E-Paper
Mahua Moitra's remarks on judge Loya's death spark uproar in Lok Sabha; BJP responds
In a passing yet contentious remark, Moitra attacked the ruling BJP for allegedly targeting institutions and opposition leaders to silence critical voices.
Trinamool Congress's (TMC) firebrand MP Mahua Moitra triggered a ruckus in Lok Sabha on Friday with her reference to the death of Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) court judge BH Loya, calling him someone "who is resting in peace long before his time”.
Judge Loya's death in 2014 had created a major row following a media report alleging foul play as he was hearing a politically sensitive case. The matter reached the Supreme Court.
While hearing some PILs, the SC had said there was no merit in pleas alleging foul play. It also said that the judge died of natural causes.
What did Mahua Moitra say
In a passing yet contentious remark, Mahua Moitra on Friday attacked the ruling BJP for allegedly targeting institutions and opposition leaders to silence critical voices.
“Honourable Defence Minister in a speech this ,morning mentioned the courage of the late justice HR Khanna to dissent in 1976. May I remind everyone, Justice HR Khanna lived for 32 years after 1976 under a largely Congress regime. Long enough to write his autobiography which the minister quoted from. Unlike poor Justice Loya, who is resting in peace long before his time,” Moitra said.
Union minister Kiren Rijiju later accused Mahua Moitra of raising a matter settled by the Supreme Court and warned of "appropriate parliamentary action".
Also Read | ‘For those who ask…’: Mahua Moitra clarifies after blocking critics on X over Kolkata rape-murder case
The House was adjourned briefly twice due to the uproar over the matter, and the debate resumed after Speaker Om Birla said he has asked her to authenticate her claims. He also assured opposition members he will look into their reservations against Rijiju's "threatening" language against a woman MP.
BJP member Nishikant Dubey first raised the issue after Moitra finished speech.
Dubey also objected to her criticism of former chief justice of India DY Chandrachud, who recently retired, for a host of reasons, including receiving Prime Minister Narendra Modi at his residence during the Ganapati festival.
The BJP MP also accused Moitra of making insinuations about Loya's death.
Later in a post on microblogging platform X, Mahua Moitra said all those reporting that "Parliament Affairs Minster warned me - it is he who will face action for threatening me! His remarks to be deleted- not mine!"
Rijiju said the judge's death case is settled and the TMC MP's remarks were very serious. There is no question of any link or interference, he added.
The parliamentary affairs minister said, "We will take appropriate parliamentary action. You cannot escape. You are setting a very wrong precedent."
Any member will otherwise make similar allegations, Rijiju added.
When the House reconvened after two adjournments, senior opposition members, Saugata Roy of the TMC and K C Venugopal of the Congress, protested against Rijiju's choice of words, saying that it was the Speaker who is the custodian of Lok Sabha.
Both the MPs said the ruling party could have resorted to appropriate rules to seek action if they had an issue with Moitra's speech.
Addressing Birla, Venugopal said, "You are the custodian. You have the powers to delete, expunge... The parliamentary affairs minister took the entire custody of House and he virtually threatened the lady member."
Roy accused Rijiju of making "brazen effort" to threaten Moitra.
Congress leader Venugopal said the minister's responsibility is to maintain peace in the House but he instead "threatened" and intimidated a woman member. He demanded that Rijiju apologise or his remarks be expunged.
The Speaker pulled up members engaging in personal allegations and counter-allegations, and asked them to have a constructive debate over issues related to the Constitution.
Birla said he has asked Moitra to authenticate her remarks, adding that he will look into what the minister has said and will delete, if needed.
