculture'.
Close
New Delhi: Tableau of Ladakh during the full dress rehearsal for the upcoming Republic Day Parade, at Rajpath in New Delhi, Saturday, Jan. 23, 2021. (PTI Photo/Atul Yadav)(PTI01_23_2021_000103B)(PTI)
New Delhi: Tableau of Ladakh during the full dress rehearsal for the upcoming Republic Day Parade, at Rajpath in New Delhi, Saturday, Jan. 23, 2021. (PTI Photo/Atul Yadav)(PTI01_23_2021_000103B)(PTI)

In a first, Ladakh tableau to be part of Republic Day parade

ANI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 03:45 PM IST
Ladakh's tableau will depict the iconic Thiksey Monastery located on top of a hill in Thikse in Leh district, and is one of the most-visited tourist sites in the region.
Close
Union Home Minister Amit Shah addresses during an event at Police Headquarters in New Delhi, on Tuesday. (ANI Photo)
Union Home Minister Amit Shah addresses during an event at Police Headquarters in New Delhi, on Tuesday. (ANI Photo)

Bodo accord has brought peace to BTR, says Amit Shah in Kokrajhar, Assam

By Utpal Parashar, Guwahati
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 03:39 PM IST
  • Shah mentioned how the Bodo accord was crucial in ensuring a peaceful election to the Bodo Territorial Council (BTC) held last month. He lambasted the opposition Congress for failing to fulfil promises.
Close
Tractor trolleys of farmers parked at Kundli border during their ongoing agitation against the new farm laws, on Sunday.(PTI Photo)
Tractor trolleys of farmers parked at Kundli border during their ongoing agitation against the new farm laws, on Sunday.(PTI Photo)

UP govt orders no diesel for tractors as farmers gear up for Jan 26 rally

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Amit Chaturvedi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 03:35 PM IST
The farmers want to take out the rally on Outer Ring Road, while the police have suggested alternate routes.
Close
The officials said a thick layer of security has been thrown around the venue – a few kilometres away from the Lal Chowk city centre here – and the area has been sanitised. (Representative Image)(AFP PHOTO.)
The officials said a thick layer of security has been thrown around the venue – a few kilometres away from the Lal Chowk city centre here – and the area has been sanitised. (Representative Image)(AFP PHOTO.)

Security tightened in Kashmir Valley ahead of Republic Day

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 03:32 PM IST
The presence of security forces around vital installations in and around the city as well as other district headquarters has been increased, the officials said.
Close
"Demonetisation, Goods and Services Tax (GST), and the response to Coronavirus has severely damaged the people of this state", Rahul Gandhi said.(PTI)
"Demonetisation, Goods and Services Tax (GST), and the response to Coronavirus has severely damaged the people of this state", Rahul Gandhi said.(PTI)

Rahul Gandhi slams Centre for Tamil Nadu's 'economic downturn'

ANI, Chennai
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 03:15 PM IST
The former Congress President was addressing the people of the state during a roadshow organised in Perundurai of Tamil Nadu's Erode district, ahead of the Tamil Nadu Assembly polls.
Close
Ageing signs include increasing cases of dam failures, progressively increasing costs of dam repair and maintenance, increasing reservoir sedimentation, and loss of a dam's functionality and effectiveness, "strongly interconnected" manifestations, the report said. (Representative Image)(HT file photo)
Ageing signs include increasing cases of dam failures, progressively increasing costs of dam repair and maintenance, increasing reservoir sedimentation, and loss of a dam's functionality and effectiveness, "strongly interconnected" manifestations, the report said. (Representative Image)(HT file photo)

Ageing dams in India, US, other nations pose growing threat: UN report

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 03:10 PM IST
The report, titled 'Ageing water infrastructure: An emerging global risk' and compiled by United Nations University's Canadian-based Institute for Water, Environment and Health, says most of the 58,700 large dams worldwide were constructed between 1930 and 1970 with a design life of 50 to 100 years.
Close
The government, in 2008 declared January 24 to be celebrated as the National Girl Child Day' every year with the objective of raising the consciousness of the society towards the girl child so that she can be valued and respected.(PTI)
The government, in 2008 declared January 24 to be celebrated as the National Girl Child Day' every year with the objective of raising the consciousness of the society towards the girl child so that she can be valued and respected.(PTI)

Centre committed to empowering women: Harsh Vardhan

ANI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 03:09 PM IST
On the National Girl Child Day, the Minister listed the achievements and initiatives of the government in empowering the girl child in a series of tweets.
Close
Farmers set to participate in a tractor rally to protest against the newly passed farm laws, in New Delhi. (Reuters File Photo )
Farmers set to participate in a tractor rally to protest against the newly passed farm laws, in New Delhi. (Reuters File Photo )

Farmers prep for Republic Day tractor rally; no clarity yet on police permission

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Kanishka Sarkar, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 02:59 PM IST
On Saturday, a police official familiar with the developments had said that the approval for farmers' tractor rally was given in principle for now.
Close
ASHA workers staged a demonstration in front of the GGH demanding that a compensation of <span class='webrupee'>₹</span>50 lakh be paid to the deceased's family.(Reuters | Representational image)
ASHA workers staged a demonstration in front of the GGH demanding that a compensation of 50 lakh be paid to the deceased's family.(Reuters | Representational image)

ASHA worker's death sparks protests in Andhra; coworkers, kin suspect AEFI

PTI, Amaravati
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 02:43 PM IST
Guntur district Collector Samuel Anand said the exact cause of the ASHA worker's death would be revealed only after a post-mortem but maintained that not a single Adverse Event Following Immunisation was reported in the district.
Close
Prime Minister Narendra Modi.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

'Playing important role in building self-reliant India': PM greets on UP Diwas

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Shivani
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 02:43 PM IST
The Yogi Adityanath government had in December 2017 decided to organise Uttar Pradesh Day on January 24 for the first time since the state came into being in 1950.
Close
New voters who have registered their mobile phone numbers with the Election Commission will be able to download their digital voter ID cards on January 25 after 11.14am.
New voters who have registered their mobile phone numbers with the Election Commission will be able to download their digital voter ID cards on January 25 after 11.14am.

Digital voter cards: How to download? Who are eligible? All you need to know

Written by Poulomi Ghosh
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 02:42 PM IST
New voters will also get hard copies of their voter ID cards, the Election Commission has said.
Close
The eleventh round of talks between farmers and the government was held on Friday.(PTI)
The eleventh round of talks between farmers and the government was held on Friday.(PTI)

Priyanka Gandhi slams Centre for blocking farmers from entering Delhi

ANI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 02:35 PM IST
Congress and opposition parties have been targetting the government over the ongoing farm laws, demanding the rollback of these newly-enacted legislations.
Close
Prime Minister Narendra Modi during a video conference in New Delhi. (PTI)
Prime Minister Narendra Modi during a video conference in New Delhi. (PTI)

World Economic Forum: PM Modi, Xi Jinping to attend 'virtual' Davos

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Mallika Soni
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 02:24 PM IST
The key themes for discussion according to the WEF website will revolve around Covid 19, climate change, technology, better businesses and healthy future of the world.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP